Theories of Organisation: Scientific Management, Bureaucracy and Human Relations
Taylor's scientific management, Fayol and Gulick's principles, Weber's bureaucracy and its critics, and Mayo's Hawthorne studies for UGC NET.
- 20 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: A Shovel, a Rulebook and a Lighting Experiment
- 1. Organisation: Meaning and Kinds
- 2. Scientific Management: F.W. Taylor
- 3. Administrative Management: the Principles School
- 4. Bureaucratic Theory: Max Weber
- 5. Human Relations Theory: Elton Mayo and the Hawthorne Studies
- 6. The Three Theories Compared
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Meaning, Evolution and Approaches — the “principles” paradigm (1927–1937) and Simon’s proverbs critique.
- Democracy and Power — Weber’s three types of authority, on which his theory of bureaucracy rests.
- Communication: Meaning, Types and Characteristics (Paper 1) — formal and informal channels, which reappear here as formal and informal organisation.
The Hook: A Shovel, a Rulebook and a Lighting Experiment
How UGC NET asks it: Taylor’s techniques and principles; Fayol’s 14 principles and 5 functions; POSDCORB; span of control and Graicunas; features of Weber’s ideal-type bureaucracy; Merton, Selznick, Gouldner and Crozier as critics; the four phases of the Hawthorne studies and their findings; match-the-following of thinker → book → year.
1. Organisation: Meaning and Kinds
An organisation is a structure of roles and relationships created to achieve a common purpose. Chester Barnard (1938) defined a formal organisation as “a system of consciously co-ordinated activities or forces of two or more persons”.
| Formal organisation | Informal organisation | |
|---|---|---|
| Created by | Deliberate design (charts, rules) | Spontaneous social relations |
| Authority | From position | From the group (personal influence) |
| Communication | Official channels | Grapevine |
| Discovered / stressed by | Classical theorists (Taylor, Fayol, Gulick, Weber) | Human relations school (Mayo), Barnard |
The theories in the syllabus fall into three families:
graph TD
A["Theories of organisation"] --> B["Classical / mechanistic
(c. 1900-1940)"]
A --> C["Neo-classical / human relations
(c. 1930-1950)"]
A --> D["Modern
(1950 onwards)"]
B --> B1["Scientific management
Taylor"]
B --> B2["Administrative management
Fayol, Gulick, Urwick, Mooney-Reiley"]
B --> B3["Bureaucratic theory
Weber"]
C --> C1["Hawthorne studies
Mayo"]
D --> D1["Behavioural / decision-making
Barnard, Simon"]
D --> D2["Systems and contingency
Katz-Kahn"]2. Scientific Management: F.W. Taylor
Frederick Winslow Taylor (1856–1915), an engineer at Midvale Steel and later Bethlehem Steel, is called the father of scientific management.
| Work | Year |
|---|---|
| “A Piece-Rate System” (paper) | 1895 |
| Shop Management | 1903 |
| The Principles of Scientific Management | 1911 |
| Testimony before a special committee of the US House of Representatives | 1912 |
Taylor’s principles
- Science, not rule of thumb — find the “one best way” of doing each job by study.
- Scientific selection, training and development of workers.
- Co-operation between management and workers to ensure work is done by the scientific method (harmony, not discord).
- Equal division of work and responsibility between management (planning) and workers (doing).
Behind these, Taylor called for a “mental revolution” on both sides: management and workers should stop quarrelling over the division of the surplus and work together to increase it.
Taylor’s techniques
| Technique | What it is |
|---|---|
| Time study | Fixing the standard time for each task element with a stopwatch |
| Motion study | Eliminating wasteful movements (developed further by Frank and Lillian Gilbreth) |
| Standardisation | Of tools, equipment, materials and working conditions |
| Differential piece-rate system | A higher rate for workers who reach the standard, a lower rate for those who do not |
| Functional foremanship | Eight specialist foremen instead of one general foreman |
| Planning department | Separating planning from doing |
| Instruction cards, task idea | Each worker gets a defined daily task with written instructions |
Functional foremanship: the eight foremen
| In the planning department | On the shop floor |
|---|---|
| Route clerk | Gang boss |
| Instruction card clerk | Speed boss |
| Time and cost clerk | Repair boss |
| Shop disciplinarian | Inspector |
Functional foremanship directly violates unity of command (each worker has eight bosses): a favourite assertion–reason point against Fayol.
Taylor’s associates
| Person | Contribution |
|---|---|
| Henry Gantt | Gantt chart (bar chart of work scheduled against time); task-and-bonus wage plan |
| Frank and Lillian Gilbreth | Motion study; therbligs (Gilbreth spelt backwards, nearly): basic units of motion |
| Harrington Emerson | Efficiency engineering; twelve principles of efficiency |
Criticisms
- Treats the worker as an extension of the machine (“economic man” motivated only by money).
- Ignores social and psychological needs, which the Hawthorne studies later showed.
- Speed-up and exhaustion; opposed by trade unions as exploitative.
- Takes all thinking away from workers; deskilling.
- Its “one best way” ignores the variety of situations (contingency theorists’ objection).
Yet its legacy is large: work study, O&M (organisation and methods) units in government, industrial engineering, performance standards, and the later NPM emphasis on measurable output.
3. Administrative Management: the Principles School
Henri Fayol (1841–1925)
A French mining engineer and managing director, Fayol wrote Administration industrielle et générale (1916; English translation General and Industrial Management, 1949). He is called the father of modern management theory (or of the “administrative” or “process” school). Where Taylor started at the shop floor, Fayol started at the top.
Six groups of activities in any enterprise: technical, commercial, financial, security, accounting, and managerial (administrative).
Five elements (functions) of management:
- Planning (prévoyance, foresight and forecasting)
- Organising
- Commanding
- Co-ordinating
- Controlling
Fourteen principles of management:
| # | Principle | # | Principle |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Division of work | 8 | Centralisation |
| 2 | Authority and responsibility | 9 | Scalar chain (line of authority) |
| 3 | Discipline | 10 | Order |
| 4 | Unity of command (one boss) | 11 | Equity |
| 5 | Unity of direction (one head, one plan for a group of activities with one objective) | 12 | Stability of tenure of personnel |
| 6 | Subordination of individual interest to general interest | 13 | Initiative |
| 7 | Remuneration | 14 | Esprit de corps |
Fayol’s gangplank (bridge): when strict use of the scalar chain is too slow, two officials at the same level in different branches may deal directly with each other, provided their superiors agree and are kept informed. It allows horizontal communication without breaking the chain.
Luther Gulick and Lyndall Urwick
Papers on the Science of Administration (eds Gulick and Urwick, 1937) was prepared for the Brownlow Committee (President’s Committee on Administrative Management, 1937) in the United States.
- POSDCORB (Gulick): Planning, Organising, Staffing, Directing, Co-ordinating, Reporting, Budgeting.
- Four bases of departmentalisation (Gulick’s “4 Ps”):
| Basis | Example |
|---|---|
| Purpose (function) | Ministry of Health, Ministry of Defence |
| Process (skill) | Law Department, Accounts Department |
| Persons (clientele) | Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Department of Ex-Servicemen Welfare |
| Place (area) | Ministry of Development of North Eastern Region |
- Lyndall Urwick, The Elements of Administration (1943), integrated Taylor and Fayol into one set of principles.
James Mooney and Alan Reiley
Onward Industry! (1931; revised as The Principles of Organization, 1939) found three principles common to the church, the army and business: the co-ordinative principle, the scalar principle (hierarchy) and the functional principle (functional differentiation, including line and staff).
The core principles of organisation
| Principle | Meaning | Note for MCQs |
|---|---|---|
| Hierarchy (scalar chain) | Graded levels of authority, each superior to the one below | Mooney-Reiley “scalar principle”; Fayol “scalar chain” |
| Unity of command | Each subordinate receives orders from one superior only | Violated by Taylor’s functional foremanship |
| Span of control | Number of subordinates one superior can effectively supervise | Urwick: ideally no more than five or six whose work interlocks |
| Delegation | Transfer of authority (not ultimate responsibility) to subordinates | Responsibility cannot be delegated away |
| Centralisation / decentralisation | Where decision-making authority lies | Fayol: a matter of proportion |
| Line and staff | Line agencies carry out the main work and command; staff agencies advise and assist | Staff has no command authority; examples: Cabinet Secretariat, PMO (staff); ministries (line) |
| Co-ordination | Harmonising the activities of different units | Mooney-Reiley: the “first principle” of organisation |
| Specialisation | Division of work by function or skill | Fayol’s first principle |
Span of control and Graicunas’s formula
V.A. Graicunas, a Lithuanian management consultant working in France, in “Relationship in Organization” (1933, reprinted in Gulick and Urwick, 1937), showed that as subordinates are added arithmetically, the relationships a superior must manage grow exponentially. With \( n \) subordinates:
- direct single relationships: \( n \)
- direct group relationships: \( n(2^{n-1} - 1) \)
- cross relationships (among subordinates): \( n(n-1) \)
| Subordinates \( n \) | Direct single | Direct group | Cross | Total \( R \) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 6 |
| 3 | 3 | 9 | 6 | 18 |
| 4 | 4 | 28 | 12 | 44 |
| 5 | 5 | 75 | 20 | 100 |
| 6 | 6 | 186 | 30 | 222 |
| 7 | 7 | 441 | 42 | 490 |
Factors affecting the span: nature of work (routine vs varied), competence of the superior and subordinates, physical dispersion, degree of delegation, use of staff assistance and technology. A narrow span creates a tall structure (many levels); a wide span creates a flat one.
Criticisms of the principles school
- Simon (1946): the principles are proverbs that contradict each other (see page 1).
- Based on the experience of practitioners, not tested research.
- Treats organisations as closed systems and people as interchangeable parts (“machine model”).
- Neglects informal organisation and human motives.
4. Bureaucratic Theory: Max Weber
Max Weber (1864–1920), German sociologist; his main statement is in Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft (Economy and Society, published posthumously, 1922).
Authority as the base
Weber distinguished power (the ability to impose one’s will despite resistance) from authority (legitimate domination, which people obey because they believe it rightful). He named three pure types:
| Type | Basis of legitimacy | Administrative staff |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional | Sanctity of age-old custom (kings, chiefs) | Personal retainers, patrimonial officials |
| Charismatic | Extraordinary personal qualities of a leader (prophets, heroes) | Disciples; no regular staff; must be “routinised” to last |
| Legal-rational | Belief in the legality of enacted rules and the right of those appointed under them | Bureaucracy |
Bureaucracy is the purest form of legal-rational authority.
Features of the ideal-type bureaucracy
An ideal type is not an ideal (a model to admire) but an analytical construct that accentuates the essential features of a phenomenon, used to compare real cases.
The organisation:
- Fixed official jurisdictional areas, ordered by rules (laws or administrative regulations)
- Hierarchy of offices: a firmly ordered system of super- and subordination
- Management based on written documents (the files) and a staff of clerks
- Expert training for office management
- Official activity demands the full working capacity of the official
- Management follows general rules that are stable, exhaustive and can be learned
The official:
- Appointed (not elected), on the basis of technical qualifications
- Paid a fixed salary, with a pension
- Office is a career, with promotion by seniority or merit
- Separated from ownership of the means of administration (cannot own the office)
- Subject to strict discipline and control
- Acts impersonally (sine ira et studio, “without anger or passion”)
Why bureaucracy spreads: Weber held it to be technically superior to other forms in precision, speed, unambiguity, knowledge of the files, continuity, discretion, unity, strict subordination and reduction of friction and costs. He also feared its power: the “iron cage” image (from his Protestant Ethic, in Talcott Parsons’s translation) expresses his worry that rationalisation would imprison modern life.
Critics of bureaucracy
| Critic | Work (year) | Criticism |
|---|---|---|
| Robert K. Merton | “Bureaucratic Structure and Personality” (1940) | Dysfunctions: rules become ends in themselves (goal displacement); “trained incapacity” (a term he took from Thorstein Veblen); rigidity, timidity, red tape |
| Philip Selznick | TVA and the Grass Roots (1949) | Co-optation; sub-units develop their own goals, diverging from the organisation’s |
| Alvin Gouldner | Patterns of Industrial Bureaucracy (1954) | Three patterns: mock (rules ignored by all), representative (rules agreed by both sides), punishment-centred (rules imposed by one side) |
| Peter Blau | The Dynamics of Bureaucracy (1955) | Informal practices and adaptation inside bureaucracy |
| Michel Crozier | The Bureaucratic Phenomenon (French 1963, English 1964) | “Vicious circle”: rigidity breeds more rules, which breed more rigidity; bureaucracy cannot correct itself from its errors |
| Warren Bennis | “The Coming Death of Bureaucracy” (1966) | Predicted bureaucracy would give way to temporary, adaptive, problem-solving systems |
| Karl Marx | Critique of Hegel’s philosophy of right (1843) | Bureaucracy serves the ruling class, not a universal interest |
| Human relations school | — | Ignores informal organisation and human needs |
Two humorous “laws” sometimes appear as options:
- Parkinson’s Law (C. Northcote Parkinson, 1955): “Work expands so as to fill the time available for its completion”; officials multiply subordinates, not rivals.
- The Peter Principle (Laurence J. Peter and Raymond Hull, 1969): in a hierarchy every employee tends to rise to his level of incompetence.
Representative bureaucracy: J. Donald Kingsley, Representative Bureaucracy (1944), argued that a bureaucracy should reflect the social composition of the society it serves; in India, reservation in public services is often discussed in these terms.
5. Human Relations Theory: Elton Mayo and the Hawthorne Studies
George Elton Mayo (1880–1949), an Australian-born psychologist at the Harvard Business School, is called the father of the human relations movement. The studies were done at the Hawthorne Works of the Western Electric Company near Chicago, roughly 1924–1932.
The four phases
| Phase | Approx. years | What was done | Finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Illumination experiments | 1924–1927 | Lighting varied for a test group, kept constant for a control group | Output rose in both groups, even when light was reduced; physical factors alone did not explain output |
| 2. Relay assembly test room | 1927–1932 | Six women assembling relays; rest pauses, shorter hours, refreshments changed one by one | Output kept rising even when privileges were withdrawn; the cause was attention, a friendly supervisor and group feeling |
| 3. Mass interviewing programme | 1928–1930 | Over 20,000 workers interviewed, moving from direct questions to non-directive interviews | Workers’ attitudes depend on their social situation; being listened to itself improved morale |
| 4. Bank wiring observation room | 1931–1932 | Fourteen men wiring telephone banks, paid by group piece-rate, observed | The informal group set its own output norm and enforced it: neither a “rate-buster” nor a “chiseler” nor a “squealer” |
The full report: F.J. Roethlisberger and W.J. Dickson, Management and the Worker (1939). Mayo’s own books: The Human Problems of an Industrial Civilization (1933) and The Social Problems of an Industrial Civilization (1945).
Main findings
- The worker is a social man, not just an economic man; money is only one motive.
- The informal group shapes output through its own norms, sanctions and leaders.
- Attention, recognition and participation raise morale and productivity.
- Supervision style matters: friendly, supportive supervisors get better results.
- Communication (listening, two-way flow) is central to managing.
- The organisation is a social system, not just a technical one.
The tendency of people to change behaviour because they know they are being studied was later named the Hawthorne effect.
Criticisms
- Methodological: small samples (six women in the relay room), uncontrolled variables, researchers’ influence.
- Manipulative: uses “happiness” to raise output without changing power relations (“cow sociology”, a jibe of some critics: contented cows give more milk).
- Ignores conflict, trade unions and the wider environment; pro-management bias.
- Over-reacts to Taylor: neglects structure and economic incentives.
From human relations to behavioural and neo-human relations
The Hawthorne studies opened the way for Barnard (informal organisation, 1938), Simon (behavioural decision-making) and the “neo-human relations” motivation theorists — Maslow, McGregor, Herzberg, Argyris, Likert — taught on Leadership and Motivation. Mary Parker Follett anticipated many of Mayo’s ideas from the 1920s: see Communication, Conflict and MBO.
6. The Three Theories Compared
| Scientific management | Bureaucratic theory | Human relations | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Founder | F.W. Taylor | Max Weber | Elton Mayo |
| Key work | Principles of Scientific Management (1911) | Economy and Society (1922) | Hawthorne studies (1924–32); Management and the Worker (1939) |
| Focus | Shop-floor tasks, efficiency | Structure, rules, authority | People, groups, morale |
| View of the person | Economic man | Rule-following official | Social man |
| Motivator | Money (piece-rate) | Career, salary, security | Recognition, belonging, participation |
| Organisation seen as | A machine | A rational legal structure | A social system |
| Informal organisation | Ignored | Ignored | Central |
| Main critics | Unions, Mayo | Merton, Selznick, Gouldner, Crozier | Marxists, behaviouralists, methodologists |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Unity of command — one boss per subordinate | vs | Unity of direction — one head and one plan for activities with one objective |
| Taylor — shop floor, bottom-up, efficiency of the worker | vs | Fayol — top management, top-down, functions of management |
| Scalar chain — line of authority (Fayol) | vs | Gangplank — authorised horizontal shortcut across the chain |
| Line agency — command, main work | vs | Staff agency — advice, no command |
| Ideal type — analytical model | vs | Ideal — a desirable state |
| Merton — trained incapacity, goal displacement | vs | Crozier — vicious circle |
| Selznick — co-optation (TVA) | vs | Gouldner — mock / representative / punishment-centred |
| Relay assembly test room — six women, attention effect | vs | Bank wiring room — fourteen men, informal output norms |
| Mayo — interpreter and leader of the human relations school | vs | Roethlisberger and Dickson — authors of the full report (1939) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who wrote The Principles of Scientific Management (1911)?
- In which company’s works were the Hawthorne studies conducted?
- Which of Weber’s three types of authority corresponds to bureaucracy?
Answers
- F.W. Taylor.
- Western Electric Company (Hawthorne Works, near Chicago).
- Legal-rational authority.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Using Graicunas’s formula, how many relationships does a superior with four subordinates potentially have to manage?
- (a) 16
- (b) 28
- (c) 44
- (d) 100
Answer and explanation
(c) 44. \( R = n(2^{n-1} + n - 1) = 4(2^{3} + 4 - 1) = 4 \times 11 = 44 \): 4 direct single + 28 direct group + 12 cross relationships. 100 is the figure for five subordinates.
Q2. (Practice) Which of the following is not one of Fayol’s fourteen principles of management?
- (a) Esprit de corps
- (b) Stability of tenure of personnel
- (c) Functional foremanship
- (d) Unity of direction
Answer and explanation
(c) Functional foremanship is Taylor’s technique, and it conflicts with Fayol’s unity of command.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Weber’s bureaucracy:
- Officials are elected by the people they serve.
- Officials are separated from ownership of the means of administration.
- Administrative acts are recorded in writing.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 2 and 3 only. Weber’s officials are appointed on the basis of technical qualifications, not elected.
Q4. (Practice) The “bank wiring observation room” phase of the Hawthorne studies is best known for showing that:
- (a) brighter lighting increases output
- (b) informal groups set and enforce their own output norms
- (c) rest pauses always raise productivity
- (d) workers respond only to monetary incentives
Answer and explanation
(b). The men restricted output to a group norm despite a group piece-rate that rewarded more output.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Taylor’s system of functional foremanship conflicts with Fayol’s principle of unity of command. Reason (R): Under functional foremanship a worker receives orders from several specialist foremen.
Answer and explanation
(a). Eight foremen giving instructions to one worker is exactly what breaks unity of command.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Merton argued that strict adherence to rules can produce dysfunctions in bureaucracy. Reason (R): Merton held that bureaucracy is the purest form of charismatic authority.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true (goal displacement, trained incapacity). R is false: bureaucracy is legal-rational authority in Weber’s typology, and the claim is not Merton’s.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Author) with List II (Work).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Henri Fayol | I. Patterns of Industrial Bureaucracy |
| B. Alvin Gouldner | II. Management and the Worker |
| C. Roethlisberger and Dickson | III. General and Industrial Management |
| D. Michel Crozier | IV. The Bureaucratic Phenomenon |
- (a) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
- (b) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
- (c) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
- (d) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
Answer and explanation
(a) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the phases of the Hawthorne studies in the order in which they began:
- Bank wiring observation room
- Illumination experiments
- Mass interviewing programme
- Relay assembly test room
- (a) 2, 4, 3, 1
- (b) 2, 3, 4, 1
- (c) 4, 2, 3, 1
- (d) 2, 4, 1, 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 2, 4, 3, 1. Illumination (from 1924) → relay assembly (from 1927) → interviews (from 1928) → bank wiring (1931–32).
Q5. (Practice) Arrange in chronological order of publication:
- Merton, “Bureaucratic Structure and Personality”
- Taylor, Shop Management
- Mooney and Reiley, Onward Industry!
- Fayol, Administration industrielle et générale
- (a) 2, 4, 3, 1
- (b) 4, 2, 3, 1
- (c) 2, 3, 4, 1
- (d) 2, 4, 1, 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 2, 4, 3, 1. 1903 → 1916 → 1931 → 1940.
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| F.W. Taylor | Shop Management / Principles of Scientific Management | 1903 / 1911 | One best way; time-motion study; functional foremanship; mental revolution |
| Henri Fayol | Administration industrielle et générale | 1916 (Eng. 1949) | 14 principles; POCCC; gangplank |
| Mooney and Reiley | Onward Industry! | 1931 | Co-ordinative, scalar, functional principles |
| V.A. Graicunas | “Relationship in Organization” | 1933 | \( R = n(2^{n-1} + n - 1) \) |
| Gulick and Urwick | Papers on the Science of Administration | 1937 | POSDCORB; 4 Ps |
| Urwick | The Elements of Administration | 1943 | Synthesis; span of five or six |
| Max Weber | Economy and Society | 1922 | Ideal-type bureaucracy; legal-rational authority |
| Merton | “Bureaucratic Structure and Personality” | 1940 | Goal displacement; trained incapacity |
| Kingsley | Representative Bureaucracy | 1944 | Bureaucracy should mirror society |
| Selznick | TVA and the Grass Roots | 1949 | Co-optation |
| Gouldner | Patterns of Industrial Bureaucracy | 1954 | Mock, representative, punishment-centred |
| Blau | The Dynamics of Bureaucracy | 1955 | Informal adaptation |
| Crozier | The Bureaucratic Phenomenon | 1963 | Vicious circle |
| Bennis | “The Coming Death of Bureaucracy” | 1966 | Adaptive, temporary systems |
| Elton Mayo | Human Problems of an Industrial Civilization | 1933 | Social man; Hawthorne (1924–32) |
| Roethlisberger and Dickson | Management and the Worker | 1939 | Full Hawthorne report |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Rational Choice, NPA, Development Administration and NPM — what replaced the classical consensus
- Leadership and Motivation — Maslow, McGregor and Herzberg build on Mayo
- Communication, Conflict and MBO — Barnard and Follett, who bridged classical and human relations thinking
- Public Administration — Quick Revision