Rational Choice, NPA, Development and Comparative Administration, NPM
Public choice, New Public Administration, development and comparative administration, New Public Management and governance after 1991 for UGC NET.
- 18 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Four Answers to “What Went Wrong with the Bureaucratic State?”
- 1. Where Scientific Management Fits
- 2. Rational Choice (Public Choice) Theory
- 3. New Public Administration (NPA)
- 4. Comparative Public Administration (CPA)
- 5. Development Administration
- 6. New Public Management (NPM)
- 7. Public Administration in the Era of Liberalisation and Globalisation
- Timeline
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Meaning, Evolution and Approaches — Henry’s paradigms and Riggs’s ecological model, which this page continues.
- Theories of Organisation — scientific management and Weber’s bureaucracy, the “orthodoxy” that every theory here criticises.
- Development and Democratisation — modernisation and dependency theories, the background to development administration.
The Hook: Four Answers to “What Went Wrong with the Bureaucratic State?”
How UGC NET asks it: Minnowbrook years and themes; public choice authors and books (Buchanan and Tullock, Downs, Niskanen, Ostrom); Hood’s seven doctrines and Osborne and Gaebler’s ten principles; Riggs and the Comparative Administration Group; “administration of development” vs “development of administration”; NPM vs New Public Service; governance and the state as “facilitator” after 1991.
1. Where Scientific Management Fits
The syllabus lists scientific management both here (as a theory and concept of public administration) and under theories of organisation. The full treatment of Taylor is on Theories of Organisation. For this line, remember three links:
- It gave public administration its first ideal of efficiency and of administration as a science (the “principles” paradigm).
- It shaped O&M units, work study and performance standards in government.
- NPM (section 6) is often described as “neo-Taylorism”: measurement, targets and managerial control return in a market setting.
2. Rational Choice (Public Choice) Theory
Assumptions
- Methodological individualism — explain collective outcomes by individual choices.
- Self-interest — individuals (voters, politicians, bureaucrats) are rational utility-maximisers, in politics as in the market.
- Rationality — they rank preferences consistently and choose the means that best serve them.
Public choice is the application of these economic assumptions to politics and administration: “politics without romance”.
Key thinkers
| Thinker | Work (year) | Contribution |
|---|---|---|
| Anthony Downs | An Economic Theory of Democracy (1957) | Parties and voters as rational actors; median voter |
| James Buchanan and Gordon Tullock | The Calculus of Consent (1962) | Founding text of public choice; constitutional choice; costs of collective decisions. Buchanan won the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1986 |
| Gordon Tullock | The Politics of Bureaucracy (1965) | Bureaucrats pursue career interests; information distortion up the hierarchy |
| Mancur Olson | The Logic of Collective Action (1965) | Free-rider problem; small, concentrated groups organise better than large, diffuse ones |
| Anthony Downs | Inside Bureaucracy (1967) | Five types of officials (below); “law of increasing conservatism” |
| William Niskanen | Bureaucracy and Representative Government (1971) | Budget-maximising bureaucrat: bureaus oversupply output because they know their costs better than the legislature (information asymmetry) |
| Vincent Ostrom | The Intellectual Crisis in American Public Administration (1973) | The Wilson–Weber paradigm of a single centre of bureaucratic power is in crisis; proposes democratic administration with polycentric, overlapping jurisdictions |
| Patrick Dunleavy | Democracy, Bureaucracy and Public Choice (1991) | Bureau-shaping model: senior officials prefer to shape their bureaus into small, elite, policy-making units rather than simply maximise budgets |
| Elinor Ostrom | Governing the Commons (1990) | Communities can manage common-pool resources without either state or market; Nobel Prize in Economics 2009 |
Downs’s five types of bureaucrats (Inside Bureaucracy, 1967):
| Type | Motivated by |
|---|---|
| Climbers | Power, income, prestige: their own advancement |
| Conservers | Security and convenience; resist change |
| Zealots | Loyalty to a narrow policy or programme |
| Advocates | Loyalty to their whole organisation or a broader set of functions |
| Statesmen | Loyalty to the nation or society as a whole |
(Climbers and conservers are purely self-interested; zealots, advocates and statesmen are “mixed-motive” officials.)
Related ideas
- Principal–agent theory: the citizen or minister (principal) cannot fully monitor the official (agent), who may pursue his own interest; hence contracts, incentives and performance measurement.
- Rent-seeking: using political influence to obtain privileges (licences, quotas) instead of creating wealth.
- Government failure: the public-choice counterpart to “market failure”: government, too, can fail through self-interest, information problems and capture.
Implications for administration
Contract out, privatise, create competition among agencies, decentralise to many small jurisdictions, use user charges, and constrain bureaucrats with rules. These became central planks of NPM.
Criticisms
- The self-interest assumption is too narrow: officials also act from duty, professional norms and public service motivation.
- Empirical support for budget maximisation is weak (Dunleavy’s own revision).
- Ideological bias towards the minimal state; ignores equity.
- Treats citizens only as customers.
3. New Public Administration (NPA)
Background
- The turbulent 1960s in the United States: the civil rights movement, urban riots, the Vietnam war, poverty.
- The Honey Report on higher education for public service (1967) and the Philadelphia Conference on the theory and practice of public administration (1967) raised doubts about the field.
- Mainstream public administration (efficiency, economy, value-neutrality) seemed irrelevant to these problems.
Minnowbrook I (1968)
Dwight Waldo, then at Syracuse University, sponsored a conference of young scholars at the Minnowbrook Conference Centre (Syracuse University), in 1968. The papers were published as Toward a New Public Administration: The Minnowbrook Perspective (ed. Frank Marini, 1971). H. George Frederickson became the leading voice; his book New Public Administration appeared in 1980.
Themes (goals) of NPA
| Theme | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Relevance | Study real public problems, not abstract efficiency |
| Values | Openly normative; reject value-neutral (Simon-style) positivism |
| Social equity | Administration should actively reduce inequalities; equity joins efficiency and economy as a goal |
| Change | Administration should promote change, not preserve the status quo |
| Client orientation and participation | Citizens and clients involved in decisions; decentralised, participatory structures |
NPA was anti-positivist, anti-hierarchical (it favoured smaller, decentralised, democratic organisations) and client-focused.
Later Minnowbrooks
Minnowbrook II (1988) and Minnowbrook III (2008) revisited the agenda, adding concerns such as diversity, leadership, ethics, technology and globalisation.
Criticisms
- More a mood or protest than a theory; its prescriptions were vague.
- Asking bureaucrats to pursue social equity on their own judgement could weaken democratic control by elected representatives.
- Its participatory ideas were hard to put into practice in large organisations.
4. Comparative Public Administration (CPA)
Why it arose
- After the Second World War the United States ran technical assistance programmes in newly independent countries; Western administrative models often failed there.
- Robert Dahl (1947) had warned that no science of administration was possible without comparative study.
- The behavioural movement and comparative politics (Almond and others) encouraged system-wide comparison.
The Comparative Administration Group (CAG)
The CAG was set up in 1960 within the American Society for Public Administration, with Fred Riggs as its chairman, and was funded by the Ford Foundation. It produced many studies of administration in developing countries during the 1960s; its activity declined in the early 1970s when funding ended.
Riggs’s three trends in CPA (1962)
- From normative to empirical approaches
- From idiographic (single-case, descriptive) to nomothetic (generalising, law-seeking) approaches
- From non-ecological to ecological approaches
Approaches in CPA (Ferrel Heady)
Ferrel Heady, Public Administration: A Comparative Perspective (first edition 1966), grouped the approaches as:
| Approach | Example |
|---|---|
| Modified traditional | Comparison of institutions (civil services) across countries |
| Development-oriented | Edward Weidner: administration for development goals |
| General system model-building | Riggs’s fused–prismatic–diffracted model |
| Middle-range theory | Weber’s bureaucracy as the focus of comparison |
Models used in CPA
- Bureaucratic model (Weber): the most common unit of comparison.
- Structural-functional (Almond, Parsons): which structures perform which functions.
- Ecological model (Gaus, Riggs): administration in its setting.
- Riggs’s models: Agraria and Industria (1957); fused, prismatic, diffracted (1964); the sala (see page 1).
Criticisms
Too abstract; Western bias; heavy jargon; little practical guidance; models were hard to test empirically; it lost momentum when funding ended.
5. Development Administration
Meaning
Development administration is administration directed at planned socio-economic change: nation-building and economic development in the new states. Indian textbooks usually credit the term to U.L. Goswami (1955); it was developed and popularised by Fred Riggs and Edward Weidner within the CAG.
Edward Weidner defined it as an action-oriented, goal-oriented administrative system, concerned with achieving progressive political, economic and social objectives.
Riggs’s two sides
| Administration of development | Development of administration (administrative development) |
|---|---|
| Using administration to carry out development programmes (plans, projects, welfare schemes) | Improving the administrative system itself: its capacity, skills, structures |
| Development is the goal | Administration is the goal |
The two are interdependent: a weak administration cannot deliver development, and development changes the administrative environment.
Development administration vs traditional administration
| Feature | Traditional (general) administration | Development administration |
|---|---|---|
| Orientation | Maintenance of law and order, revenue | Change, development, nation-building |
| Goals | Stable, routine | Goal-oriented, results-oriented |
| Structure | Hierarchical, centralised | Flexible, decentralised, participatory |
| Attitude to citizens | Subjects to be regulated | Clients and participants |
| Method | Rules and procedures | Innovation, planning, projects |
| Time | No urgency | Temporal dimension: targets with deadlines |
| Ecology | Ignored | Ecology-sensitive |
Features (often listed)
Change orientation, goal orientation, client orientation, citizen participation, innovativeness, effectiveness in delivering results, flexibility, ecological sensitivity, and a temporal (time-bound) dimension.
India as a case
Five-Year Plans, the Community Development Programme (1952), district planning and the Panchayati Raj institutions (constitutional status by the 73rd and 74th Amendments, 1992) made India a laboratory of development administration. The Planning Commission (1950) was replaced by the NITI Aayog in 2015.
Criticisms
- Bureaucracy-centred: assumed that administrators would lead development, sometimes at the cost of democracy and participation.
- Western, modernisation-theory bias; assumed development means becoming like the West.
- By the 1980s, debt crises and the turn to markets moved attention to NPM, structural adjustment and later governance.
6. New Public Management (NPM)
Origins
1980s reforms in Britain (Thatcher: Financial Management Initiative, 1982; Next Steps executive agencies, 1988; the Citizen’s Charter, 1991, under John Major), New Zealand (State Sector Act, 1988), Australia and the United States (the National Performance Review, 1993, led by Vice-President Al Gore). Its intellectual sources are public choice theory, principal–agent and transaction-cost economics, and private-sector managerialism (Christopher Pollitt, Managerialism and the Public Services, 1990).
Christopher Hood’s seven doctrines
Christopher Hood, “A Public Management for All Seasons?” (Public Administration, 1991), the article that popularised the term “New Public Management”:
- Hands-on professional management — visible managers at the top, free to manage
- Explicit standards and measures of performance
- Greater emphasis on output controls (results rather than procedures)
- Disaggregation of units (break up large departments into agencies)
- Greater competition (contracts, tendering)
- Private-sector styles of management practice
- Stress on discipline and parsimony in resource use (“do more with less”)
Osborne and Gaebler: Reinventing Government (1992)
David Osborne and Ted Gaebler argued for an entrepreneurial government that “steers rather than rows”. Their ten principles:
| # | Government should be… | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Catalytic | Steering rather than rowing |
| 2 | Community-owned | Empowering rather than serving |
| 3 | Competitive | Injecting competition into service delivery |
| 4 | Mission-driven | Transforming rule-driven organisations |
| 5 | Results-oriented | Funding outcomes, not inputs |
| 6 | Customer-driven | Meeting the needs of the customer, not the bureaucracy |
| 7 | Enterprising | Earning rather than spending |
| 8 | Anticipatory | Prevention rather than cure |
| 9 | Decentralised | From hierarchy to participation and teamwork |
| 10 | Market-oriented | Leveraging change through the market |
Main features of NPM, summarised
Managerial autonomy (“let managers manage”), performance targets and indicators, output and outcome budgeting, executive agencies, contracting out, public–private partnerships, privatisation and disinvestment, user charges, citizens as customers, citizen’s charters.
Criticisms
- Citizen reduced to customer; equity and rights neglected.
- Accountability is blurred when services are contracted out.
- Fragmentation of government into many agencies weakens co-ordination.
- Measurement distorts behaviour (gaming of targets).
- Ignores the public-private differences that Appleby stressed; “neo-Taylorism”.
After NPM
| Model | Author (year) | Core claim |
|---|---|---|
| New Public Service | Janet and Robert Denhardt, “The New Public Service: Serving Rather than Steering” (Public Administration Review, 2000) | Serve citizens, not customers; seek the public interest; value citizenship over entrepreneurship; “serve rather than steer” |
| Governance / network governance | R.A.W. Rhodes, “governing without government” (1996) | Policy made through networks of state, market and civil society actors |
| New Public Governance | Stephen Osborne (2006) | Plural, inter-organisational delivery; relationships over markets |
| Good governance | World Bank (Sub-Saharan Africa: From Crisis to Sustainable Growth, 1989; Governance and Development, 1992) | Accountability, transparency, rule of law, participation, efficiency |
7. Public Administration in the Era of Liberalisation and Globalisation
What changed
| Before (welfare / developmental state) | After (liberalisation and globalisation) |
|---|---|
| State as provider and producer (public sector “commanding heights”) | State as facilitator, enabler and regulator |
| Licence, permit and quota controls | Deregulation; independent regulatory agencies |
| Rowing | Steering |
| Government | Governance (state + market + civil society) |
| Citizens as beneficiaries | Citizens as customers, stakeholders and partners |
| Closed, secretive administration | Transparency, Right to Information, e-governance |
| National policy space | Policy shaped by global markets and institutions (WTO, IMF, World Bank), global competition |
The British scholar R.A.W. Rhodes described the resulting shrinkage of the central state’s direct role as the “hollowing out of the state” (1994).
The Indian experience
| Year | Marker |
|---|---|
| 1991 | New Economic Policy: liberalisation, privatisation, globalisation (LPG); dereservation and delicensing; disinvestment begins |
| 1992 | 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments (in force 1993): constitutional local self-government, decentralisation |
| 1997 | Citizen’s Charter initiative launched in India |
| 2005 | Right to Information Act; Second Administrative Reforms Commission set up |
| 2006 | National e-Governance Plan |
| 2015 | NITI Aayog replaces the Planning Commission; Digital India launched |
Regulatory agencies of the period include SEBI (statutory powers from 1992), TRAI (1997) and the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority (1999, now IRDAI).
Debates
- Minimal vs strong state: liberalisation needs a capable state to regulate markets, protect the vulnerable and enforce contracts. The World Bank’s World Development Report 1997 was titled The State in a Changing World and stressed state capability.
- Accountability: who answers for a privatised or contracted-out service?
- Equity: market reforms may widen inequality; NPA’s social equity concern returns.
- Sovereignty: global institutions and capital constrain national administrative choices.
- Convergence? Some argue globalisation is making administrations more alike; others stress path dependence and local ecology (Riggs’s lesson).
Timeline
graph LR
A["1955
'Development administration'
(Goswami)"] --> B["1960
CAG founded
(Riggs)"]
B --> C["1962
Calculus of Consent"]
C --> D["1968
Minnowbrook I
(NPA)"]
D --> E["1971 / 1973
Niskanen;
V. Ostrom"]
E --> F["1991
Hood's NPM;
India's LPG"]
F --> G["1992
Reinventing
Government"]
G --> H["2000
New Public
Service"]Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| New Public Administration (1968, Minnowbrook) — equity, values | vs | New Public Management (1980s–90s) — markets, efficiency, customers |
| New Public Management — steer, customers | vs | New Public Service (Denhardts, 2000) — serve, citizens |
| Vincent Ostrom — Intellectual Crisis (1973), democratic administration | vs | Elinor Ostrom — Governing the Commons (1990), Nobel 2009 |
| Niskanen — budget-maximising (1971) | vs | Dunleavy — bureau-shaping (1991) |
| Administration of development — administration for development programmes | vs | Development of administration — building administrative capacity |
| Comparative public administration — study of administration across systems (CAG, 1960) | vs | Development administration — administration for planned change in developing countries |
| Hood (1991) — seven doctrines of NPM | vs | Osborne and Gaebler (1992) — ten principles of entrepreneurial government |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- In which year was the first Minnowbrook Conference held?
- Who described bureaucrats as budget-maximisers in Bureaucracy and Representative Government (1971)?
- Which phrase did Osborne and Gaebler use for catalytic government?
Answers
- 1968.
- William Niskanen.
- “Steering rather than rowing.”
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Which of the following is not among the themes of the New Public Administration?
- (a) Relevance
- (b) Social equity
- (c) Value-neutrality
- (d) Change
Answer and explanation
(c) Value-neutrality. NPA openly embraced values and rejected the value-neutral, positivist stance associated with Simon.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Vincent Ostrom proposed “democratic administration” based on polycentric jurisdictions.
- Patrick Dunleavy’s bureau-shaping model holds that senior officials always prefer to maximise their bureau’s total budget.
- The Calculus of Consent was written by James Buchanan and Gordon Tullock.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Statement 2 describes Niskanen’s model; Dunleavy argued that senior officials prefer to shape their bureaus into small, policy-focused units rather than maximise budgets.
Q3. (Practice) “Disaggregation of units” and “greater emphasis on output controls” are among the doctrines of New Public Management listed by:
- (a) David Osborne and Ted Gaebler
- (b) Christopher Hood
- (c) H. George Frederickson
- (d) Janet and Robert Denhardt
Answer and explanation
(b) Christopher Hood, “A Public Management for All Seasons?” (1991), seven doctrines.
Q4. (Practice) Fred Riggs’s distinction between “administration of development” and “development of administration” belongs to which field?
- (a) New Public Management
- (b) Development administration
- (c) Public choice theory
- (d) Scientific management
Answer and explanation
(b) Development administration. The first uses administration to implement development; the second builds the capacity of administration itself.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Public choice theorists favour contracting out and competition in the delivery of public services. Reason (R): Public choice theory assumes that bureaucrats, like other individuals, pursue their own interests.
Answer and explanation
(a). Because self-interested bureaucrats will expand their bureaus and budgets, competition and contracting are proposed to discipline them; R explains A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): The New Public Service model treats citizens primarily as customers. Reason (R): The Denhardts argued that public administrators should serve rather than steer.
Answer and explanation
(d). A is false: it is NPM that treats citizens as customers; the New Public Service insists on serving citizens. R is true.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Author) with List II (Work).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Anthony Downs | I. Reinventing Government |
| B. Frank Marini (ed.) | II. Inside Bureaucracy |
| C. Osborne and Gaebler | III. The Intellectual Crisis in American Public Administration |
| D. Vincent Ostrom | IV. Toward a New Public Administration |
- (a) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (b) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (c) A-III, B-IV, C-I, D-II
- (d) A-IV, B-II, C-I, D-III
Answer and explanation
(a) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order:
- Publication of Reinventing Government
- Minnowbrook I conference
- Setting up of the Comparative Administration Group
- Publication of Niskanen’s Bureaucracy and Representative Government
- (a) 3, 2, 4, 1
- (b) 2, 3, 4, 1
- (c) 3, 4, 2, 1
- (d) 3, 2, 1, 4
Answer and explanation
(a) 3, 2, 4, 1. CAG (1960) → Minnowbrook I (1968) → Niskanen (1971) → Osborne and Gaebler (1992).
Quick Revision Table
| Theory / event | Who | Year | Key point |
|---|---|---|---|
| “Development administration” | U.L. Goswami (as credited in Indian texts) | 1955 | Administration for planned change |
| An Economic Theory of Democracy | Anthony Downs | 1957 | Rational voters and parties |
| Comparative Administration Group | Fred Riggs (chair), ASPA, Ford Foundation | 1960 | Comparative public administration |
| The Calculus of Consent | Buchanan and Tullock | 1962 | Founding public choice text |
| Public Administration: A Comparative Perspective | Ferrel Heady | 1966 | Four approaches to CPA |
| Inside Bureaucracy | Anthony Downs | 1967 | Climbers, conservers, zealots, advocates, statesmen |
| Minnowbrook I | Dwight Waldo (sponsor) | 1968 | NPA: relevance, values, equity, change |
| Toward a New Public Administration | Frank Marini (ed.) | 1971 | Minnowbrook papers |
| Bureaucracy and Representative Government | William Niskanen | 1971 | Budget-maximising bureaucrat |
| The Intellectual Crisis in American Public Administration | Vincent Ostrom | 1973 | Democratic administration, polycentricity |
| Governing the Commons | Elinor Ostrom | 1990 | Commons; Nobel 2009 |
| “A Public Management for All Seasons?” | Christopher Hood | 1991 | Seven doctrines of NPM |
| Bureau-shaping model | Patrick Dunleavy | 1991 | Senior officials shape bureaus |
| Reinventing Government | Osborne and Gaebler | 1992 | Ten principles; steering not rowing |
| National Performance Review | Al Gore (US) | 1993 | Reinvention in practice |
| “The New Public Service” | Denhardt and Denhardt | 2000 | Serve citizens rather than steer |
| India: LPG reforms | — | 1991 | State as facilitator and regulator |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Leadership and Motivation — how managers get results from people, the “managing the organisation” line
- Communication, Conflict and MBO — Drucker’s MBO, a forerunner of NPM’s results orientation
- Development and Democratisation — modernisation and dependency theories behind development administration
- Public Administration — Quick Revision