Public Administration: Meaning, Evolution and Approaches
Meaning and evolution of public administration, public vs private administration, and the systems, decision-making and ecological approaches for UGC NET.
- 19 min
On this page · 13 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: An Essay That Founded a Discipline
- 1. Meaning of Public Administration
- 2. Evolution of the Discipline
- 3. Public and Private Administration
- 4. Approaches to the Study of Public Administration
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- The chapter overview for how this unit is asked.
- Approaches and Comparative Methods — the behavioural movement (Easton, Almond), whose systems thinking public administration borrowed.
- Research Meaning, Types and Approaches (Paper 1) — positivism and the fact–value distinction, which Simon brought into the study of administration.
The Hook: An Essay That Founded a Discipline
How UGC NET asks it: definitions matched to authors (Wilson, White, Gulick, Simon); Nicholas Henry’s five paradigms in sequence; the politics–administration dichotomy as assertion–reason; public versus private administration (Appleby, Sayre); Simon’s bounded rationality and satisficing; Riggs’s fused–prismatic–diffracted model and Gaus’s ecological factors.
1. Meaning of Public Administration
“Public administration” has two senses, and questions sometimes turn on the difference:
- As an activity: the work of government departments, agencies and officials in carrying out public policy.
- As a discipline: the academic study of that activity (usually written with capitals, “Public Administration”).
Classic definitions
| Author | Definition (in substance) | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Woodrow Wilson | “Detailed and systematic execution of public law” | Founding essay, 1887 |
| L.D. White | All those operations having for their purpose the fulfilment or enforcement of public policy | Introduction to the Study of Public Administration (1926), the first textbook |
| Luther Gulick | That part of the science of administration which has to do with government, mainly the executive branch | Managerial view; POSDCORB (1937) |
| Herbert Simon (with Smithburg and Thompson) | Administration is the activities of groups co-operating to accomplish common goals | Behavioural view |
| Dwight Waldo | The organisation and management of people and materials to achieve the purposes of government | Best-known work: The Administrative State (1948) |
Two views of its nature
| Integral view | Managerial view | |
|---|---|---|
| What counts as administration | All activities of officials, from the clerk and the peon to the head of department: manual, clerical, technical and managerial | Only the managerial activities of those at the top (planning, organising, directing, co-ordinating, controlling) |
| Associated with | L.D. White, Marshall Dimock | Luther Gulick, Herbert Simon, Smithburg and Thompson |
| Depends on | The kind of agency’s subject matter | Technique common to all agencies |
Scope: the POSDCORB view and its critics
Luther Gulick, in “Notes on the Theory of Organization” (in Gulick and Urwick, eds, Papers on the Science of Administration, 1937), summed up the work of the chief executive in the acronym POSDCORB:
| Letter | Function |
|---|---|
| P | Planning |
| O | Organising |
| S | Staffing |
| D | Directing |
| CO | Co-ordinating |
| R | Reporting |
| B | Budgeting |
The subject-matter view objects that POSDCORB is only the technique; the real content of administration is the substance of each service (health, police, education). The modern consensus combines the two: administration = technique + substance + its political and social setting.
Is it a science?
Robert Dahl, “The Science of Public Administration: Three Problems” (Public Administration Review, 1947), argued that a science of administration faced three obstacles:
- Normative values — administration cannot be value-free, because ends are chosen politically.
- Human behaviour — people are not machines, so universal “principles” of structure do not hold.
- Social setting — administration differs across nations and cultures, so generalisations need comparative study.
The third problem is the seed of the ecological and comparative approaches below.
2. Evolution of the Discipline
Before Wilson
- Kautilya’s Arthashastra describes the king’s officials, revenue, espionage and the treasury in detail; Indian textbooks treat it as an early treatise on statecraft and administration.
- Cameralism (17th–18th century Germany and Austria): training of officials in the management of state finances and administration; often called the forerunner of the academic study of administration in Europe.
Nicholas Henry’s five paradigms
Nicholas Henry, “Paradigms of Public Administration” (Public Administration Review, 1975), gave the sequence that UGC NET asks most often:
| # | Paradigm | Period (Henry) | Landmark |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Politics–administration dichotomy | 1900–1926 | Frank Goodnow, Politics and Administration (1900): politics expresses the will of the state, administration executes it; L.D. White’s textbook (1926) |
| 2 | Principles of administration | 1927–1937 | W.F. Willoughby, Principles of Public Administration (1927); Gulick and Urwick, Papers on the Science of Administration (1937) |
| — | Challenge (1938–1950) | — | Barnard (1938); Simon, “The Proverbs of Administration” (1946) and Administrative Behavior (1947); Dahl (1947); Waldo, The Administrative State (1948) |
| 3 | Public administration as political science | 1950–1970 | The discipline returns to political science departments but loses its separate identity |
| 4 | Public administration as management (administrative science) | 1956–1970 | Business-school and organisation-theory approach; generic management |
| 5 | Public administration as public administration | 1970 onwards | Separate schools and programmes; focus on policy, public interest and organisation theory |
graph LR
A["1887
Wilson's essay"] --> B["P1: 1900-1926
Dichotomy
Goodnow, White"]
B --> C["P2: 1927-1937
Principles
Willoughby, Gulick-Urwick"]
C --> D["1938-1950
Challenge
Barnard, Simon, Dahl, Waldo"]
D --> E["P3: 1950-1970
As political science"]
D --> F["P4: 1956-1970
As management"]
E --> G["P5: 1970-
As public administration"]
F --> GThe politics–administration dichotomy: for and against
| For (Wilson, Goodnow, early White) | Against (Appleby, Waldo, Dahl) |
|---|---|
| Administration is a field of business, removed from the hurry and strife of politics | Administration is politics: officials make policy daily through discretion |
| Keeps the civil service neutral, merit-based and free of the spoils system | Values cannot be kept out; efficiency itself is a value choice |
| Makes a science of administration possible | Paul Appleby, Policy and Administration (1949): administration is one of the basic political processes |
Wilson himself did not say administration was outside the reach of politics entirely: politics sets the tasks, but should not “manipulate its offices”. The rigid separation is a later textbook reading.
Public administration in India: key markers
| Year | Marker |
|---|---|
| 1953 | Paul Appleby’s first report, Public Administration in India: Report of a Survey |
| 1954 | Indian Institute of Public Administration (IIPA) set up in New Delhi, following Appleby’s recommendation |
| 1966 | First Administrative Reforms Commission (chaired first by Morarji Desai, later K. Hanumanthaiya) |
| 2005 | Second Administrative Reforms Commission (chaired by M. Veerappa Moily) |
3. Public and Private Administration
The similarity view
- Henri Fayol held that administration is a universal activity: the same functions (planning, organising, commanding, co-ordinating, controlling) apply in business, government and other undertakings.
- Lyndall Urwick and the “principles” school: one science of administration for all organisations.
- Simon, Smithburg and Thompson (Public Administration, 1950): the differences are of degree, not kind; large private firms have bureaucracies, files and hierarchies too.
- Both share techniques: accounting, office management, personnel, O&M, information systems.
The difference view
Paul Appleby, Big Democracy (1945), put it in three words: “government is different”. The differences below are the ones textbooks now list.
| Basis | Public administration | Private administration |
|---|---|---|
| Aim | Public interest, welfare, law and order; no profit motive | Profit for owners |
| Political direction | Under elected ministers and legislature | Under owners or the board |
| Accountability | Public: legislature, courts, audit (CAG in India), media, RTI | To shareholders and the market |
| Legal framework | Every action must have legal authority; rule of law | Free to act unless the law forbids |
| Uniformity | Consistency of treatment; equal treatment of citizens | Can discriminate among customers |
| Monopoly | Often a monopoly (defence, police, revenue) | Usually faces competition |
| Financial control | External (budget passed by the legislature) | Internal (management decides) |
| Scale and impact | Very wide; affects the whole society | Narrower |
| Service motive | Must serve even at a loss | Can withdraw from loss-making activities |
| Secrecy / openness | Increasingly open to public scrutiny | Commercial confidentiality |
4. Approaches to the Study of Public Administration
The official syllabus names three approaches: system theory, decision-making and ecological. They arrived in roughly this order of influence in public administration: systems thinking (Barnard, 1938, organisation as a co-operative system), decision-making (Simon, 1947), ecology (Gaus, 1947; Riggs, 1961).
(a) Systems approach
Roots: biologist Ludwig von Bertalanffy’s general systems theory; in politics, David Easton’s political system (The Political System, 1953; A Systems Analysis of Political Life, 1965); in organisation theory, Chester Barnard (organisation as a co-operative system, 1938) and Daniel Katz and Robert Kahn, The Social Psychology of Organizations (1966), the classic statement of the organisation as an open system.
Core idea: an organisation is a set of interdependent parts that takes inputs from its environment, converts them, and returns outputs, with feedback that adjusts later inputs.
graph LR
ENV["Environment
(political, economic, social)"] -->|Inputs: demands, resources,
information, support| CONV["Conversion process
(the administrative system:
structure, people, technology)"]
CONV -->|Outputs: decisions,
services, regulations| OUT["Outputs to society"]
OUT -->|Feedback| ENV| Concept | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Open system | Exchanges energy, information and resources with its environment (all real organisations) |
| Closed system | Self-contained; classical theories implicitly treated organisations this way |
| Subsystems | Parts of the system (Katz and Kahn: production, supportive, maintenance, adaptive and managerial subsystems) |
| Boundary | Separates the system from the environment |
| Entropy / negative entropy | Systems tend to run down; open systems import energy to survive |
| Homeostasis | Dynamic equilibrium: self-regulation to stay stable |
| Equifinality | The same final state can be reached by different paths, so there is no one best way |
| Feedback | Information about outputs that corrects future action |
Contributions: sees administration as a whole; links it to its environment; prepares the ground for contingency theory (no one best way; structure depends on environment and technology). Criticisms: abstract; better at describing equilibrium than change and conflict; can be conservative (system maintenance is treated as the goal).
(b) Decision-making approach: Herbert Simon
Herbert A. Simon (1916–2001) made decision-making the “heart of administration”. He won the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1978 for his research on decision-making in economic organisations.
Key works: “The Proverbs of Administration” (Public Administration Review, 1946); Administrative Behavior (1947); Organizations with James March (1958); The New Science of Management Decision (1960).
1. The proverbs critique. The classical principles (span of control, unity of command, specialisation, hierarchy) come in contradictory pairs, like proverbs (“look before you leap” vs “he who hesitates is lost”). A narrow span of control means more levels of hierarchy, which contradicts the principle of keeping levels few. So they are not scientific principles.
2. Logical positivism and the fact–value distinction. Every decision has factual premises (testable) and value premises (not testable). A science of administration can study only the factual element; values are set by the political process. This is why Simon is called a logical positivist in administration.
3. Bounded rationality. Real decision-makers cannot know all alternatives and all consequences; they have limited information, time and computing capacity. So rationality is bounded.
4. Satisficing. Instead of maximising, the decision-maker accepts the first alternative that is “good enough” (satisfactory + sufficient).
| Economic man | Administrative man (Simon) |
|---|---|
| Maximises | Satisfices |
| Deals with the real world in all its complexity | Works with a simplified model of the world |
| Knows all alternatives | Considers a few alternatives sequentially |
| Fully rational | Boundedly rational |
5. Stages of decision-making (Simon, 1960):
- Intelligence — finding occasions for decision (scanning the environment for problems).
- Design — inventing and analysing possible courses of action.
- Choice — selecting one of them.
(Some texts add review as a fourth stage.)
6. Programmed vs non-programmed decisions. Programmed decisions are repetitive and routine, handled by standard procedures; non-programmed decisions are novel and unstructured, handled by judgement and creative problem-solving.
7. Authority and the zone of acceptance. Simon adapted Barnard’s zone of indifference into his zone of acceptance: the range within which a subordinate accepts a superior’s decision without questioning it.
8. Other models of decision-making (often set as match-the-following):
| Model | Author | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Rational-comprehensive | Classical / economic model | List all alternatives, evaluate all consequences, choose the best |
| Bounded rationality / satisficing | Herbert Simon (1947) | Limited rationality; “good enough” |
| Incrementalism (“muddling through”) | Charles Lindblom, “The Science of ‘Muddling Through’” (1959) | Successive limited comparisons; small changes from the existing policy (the “branch” method vs the “root” method) |
| Mixed scanning | Amitai Etzioni (1967) | Broad scan for fundamental decisions + detailed look at incremental ones |
| Optimal model | Yehezkel Dror, Public Policymaking Reexamined (1968) | Combines rational and extra-rational elements (intuition, judgement) |
Criticisms of Simon: the fact–value distinction is hard to hold in practice (Waldo); neglects the political and normative side; too focused on the individual decision; less useful for the large policy choices of government.
(c) Ecological approach
Ecology in biology studies the relation between organisms and their environment. In administration it asks how administration shapes and is shaped by its environment: geography, economy, society, culture, politics.
John M. Gaus, Reflections on Public Administration (1947), introduced the approach into American public administration. He listed the ecological factors that explain why administration takes the form it does:
- People (population, age structure, distribution)
- Place (location, geography, climate)
- Physical technology
- Social technology (new forms of organisation)
- Wishes and ideas (what people want and believe)
- Catastrophe (wars, depressions, natural disasters)
- Personality (individual leaders)
Fred W. Riggs (1917–2008) developed the approach into a model of whole societies, mainly to explain administration in the newly independent countries.
| Riggs’s work | Year | Contribution |
|---|---|---|
| “Agraria and Industria” | 1957 | Two ideal types: agricultural and industrial societies (with “Transitia” between) |
| The Ecology of Public Administration | 1961 | Administration studied in its social setting |
| Administration in Developing Countries: The Theory of Prismatic Society | 1964 | Fused–prismatic–diffracted model; the sala |
The prism analogy. White light (all functions mixed together) passes through a prism and comes out as a spectrum of separate colours (each function performed by a specialised structure).
| Society | Structures and functions | Example (Riggs’s ideal type) |
|---|---|---|
| Fused | One structure performs many functions (the household or king does everything) | Traditional agrarian society |
| Prismatic | Partly differentiated: new formal structures exist, but old ones still do the real work | Developing societies |
| Diffracted | Each function has its own specialised structure | Industrial societies |
Three features of the prismatic society:
- Heterogeneity — modern and traditional practices, groups and ideas exist side by side (modern city offices and village customs).
- Formalism — a gap between formal norms (laws, rules) and actual behaviour; laws are on paper but not enforced as written.
- Overlapping — new formal structures are created, but the old undifferentiated ones continue to determine behaviour.
The sala is Riggs’s name for the bureaucracy of a prismatic society (the word suggests a room, a pavilion or an office). Features: poly-communalism (several communities in mutual tension), clects (groups that use modern methods for communal ends), poly-normativism (several sets of norms at once), nepotism in recruitment, and separation of authority from control (formal authority lies with the bureaucracy, real control with others, or vice versa). The prismatic economy is a bazaar-canteen model, where prices are set by the status of the buyer, not the market.
Contributions: made administration comparative; explained why Western techniques failed when transplanted; influenced development administration (page 3). Criticisms: “prismatic” carries a negative tone towards developing countries; the model is static; too abstract to test; new jargon.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Wilson, “The Study of Administration” (1887, essay) | vs | Goodnow, Politics and Administration (1900, book) |
| L.D. White (1926) — first textbook | vs | W.F. Willoughby (1927) — Principles of Public Administration |
| Appleby, Big Democracy (1945) — “government is different” | vs | Appleby, Policy and Administration (1949) — against the dichotomy |
| Barnard — zone of indifference | vs | Simon — zone of acceptance |
| Simon — satisficing, bounded rationality | vs | Lindblom — incrementalism, muddling through |
| Gaus (1947) — seven ecological factors | vs | Riggs (1961, 1964) — fused–prismatic–diffracted model |
| Formalism — norms vs actual practice | vs | Overlapping — new structures vs old ones that still work |
| Integral view — all activities | vs | Managerial view — only managerial activities (POSDCORB) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who wrote “The Study of Administration” (1887)?
- What does the “B” in POSDCORB stand for?
- Name the three features of Riggs’s prismatic society.
Answers
- Woodrow Wilson.
- Budgeting.
- Heterogeneity, formalism and overlapping.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Which of the following thinkers is associated with the view that “government is different” from private business?
- (a) Henri Fayol
- (b) Paul Appleby
- (c) Lyndall Urwick
- (d) Herbert Simon
Answer and explanation
(b) Paul Appleby, Big Democracy (1945). Fayol and Urwick held that administration is universal; Simon (with Smithburg and Thompson) stressed similarities of degree.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Herbert Simon:
- He argued that the classical principles of administration were like proverbs.
- He held that the administrative man maximises.
- He identified intelligence, design and choice as phases of decision-making.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Statement 2 reverses Simon: the administrative man satisfices; it is the economic man who maximises.
Q3. (Practice) In Nicholas Henry’s classification, the paradigm “principles of administration” is associated with which period?
- (a) 1900–1926
- (b) 1927–1937
- (c) 1950–1970
- (d) 1970 onwards
Answer and explanation
(b) 1927–1937, from Willoughby’s Principles of Public Administration (1927) to Gulick and Urwick’s Papers on the Science of Administration (1937).
Q4. (Practice) In the systems approach, the principle that an organisation can reach the same final state by different paths is called:
- (a) Homeostasis
- (b) Entropy
- (c) Equifinality
- (d) Feedback
Answer and explanation
(c) Equifinality. Homeostasis is self-regulating equilibrium; entropy is the tendency to run down; feedback is information on outputs that adjusts later action.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Riggs describes the administration of developing societies as marked by formalism. Reason (R): In prismatic societies there is a wide gap between prescribed norms and actual behaviour.
Answer and explanation
(a). Formalism is the gap between formal norms and actual practice, so R explains A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Herbert Simon called for a science of administration restricted to the factual premises of decisions. Reason (R): Simon held that value premises can be empirically tested in the same way as factual premises.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true. R is false: for Simon, value premises cannot be empirically tested, which is exactly why the science is limited to factual premises.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Thinker) with List II (Contribution).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. John M. Gaus | I. Incrementalism |
| B. Charles Lindblom | II. Ecological factors of administration |
| C. Amitai Etzioni | III. Bounded rationality |
| D. Herbert Simon | IV. Mixed scanning |
- (a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (b) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (c) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
- (d) A-I, B-II, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following works in chronological order of publication:
- Goodnow, Politics and Administration
- Wilson, “The Study of Administration”
- Simon, Administrative Behavior
- Gulick and Urwick (eds), Papers on the Science of Administration
- (a) 2, 1, 4, 3
- (b) 1, 2, 4, 3
- (c) 2, 1, 3, 4
- (d) 2, 4, 1, 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 2, 1, 4, 3. 1887 → 1900 → 1937 → 1947.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange Nicholas Henry’s paradigms in their chronological order:
- Public administration as management
- Politics–administration dichotomy
- Public administration as political science
- Principles of administration
- (a) 2, 4, 3, 1
- (b) 2, 4, 1, 3
- (c) 4, 2, 3, 1
- (d) 2, 3, 4, 1
Answer and explanation
(a) 2, 4, 3, 1. Dichotomy (1900) → principles (1927) → political science (1950) → management (1956). Paradigm 5 (1970) would come last.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Who / what | Year | Key point |
|---|---|---|---|
| “The Study of Administration” | Woodrow Wilson | 1887 | Founding essay; dichotomy; “harder to run a constitution than to frame one” |
| Politics and Administration | Frank Goodnow | 1900 | Politics = will of state; administration = execution |
| First textbook | L.D. White | 1926 | Integral view |
| Principles of Public Administration | W.F. Willoughby | 1927 | Principles paradigm |
| Papers on the Science of Administration | Gulick and Urwick (eds) | 1937 | POSDCORB |
| Big Democracy | Paul Appleby | 1945 | “Government is different” |
| “The Proverbs of Administration” | Herbert Simon | 1946 | Principles are contradictory proverbs |
| Administrative Behavior | Herbert Simon | 1947 | Bounded rationality, satisficing, fact–value |
| “Three Problems” | Robert Dahl | 1947 | Values, behaviour, social setting |
| Reflections on Public Administration | John Gaus | 1947 | Seven ecological factors |
| The Administrative State | Dwight Waldo | 1948 | Administration is political theory |
| “Muddling Through” | Charles Lindblom | 1959 | Incrementalism |
| The Ecology of Public Administration | Fred Riggs | 1961 | Ecological approach |
| Theory of Prismatic Society | Fred Riggs | 1964 | Fused–prismatic–diffracted; sala |
| The Social Psychology of Organizations | Katz and Kahn | 1966 | Open systems |
| Mixed scanning | Amitai Etzioni | 1967 | Third approach |
| “Paradigms of Public Administration” | Nicholas Henry | 1975 | Five paradigms |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Theories of Organisation: Scientific Management, Bureaucracy and Human Relations — the classical principles that Simon called proverbs
- Rational Choice, NPA, Development Administration and NPM — how Riggs’s ecology became comparative and development administration
- Democracy and Power — Weber’s authority types, the background to bureaucratic theory
- Public Administration — Quick Revision