Machiavelli and Hobbes
Machiavelli's Prince and Discourses (virtù, fortuna, lion and fox) and Hobbes's Leviathan (state of nature, covenant, absolute sovereignty) for UGC NET.
- 16 min
On this page · 12 sections
Prerequisites
- Confucius, Plato and Aristotle: the classical view that politics serves virtue, which both thinkers on this page reject.
- Liberty and Equality in Unit 1 introduces Hobbes’s definition of liberty as the absence of external impediments.
The Hook: Two Exiles and a New Science
How UGC NET asks it: quotation-based questions (“better to be feared than loved”, “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short”), chapter-level ideas of The Prince, Hobbes’s laws of nature and the features of his sovereign, and comparisons with Locke and Rousseau on the next page.
1. Niccolò Machiavelli (1469–1527)
Life in Florence
- Served the Florentine republic as Secretary of the Second Chancery from 1498 to 1512, with diplomatic missions to France, the papal court and Cesare Borgia, whom he observed closely.
- In 1512 the Medici returned to power and the republic fell. Machiavelli was dismissed, then in 1513 imprisoned and tortured on suspicion of conspiracy, and released.
- In retirement he wrote his political works, hoping to return to public service.
Works
| Work | Written / published | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| The Prince (Il Principe) | Written 1513; published 1532 (after his death) | Advice to a new prince on gaining and keeping a state; dedicated to Lorenzo de’ Medici |
| Discourses on the First Ten Books of Titus Livy | Written c. 1513–1519; published 1531 | His republican work: Rome as model, liberty, mixed government |
| The Art of War | Published 1521 | Military organisation; citizen militia (published in his lifetime) |
| Florentine Histories | Commissioned by the Medici | History of Florence |
| Mandragola | Comedy | Literary work |
Key ideas of The Prince
The “effectual truth” (chapter 15). Many have imagined republics and principalities never seen in reality; Machiavelli will go to the effectual truth of the thing, how people actually live, not how they ought to live. A prince who wants to keep his state must learn how not to be good, and to use this or not according to necessity.
Human nature (chapter 17). People are “ungrateful, fickle, liars and deceivers, avoiders of danger, eager for gain”. They forget the death of a father sooner than the loss of their patrimony.
Feared or loved (chapter 17). It is best to be both, but since that is hard, it is much safer to be feared than loved, if one must lack one of the two. The prince must still avoid being hated, which he does by keeping his hands off his subjects’ property and women.
The lion and the fox (chapter 18). There are two ways of fighting, by law (proper to men) and by force (proper to beasts). A prince must know how to use both natures: the fox to recognise traps, the lion to frighten wolves. A prudent ruler need not keep his word when doing so works against him. The prince need not have the conventional virtues, but must appear to have them. People judge by outcomes, so if the prince wins and keeps his state, the means will be judged honourable.
Virtù and fortuna (chapter 25). Fortuna (chance, circumstance) is “arbiter of half our actions”, but leaves the other half, or close to it, to us. Machiavelli compares fortune to a violent river that floods the plain; a prudent ruler builds dykes and embankments in quiet times. Virtù is the ruler’s energy, skill, boldness and adaptability, not Christian moral virtue. Since times change, a ruler succeeds when his conduct suits the times. The chapter ends with the image of fortune as a woman who favours the bold and the young.
Arms (chapters 12–14). Mercenaries and auxiliaries are useless and dangerous; a state must rely on its own arms, a citizen militia. “Good laws and good arms” are the foundations of states, and there cannot be good laws where there are not good arms.
Kinds of principalities. Hereditary, mixed, new ones acquired by one’s own arms and virtù, by fortune and others’ arms (Cesare Borgia is the example, in chapter 7), by crime, civil principalities and ecclesiastical ones.
Exhortation (chapter 26). The book ends with an appeal to the Medici to liberate Italy from the barbarians, the foreign powers that had overrun it. This is why Machiavelli is read as an early Italian patriot and nationalist.
The Discourses: Machiavelli the republican
- Republics are preferable to principalities in the long run: the people are wiser and more constant than a prince.
- Rome became great through mixed government (consuls, senate, tribunes) and through the conflict between nobles and plebs, which, he argues, produced laws favourable to liberty.
- Religion is valuable as a civic instrument: Roman religion bred discipline and patriotism. He blames the Church for keeping Italy divided.
- Corruption destroys republics; periodic “return to first principles” renews them.
- Constitutions move in a cycle of good and bad forms, an idea taken from the Greek historian Polybius.
Assessments of Machiavelli
| View | Who says it |
|---|---|
| Founder of a new science of politics, separating politics from ethics and theology | Common textbook view; “father of modern political science” |
| “Teacher of evil” | Leo Strauss, Thoughts on Machiavelli (1958) |
| Not amoral but a pluralist: he chose pagan civic virtue over Christian virtue | Isaiah Berlin, “The Originality of Machiavelli” |
| A civic republican; a “Machiavellian moment” in Atlantic thought | J.G.A. Pocock, The Machiavellian Moment (1975); Quentin Skinner |
| The Prince as a satire or warning to the people | An old minority reading (Rousseau called it “the book of republicans”) |
He is also among the first to use lo stato in something close to its modern sense of a political entity that a ruler acquires and keeps.
2. Thomas Hobbes (1588–1679)
Life and works
- Born in 1588, the year of the Spanish Armada; later wrote that his mother gave birth to twins, himself and fear.
- Tutor and secretary to the Cavendish family; met Galileo; deeply influenced by geometry and the new mechanical science.
- Left England for Paris in 1640 as the crisis that led to the English Civil War deepened; returned to England soon after Leviathan appeared.
| Work | Year | Note |
|---|---|---|
| The Elements of Law, Natural and Politic | Circulated 1640 | First statement of his political theory |
| De Cive (On the Citizen) | 1642 (Latin) | English version 1651 |
| Leviathan | 1651 | His masterpiece: “the matter, forme and power of a commonwealth ecclesiasticall and civil” |
| Behemoth | Written after the Restoration; Charles II refused it a licence | History of the Civil War |
Method: materialism and the resolutive–compositive method
- Everything is matter in motion. Human beings are machines driven by appetites (motion towards) and aversions (motion away).
- Following Galileo, Hobbes resolves society into its parts (individuals and their passions) and then recomposes it rationally. The state is an artificial person, an “artificial man”.
- Power: “a perpetual and restless desire of power after power, that ceaseth only in death” is a general inclination of all mankind (Leviathan, ch. 11).
The state of nature (Leviathan, ch. 13)
- Equality: people are roughly equal in body and mind; the weakest can kill the strongest by secret machination or in alliance with others. Equality of ability breeds equality of hope, and so conflict.
- Three principal causes of quarrel: competition (for gain), diffidence (distrust, for safety) and glory (for reputation).
- Without a common power to keep them all in awe, people live in a condition of war of every man against every man. War consists not only in actual fighting but in the known disposition to fight.
- In that condition there is no industry, agriculture, navigation, arts or letters, “and the life of man, solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short”.
- No justice or injustice, no property, no “mine and thine” in the state of nature: where there is no common power there is no law, and where no law, no injustice.
Right of nature and laws of nature (ch. 14–15)
- Right of nature: the liberty each person has to use his own power for the preservation of his own life.
- Law of nature: a precept found out by reason, forbidding a person to do what is destructive of his life.
- First: seek peace and follow it; if peace cannot be had, defend yourself by all means.
- Second: be willing, when others are too, to lay down the right to all things, and be content with as much liberty against others as you would allow them against yourself.
- Third: perform covenants made (the origin of justice).
- Leviathan lists nineteen laws of nature in chapters 14 and 15. Hobbes sums them up in the negative golden rule: do not do to another what you would not have done to yourself.
The covenant and the sovereign (ch. 17–18)
- Each person covenants with every other to authorise one man or assembly: “I authorise and give up my right of governing myself to this man, or to this assembly of men, on this condition, that thou give up thy right to him, and authorise all his actions in like manner.”
- The multitude so united is called a commonwealth, the “great Leviathan”, that “mortal god” to which we owe our peace and defence under the immortal God.
- “Covenants, without the sword, are but words” (ch. 17): agreement alone is not enough; there must be a power to enforce it.
- Not a party to the covenant, so he cannot break it and subjects cannot accuse him of breach.
- Absolute, indivisible and inalienable: dividing sovereignty dissolves the commonwealth (Hobbes’s diagnosis of the Civil War).
- The sovereign is the source of law and judge of what doctrines may be taught; the church is subordinate to him (Erastianism).
- He cannot do injustice to his subjects, since they authorised all his actions; he may still sin against the law of nature.
- Monarchy, aristocracy or democracy are possible, but Hobbes prefers monarchy.
Liberty of subjects (ch. 21)
- Liberty is the absence of external impediments to motion. Liberty and necessity are consistent; fear and liberty are consistent too.
- The liberty of subjects lies in the silence of the law: in what the sovereign has not regulated.
- Inalienable right of self-preservation: a subject may resist if the sovereign commands him to kill, wound or maim himself, and is not bound to accuse himself. The obligation of subjects lasts as long as, and no longer than, the sovereign can protect them.
Hobbes in the history of ideas
- Founder of the social contract tradition in its modern form, and of the idea of the state as an artificial person based on consent, even though the result is absolute.
- Individualism as the starting point: Hobbes begins with separate individuals and their rights, which is why some read him as a forerunner of liberalism even though he defended absolute sovereignty.
- Legal positivism: law is the command of the sovereign, a line later taken up by Bentham and Austin.
- C.B. Macpherson, The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism: Hobbes to Locke (1962): Hobbes’s “natural man” is really the market man of seventeenth-century bourgeois society.
Machiavelli and Hobbes Compared
| Machiavelli | Hobbes | |
|---|---|---|
| Key work | The Prince (written 1513) | Leviathan (1651) |
| Human nature | Selfish, ungrateful, fickle | Selfish, fearful, seeking power after power |
| Method | History and observation | Geometry and mechanics (deductive) |
| Aim of the state | Acquire, keep and expand power; greatness | Peace and self-preservation |
| Legitimacy | Success, virtù | Consent through a covenant |
| Preferred form | Republic (Discourses); strong prince in emergencies | Absolute sovereign, preferably a monarch |
| Religion | Civic instrument | Subordinate to the sovereign |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| The Prince: written 1513, published 1532 | vs | Discourses: published 1531, republican |
| Virtù: political energy, skill, boldness | vs | Virtue: Christian or classical moral excellence |
| Fortuna compared to a river and a woman | vs | Necessity (necessità), which compels action |
| Right of nature: liberty to preserve oneself | vs | Law of nature: rule of reason forbidding self-destruction |
| Hobbes’s sovereign: not party to the covenant | vs | Locke’s government: holds power on trust, can be resisted |
| Leviathan: the state (sea monster) | vs | Behemoth: Hobbes’s history of the Civil War (land monster) |
| Leo Strauss: Machiavelli the “teacher of evil” | vs | Pocock: Machiavelli the civic republican |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Name Hobbes’s three principal causes of quarrel.
- Which two animals must a prince imitate, according to The Prince, chapter 18?
- In which year was Leviathan published?
Answers
- Competition, diffidence and glory.
- The lion and the fox.
- 1651.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) “Covenants, without the sword, are but words.” This line is from:
- (a) The Prince
- (b) Leviathan
- (c) Two Treatises of Government
- (d) The Social Contract
Answer and explanation
(b) Leviathan (ch. 17), where Hobbes argues that agreement needs a common power to enforce it.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Machiavelli:
- The Discourses on Livy shows a preference for republican government.
- He recommended that a state rely on mercenary armies.
- He compared fortune to a violent river against which dykes can be built.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(c) 1 and 3 only. Machiavelli condemned mercenaries as useless and dangerous and wanted a citizen militia.
Q3. (Practice) For Hobbes, the liberty of subjects consists chiefly in:
- (a) participation in the general will
- (b) the silence of the law
- (c) the right to overthrow a tyrant
- (d) obedience to the law one prescribes to oneself
Answer and explanation
(b). Where the sovereign has prescribed no rule, subjects are free. (a) and (d) are Rousseau’s ideas; (c) is closer to Locke.
Q4. (Practice) Who described Machiavelli as a “teacher of evil”?
- (a) Isaiah Berlin
- (b) J.G.A. Pocock
- (c) Leo Strauss
- (d) Quentin Skinner
Answer and explanation
(c) Leo Strauss, Thoughts on Machiavelli (1958). Berlin, Pocock and Skinner offered more sympathetic or republican readings.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): For Hobbes, the sovereign cannot commit injustice against his subjects. Reason (R): Subjects have authorised all the sovereign’s actions through the covenant.
Answer and explanation
(a). One cannot do injustice to someone who has authorised the act; R is Hobbes’s own explanation.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Machiavelli advised the prince to appear merciful, faithful and religious. Reason (R): Machiavelli held that a prince must always actually practise the conventional virtues.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true (chapter 18). R is false: the prince need only appear to have these qualities, and must be ready to act against them when necessary.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Phrase) with List II (Source).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. “Effectual truth of the thing” | I. Leviathan, ch. 13 |
| B. “Solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short” | II. The Prince, ch. 15 |
| C. “Mortal god” | III. The Prince, ch. 26 |
| D. Exhortation to free Italy from the barbarians | IV. Leviathan, ch. 17 |
- (a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (b) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (c) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
- (d) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange in chronological order of publication:
- Leviathan
- The Prince
- De Cive
- Discourses on Livy
- (a) 2, 4, 3, 1
- (b) 4, 2, 3, 1
- (c) 2, 4, 1, 3
- (d) 4, 2, 1, 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 4, 2, 3, 1. Discourses 1531 → The Prince 1532 → De Cive 1642 → Leviathan 1651. The trap is that The Prince was written first but published after the Discourses.
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker | Work (year) | Key ideas |
|---|---|---|
| Machiavelli (1469–1527) | The Prince (written 1513, published 1532) | Effectual truth; feared rather than loved, never hated; lion and fox; virtù vs fortuna; own arms; free Italy |
| Machiavelli | Discourses on Livy (1531) | Republic, mixed government, civic religion, conflict as source of liberty |
| Machiavelli | The Art of War (1521) | Citizen militia |
| Hobbes (1588–1679) | Elements of Law (1640), De Cive (1642) | Early statements |
| Hobbes | Leviathan (1651) | Matter in motion; equality; competition, diffidence, glory; war of all against all; laws of nature; covenant; absolute, indivisible sovereign; silence of the law; self-preservation |
| Strauss | Thoughts on Machiavelli (1958) | “Teacher of evil” |
| Macpherson | Political Theory of Possessive Individualism (1962) | Hobbes and Locke as theorists of market society |
| Pocock | The Machiavellian Moment (1975) | Civic republicanism |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Locke and Rousseau: two answers to Hobbes, limited government and the general will
- Liberalism, Conservatism, Socialism and Marxism: how Hobbes’s individualism feeds into liberal thought
- Political Thought: Quick Revision