Rights and Citizenship
Rights and citizenship for UGC NET: natural and legal rights, Hohfeld, will vs interest theory, rights generations, T.H. Marshall, differentiated citizenship.
- 15 min
On this page · 11 sections
Prerequisites
- Liberty and Equality — rights are liberty and equality given legal and moral form.
- Justice — Rawls’s equal basic liberties and Nozick’s side-constraints are both theories of rights.
The Hook: “The Right to Have Rights”
How UGC NET asks it: match-the-following on theories of rights (natural, legal, historical, social welfare, Marxist), Hohfeld’s four incidents, Vasak’s generations, and T.H. Marshall’s sequence of civil, political and social citizenship, which is a favourite sequencing item.
Part A: Rights
1. What is a right?
A right is a justified claim that is recognised (morally, socially or legally) and that imposes duties on others. Three working definitions recur in Indian textbooks:
- Harold Laski, A Grammar of Politics (1925): rights are those conditions of social life without which no person can seek, in general, to be themselves at their best. Every state is known by the rights it maintains.
- T.H. Green: rights are powers claimed and recognised by society as contributing to the common good; a right needs social recognition.
- Bernard Bosanquet: a right is a claim recognised by society and enforced by the state.
Rights and duties are correlative: my right is your duty, and a right claimed without accepting duties is, for Laski and Green, incoherent.
2. Theories of rights
| Theory | Core claim | Thinkers / sources |
|---|---|---|
| Natural rights | People have rights by virtue of being human, prior to the state; the state exists to protect them | Locke, Two Treatises of Government (published 1689): life, liberty and estate (property); US Declaration of Independence (1776): life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness; French Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (1789) |
| Legal rights | Rights exist only when created and enforced by law (the sovereign) | Bentham (natural rights are “simple nonsense”, and natural and imprescriptible rights “nonsense upon stilts”, in Anarchical Fallacies); Austin |
| Historical / prescriptive | Rights grow out of custom and tradition; inherited, not abstract | Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790): the “rights of Englishmen” rather than the abstract rights of man |
| Social welfare / idealist | Rights are conditions for the common good and self-realisation, recognised by society | Green, Laski, Bosanquet |
| Marxist | “Rights of man” in bourgeois society are the rights of the egoistic, separated individual; they protect property | Marx, “On the Jewish Question” (1843); rights are realised only in a classless society |
| Rights as trumps | Individual rights override collective goals and majority preferences | Ronald Dworkin, Taking Rights Seriously (1977) |
| Rights as side-constraints | Rights set limits on what anyone, including the state, may do to a person | Nozick, Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974) |
3. Hohfeld’s analysis of rights
Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld, in “Some Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning” (Yale Law Journal, 1913), showed that “right” is used for four different relations:
| Incident | Meaning | Correlative (what the other party has) | Opposite |
|---|---|---|---|
| Claim-right (right stricto sensu) | A is owed a duty by B | Duty | No-right |
| Privilege (liberty) | A has no duty not to do X | No-right | Duty |
| Power | A can change legal relations (make a will, sign a contract) | Liability | Disability |
| Immunity | B cannot change A’s legal relations | Disability | Liability |
Claim-rights and privileges are first-order incidents (about actions); powers and immunities are second-order (about changing first-order relations).
4. What do rights protect? Will theory vs interest theory
| Will (choice) theory | Interest (benefit) theory | |
|---|---|---|
| Function of a right | Gives the holder control over another’s duty (can waive or enforce) | Protects an important interest of the holder |
| Key thinkers | H.L.A. Hart, “Are There Any Natural Rights?” (1955); Kant, Hillel Steiner | Joseph Raz, The Morality of Freedom (1986); Bentham, Neil MacCormick |
| Difficulty | Cannot explain rights of infants, animals, the comatose, or inalienable rights one cannot waive | May turn every protected interest into a right |
5. Kinds and generations of rights
Classification by source: moral vs legal rights; within legal rights, civil, political and economic/social.
Karel Vasak, a Czech-French jurist at UNESCO, proposed in 1977 the three “generations” of human rights, mapped onto the French revolutionary slogan:
| Generation | Slogan | Content | Instrument |
|---|---|---|---|
| First | Liberty (liberté) | Civil and political rights: life, speech, religion, fair trial, vote; “negative” rights against the state | ICCPR (1966) |
| Second | Equality (égalité) | Economic, social and cultural rights: work, education, health, social security; “positive” rights needing provision | ICESCR (1966) |
| Third | Fraternity (fraternité) | Solidarity / collective rights: development, peace, healthy environment, self-determination | Declaration on the Right to Development (1986), environmental instruments |
The International Bill of Human Rights:
- Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR): adopted by the UN General Assembly in Paris on 10 December 1948 (now Human Rights Day); 30 articles; not itself a treaty. The drafting committee was chaired by Eleanor Roosevelt; India’s Hansa Mehta is credited with changing “all men are born free and equal” to “all human beings…”.
- ICCPR and ICESCR: adopted 16 December 1966; entered into force 1976.
6. Rights in the Indian context
The Indian Constitution reflects the generations split: Fundamental Rights (Part III, justiciable: mostly first-generation, plus Articles 17, 23, 24) and Directive Principles (Part IV, non-justiciable: mostly second-generation). The courts have since read many socio-economic rights into Article 21: livelihood (Olga Tellis, 1985), education (Unni Krishnan, 1993; then Article 21A by the 86th Amendment, 2002), and privacy (K.S. Puttaswamy, 2017, nine judges). Ambedkar called the right to constitutional remedies (Article 32) the “heart and soul” of the Constitution.
7. Group and minority rights
Liberal theory traditionally treats only individuals as right-bearers. Will Kymlicka, Multicultural Citizenship (1995), defends group-differentiated rights of three kinds:
- Self-government rights — for national minorities and indigenous peoples (devolution, federal units);
- Polyethnic rights — for immigrant groups (exemptions, funding for cultural practices);
- Special representation rights — guaranteed seats or quotas in political institutions.
He separates external protections (protecting the group against the wider society, acceptable) from internal restrictions (limiting members’ liberty, not acceptable). India’s Articles 29–30 and reserved constituencies are classic examples. See Multiculturalism.
Part B: Citizenship
8. Meanings of citizenship
Citizenship is full membership of a political community, combining three elements: status (legal membership), rights (and duties), and participation / identity (belonging and active involvement).
| Tradition | Emphasis | Thinkers |
|---|---|---|
| Classical / civic republican | Citizenship as active participation in self-government; civic virtue | Aristotle, Politics: a citizen is one who shares in deliberative and judicial office, ruling and being ruled in turn; Machiavelli, Rousseau, Arendt |
| Liberal | Citizenship as a legal status carrying equal rights; a protective shell for private life | Locke, Rawls; T.H. Marshall’s rights-based account |
| Communitarian | Citizenship as belonging to a community with shared values | Sandel, MacIntyre, Walzer |
| Marxist | Formal citizenship masks class inequality | Marx, “On the Jewish Question” |
| Feminist | Citizenship has been built on a male, public-sphere model; care work and the private sphere are ignored | Pateman, Ruth Lister (Citizenship: Feminist Perspectives, 1997) |
Note that for Aristotle, women, slaves and resident aliens (metics) were excluded; ancient citizenship was participatory but narrow.
9. T.H. Marshall: Citizenship and Social Class (1950)
T.H. Marshall gave the Marshall Lectures at Cambridge in 1949; they were published as Citizenship and Social Class in 1950. Using English history, he divided citizenship into three elements, each institutionalised in roughly one century:
| Element | Century | Content | Institutions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Civil | 18th | Liberty of the person, speech, thought, faith; right to own property and conclude contracts; right to justice | Courts |
| Political | 19th | Right to participate in political power: vote, stand for office | Parliament, local councils |
| Social | 20th | Right to economic welfare and security, to share in the social heritage and live as a civilised being | Education system and social services |
His thesis: social citizenship (the welfare state) moderates the class inequalities that capitalism produces, without abolishing classes. Critics note that the sequence is English and male (women’s civil and political rights came later), and does not fit countries such as India, where universal political rights (1950) came before effective social rights.
10. Contemporary debates
| Idea | Thinker / source | Point |
|---|---|---|
| Differentiated citizenship | Iris Marion Young, “Polity and Group Difference: A Critique of the Ideal of Universal Citizenship”, Ethics (1989) | Universal citizenship (“treat everyone the same”) reproduces the dominance of privileged groups; oppressed groups need special representation and rights |
| Multicultural citizenship | Kymlicka (1995) | Group-differentiated rights within liberalism |
| Return of the citizen | Kymlicka and Wayne Norman, Ethics (1994) | Revival of citizenship theory in the 1990s; stable democracy needs citizens’ qualities, not just institutions |
| Jus soli vs jus sanguinis | Rogers Brubaker, Citizenship and Nationhood in France and Germany (1992) | Citizenship by birthplace (France, territorial) vs by descent (Germany, ethnocultural) |
| Flexible citizenship | Aihwa Ong (1999) | Transnational elites accumulate passports and residencies strategically |
| Cosmopolitan / global citizenship | David Held, Andrew Linklater; Kant’s Perpetual Peace (1795) and “cosmopolitan right” | Duties and identities beyond the nation-state |
| Denizenship | Tomas Hammar | Long-term resident non-citizens with most social rights but not political rights |
11. Citizenship in India
- Constitution, Part II, Articles 5–11: Articles 5–8 settle who was a citizen at the commencement of the Constitution (26 January 1950); Article 9 excludes those who voluntarily acquire foreign citizenship; Article 11 empowers Parliament to regulate citizenship.
- Citizenship Act, 1955: acquisition by birth, descent, registration, naturalisation and incorporation of territory; loss by renunciation, termination and deprivation. India has single citizenship; it does not allow dual citizenship, though Overseas Citizenship of India (OCI) gives long-term residence and other benefits without political rights.
- Movement from jus soli toward jus sanguinis: birth in India alone made a person a citizen until 1987; amendments in 1986 and 2003 added parental-citizenship conditions.
- Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019: a faster path to citizenship for Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi and Christian migrants from Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan who entered India on or before 31 December 2014; its rules were notified in March 2024. It is debated as a test of whether Indian citizenship remains civic rather than religious.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Burke, Reflections (1790) — prescriptive rights | vs | Paine, Rights of Man (1791–92) — natural rights |
| Bentham — “nonsense upon stilts” | vs | Locke — natural rights to life, liberty, estate |
| Will theory (Hart) — control | vs | Interest theory (Raz) — benefit |
| Dworkin — rights as trumps | vs | Nozick — rights as side-constraints |
| Young — differentiated citizenship (1989) | vs | Kymlicka — multicultural citizenship (1995) |
| Jus soli — by birthplace | vs | Jus sanguinis — by descent |
| Arendt — “right to have rights” (1951) | vs | Marshall — three elements of citizenship (1950) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who described natural and imprescriptible rights as “nonsense upon stilts”?
- In which year was the UDHR adopted?
- Which element of citizenship did T.H. Marshall link with the 20th century?
Answers
- Jeremy Bentham.
- 1948 (10 December).
- Social citizenship.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) “Rights are those conditions of social life without which no man can seek, in general, to be himself at his best.” This definition is associated with:
- (a) John Locke
- (b) Harold Laski
- (c) Jeremy Bentham
- (d) Edmund Burke
Answer and explanation
(b) Harold Laski, A Grammar of Politics (1925).
Q2. (Practice) In Hohfeld’s scheme, the correlative of a “power” is:
- (a) Duty
- (b) No-right
- (c) Liability
- (d) Disability
Answer and explanation
(c) Liability. Claim–duty, privilege–no-right, power–liability, immunity–disability.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Will Kymlicka’s theory:
- He distinguishes self-government, polyethnic and special representation rights.
- He accepts “internal restrictions” that limit the liberty of a group’s own members.
- He treats national minorities and immigrant groups differently.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Kymlicka accepts external protections but rejects internal restrictions.
Q4. (Practice) The idea that universal citizenship can reproduce the dominance of privileged groups, and that oppressed groups need differentiated citizenship, is associated with:
- (a) T.H. Marshall
- (b) Rogers Brubaker
- (c) Iris Marion Young
- (d) Aristotle
Answer and explanation
(c) Iris Marion Young (“Polity and Group Difference”, 1989).
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): The will theory of rights has difficulty explaining the rights of infants. Reason (R): For the will theory, having a right means having control over another’s duty, which infants cannot exercise.
Answer and explanation
(a). The will theory ties rights to the power to waive or enforce; infants cannot exercise such choice, so the theory struggles to call them right-holders.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Marx criticised the “rights of man” in “On the Jewish Question”. Reason (R): Marx held that these rights were the rights of the egoistic individual separated from the community.
Answer and explanation
(a). R gives Marx’s actual ground for criticism.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Thinker) with List II (Idea).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Ronald Dworkin | I. The right to have rights |
| B. Hannah Arendt | II. Rights as trumps |
| C. Karel Vasak | III. Citizenship by birthplace vs descent |
| D. Rogers Brubaker | IV. Three generations of human rights |
- (a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (b) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (c) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (d) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
Answer and explanation
(a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange in chronological order:
- Rights of Man (Paine)
- Universal Declaration of Human Rights
- Two Treatises of Government (Locke)
- Taking Rights Seriously (Dworkin)
- (a) 3, 1, 2, 4
- (b) 1, 3, 2, 4
- (c) 3, 2, 1, 4
- (d) 3, 1, 4, 2
Answer and explanation
(a). 1689 → 1791 → 1948 → 1977.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange T.H. Marshall’s elements of citizenship in the order in which he says they developed in England:
- Social
- Civil
- Political
- (a) 2, 3, 1
- (b) 3, 2, 1
- (c) 2, 1, 3
- (d) 1, 2, 3
Answer and explanation
(a) Civil (18th) → Political (19th) → Social (20th).
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker / source | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Locke | Two Treatises of Government | 1689 | Life, liberty, estate |
| French Declaration | Rights of Man and of the Citizen | 1789 | Natural, inalienable rights |
| Burke | Reflections on the Revolution in France | 1790 | Prescriptive rights |
| Paine | Rights of Man | 1791–92 | Natural rights; defends Revolution |
| Bentham | Anarchical Fallacies | — | “Nonsense upon stilts” |
| Marx | “On the Jewish Question” | 1843 | Rights of egoistic man |
| Hohfeld | “Some Fundamental Legal Conceptions…” | 1913 | Claim, privilege, power, immunity |
| Laski | A Grammar of Politics | 1925 | Rights as conditions of best self |
| UDHR | UN General Assembly | 1948 | 30 articles; 10 December |
| Marshall | Citizenship and Social Class | 1950 | Civil → political → social |
| Arendt | The Origins of Totalitarianism | 1951 | Right to have rights |
| Hart | “Are There Any Natural Rights?” | 1955 | Will (choice) theory |
| ICCPR / ICESCR | UN | 1966 (in force 1976) | Binding covenants |
| Dworkin | Taking Rights Seriously | 1977 | Rights as trumps |
| Vasak | Three generations | 1977 | Liberty, equality, fraternity |
| Raz | The Morality of Freedom | 1986 | Interest theory |
| Young | “Polity and Group Difference” | 1989 | Differentiated citizenship |
| Brubaker | Citizenship and Nationhood in France and Germany | 1992 | Jus soli vs jus sanguinis |
| Kymlicka | Multicultural Citizenship | 1995 | Group-differentiated rights |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Democracy and Power — citizenship in action: participation, representation and who really rules
- Feminism, Ecologism, Multiculturalism and Postmodernism — group rights and the politics of recognition
- Justice — the distributive theories behind social rights
- Political Theory — Quick Revision