Democracy and Power
Democracy and power for UGC NET: elitist, pluralist, participatory and deliberative democracy; Weber, Dahl, Lukes, Gramsci, Foucault and Arendt on power.
- 15 min
On this page · 12 sections
Prerequisites
- Rights and Citizenship — democracy presupposes citizens with equal political rights.
- Liberty and Equality — Constant’s ancient (participatory) and modern (private) liberty map onto direct and representative democracy.
The Hook: Who Governs New Haven?
How UGC NET asks it: definitions matched to thinkers (Lincoln, Schumpeter, Dahl, Weber, Lukes), the three faces of power in sequence, Weber’s three types of authority, Macpherson’s and Held’s models of democracy, and assertion–reason on elitism versus pluralism.
Part A: Democracy
1. Meaning
“Democracy” comes from the Greek demos (people) and kratos (rule or power). Abraham Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address (19 November 1863) gave the most quoted definition: government of the people, by the people, for the people. Pericles’ Funeral Oration (as reported by Thucydides) praised Athenian democracy, in which administration was in the hands of the many, not the few. Plato and Aristotle were critics: Aristotle classed democracy (rule of the poor many in their own interest) as a deviant form, with polity as its good counterpart.
2. Models of democracy
| Model | Core idea | Key thinkers and works |
|---|---|---|
| Classical / direct (Athenian) | Citizens decide directly in the assembly; offices by lot and rotation | Pericles; Aristotle’s description; Rousseau’s general will (The Social Contract, 1762): sovereignty cannot be represented |
| Protective (liberal) democracy | Democracy protects citizens from the government and from each other; accountability through elections | Bentham, James Mill |
| Developmental democracy | Participation develops citizens’ faculties | J.S. Mill, Considerations on Representative Government (1861): proportional representation (Hare scheme), plural voting for the educated |
| Competitive elitism | Democracy as a method: people choose between competing elites | Joseph Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (1942) |
| Pluralism | Power dispersed among many competing groups; government as arbiter | Robert Dahl, A Preface to Democratic Theory (1956), Who Governs? (1961); Arthur Bentley, David Truman |
| Polyarchy | Real-world democracies are “polyarchies”, judged on two dimensions: public contestation and inclusiveness (participation) | Dahl, Polyarchy (1971) |
| Participatory democracy | Widen participation into workplaces and communities; participation educates | Carole Pateman, Participation and Democratic Theory (1970); C.B. Macpherson; Benjamin Barber, Strong Democracy (1984) |
| Deliberative democracy | Legitimacy comes from free, reasoned public deliberation, not just aggregation of votes | Jürgen Habermas, Between Facts and Norms (1992); Joshua Cohen; Amy Gutmann and Dennis Thompson; John Dryzek; Rawls’s public reason |
| Consociational democracy | Power-sharing among elites of divided segments | Arend Lijphart, Democracy in Plural Societies (1977): grand coalition, mutual veto, proportionality, segmental autonomy |
| Agonistic democracy | Conflict is permanent; turn enemies into adversaries, not into consensus | Chantal Mouffe, The Democratic Paradox (2000) |
| Cosmopolitan democracy | Democracy beyond the nation-state | David Held, Democracy and the Global Order (1995) |
3. Macpherson’s and Held’s typologies
C.B. Macpherson, The Life and Times of Liberal Democracy (1977), traced four models of liberal democracy:
- Protective democracy — Bentham, James Mill;
- Developmental democracy — J.S. Mill (and later Dewey, Lindsay, Barker);
- Equilibrium democracy (pluralist-elitist) — Schumpeter, Dahl;
- Participatory democracy — his own proposal.
Macpherson’s earlier The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism (1962) argued that liberalism from Hobbes to Locke assumed the individual as the proprietor of his own person and capacities, owing nothing to society.
David Held, Models of Democracy (first edition 1987, expanded in later editions), gives a wider set: classical, republican and liberal models (each with protective and developmental forms), direct democracy (Marx), competitive elitism, pluralism, legal democracy (New Right) and participatory democracy; later editions add deliberative and cosmopolitan models.
4. Critics and challenges
- Tocqueville, Democracy in America (vol. 1 1835, vol. 2 1840): praised American associational life and local self-government but warned of the tyranny of the majority and of a soft “democratic despotism”.
- Marxist view: liberal democracy is a bourgeois democracy; the state is the executive committee of the bourgeoisie (Communist Manifesto, 1848); Lenin preferred “proletarian democracy” through soviets.
- Elitists (next section): every society is ruled by a minority.
- Waves of democratisation: Samuel Huntington, The Third Wave (1991), dated the third wave from Portugal’s Carnation Revolution of 1974.
- Francis Fukuyama, “The End of History?” (article 1989; book The End of History and the Last Man 1992): liberal democracy as the final form of human government.
5. Indian angle
India is a representative, parliamentary democracy with universal adult franchise from the first elections of 1951–52. Rajni Kothari’s “Congress system” (one-party dominance within a competitive system) and Lijphart’s later argument that India showed consociational features are standard items linking theory to Indian politics. Ambedkar insisted that political democracy cannot last unless it rests on social democracy, a way of life that recognises liberty, equality and fraternity together.
Part B: Elite Theory
| Thinker | Work (year) | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Gaetano Mosca | Elementi di scienza politica (1896), English The Ruling Class (1939) | In all societies there are two classes: a ruling class (minority, organised) and a ruled class (majority, unorganised); the “political formula” legitimises the rulers |
| Vilfredo Pareto | Trattato di sociologia generale (1916), English The Mind and Society (1935) | Circulation of elites; “history is a graveyard of aristocracies”; governing elites of lions (force, conservative) and foxes (cunning, innovative) |
| Robert Michels | Political Parties (1911) | Iron law of oligarchy: “who says organisation, says oligarchy”; studied the German Social Democratic Party |
| C. Wright Mills | The Power Elite (1956) | In the US a unified elite of corporate, military and political leaders makes key decisions |
| Schumpeter | 1942 | Democratic elitism: elites compete for votes |
Part C: Power, Authority and Legitimacy
6. Definitions
| Thinker | Work (year) | Definition / idea |
|---|---|---|
| Thomas Hobbes | Leviathan (1651) | A general inclination of all mankind is a perpetual and restless desire of power after power, that ceases only in death |
| Max Weber | Economy and Society (posthumous, 1922) | Power (Macht): the probability that an actor in a social relationship can carry out his own will despite resistance |
| Max Weber | “Politics as a Vocation” (lecture, 1919) | The state is a human community that successfully claims the monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within a territory |
| Bertrand Russell | Power: A New Social Analysis (1938) | Power is the production of intended effects; power is the fundamental concept of social science, as energy is in physics |
| Harold Lasswell | Politics: Who Gets What, When, How (1936); with Abraham Kaplan, Power and Society (1950) | Politics as the study of influence and the influential |
| David Easton | The Political System (1953) | Politics as the authoritative allocation of values for a society |
| Robert Dahl | “The Concept of Power” (1957) | A has power over B to the extent that he can get B to do something B would not otherwise do |
| Hannah Arendt | On Violence (1970) | Power is the human ability to act in concert; it belongs to a group, not an individual; power and violence are opposites — where one rules absolutely, the other is absent |
| Talcott Parsons | — | Power as a generalised capacity of the system to get things done for collective goals; a variable-sum, not zero-sum, view |
| Joseph Nye | Bound to Lead (1990); Soft Power (2004) | Soft power: getting others to want what you want through attraction (culture, values, policies), as against hard power (coercion, payment) |
7. The three faces (dimensions) of power
| Face | Thinkers | Focus | What it misses (according to the next) |
|---|---|---|---|
| One-dimensional | Dahl (1957, 1961); Polsby | Observable decision-making on key issues where there is overt conflict | Ignores agenda-setting |
| Two-dimensional | Bachrach and Baratz, “Two Faces of Power” (APSR, 1962); “Decisions and Nondecisions” (1963) | Non-decision-making: the “mobilisation of bias” (E.E. Schattschneider’s phrase) keeps issues off the agenda | Still assumes observable conflict and grievances |
| Three-dimensional | Steven Lukes, Power: A Radical View (1974; 2nd ed. 2005) | Shaping preferences so that people do not even recognise their real interests; the most effective power prevents conflict from arising | — |
8. Gramsci and Foucault
- Antonio Gramsci, Prison Notebooks (written 1929–1935): hegemony is rule by consent organised through civil society (church, schools, media, culture) backed by coercion in political society (the state). The ruling class becomes “leading” as well as “dominant”. Counter-hegemony needs organic intellectuals and a war of position (slow cultural struggle) rather than a war of manoeuvre (frontal assault, as in Russia 1917).
- Michel Foucault: power is not a possession held by a sovereign or class but a relation exercised throughout society (“power is everywhere”); it is productive (it produces knowledge, subjects, norms), not only repressive.
- Discipline and Punish (1975): from spectacular torture to disciplinary power; Bentham’s Panopticon as model of surveillance; normalisation, examination, hierarchical observation.
- The History of Sexuality, vol. 1 (1976): biopower and biopolitics, power over the life of populations (birth rates, health, hygiene).
- Power/knowledge: each produces the other; governmentality in his later lectures.
9. Authority and legitimacy
Authority is power accepted as legitimate: rightful power. Weber’s three ideal types of legitimate domination (Herrschaft):
| Type | Basis of legitimacy | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional | Sanctity of age-old customs and the inherited status of rulers | Patriarchal, patrimonial and feudal rule; hereditary monarchy |
| Charismatic | Extraordinary personal qualities of a leader, and followers’ devotion; unstable, subject to routinisation | Prophets, revolutionary leaders, Gandhi (commonly cited) |
| Legal-rational | Belief in the legality of enacted rules and the right of those appointed under them to give orders | Modern bureaucracy, constitutional government |
Legitimacy crises: Habermas, Legitimation Crisis (1973), argued that late capitalism faces economic, rationality, legitimation and motivation crises as the state takes on economic management.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Schumpeter — competitive elitism (1942) | vs | Mills — power elite (1956) |
| Dahl, Preface (1956) / Who Governs? (1961) | vs | Dahl, Polyarchy (1971) |
| Pateman — participatory (1970) | vs | Habermas — deliberative (1992) |
| Macpherson — four models of liberal democracy (1977) | vs | Held — Models of Democracy (1987) |
| Arendt — power and violence are opposites | vs | Weber — state = monopoly of legitimate force |
| Gramsci — hegemony via consent in civil society | vs | Foucault — capillary, productive, disciplinary power |
| Lijphart — consociational (power-sharing) | vs | Mouffe — agonistic (conflict as adversaries) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who wrote Political Parties (1911) and formulated the iron law of oligarchy?
- What are Dahl’s two dimensions of polyarchy?
- Which of Weber’s types of authority is based on belief in enacted rules?
Answers
- Robert Michels.
- Public contestation (liberalisation) and inclusiveness (participation).
- Legal-rational authority.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) “A has power over B to the extent that he can get B to do something that B would not otherwise do.” This definition was given by:
- (a) Max Weber
- (b) Robert Dahl
- (c) Steven Lukes
- (d) Harold Lasswell
Answer and explanation
(b) Robert Dahl, “The Concept of Power” (1957).
Q2. (Practice) Which of the following is not one of the features of consociational democracy identified by Arend Lijphart?
- (a) Grand coalition
- (b) Mutual veto
- (c) Proportionality
- (d) Winner-takes-all majority rule
Answer and explanation
(d). Consociationalism is the opposite of majoritarian winner-takes-all; its four features are grand coalition, mutual veto, proportionality and segmental autonomy.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Gramsci distinguished between a war of position and a war of manoeuvre.
- Foucault’s Discipline and Punish uses Bentham’s Panopticon as a model of disciplinary power.
- Hannah Arendt held that power is the property of an individual and grows out of the barrel of a gun.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 2 only. Arendt held that power belongs to a group acting in concert, and she explicitly rejected the idea that power grows out of the barrel of a gun (Mao’s phrase): violence can destroy power but cannot create it.
Q4. (Practice) C.B. Macpherson’s four models of liberal democracy are:
- (a) Protective, developmental, equilibrium, participatory
- (b) Classical, republican, elitist, deliberative
- (c) Direct, representative, consociational, cosmopolitan
- (d) Liberal, social, people’s, guided
Answer and explanation
(a), from The Life and Times of Liberal Democracy (1977).
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Bachrach and Baratz criticised Dahl’s study of power in New Haven. Reason (R): Dahl’s method studied only observable decisions and ignored non-decision-making.
Answer and explanation
(a). The neglect of non-decisions is exactly their criticism in “Two Faces of Power” (1962).
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Schumpeter’s theory is called competitive elitism. Reason (R): Schumpeter held that voters directly decide policies through referendums.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true. R is false: for Schumpeter voters choose between competing leaders, not policies.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Thinker) with List II (Concept).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Vilfredo Pareto | I. Political formula |
| B. Gaetano Mosca | II. Circulation of elites |
| C. Robert Michels | III. Power elite |
| D. C. Wright Mills | IV. Iron law of oligarchy |
- (a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (b) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (c) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (d) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation
(a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following contributions to the debate on power in chronological order:
- Lukes, Power: A Radical View
- Dahl, “The Concept of Power”
- Bachrach and Baratz, “Two Faces of Power”
- Foucault, Discipline and Punish
- (a) 2, 3, 1, 4
- (b) 3, 2, 1, 4
- (c) 2, 3, 4, 1
- (d) 2, 1, 3, 4
Answer and explanation
(a). 1957 → 1962 → 1974 → 1975.
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lincoln | Gettysburg Address | 1863 | Of, by, for the people |
| Tocqueville | Democracy in America | 1835, 1840 | Tyranny of the majority; associations |
| J.S. Mill | Considerations on Representative Government | 1861 | Developmental democracy; PR |
| Mosca | Elementi di scienza politica | 1896 | Ruling class; political formula |
| Michels | Political Parties | 1911 | Iron law of oligarchy |
| Pareto | Trattato di sociologia generale | 1916 | Circulation of elites; lions and foxes |
| Weber | “Politics as a Vocation” / Economy and Society | 1919 / 1922 | Monopoly of legitimate force; three authorities |
| Schumpeter | Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy | 1942 | Competitive elitism |
| Easton | The Political System | 1953 | Authoritative allocation of values |
| Mills | The Power Elite | 1956 | Corporate–military–political elite |
| Dahl | “The Concept of Power” / Who Governs? / Polyarchy | 1957 / 1961 / 1971 | Pluralism; polyarchy |
| Bachrach and Baratz | “Two Faces of Power” | 1962 | Non-decision-making |
| Pateman | Participation and Democratic Theory | 1970 | Participatory democracy |
| Arendt | On Violence | 1970 | Power as acting in concert |
| Lukes | Power: A Radical View | 1974 | Third dimension |
| Foucault | Discipline and Punish | 1975 | Disciplinary power; Panopticon |
| Macpherson | The Life and Times of Liberal Democracy | 1977 | Four models |
| Lijphart | Democracy in Plural Societies | 1977 | Consociationalism |
| Held | Models of Democracy | 1987 | Typology of democracy |
| Huntington | The Third Wave | 1991 | Democratisation since 1974 |
| Habermas | Between Facts and Norms | 1992 | Deliberative democracy |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Liberalism, Conservatism, Socialism and Marxism — the ideologies that give these theories of democracy their content
- Feminism, Ecologism, Multiculturalism and Postmodernism — Foucault’s power in postmodern theory
- Political Theory — Quick Revision
- Paper 1 link: Research Aptitude — Dahl’s New Haven study is a case study, and behaviourist political science grew out of positivism