Dharmashastra, Kautilya, Aggannasutta, Barani and Kabir
Ancient and medieval Indian political thought for UGC NET: Manu's rajadharma, Kautilya's saptanga and mandala, the Aggannasutta, Barani's zawabit and Kabir.
- 21 min
On this page · 14 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Three Answers to “Why a King?”
- 1. Dharmashastra: Rajadharma and Danda
- 2. Kautilya: The Arthashastra
- 3. The Aggannasutta: A Buddhist Social Contract
- 4. Ziauddin Barani: Kingship in the Delhi Sultanate
- 5. Kabir: Dissent from Below
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- The chapter overview for how this unit is asked.
- From History Paper 2, Sources of Ancient Indian History covers the Arthashastra as a source (its discovery and dating debate) and Jainism, Buddhism and the Ajivikas gives the Buddhist background to the Aggannasutta.
- Justice in Unit 1 already uses two Sanskrit terms from this page’s world, nyaya and matsyanyaya, through Amartya Sen.
The Hook: Three Answers to “Why a King?”
How UGC NET asks it: the seven limbs and their order; the six measures (shadgunya) and four means (upayas); the four vidyas and which school accepted how many; Mahasammata, Khattiya and Raja; Barani’s zawabit and his two books; Kabir’s forms (sakhi, sabad, ramaini) and his critique of caste.
1. Dharmashastra: Rajadharma and Danda
What the texts are
Dharmashastra is the Sanskrit genre of texts on dharma: duty, law, ritual and right conduct. It has two layers.
| Layer | Form | Main texts |
|---|---|---|
| Dharmasutras | Prose aphorisms, older | Apastamba, Gautama, Baudhayana, Vasishtha |
| Dharmashastras / Smritis | Verse, later and systematic | Manusmriti (Manava Dharmashastra), Yajnavalkya Smriti, Narada Smriti, Brihaspati, Katyayana |
| Commentaries and digests | Medieval | Vijnaneshvara’s Mitakshara (on Yajnavalkya); Jimutavahana’s Dayabhaga |
The Manusmriti is the most cited. Its date is debated; it is usually placed somewhere between about the 2nd century BCE and the 2nd century CE. It has 12 chapters: chapter 7 is on the king’s duties (rajadharma), and chapters 8 and 9 on law and procedure (vyavahara), including the eighteen titles of law (grounds of litigation such as debt, deposits, boundary disputes, assault, theft and inheritance).
The Mitakshara and Dayabhaga became the two classical schools of Hindu family and inheritance law; colonial courts used them. P.V. Kane’s multi-volume History of Dharmasastra is the standard modern survey.
Sources of dharma
Manu names four sources, in order of authority:
- Shruti — the Veda (revealed)
- Smriti — remembered tradition (the Dharmashastras themselves)
- Sadachara — the conduct of the virtuous
- Atmatushti — what is pleasing to oneself (one’s conscience)
Political ideas
| Idea | What the Dharmashastra says |
|---|---|
| Origin of kingship | When people were without a king and scattered in fear, the Lord created the king for the protection of all, from particles of eight guardian deities (Indra, Vayu, Yama, Surya, Agni, Varuna, Chandra and Kubera). Hence the king is a great deity in human form, not to be despised even as a child. |
| Danda | Punishment is itself the true king: it governs and protects all creatures, and without it the strong would roast the weak like fish on a spit. Justly used, it makes people prosper; misused, it destroys the king. |
| Purpose of the state | To protect the social order of varna and ashrama (varnashrama dharma); the king does not make dharma but upholds it. |
| Seven limbs | Manu also lists seven constituents of the state (lord, minister, capital, territory, treasury, army, ally), close to Kautilya’s saptanga. |
| Ministers and council | The king should take counsel with a small body of ministers of good family, learned in the shastras; the Brahmin purohita has a special place. |
| Foreign policy | The circle of states and the six measures (peace, war and so on) also appear in Manu, in brief. |
| Apaddharma | Rules for times of distress, when normal duties may be relaxed. |
The broader rajadharma tradition includes the Shantiparva of the Mahabharata, where the dying Bhishma instructs Yudhishthira. It has both a divine-origin story and a contract-like story in which people, tired of matsyanyaya, accept Manu as king and agree to pay him a share of their produce.
2. Kautilya: The Arthashastra
The text
- Author: Kautilya, identified in tradition with Chanakya and Vishnugupta, minister of Chandragupta Maurya (late 4th century BCE).
- Rediscovery: the manuscript was found and published by R. Shamasastry (text 1909, English translation 1915).
- Date debate: tradition makes it Mauryan; many modern scholars (for example Thomas Trautmann’s statistical study of 1971) see a composite text with a Mauryan core and layers added in the early centuries CE. Say “dated variously” if asked.
- Structure (as the text describes itself): 15 books (adhikaranas), 150 chapters, 180 sections (prakaranas).
- Meaning: artha is the earth inhabited by people (and wealth); Arthashastra is the science of acquiring and protecting the earth.
The four sciences (vidyas)
Kautilya opens by listing the sciences a king must study, and reports what earlier schools said:
| School | Number of sciences accepted |
|---|---|
| Manavas (followers of Manu) | Three: trayi, varta, dandaniti (they treat anvikshiki as part of trayi) |
| Barhaspatyas (followers of Brihaspati) | Two: varta, dandaniti |
| Aushanasas (followers of Ushanas/Shukra) | One: dandaniti |
| Kautilya | Four: anvikshiki (philosophy and logic: Samkhya, Yoga, Lokayata), trayi (the three Vedas), varta (economics: agriculture, cattle-rearing, trade), dandaniti (the science of government) |
Dandaniti secures the other three; without the rod, matsyanyaya prevails.
Saptanga: the seven limbs of the state
- Swami — the king
- Amatya — ministers and officials
- Janapada — the territory with its people
- Durga — the fortified city
- Kosha — the treasury
- Danda — the army (also the coercive power)
- Mitra — the ally
The order matters: Kautilya ranks a calamity to an earlier limb as more serious than one to a later limb, and the king is the most important because he appoints and corrects the others. The organic image (limbs of one body) is often compared with Western organic theories of the state.
The king and his duties
- Ideal king: disciplined, master of his senses (indriyajaya), guided by elders, with a strict daily timetable for audience, revenue, council, spies and rest.
- Welfare as legitimacy: “In the happiness of the subjects lies the happiness of the king; in their welfare his own welfare” (paraphrase of Book 1). The king’s personal pleasure is not his good; the subjects’ good is.
- Danda: a king with too severe a rod terrifies people; one with too mild a rod is despised; a just rod is respected.
- Administration: superintendents (adhyakshas) of departments (treasury, mines, trade, agriculture, liquor and others) in Book 2; a dense system of spies (gudhapurushas), many in disguise.
- Courts: dharmasthiya courts for civil disputes and kantakashodhana (“removal of thorns”) courts for criminal matters and threats to public order.
- Four sources of law: dharma, vyavahara (transactions and evidence), charitra (custom) and rajashasana (the royal edict). Where they conflict, the later prevails, so the king’s edict stands above the others in the courts.
Foreign policy: the mandala and the six measures
The mandala (circle of kings) is built around the vijigishu, the would-be conqueror.
| Position | Who |
|---|---|
| In front of the vijigishu, in order | Ari (enemy, the immediate neighbour) → mitra (friend, the enemy’s neighbour) → ari-mitra (the enemy’s friend) → mitra-mitra (friend’s friend) → ari-mitra-mitra (enemy’s friend’s friend) |
| Behind the vijigishu | Parshnigraha (rear enemy) → akranda (rear friend) → parshnigrahasara (ally of the rear enemy) → akrandasara (ally of the rear friend) |
| Outside the two camps | Madhyama (the middle king, bordering both, stronger than either) and udasina (the neutral king, stronger still) |
Counting the vijigishu, that is 12 kings: 1 + 5 in front + 4 behind + 2 outside. The logic, “my neighbour is my natural enemy; my neighbour’s neighbour is my natural friend”, is why Kautilya is read as an early realist.
The six measures (shadgunya):
| Measure | Meaning | When to use (Kautilya’s rule of thumb) |
|---|---|---|
| Sandhi | Peace, treaty | When declining (weaker) relative to the enemy |
| Vigraha | Hostility, war | When prospering (stronger) relative to the enemy |
| Asana | Staying quiet, neutrality | When neither can harm the other |
| Yana | Marching, preparing to attack | When one has a marked superiority (an excess of strength and good qualities) |
| Samshraya | Seeking shelter with a stronger king | When very weak |
| Dvaidhibhava | Double policy: peace with one, war with another | When one needs help from one to fight another |
The four means (upayas): sama (conciliation), dana (gifts), bheda (sowing dissension) and danda (force). Book 12 also distinguishes three kinds of conqueror: the righteous (dharmavijayi, content with submission), the greedy (lobhavijayi, wants land and wealth) and the demoniac (asuravijayi, wants land, wealth, family and life).
3. The Aggannasutta: A Buddhist Social Contract
The text and setting
- The Aggañña Sutta (“Discourse on Origins”, or “on what is primary”) is the 27th sutta of the Digha Nikaya of the Pali canon (Sutta Pitaka).
- The Buddha, staying near Savatthi (Shravasti), speaks to two young Brahmins, Vasettha and Bharadvaja, who are living among the monks in the hope of ordination and are being abused by other Brahmins for leaving the “highest caste”.
- His first point: Brahmins claim to be born from the mouth of Brahma, yet Brahmin women are seen to menstruate, conceive and give birth like everyone else. The claim of birth-based superiority is simply false.
The origin story
| Stage | What happens |
|---|---|
| 1. Golden age | Beings are self-luminous, mind-made, feeding on joy |
| 2. Fall through craving | They taste a savoury earth; greed grows, their radiance fades; sun, moon and the distinction of beauty appear, and with it pride |
| 3. Rice and storing | Self-growing rice appears; people start storing it out of laziness; it stops regrowing |
| 4. Property | They divide the land into plots: private property begins |
| 5. Crime | Someone steals from another’s plot; theft brings lying, blame and violence |
| 6. Election | People meet and choose the most handsome, capable person to be angry where anger is due, censure and banish wrongdoers, in return for a share of rice |
Three titles of the first ruler
- Mahasammata — “the Great Elect”, chosen by the whole people.
- Khattiya — “lord of the fields” (khettanam pati).
- Raja — “he who delights (gladdens) others by dhamma”.
The other groups are then explained by occupation, not divine birth: Brahmins as those who put aside evil and meditate (or, failing, compose texts), Vessas by trades, Suddas by hunting and lesser work. People from all four can renounce and become samanas. The sutta ends that dhamma is the best thing among people, in this life and the next, and that the person perfect in knowledge and conduct is highest among gods and humans.
Why political scientists read it
- One of the oldest social-contract accounts of the state anywhere: authority comes from an agreement to end disorder, and the ruler is paid for a service.
- It desacralises kingship and caste, in contrast to the Dharmashastra’s divine king.
- Like Hobbes, it starts from conflict over property; like Locke, it makes the ruler an agent to protect property; unlike both, it is framed as a moral fall through craving (tanha).
- The neighbouring sutta in the same collection, the Cakkavatti-Sihanada Sutta (Digha Nikaya 26), describes the righteous universal monarch (chakravartin) who rules by dhamma: the Buddhist ideal of kingship that Ashoka’s dhamma is often compared with.
4. Ziauddin Barani: Kingship in the Delhi Sultanate
The man and his works
Ziauddin Barani (c. 1285–c. 1357), named after Baran (modern Bulandshahr), was a courtier (nadim) of Muhammad bin Tughluq, a disciple of the Sufi Nizamuddin Auliya and a friend of the poet Amir Khusrau. He lost favour under Firuz Shah Tughluq and wrote in disgrace.
| Work | Type | Key content |
|---|---|---|
| Tarikh-i-Firuz Shahi (completed 1357) | History | The Delhi Sultans from Balban to the early years of Firuz Shah Tughluq; the main source for Alauddin Khalji’s market control and Muhammad bin Tughluq’s experiments |
| Fatawa-i-Jahandari | Political treatise, a “mirror for princes” | Advice on kingship, framed as the counsel of Sultan Mahmud of Ghazni to his sons |
Key ideas
- Kingship and religion are twins but in tension. True religion (din) needs the protection of a king; but the ways of successful kingship come from the ancient Persian emperors, pomp, majesty, harsh punishment, and these are opposed to the simple life of the Prophet. A Muslim king therefore lives in a moral dilemma; he must follow the shariat as far as he can and seek forgiveness for what statecraft forces on him.
- Zawabit. Because the shariat does not cover everything a state must do, the ruler may issue state laws (zawabit), made after consultation with wise counsellors, in the public interest, without contradicting the shariat. This is Barani’s best-known concept: a theory of secular state legislation inside a religious frame.
- Duties of the ruler: protect and promote the true faith (Sunni orthodoxy), patronise the ulama, suppress heresy, and above all do justice (adl); justice is the foundation of a kingdom.
- Counsel (mashwarat): a king must consult wise, experienced and loyal advisers.
- Hierarchy of birth. Barani is openly aristocratic: offices should go to the high-born (ashraf), not the low-born (ajlaf), and he even urged that the low-born not be taught letters. He was also harsh towards Hindu subjects and wanted them kept humbled.
- Ideal rulers: he praises Balban (majesty and order) and Alauddin’s control of prices, while criticising Muhammad bin Tughluq’s “experiments”.
5. Kabir: Dissent from Below
Life and works
- Kabir lived in the 15th century in Kashi (Varanasi), a weaver (julaha) by occupation. His exact dates are uncertain; the traditional span of 1398 to 1518 is not reliable. Tradition makes Ramananda his guru and says he died at Maghar.
- His sayings survive in three main collections: the Bijak (of the Kabirpanth), the Kabir Granthavali (Rajasthani tradition) and the verses included in the Guru Granth Sahib.
- Forms: sakhi (couplets, “witness”), sabad (songs) and ramaini (verses in chaupai-doha form).
- His language mixes several dialects, called sadhukkadi (language of wandering ascetics). Rabindranath Tagore published English translations, Songs of Kabir (1915).
Ideas with political meaning
| Theme | Kabir’s position |
|---|---|
| God | Nirguna — without attributes, form or incarnation; Ram, Rahim, Hari are names of one reality found within |
| Caste | Birth gives no merit: “do not ask a holy man his caste, ask about his knowledge” (the well-known line jati na puchho sadhu ki) |
| Religious authority | Mocks both the pandit and the mullah, idol worship and pilgrimage as well as the call to prayer and fasting; both “Hindu” and “Turk” have lost the way |
| Ritual and scripture | Experience and love (prem) above book learning: the reader of many books dies without becoming learned; one who knows the “two and a half letters of love” is the true pandit |
| Labour and the everyday | Speaks from the loom and the market, in the voice of the working poor |
Kabir did not write a theory of the state. He is in a political thought syllabus because he is the most powerful pre-modern voice of equality and dissent from below: against caste, priesthood and communal boundaries. Ambedkar named three gurus: the Buddha, Kabir and Jotirao Phule. Gandhi’s prayer meetings, Tagore’s humanism and the anti-caste movements all drew on Kabir.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Dharmasutras — older prose (Apastamba, Gautama) | vs | Dharmashastras — later verse smritis (Manu, Yajnavalkya) |
| Mitakshara — Vijnaneshvara, commentary on Yajnavalkya | vs | Dayabhaga — Jimutavahana, Bengal school |
| Danda as one of the seven limbs — the army | vs | Danda as one of the four upayas — force; and dandaniti — the science of government |
| Mitra — the friend beyond the enemy (front) | vs | Akranda — the friend behind the vijigishu (rear) |
| Madhyama — middle king, borders both | vs | Udasina — neutral king, outside and strongest |
| Dharmasthiya — civil courts | vs | Kantakashodhana — criminal courts, “removal of thorns” |
| Aggannasutta — Digha Nikaya 27, origin of king and varnas | vs | Cakkavatti-Sihanada Sutta — Digha Nikaya 26, the universal monarch |
| Tarikh-i-Firuz Shahi — Barani’s history | vs | Fatawa-i-Jahandari — Barani’s political treatise |
| Kabir — nirguna, weaver of Kashi | vs | Ravidas — nirguna, leather-worker; his ideal city is Begampura (not Kabir’s) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Name the seventh and last limb in Kautilya’s saptanga.
- In the Aggannasutta, what is the title of the first ruler chosen by the people?
- What did Barani call the state laws a Sultan may make alongside the shariat?
- How many kings make up Kautilya’s mandala, counting the vijigishu?
Answers
- Mitra (the ally).
- Mahasammata, “the Great Elect”.
- Zawabit.
- Twelve: the vijigishu, five kings in front, four behind, and the madhyama and udasina (1 + 5 + 4 + 2 = 12).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) According to Kautilya, which school of thought accepted only dandaniti as a science?
- (a) Manavas
- (b) Barhaspatyas
- (c) Aushanasas
- (d) Lokayatas
Answer and explanation
(c) Aushanasas (followers of Ushanas/Shukra). The Manavas accepted three and the Barhaspatyas two; Kautilya accepted four. Lokayata is one of the philosophies inside anvikshiki, not a school counting the sciences.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about the Aggannasutta:
- It is part of the Digha Nikaya.
- It explains the origin of kingship through an agreement among people troubled by theft.
- It upholds the Brahmin claim of birth from the mouth of Brahma.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 1 and 2 only. It is Digha Nikaya 27 and gives a contractual origin of kingship. Statement 3 is the claim the Buddha ridicules: Brahmin women give birth like everyone else.
Q3. (Practice) In Kautilya’s scheme, a king who is weaker than his enemy should normally adopt:
- (a) Vigraha
- (b) Sandhi
- (c) Yana
- (d) Asana
Answer and explanation
(b) Sandhi (peace). Vigraha is for the king who is prospering relative to the enemy, yana for a king with a marked superiority, and asana when neither side can harm the other.
Q4. (Practice) Which of the following pairs is incorrectly matched?
- (a) Fatawa-i-Jahandari — Ziauddin Barani
- (b) Mitakshara — Vijnaneshvara
- (c) Bijak — Kabir
- (d) Dayabhaga — Yajnavalkya
Answer and explanation
(d). The Dayabhaga is by Jimutavahana. Yajnavalkya is the smriti on which Vijnaneshvara’s Mitakshara comments.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Barani held that a Muslim ruler faces a moral dilemma in governing. Reason (R): Barani believed that the practices needed for successful kingship come from the Persian emperors and conflict with the Prophet’s way of life.
Answer and explanation
(a). The dilemma in A follows from R: statecraft requires Persian majesty and severity, which religion does not approve, so the king must follow the shariat as far as possible and seek forgiveness for the rest.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): In Kautilya’s mandala, the immediate neighbour of the vijigishu is treated as his natural enemy. Reason (R): Kautilya regarded the madhyama king as stronger than the udasina king.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true: the neighbour is the ari. R is false: the udasina (neutral) is described as the stronger of the two, beyond both the vijigishu’s camp and the madhyama.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Term) with List II (Meaning).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Kantakashodhana | I. Seeking shelter with a stronger king |
| B. Samshraya | II. Criminal courts, “removal of thorns” |
| C. Varta | III. Lord of the fields |
| D. Khattiya | IV. Economics: agriculture, cattle-rearing and trade |
- (a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (b) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (c) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (d) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation
(a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III. Khattiya comes from the Aggannasutta; the other three are Kautilyan terms.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the limbs of the state in the order Kautilya lists them:
- Kosha
- Amatya
- Durga
- Mitra
- Janapada
- (a) 2, 5, 3, 1, 4
- (b) 2, 3, 5, 1, 4
- (c) 5, 2, 3, 1, 4
- (d) 2, 5, 1, 3, 4
Answer and explanation
(a) 2, 5, 3, 1, 4. The full order is swami, amatya, janapada, durga, kosha, danda, mitra.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange Kautilya’s four sources of law from the weakest to the strongest when they conflict:
- Rajashasana
- Charitra
- Dharma
- Vyavahara
- (a) 3, 4, 2, 1
- (b) 1, 2, 4, 3
- (c) 3, 2, 4, 1
- (d) 4, 3, 2, 1
Answer and explanation
(a) 3, 4, 2, 1. Kautilya lists dharma, vyavahara, charitra, rajashasana, and each later one prevails over the earlier.
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker / text | Work | Date | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manu | Manusmriti (12 chapters) | c. 2nd c. BCE–2nd c. CE (debated) | Divine king from eight deities; danda is the real king; varnashrama; 18 titles of law |
| Yajnavalkya / Vijnaneshvara | Yajnavalkya Smriti / Mitakshara | — / medieval | Classical school of Hindu law |
| Jimutavahana | Dayabhaga | Medieval | Bengal school of inheritance |
| Kautilya | Arthashastra (15 books, 150 chapters, 180 sections) | Mauryan tradition; date debated | Saptanga, mandala (12 kings), shadgunya, four upayas, four vidyas |
| R. Shamasastry | Edition / translation of Arthashastra | 1909 / 1915 | Rediscovery |
| Buddha | Aggannasutta (Digha Nikaya 27) | Pali canon | Mahasammata: elected king; varnas by occupation |
| Barani | Tarikh-i-Firuz Shahi; Fatawa-i-Jahandari | 1357 (Tarikh) | Zawabit; din vs jahandari; high-born for office |
| Kabir | Bijak; verses in Guru Granth Sahib | 15th century | Nirguna; against caste, pandit and mullah |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Ramabai, Tilak, Vivekananda, Tagore and Aurobindo — how the 19th-century renaissance turned these traditions into arguments about reform and nation
- Ambedkar, Periyar, Iqbal and Savarkar — the modern attack on the Manusmriti and on caste
- Liberty and Equality — the Unit 1 concepts that Kabir and Ambedkar give an Indian voice
- Indian Political Thought — Quick Revision