Skip to content

Comparative Political Analysis Short Notes

One-page UGC NET revision for Comparative Political Analysis: approaches, nationalism, state, regimes, constitutionalism, development, democratisation, parties.

  • 13 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 12 sections
  1. 1. Approaches and Comparative Methods
  2. 2. Colonialism and Decolonisation
  3. 3. Nationalism
  4. 4. State Theory
  5. 5. Structures of Power
  6. 6. Political Regimes
  7. 7. Constitutions and Constitutionalism
  8. 8. Development
  9. 9. Democratisation
  10. 10. Actors and Processes
  11. Ten Traps in One Box
  12. Where to Go Next

The whole of Unit 4 on one page. For explanations, go back to the chapter.

1. Approaches and Comparative Methods

ThinkerWorkYearKey idea
MillA System of Logic1843Methods of agreement, difference, concomitant variations
BryceModern Democracies1921Traditional institutional comparison
EastonThe Political System1953Systems approach
MacridisThe Study of Comparative Government1955Non-comparative, descriptive, parochial, static, monographic
BanfieldThe Moral Basis of a Backward Society1958Amoral familism
Almond and ColemanThe Politics of the Developing Areas1960Input and output functions
Almond and VerbaThe Civic Culture1963Parochial, subject, participant; USA, UK, W. Germany, Italy, Mexico
Barrington MooreSocial Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy1966Three routes; “no bourgeois, no democracy”
Sartori“Concept Misformation in Comparative Politics”1970Conceptual stretching; ladder of abstraction
Przeworski and TeuneThe Logic of Comparative Social Inquiry1970MSSD (difference) and MDSD (agreement)
Lijphart“Comparative Politics and the Comparative Method”1971Many variables, small N; six case-study types
InglehartThe Silent Revolution1977Post-materialism
DiMaggio and Powell“The Iron Cage Revisited”1983Coercive, mimetic, normative isomorphism
March and Olsen“The New Institutionalism”1984Logic of appropriateness
Evans, Rueschemeyer, SkocpolBringing the State Back In1985State as actor
RaginThe Comparative Method1987QCA
NorthInstitutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance1990Rules of the game
PutnamMaking Democracy Work1993Social capital, Italian regions
Hall and Taylor“Political Science and the Three New Institutionalisms”1996Historical, rational choice, sociological
Hall and SoskiceVarieties of Capitalism2001LMEs vs CMEs

Moore’s routes: bourgeois revolution → democracy (England, France, US); revolution from above → fascism (Germany, Japan); peasant revolution → communism (Russia, China).

Design rule: most similar systems ↔ method of difference; most different systems ↔ method of agreement.

2. Colonialism and Decolonisation

Form of colonialismExample
SettlerNorth America, Australia, Algeria, South Africa
ExploitationBritish India, Belgian Congo
PlantationCaribbean, Mauritius, Fiji
ProtectorateIndian princely states, Morocco
Mandate / trusteeshipLeague Article 22 (A, B, C); UN Charter Chapters XII–XIII
Informal empireGallagher and Robinson (1953)
Internal colonialismHechter (1975), Celtic fringe
Thinker / eventWork / detailYearKey idea
Berlin ConferencePartition of Africa1884–85Arbitrary borders
HobsonImperialism: A Study1902Underconsumption
NaorojiPoverty and Un-British Rule in India1901Drain of wealth
HilferdingFinance Capital1910Finance capital
LuxemburgThe Accumulation of Capital1913Need for non-capitalist areas
LeninImperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism1917Monopoly stage; five features
Schumpeter“The Sociology of Imperialisms”1919Atavism
LugardThe Dual Mandate1922Indirect rule
Pan-African CongressManchester1945Pan-Africanism
CésaireDiscourse on Colonialism1950Négritude
FanonBlack Skin, White Masks1952Psychology of racism
BandungAsian–African Conference195529 states
MemmiThe Colonizer and the Colonized1957Mutual dehumanisation
UNGAResolution 1514 (XV), 14 December1960Independence declaration
FanonThe Wretched of the Earth1961Violence; distrust of national bourgeoisie
NAMBelgrade summit1961Non-alignment
NkrumahNeo-Colonialism1965Last stage of imperialism
SaidOrientalism1978Constructed Orient
Guha (ed.)Subaltern Studies I1982History from below
NandyThe Intimate Enemy1983Colonised mind
Spivak“Can the Subaltern Speak?”1988Silenced subaltern
BhabhaThe Location of Culture1994Hybridity, mimicry

Decolonisation waves: Americas (1776–1820s) → post-1918 empires → Asia (1946–49) → Africa (1957–60s) → Portuguese Africa (1974–75), Zimbabwe (1980), Namibia (1990) → Hong Kong (1997), Macau (1999), Timor-Leste (2002).

3. Nationalism

ThinkerWorkYearKey idea
FichteAddresses to the German Nation1807–08Cultural nationalism
Renan“What Is a Nation?”1882Daily plebiscite
TagoreNationalism1917Critique of the nation-state
StalinMarxism and the National Question1913Language, territory, economic life, psychological make-up
KohnThe Idea of Nationalism1944Civic (West) vs ethnic (East)
DesaiSocial Background of Indian Nationalism1948Marxist interpretation
KedourieNationalism1960Invented in Europe, early nineteenth century
SealThe Emergence of Indian Nationalism1968Cambridge School
NairnThe Break-up of Britain1977Modern Janus
BreuillyNationalism and the State1982Nationalism as politics
GellnerNations and Nationalism1983Political and national unit congruent
AndersonImagined Communities1983Imagined, limited, sovereign; print capitalism
Hobsbawm and RangerThe Invention of Tradition1983Invented traditions
SmithThe Ethnic Origins of Nations1986Ethnie; ethno-symbolism
ChatterjeeNationalist Thought and the Colonial World1986Departure (Bankim), manoeuvre (Gandhi), arrival (Nehru)
HobsbawmNations and Nationalism since 17801990Modernist
ChatterjeeThe Nation and Its Fragments1993Inner vs outer domain

Schools: primordialism (Shils, Geertz) · perennialism (Hastings) · modernism (Gellner, Anderson, Hobsbawm, Breuilly) · ethno-symbolism (Smith, Hutchinson, Armstrong). Hroch: phases A (scholarly), B (agitation), C (mass).

4. State Theory

ThinkerWorkYearKey idea
Marx and EngelsCommunist Manifesto1848Committee of the bourgeoisie
MarxEighteenth Brumaire1852Bonapartism
EngelsAnti-Dühring / Origin of the Family…1878 / 1884State withers away; class origin of state
LeninThe State and Revolution1917Smash the state; dictatorship of proletariat
Weber“Politics as a Vocation”1919Monopoly of legitimate force
TrotskyThe Revolution Betrayed1936Degenerated workers’ state
BeveridgeReport1942Want, Disease, Ignorance, Squalor, Idleness
MarshallCitizenship and Social Class1950Social rights
Friedrich and BrzezinskiTotalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy1956Six-point syndrome
DjilasThe New Class1957Bureaucracy as ruling class
MyrdalAsian Drama1968Soft state
PoulantzasPolitical Power and Social Classes1968Structuralism; relative autonomy
MilibandThe State in Capitalist Society1969Instrumentalism
Althusser“Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses”1970RSA vs ISAs
Alavi“The State in Post-Colonial Societies”1972Overdeveloped state; military-bureaucratic oligarchy; three classes
O’ConnorThe Fiscal Crisis of the State1973Accumulation vs legitimation
TitmussSocial Policy1974Residual, achievement-performance, institutional
LindblomPolitics and Markets1977Privileged position of business
SkocpolStates and Social Revolutions1979State autonomy
KornaiEconomics of Shortage1980Soft budget constraint
JohnsonMITI and the Japanese Miracle1982Developmental state
BardhanThe Political Economy of Development in India1984Three dominant proprietary classes
Mann“The Autonomous Power of the State”1984Despotic vs infrastructural power
OffeContradictions of the Welfare State1984Can’t live with or without it
Rudolph and RudolphIn Pursuit of Lakshmi1987Weak-strong state; demand vs command polity
MigdalStrong Societies and Weak States1988State in society
Esping-AndersenThe Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism1990Liberal, conservative-corporatist, social democratic; decommodification
JacksonQuasi-States1990Negative sovereignty
OhmaeThe End of the Nation State1995Hyperglobalist
EvansEmbedded Autonomy1995Developmental vs predatory
Hirst and ThompsonGlobalization in Question1996Sceptic
StrangeThe Retreat of the State1996Authority shifts to markets
MamdaniCitizen and Subject1996Bifurcated state
GiddensThe Third Way1998Social investment state
Held et al.Global Transformations1999Transformationalist
RodrikThe Globalization Paradox2011Trilemma

5. Structures of Power

ThinkerWorkYearKey idea
MoscaElementi di scienza politica1896Ruling class; political formula
MichelsPolitical Parties1911Iron law of oligarchy
ParetoTrattato di sociologia generale1916Circulation of elites
BurnhamThe Managerial Revolution1941Managerial elite
SchumpeterCapitalism, Socialism and Democracy1942Democratic (competitive) elitism
HunterCommunity Power Structure1953Reputational method, Atlanta
MillsThe Power Elite1956Corporate, military, political
Dahl“A Critique of the Ruling Elite Model” / Who Governs?1958 / 1961Pluralism
SartoriDemocratic Theory (English)1962Selective polyarchy
DomhoffWho Rules America?1967Upper-class dominance
BachrachThe Theory of Democratic Elitism: A Critique1967Critique of democratic elitism

6. Political Regimes

ThinkerWorkYearKey idea
ArendtThe Origins of Totalitarianism1951Ideology and terror
Friedrich and BrzezinskiTotalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy1956Ideology, single party, terror, media, weapons, economy
HuntingtonThe Soldier and the State1957Objective vs subjective control
FinerThe Man on Horseback1962Influence → pressure → displacement → supplantment
NolteThree Faces of Fascism1963Action Française, Fascism, Nazism
Linz“An Authoritarian Regime: Spain”1964Limited pluralism, mentalities, low mobilisation
HuntingtonPolitical Order in Changing Societies1968Praetorianism
O’DonnellModernization and Bureaucratic-Authoritarianism1973Brazil 1964, Argentina 1966; technocrats; exclusion; deepening
EisenstadtTraditional Patrimonialism and Modern Neopatrimonialism1973Neo-patrimonialism
NordlingerSoldiers in Politics1977Moderators, guardians, rulers
DahlDemocracy and Its Critics1989Six institutions of polyarchy
GriffinThe Nature of Fascism1991Palingenetic ultranationalism
O’Donnell“Delegative Democracy”1994Weak horizontal accountability
Linz and StepanProblems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation1996Post-totalitarian, sultanistic
Zakaria“The Rise of Illiberal Democracy”1997Illiberal democracy
Chehabi and LinzSultanistic Regimes1998Sultanism
LijphartPatterns of Democracy1999Majoritarian vs consensus (ten variables)
Levitsky and WayCompetitive authoritarianism2002 / 2010Hybrid regime
PaxtonThe Anatomy of Fascism2004Stages of fascism
Schedler (ed.)Electoral Authoritarianism2006Hybrid regime

Democratic types: electoral (minimal) · liberal (rights and limits) · majoritarian (Westminster) · participatory (Pateman; Porto Alegre from 1989). Non-democratic: patrimonial/sultanistic · bureaucratic-authoritarian · military · totalitarian · fascist.

7. Constitutions and Constitutionalism

Thinker / sourceWorkYearKey idea
Act of Settlement—1701Judicial tenure during good behaviour
MontesquieuThe Spirit of the Laws1748Separation of powers
Madison / HamiltonFederalist Nos. 51 / 781788Checks and balances / least dangerous branch
Marbury v. MadisonUS Supreme Court1803Judicial review
DiceyIntroduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution1885Supremacy of law, equality before law, constitution from ordinary law
Bryce“Flexible and Rigid Constitutions”1901Rigid vs flexible
SchmittDictatorship / Political Theology1921 / 1922Commissarial vs sovereign / decides on the exception
McIlwainConstitutionalism: Ancient and Modern1940Legal limitation on government
RossiterConstitutional Dictatorship1948Crisis government
WheareModern Constitutions1951Classification
LoewensteinPolitical Power and the Governmental Process1957Normative, nominal, semantic
Sartori“Constitutionalism: A Preliminary Discussion”1962Garantiste, nominal, façade
FullerThe Morality of Law1964Eight principles of legality
Raz“The Rule of Law and its Virtue”1977Formal rule of law
Bangalore PrinciplesJudicial conduct2002Six values
AgambenState of Exception2003Exception as paradigm
BellamyPolitical Constitutionalism2007Against legal constitutionalism
BinghamThe Rule of Law2010Eight principles
Landau“Abusive Constitutionalism”2013Erosion through amendment
Levitsky and ZiblattHow Democracies Die2018Toleration and forbearance

India: Art. 352 (national emergency: war, external aggression, armed rebellion), 356 (President’s Rule; S.R. Bommai, 1994), 360 (financial; never used). Emergency 25 June 1975 – March 1977. 44th Amendment (1978): “armed rebellion” for “internal disturbance”; written Cabinet advice; Arts. 20 and 21 not suspendable. ADM Jabalpur (1976) overruled in Puttaswamy (2017). Collegium: Second Judges case (1993); NJAC struck down (2015).

8. Development

ThinkerWorkYearKey idea
Prebisch / SingerECLA report / article1950Declining terms of trade; ISI
ParsonsThe Social System1951Pattern variables
BaranThe Political Economy of Growth1957Surplus
LernerThe Passing of Traditional Society1958Empathy
RostowThe Stages of Economic Growth1960Traditional → preconditions → take-off → maturity → high mass consumption
OrganskiThe Stages of Political Development1965Four stages
PyeAspects of Political Development1966Equality, capacity, differentiation
Frank“The Development of Underdevelopment”1966Metropolis–satellite
Rudolph and RudolphThe Modernity of Tradition1967Tradition adapts
HuntingtonPolitical Order in Changing Societies1968Institutionalisation: adaptability, complexity, autonomy, coherence
Cardoso and FalettoDependency and Development in Latin America1969Associated dependent development
EmmanuelUnequal Exchange1969Wage-based unequal exchange
dos Santos“The Structure of Dependence”1970Definition of dependence
AminAccumulation on a World Scale1970Delinking
Galtung“A Structural Theory of Imperialism”1971Centre–periphery within nations
Binder et al.Crises and Sequences in Political Development1971Identity, legitimacy, participation, penetration, distribution, integration
RodneyHow Europe Underdeveloped Africa1972Africa underdeveloped
WallersteinThe Modern World-System I1974Core, semi-periphery, periphery; hegemonic cycles
EvansDependent Development1979Triple alliance (Brazil)
WarrenImperialism: Pioneer of Capitalism1980Marxist critique of dependency
BrundtlandOur Common Future1987Sustainable development
UNDPFirst Human Development Report1990HDI
ArrighiThe Long Twentieth Century1994Systemic cycles
EscobarEncountering Development1995Post-development
SenDevelopment as Freedom1999Capabilities; no famine in democracy

Development and democracy: Lipset (1959) wealth sustains democracy · Moore (1966) class routes · O’Donnell (1973) growth → authoritarianism · Rueschemeyer et al. (1992) working class · Przeworski and Limongi (1997) exogenous survival · Boix (2003) inequality · Acemoglu and Robinson (2006, 2012) inclusive vs extractive institutions.

9. Democratisation

ThinkerWorkYearKey idea
Rustow“Transitions to Democracy”1970National unity → preparatory → decision → habituation
DahlPolyarchy1971Liberalisation before inclusiveness
O’Donnell, Schmitter, WhiteheadTransitions from Authoritarian Rule1986Hard-liners vs soft-liners; pacts; liberalisation vs democratisation
HuntingtonThe Third Wave1991Waves; transformation, replacement, transplacement; two-turnover test
PrzeworskiDemocracy and the Market1991Parties lose elections; only game in town
Linz and StepanProblems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation1996Behavioural, attitudinal, constitutional; five arenas
Schedler“What Is Democratic Consolidation?”1998Avoiding breakdown and erosion
Carothers“The End of the Transition Paradigm”2002Grey zone
McFaulFourth wave2002Post-communist outcomes
Diamond“Facing Up to the Democratic Recession”2015Democratic recession
Lührmann and Lindberg“A Third Wave of Autocratization Is Here”2019Autocratisation

Huntington’s waves: 1st 1828–1926 · reverse 1922–42 · 2nd 1943–62 · reverse 1958–75 · 3rd from 1974 (Portugal, 25 April).

10. Actors and Processes

ThinkerWorkYearKey idea
BurkeThoughts on the Cause of the Present Discontents1770Party as union on principle
BentleyThe Process of Government1908Group theory
BrintonThe Anatomy of Revolution1938Moderates → extremists → terror → Thermidor
DuvergerPolitical Parties1951Plurality → two-party (law); PR → multiparty; cadre vs mass
TrumanThe Governmental Process1951Potential groups
NeumannModern Political Parties1956Representation vs integration parties
DownsAn Economic Theory of Democracy1957Office-seeking teams
SchattschneiderThe Semisovereign People1960Upper-class accent
Davies“Toward a Theory of Revolution”1962J-curve
SmelserTheory of Collective Behavior1962Value-added model
ArendtOn Revolution1963American vs French
Kothari“The Congress ‘System’ in India”1964Party of consensus, parties of pressure
OlsonThe Logic of Collective Action1965Free rider; selective incentives
KirchheimerCatch-all party1966De-ideologisation
Almond and PowellComparative Politics1966Anomic, non-associational, institutional, associational
C. JohnsonRevolutionary Change1966Disequilibrated system
Lipset and Rokkan“Cleavage Structures…”1967Centre–periphery, state–church, land–industry, owner–worker; freezing
RaeThe Political Consequences of Electoral Laws1967Electoral effects
BlondelParty system types1968Two-and-a-half party
GurrWhy Men Rebel1970Relative deprivation
Schmitter“Still the Century of Corporatism?”1974Representational monopoly
SartoriParties and Party Systems1976Seven classes; polarised pluralism
McCarthy and ZaldResource mobilisation1977SMOs
TillyFrom Mobilization to Revolution1978Multiple sovereignty
Laakso and TaageperaEffective number of parties1979\( N = 1 / \sum p_i^2 \)
SkocpolStates and Social Revolutions1979France, Russia, China; state breakdown + peasant revolt
McAdamPolitical Process and the Development of Black Insurgency1982Political opportunity
Offe“New Social Movements”1985NSMs
MelucciNomads of the Present1989Collective identity
TarrowPower in Movement1994Political opportunity, cycles of protest
Katz and MairCartel party1995State-financed parties
Keck and SikkinkActivists Beyond Borders1998Boomerang pattern
McAdam, Tarrow, TillyDynamics of Contention2001Contentious politics
TillySocial Movements, 1768–20042004WUNC
ChatterjeeThe Politics of the Governed2004Political society

Electoral systems: FPTP (UK, Lok Sabha) · two-round (France) · AV (Australian House) · list PR (Israel, Netherlands) · STV (Ireland, Malta; Indian President, Vice-President, Rajya Sabha) · MMP (Germany, NZ) · parallel (Japan).

Formulas: Hare = votes ÷ seats · Droop = ⌊votes ÷ (seats + 1)⌋ + 1 · D’Hondt divisors 1, 2, 3… (favours large parties) · Sainte-Laguë 1, 3, 5… · \( N = 1 / \sum p_i^2 \).

Campaigns: ICBL → Ottawa Treaty and Nobel (1997) · ICAN → TPNW and Nobel (2017) · MKSS (1990) → RTI Act (2005) · India Against Corruption (2011) → Lokpal Act (2013).


Ten Traps in One Box

Where to Go Next

Advertisement
Advertisement