Research Ethics and Plagiarism
UGC NET Paper 1: research ethics, informed consent, Nuremberg, Helsinki, Belmont, FFP misconduct, authorship and the UGC 2018 plagiarism levels and penalties.
- 14 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Thesis and Article Writing, Referencing and ICT — referencing is the everyday practice of research ethics.
- Methods and Steps of Research — ethical questions arise at every step, from sampling to reporting.
The Hook: The Borrowed Review
1. What Research Ethics Means
Research ethics is the set of moral principles that govern how research is planned, conducted and reported: towards participants (people and animals studied), towards data and truth, and towards the scholarly community and society. Academic integrity is the commitment to honesty, trust, fairness, respect and responsibility in all academic work.
Ethical principles in dealing with participants
| Principle | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Informed consent | Participants are told the purpose, procedure, risks, benefits and their rights, and agree freely before taking part; for children, consent from a parent or guardian and the child’s own assent |
| Voluntary participation | No coercion or undue inducement; participants may withdraw at any time without penalty |
| Non-maleficence | Do no harm, physical, psychological, social or economic |
| Beneficence | Maximise possible benefits and minimise risks |
| Confidentiality | Information given is not disclosed in a way that identifies the participant |
| Anonymity | Even the researcher cannot (or does not) link responses to identities |
| Privacy | Respect for participants’ control over information about themselves |
| Justice | Fair selection of participants and fair sharing of burdens and benefits |
| Protection of the vulnerable | Extra safeguards for children, prisoners, patients, people with cognitive impairment and dependent groups such as one’s own students |
| Deception and debriefing | Deception is used only when unavoidable and approved, and participants are debriefed afterwards |
Ethics review
Studies involving human participants are reviewed in advance by an Institutional Ethics Committee (IEC), called an Institutional Review Board (IRB) in the USA. It examines the protocol, the consent form, the risk–benefit balance and data protection before the research begins.
2. Landmark Codes
| Document | Year | Context and contribution |
|---|---|---|
| Nuremberg Code | 1947 | Came out of the trial of Nazi doctors after the Second World War; made voluntary consent of the human subject “absolutely essential” |
| Declaration of Helsinki | 1964 | Adopted by the World Medical Association; ethical principles for medical research on humans; revised several times since |
| Belmont Report | 1979 | US national commission’s report after the Tuskegee syphilis study (1932–1972) came to light; three principles: respect for persons, beneficence, justice |
| ICMR National Ethical Guidelines for Biomedical and Health Research Involving Human Participants | 2017 | India’s guidelines for biomedical and health research, from the Indian Council of Medical Research |
| UGC plagiarism regulations | 2018 | India’s binding rules on plagiarism in higher education institutions |
3. Research Misconduct
The core forms of research misconduct are summed up as FFP:
| Misconduct | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Fabrication | Making up data or results | Reporting interviews that never took place |
| Falsification | Manipulating materials, processes or data, or omitting data, so the record is not accurate | Dropping inconvenient responses; editing an image |
| Plagiarism | Using another’s ideas, words or results without due credit | Copying a literature review |
Questionable research practices fall short of FFP but damage reliability: selective reporting of results, p-hacking (running analyses until something is significant), HARKing (hypothesising after the results are known), poor data storage, and refusing to share data for verification.
Types of plagiarism
| Type | What it is |
|---|---|
| Direct (verbatim) | Word-for-word copying without quotation marks and citation |
| Mosaic (patchwriting) | Mixing copied phrases with one’s own words, or changing a few words, without citation |
| Paraphrasing without credit | Rewording someone’s idea fully but not citing it |
| Self-plagiarism (text recycling) | Reusing one’s own published text or data as if new, without disclosure |
| Source-based | Citing a source wrongly, citing one never read, or inventing a source |
| Accidental | Careless note-taking or forgetting a citation; still plagiarism |
| Idea plagiarism | Presenting someone’s original idea, theory or design as one’s own |
Publication ethics
| Issue | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Duplicate (redundant) publication | Publishing the same study in two journals |
| Salami slicing | Splitting one study into several thin papers to increase the count |
| Gift (honorary) authorship | Naming someone who did not contribute, such as a department head |
| Ghost authorship | Leaving out someone who did substantial work, such as a paid writer |
| Conflict of interest | Undisclosed financial or personal interests that could bias the work |
| Citation manipulation | Coercive citation by editors or reviewers, or citation cartels |
| Predatory publishing | Paying journals with no real peer review |
The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) gives four criteria for authorship, all of which must be met: substantial contribution to the conception or design, or to data acquisition, analysis or interpretation; drafting or critically revising the work; final approval of the version to be published; and agreement to be accountable for the work. The Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) advises journals and editors on handling misconduct, and published papers found to be seriously flawed or fraudulent are retracted.
Intellectual property
Research outputs are protected by copyright (in India, the Copyright Act, 1957), and inventions by patents. Copyright law allows limited fair dealing for purposes such as private use, research, criticism and review. Creative Commons licences let authors grant reuse in advance (for example, CC BY: reuse allowed with attribution).
4. The UGC Plagiarism Regulations, 2018
The full name is the University Grants Commission (Promotion of Academic Integrity and Prevention of Plagiarism in Higher Educational Institutions) Regulations, 2018. They apply to students, faculty, researchers and staff of higher education institutions (HEIs).
What the regulations require
- Awareness and training: HEIs must make students, faculty and staff aware of responsible conduct of research and academic integrity.
- Detection tools: HEIs must use plagiarism-detection software on dissertations, theses and other submissions.
- Undertaking: the student submits a declaration that the work is original and free of plagiarism, and the supervisor certifies it.
- Academic integrity panels: allegations are examined by a Departmental Academic Integrity Panel (DAIP) and an Institutional Academic Integrity Panel (IAIP).
What is excluded from the similarity check
- Quoted work reproduced with the necessary permission and/or attribution
- References, bibliography, table of contents, preface and acknowledgements
- Generic terms, laws, standard symbols and standard equations
The four levels
Plagiarism is quantified by the percentage of similarity, after the exclusions above:
| Level | Similarity |
|---|---|
| Level 0 | Up to 10% — minor similarities, no penalty |
| Level 1 | Above 10% to 40% |
| Level 2 | Above 40% to 60% |
| Level 3 | Above 60% |
Penalties: students (theses and dissertations)
| Level | Penalty |
|---|---|
| 0 | No penalty |
| 1 | Must submit a revised script within a stipulated time not exceeding six months |
| 2 | Debarred from submitting a revised script for one year |
| 3 | Registration for that programme is cancelled |
These penalties are imposed by the IAIP, considering the severity of the plagiarism. If plagiarism is proved after a degree or credit has been awarded, the degree or credit is put in abeyance for a period recommended by the IAIP and approved by the head of the institution.
Penalties: faculty, researchers and staff (academic and research publications)
| Level | Penalty |
|---|---|
| 0 | No penalty |
| 1 | Asked to withdraw the manuscript |
| 2 | Withdraw the manuscript; denied one annual increment; not allowed to supervise any new Master’s, MPhil or PhD student or scholar for two years |
| 3 | Withdraw the manuscript; denied two successive annual increments; not allowed to supervise any new Master’s, MPhil or PhD student or scholar for three years |
Repeat offences: a repeated offence attracts the penalty of the next higher level (where the highest level is already reached, that level’s penalty applies). For faculty, a repeated Level 3 offence leads to disciplinary action, including suspension or termination, under the service rules.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Fabrication: inventing data | vs | Falsification: altering real data |
| Confidentiality: identity known, not disclosed | vs | Anonymity: identity not known |
| Gift authorship: non-contributor named | vs | Ghost authorship: contributor left out |
| Duplicate publication: same paper twice | vs | Salami slicing: one study cut into many papers |
| Student Level 2: debarred from revised script for 1 year | vs | Faculty Level 2: 1 increment, no new supervision for 2 years |
| Student Level 3: registration cancelled | vs | Faculty Level 3: 2 increments, no new supervision for 3 years |
| Nuremberg (1947): voluntary consent | vs | Belmont (1979): respect, beneficence, justice |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Under the UGC 2018 regulations, up to what similarity is treated as Level 0?
- Expand FFP in research misconduct.
- Name the three principles of the Belmont Report.
Answers
- Up to 10% (minor similarities, no penalty).
- Fabrication, falsification and plagiarism.
- Respect for persons, beneficence and justice.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) A PhD thesis shows 52% similarity after permitted exclusions. Under the UGC 2018 regulations, the student will:
- (a) Face no penalty
- (b) Be asked to submit a revised script within six months
- (c) Be debarred from submitting a revised script for one year
- (d) Have the registration for the programme cancelled
Answer and explanation
(c). 52% lies in “above 40% to 60%”, which is Level 2.
Q2. (Practice) A faculty member’s research paper is found to have Level 3 plagiarism (a first offence). Which of the following is part of the prescribed penalty?
- (a) Withdrawal of the manuscript only
- (b) Denial of one annual increment and no new supervision for two years
- (c) Denial of two successive annual increments and no new supervision for three years
- (d) Immediate termination of service
Answer and explanation
(c). Level 3 for faculty: withdraw the manuscript, lose two successive annual increments and not supervise new Master’s, MPhil or PhD students for three years. Suspension or termination is for a repeated Level 3 offence.
Q3. (Practice) Which of the following is excluded from the similarity check under the UGC 2018 regulations?
- (a) The review of literature
- (b) The bibliography and acknowledgements
- (c) The discussion of results
- (d) The abstract
Answer and explanation
(b). References, bibliography, table of contents, preface and acknowledgements are excluded, as are properly attributed quotations and generic terms, laws, standard symbols and equations.
Q4. (Practice) A researcher splits the findings of one survey into five separate papers, each reporting a small part of the same data, to increase the number of publications. This practice is called:
- (a) Ghost authorship
- (b) Salami slicing
- (c) Fabrication
- (d) Triangulation
Answer and explanation
(b) Salami slicing.
Q5. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- In an anonymous survey the researcher cannot link responses to individual respondents.
- Participants who have given informed consent may still withdraw from the study.
- Deception, where approved, should be followed by debriefing.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(d) 1, 2 and 3. All three are standard ethical principles.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Under the UGC 2018 regulations, a thesis with 8% similarity attracts no penalty. Reason (R): Similarities up to 10% are classed as Level 0, minor similarities.
Answer and explanation
(a). 8% falls within Level 0, and Level 0 carries no penalty. R explains A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Informed consent must be obtained before data are collected from human participants. Reason (R): Participants have the right to know the purpose, procedure and risks of a study and to decide freely whether to take part.
Answer and explanation
(a). Consent is required precisely because of the participant’s right to an informed, free choice.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I with List II.
| List I (Document) | List II (Year) |
|---|---|
| A. Nuremberg Code | I. 1979 |
| B. Declaration of Helsinki | II. 2018 |
| C. Belmont Report | III. 1947 |
| D. UGC plagiarism regulations | IV. 1964 |
- (1) A-III, B-IV, C-I, D-II
- (2) A-IV, B-III, C-I, D-II
- (3) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
- (4) A-I, B-IV, C-III, D-II
Answer and explanation
(1) A-III, B-IV, C-I, D-II.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following penalties for plagiarism in a student’s thesis under the UGC 2018 regulations from the least to the most severe:
A. Registration for the programme cancelled
B. Revised script to be submitted within six months
C. Debarred from submitting a revised script for one year
D. No penalty
(1) D, B, C, A
(2) D, C, B, A
(3) B, D, C, A
(4) D, B, A, C
Answer and explanation
(1) D, B, C, A. Level 0 → Level 1 → Level 2 → Level 3.
Quick Revision Table
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Participant ethics | Informed consent, voluntary participation, right to withdraw, no harm, confidentiality, anonymity, justice, debriefing |
| Nuremberg Code | 1947; voluntary consent essential |
| Declaration of Helsinki | 1964; World Medical Association |
| Belmont Report | 1979; respect for persons, beneficence, justice; after Tuskegee (1932–1972) |
| ICMR guidelines | 2017; biomedical and health research |
| Misconduct | FFP: fabrication, falsification, plagiarism |
| Questionable practices | p-hacking, HARKing, selective reporting |
| Authorship | ICMJE four criteria; gift vs ghost authorship |
| Publication ethics | COPE; duplicate publication; salami slicing; retraction |
| Copyright | Copyright Act, 1957; fair dealing; Creative Commons |
| UGC regulations | 2018; students, faculty, researchers, staff; DAIP and IAIP |
| Excluded | Attributed quotations; references, bibliography, contents, preface, acknowledgements; generic terms, laws, symbols, equations |
| Levels | 0: up to 10% · 1: above 10–40% · 2: above 40–60% · 3: above 60% |
| Students | 0 none · 1 revise within 6 months · 2 debarred 1 year · 3 registration cancelled |
| Faculty | 0 none · 1 withdraw · 2 withdraw + 1 increment + 2 yrs no supervision · 3 withdraw + 2 increments + 3 yrs |
| Repeat | Next higher level; faculty repeat Level 3 → suspension/termination |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Quick Revision — the whole unit on one page
- Thesis and Article Writing, Referencing and ICT — Shodh Shuddhi and the similarity-checking tools behind these rules
- Research: Meaning, Types and Approaches — back to the start of the unit
- Paper 1 overview — the other nine units