Frontier Policies and Inter-state Relations: Sultanate and Mughals
UGC NET History Unit 5: Mongol frontier of the Sultanate, the Mughal north-west and Qandahar, the Ahom frontier, Rajput and Deccan policy, Safavids and Uzbeks.
- 16 min
On this page · 14 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: One Fortress, Three Emperors
- 1. The Sultanate’s North-West Frontier: the Mongol Problem
- 2. The Mughal North-West Frontier
- 3. The Mughal North-East Frontier
- 4. Inter-state Relations under the Sultanate
- 5. Inter-state Relations under the Mughals
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Administration under the Delhi Sultanate — the standing army, the Diwan-i-Arz and the iqta, which paid for frontier defence.
- Sher Shah and Mughal Administration — the mansab and the watan jagir, the instruments of Mughal Rajput policy.
- Deccan Administration: Vijayanagara, Bahmanis and Marathas — the Deccan states as the Mughals’ southern neighbours.
The Hook: One Fortress, Three Emperors
How UGC NET asks it: sequence Mongol invasions or the Qandahar episodes; match a ruler with a frontier measure (Balban’s consolidation, Alauddin’s Siri and Dipalpur, Akbar at Lahore); statements on Rajput policy and the 1615 treaty with Mewar; assertion–reason on the failure of the Balkh campaign; match battles of the north-east frontier.
1. The Sultanate’s North-West Frontier: the Mongol Problem
1.1 Why the frontier mattered
From 1221, when Chinggis Khan reached the Indus in pursuit of the Khwarazmian prince Jalaluddin Mangbarni, the Mongols were the Sultanate’s main external threat. Iltutmish refused Jalaluddin shelter, keeping the Mongols from turning on Delhi. The Mongols held parts of Afghanistan and the trans-Indus region; they sacked Lahore in 1241 and repeatedly raided Punjab.
1.2 Balban: consolidation, not expansion
Balban (r. 1266–87) made a deliberate choice:
- Consolidation: no distant conquests, so that the army stayed near Delhi; harsh suppression of the Mewatis near the capital and of rebels in the doab.
- A defended frontier: fortified posts in Punjab with strong garrisons; the frontier was first entrusted to his cousin Sher Khan, later divided between his sons, with Prince Muhammad at Multan and Bughra Khan at Samana.
- Cost: Prince Muhammad, his chosen heir, was killed fighting the Mongols in 1285, a blow from which the succession never recovered.
1.3 Alauddin Khalji: the frontier as the reason for reform
The Mongols invaded repeatedly under Alauddin. The most serious were Qutlugh Khwaja (1299, the battle of Kili near Delhi, where Alauddin’s general Zafar Khan was killed) and Targhi (1303, who besieged Delhi while the army was returning from Chittor). Later invasions (1305, towards Amroha, and 1306) were defeated.
Alauddin’s response:
| Measure | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Built Siri as a fortified capital | Protect Delhi itself |
| Repaired old forts on the route; strong garrisons at Samana and Dipalpur | Block the invasion routes |
| Ghazi Malik (later Ghiyasuddin Tughluq) made warden of the marches at Dipalpur | A trusted commander on the frontier |
| A large standing army paid in cash | Always ready, not dependent on iqta levies |
| Market control and revenue at 50 per cent | Keep prices low enough to pay that army (Barani’s explanation) |
1.4 The Tughluqs
- Ghiyasuddin Tughluq had built his career defending the frontier.
- Muhammad bin Tughluq planned a Khurasan expedition (Barani says an army of about 3,70,000 was raised and paid for a year, then disbanded) and sent a disastrous expedition into the Qarachil mountains (the Kumaon–Garhwal Himalaya); the aim of the Qarachil campaign is debated.
- After Firuz Shah, the frontier weakened. Timur invaded in 1398 and sacked Delhi, leaving the Sultanate a regional power.
1.5 The north-east under the Sultanate
Bakhtiyar Khalji, after conquering Bihar and western Bengal, led an expedition towards Tibet (c. 1206) that ended in disaster. Bengal itself often broke away from Delhi; the north-east (the Ahom and Kamata kingdoms) remained outside Sultanate control.
2. The Mughal North-West Frontier
2.1 Why it was different
The Mughals were themselves from Kabul: Babur ruled there before he conquered Hindustan. Their frontier problems were therefore about holding Kabul and Qandahar against two rival powers, the Safavids of Persia (west) and the Uzbeks of Transoxiana (north), and about controlling the Afghan tribes of the passes.
graph TD
U["Uzbeks
Transoxiana, Balkh"] -->|Hindu Kush passes| K["Kabul"]
P["Safavids
Persia"] -->|Herat road| Q["Qandahar"]
K --> L["Peshawar, Attock,
Lahore"]
Q --> L
T["Afghan tribes
Yusufzai, Afridi"] -.->|control of
Khyber route| K2.2 Akbar
| Event | Significance |
|---|---|
| 1581 campaign to Kabul against his half-brother Mirza Hakim | Ended Hakim’s challenge after Hakim invaded Punjab |
| 1585 Kabul annexed after Hakim’s death | Kabul became a Mughal province |
| 1585–98 Akbar based at Lahore | To watch the north-west while the Uzbek ruler Abdullah Khan was strong; Akbar returned to Agra only after Abdullah Khan’s death (1598) |
| 1586 campaign against the Yusufzai | Birbal was killed in the Swat–Bajaur hills |
| 1586 Kashmir; 1591 Sind (Thatta); 1595 Qandahar recovered | Completed a defensive arc in the north-west |
Akbar’s line of Kabul–Ghazni–Qandahar is sometimes called his “scientific frontier”, a phrase borrowed from 19th-century British debates; the idea is that a mountain line resting on these three points could be held against invaders. With Abdullah Khan, an understanding kept the Hindu Kush as the practical boundary.
2.3 Jahangir and Shah Jahan
- 1622: Shah Abbas I captured Qandahar. Prince Khurram (the future Shah Jahan), ordered to march, rebelled instead; the fort was lost.
- 1638: the Persian governor Ali Mardan Khan surrendered Qandahar to Shah Jahan; he later served the Mughals and is remembered for canal works in Delhi and Lahore.
- 1646–47: the Balkh–Badakhshan campaign. Mughal armies under Murad Bakhsh and then Aurangzeb occupied Balkh but withdrew in 1647. Causes of failure: the hostility of the local Uzbek population, the cold, supply lines through the Hindu Kush, and Mughal nobles’ unwillingness to serve so far away. Historians debate the aim: a Timurid dream of recovering Samarqand, or a more limited plan to install a friendly ruler and secure Kabul.
- 1649: Shah Abbas II retook Qandahar. Mughal sieges in 1649 and 1652 (Aurangzeb) and 1653 (Dara Shikoh) all failed; the heavy Mughal guns could not be brought up in time and Persian artillery was superior.
2.4 Aurangzeb and the tribes
- 1667: rising of the Yusufzai.
- 1672: rising of the Afridis under Aimal Khan, who destroyed a Mughal army in the Khyber; Khushhal Khan Khattak, the Pashto poet, joined the resistance.
- 1674–75: Aurangzeb himself camped at Hasan Abdal to direct operations. The frontier was quietened by a mix of force, subsidies to tribal chiefs and setting clans against each other, at a heavy cost in men and money that some historians link to the later Deccan difficulties.
3. The Mughal North-East Frontier
| Event | Detail |
|---|---|
| Cooch Behar | Mughal pressure from Akbar’s time; occupied by Mir Jumla in 1661 |
| Mir Jumla’s Assam campaign (1662–63) | Occupied the Ahom capital Garhgaon; the treaty of Ghilajharighat (1663) imposed tribute and ceded territory, but the army suffered terribly from rain and disease, and Mir Jumla died on his return |
| Battle of Saraighat (1671) | Ahom commander Lachit Borphukan defeated the Mughal army under Raja Ram Singh of Amber on the Brahmaputra near Guwahati |
| Guwahati | Changed hands; the Ahoms had regained it by the early 1680s, and the Manas river became the effective boundary |
| Chittagong (1666) | Shaista Khan, governor of Bengal, took Chittagong from the Arakanese, ending Arakanese–Portuguese piracy in the delta |
The north-east shows the limits of the Mughal military system: heavy cavalry and artillery were ill-suited to rivers, rain and forests, where the Ahoms’ boats and local knowledge counted.
4. Inter-state Relations under the Sultanate
4.1 Rajput and central Indian states
Alauddin annexed in the north and centre: Ranthambhor (1301), Chittor (1303), Malwa (1305), then Siwana and Jalor. Annexation, with forts garrisoned by the Sultan’s troops, was the norm close to Delhi.
4.2 The Deccan and the south: tribute or annexation?
| Phase | Policy |
|---|---|
| Alauddin Khalji (expeditions of Malik Kafur, 1307–11: Devagiri, Warangal, Dwarasamudra, Madurai) | Tribute and submission, not annexation. Ramachandradeva of Devagiri was restored, given the title Rai Rayan and the district of Navsari, and became a loyal tributary |
| Muhammad bin Tughluq | Annexation and direct rule; the shift of the capital to Daulatabad (Devagiri) in 1327 |
| Result | Revolts and new states: the Madurai Sultanate (1335), Vijayanagara (1336), the Bahmani kingdom (1347) |
4.3 The 15th-century multi-state system
After Timur, the Sultanate was one power among many: the Sharqis of Jaunpur, the sultans of Malwa, Gujarat and Bengal, the Rajput state of Mewar, and in the Deccan, Vijayanagara and the Bahmanis. Relations were governed by interest, not religion:
- Mewar under Rana Kumbha fought Malwa and Gujarat; the Vijay Stambha at Chittor commemorates his victory over Mahmud Khalji of Malwa.
- Vijayanagara and the Bahmanis fought repeatedly over the fertile Raichur doab (between the Krishna and the Tungabhadra), the Krishna–Godavari delta and the western coastal ports through which horses arrived.
- Alliances crossed religious lines: Vijayanagara recruited Muslim cavalrymen and archers; its regent Rama Raya played the Deccan sultanates against each other until four of them (Bijapur, Ahmadnagar, Golkonda and Bidar; Berar stayed out) combined to defeat Vijayanagara at Talikota (Rakshasa–Tangadi), 1565.
4.4 The instruments of diplomacy
| Instrument | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Khutba and coinage | Reading the overlord’s name in Friday prayers and striking coins in his name signalled submission |
| Peshkash | Tribute or a ceremonial present from a subordinate ruler |
| Envoys (rasul, safir) | Exchanged with neighbours and distant powers |
| Marriage alliances | Used by sultans and Rajput rulers alike, long before Akbar |
| Investiture | The Sultan’s own relationship with the Caliph (see the Sultanate page) |
5. Inter-state Relations under the Mughals
5.1 Rajput policy
| Stage | Detail |
|---|---|
| 1562 | Raja Bharmal of Amber (Kachhwaha) gave his daughter in marriage to Akbar; his son Bhagwant Das and grandson Man Singh became leading mansabdars |
| Terms | Rajput chiefs became mansabdars, kept their homelands as watan jagirs, received high commands, and were not required to convert |
| Mewar resists | Chittor fell after a siege in 1567–68; Rana Pratap fought the Mughals at Haldighati (1576) and continued resistance |
| 1615 treaty | Prince Khurram negotiated peace with Rana Amar Singh: the Rana was excused personal attendance at court (his son served instead) and received back his lands, but Chittor was not to be refortified |
| Aurangzeb and Marwar (1679) | After Jaswant Singh of Marwar died, Aurangzeb tried to control the succession; Durgadas Rathore led resistance, Mewar joined, and Prince Akbar rebelled (1681). The breach weakened the Rajput alliance |
5.2 Deccan policy
| Ruler | Policy and events |
|---|---|
| Akbar | Demanded submission from the Deccan sultans; annexed Khandesh (fall of Asirgarh, 1601) and part of Ahmadnagar (1600, after Chand Bibi’s defence) |
| Jahangir | Resistance led by Malik Ambar of Ahmadnagar, using Maratha light cavalry |
| Shah Jahan | Ended Ahmadnagar (1633); the Deed of Submission (1636) with Bijapur and Golkonda: they accepted Mughal overlordship, paid tribute (Golkonda) and fixed boundaries; a long peace followed |
| Aurangzeb | Annexed Bijapur (1686) and Golkonda (1687); then a long war with the Marathas (Purandar, 1665, had been a Mughal success against Shivaji) |
5.3 Persia, the Uzbeks and the Ottomans
- Safavid Persia: friendly and rival at once. Humayun took refuge with Shah Tahmasp (1544) and recovered his kingdom with Persian help; embassies and gifts were exchanged; Qandahar was the constant dispute.
- Uzbeks: the main danger from Central Asia under Akbar (Abdullah Khan) and the target of Shah Jahan’s Balkh campaign.
- Ottomans: distant. Their direct role in India was naval, against the Portuguese, most notably helping Gujarat besiege Diu in 1538. The Mughals exchanged occasional embassies with the Ottomans but saw themselves as their equals, not subordinates.
5.4 Europeans
- The Portuguese controlled sea lanes with the cartaz (a pass that Asian ships had to buy); even Mughal pilgrim ships to Mecca took cartazes. Shah Jahan expelled the Portuguese from Hughli in 1632.
- The English obtained trading rights from Jahangir after Sir Thomas Roe’s embassy (1615–19) and earlier contacts by William Hawkins. These are trading privileges granted by a superior power, not treaties between equals. (Details in Industries, Trade, Currency and Banking.)
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Kili (1299) — Qutlugh Khwaja; Zafar Khan killed | vs | Targhi (1303) — siege of Delhi |
| Balban — consolidation; Prince Muhammad killed 1285 | vs | Alauddin — Siri, Dipalpur, standing army |
| Yusufzai (1586) — Birbal killed | vs | Afridi (1672) — Aimal Khan, Khyber |
| Ghilajharighat (1663) — Mir Jumla’s treaty | vs | Saraighat (1671) — Lachit Borphukan’s victory |
| Treaty with Mewar (1615) — Jahangir, Amar Singh | vs | Deed of Submission (1636) — Shah Jahan, Bijapur and Golkonda |
| Shah Abbas I — took Qandahar 1622 | vs | Shah Abbas II — took it 1649 |
| Talikota (1565) — four sultanates vs Vijayanagara | vs | Haldighati (1576) — Mughals vs Mewar |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which Persian governor surrendered Qandahar to Shah Jahan in 1638?
- Who led the Ahoms at Saraighat in 1671?
- Which Sultan’s son, Prince Muhammad, was killed fighting the Mongols in 1285?
Answers
- Ali Mardan Khan.
- Lachit Borphukan.
- Balban.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Akbar stayed at Lahore from 1585 to 1598 mainly because:
- (a) Agra had been destroyed by floods
- (b) of the threat from the Uzbek ruler Abdullah Khan in the north-west
- (c) he was preparing to invade the Deccan
- (d) of a war of succession among his sons
Answer and explanation
(b). Lahore was the base for watching the north-west; he returned after Abdullah Khan’s death in 1598.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Alauddin Khalji generally left the southern kingdoms to their rulers in return for tribute.
- Muhammad bin Tughluq moved the capital to Daulatabad.
- The Madurai Sultanate was founded before Vijayanagara.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(d) 1, 2 and 3. Madurai 1335, Vijayanagara 1336.
Q3. (Practice) The “Deed of Submission” of 1636 was concluded by Shah Jahan with:
- (a) Ahmadnagar and Berar
- (b) Bijapur and Golkonda
- (c) Mewar and Marwar
- (d) the Ahoms and Cooch Behar
Answer and explanation
(b) Bijapur and Golkonda. Ahmadnagar had been ended in 1633.
Q4. (Practice) Which of the following was not a reason for the failure of the Mughal Balkh campaign of 1646–47?
- (a) Hostility of the local Uzbek population
- (b) Difficult supply lines across the Hindu Kush
- (c) Reluctance of Mughal nobles to serve in Central Asia
- (d) The Persian capture of Kabul
Answer and explanation
(d). Kabul stayed Mughal; the Persians took Qandahar in 1649, after the campaign.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): According to Barani, Alauddin Khalji introduced price controls in the markets of Delhi. Reason (R): Alauddin needed a large standing army against the Mongols and wanted to pay it a modest cash salary.
Answer and explanation
(a). This is Barani’s explanation of the market regulations.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): The Rajput alliance helped the Mughals hold their empire. Reason (R): Rajput chiefs who joined Mughal service lost all rights over their ancestral lands.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true. R is false: chiefs kept their homelands as watan jagirs.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (event) with List II (year).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Persians take Qandahar from Jahangir | I. 1638 |
| B. Ali Mardan Khan surrenders Qandahar | II. 1622 |
| C. Battle of Saraighat | III. 1671 |
| D. Treaty with Mewar | IV. 1615 |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (2) A-I, B-II, C-III, D-IV
- (3) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (4) A-II, B-III, C-I, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV.
Q4. (Practice) Match List I (frontier figure) with List II (association).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Ghazi Malik | I. Afridi rising, 1672 |
| B. Aimal Khan | II. Warden of the marches at Dipalpur |
| C. Mir Jumla | III. Chittagong taken from Arakan |
| D. Shaista Khan | IV. Occupation of Garhgaon |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (3) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (4) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange in chronological order: (1) Timur sacks Delhi, (2) Mongols sack Lahore, (3) Qutlugh Khwaja’s invasion, (4) Chinggis Khan reaches the Indus.
- (a) 4, 2, 3, 1
- (b) 2, 4, 3, 1
- (c) 4, 3, 2, 1
- (d) 4, 2, 1, 3
Answer and explanation
(a). 1221 → 1241 → 1299 → 1398.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Mongols reach Indus | 1221, Chinggis Khan pursuing Jalaluddin Mangbarni |
| Lahore sacked | 1241 |
| Balban | Consolidation; frontier commands; Prince Muhammad killed 1285 |
| Alauddin | Kili 1299; Targhi 1303; Siri; Samana, Dipalpur; Ghazi Malik; standing army; market control |
| Muhammad bin Tughluq | Khurasan plan; Qarachil disaster |
| Timur | 1398 |
| Akbar NW | Kabul 1581/1585; Lahore 1585–98; Yusufzai 1586 (Birbal); Kashmir 1586; Sind 1591; Qandahar 1595 |
| Qandahar | 1595 in, 1622 out, 1638 in, 1649 out; sieges 1649, 1652, 1653 |
| Balkh | 1646–47; Murad, Aurangzeb; failed |
| Afghan tribes | Yusufzai 1667; Afridi 1672 (Aimal Khan); Hasan Abdal 1674–75 |
| North-east | Mir Jumla 1662–63 (Ghilajharighat); Saraighat 1671; Chittagong 1666 |
| Sultanate south | Tribute (Alauddin) → annexation (Muhammad bin Tughluq) → Madurai, Vijayanagara, Bahmani |
| Talikota | 1565; Bijapur, Ahmadnagar, Golkonda, Bidar |
| Rajputs | Amber 1562; Haldighati 1576; Mewar treaty 1615; Marwar 1679 |
| Deccan | Asirgarh 1601; Deed of Submission 1636; Bijapur 1686; Golkonda 1687 |
| Europeans | Cartaz; Hughli 1632; Roe 1615–19 |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
Armies, frontiers and diplomacy all depended on the land revenue. Continue with Agrarian Economy, Urbanisation, Famines and Peasant Revolts, or revise with the Quick Revision sheet. For the modern theory of the state’s external relations, compare State, Power, Sovereignty and Security in Political Science.