Research Methodology and Thesis Writing in History
UGC NET History Unit 10: research design, hypothesis, area of research, topic selection, note-taking, footnotes, bibliography, thesis writing and plagiarism.
- 17 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: The Topic That Was Too Big
- 1. Research Methodology in History
- 2. Selection of Topic and Area of Proposed Research
- 3. Hypothesis in History
- 4. Note-Taking
- 5. References, Footnotes and Bibliography
- 6. Thesis and Assignment Writing
- 7. Plagiarism, Intellectual Dishonesty and History Writing
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Historical Method: Sources, Heuristics, Criticism and Synthesis — the operations a research project strings together.
- Thesis and Article Writing, Referencing and ICT (Paper 1) — APA, MLA and Chicago styles in detail.
- Research Ethics and Plagiarism (Paper 1) — the full UGC 2018 regulations, levels and penalties.
The Hook: The Topic That Was Too Big
How UGC NET asks it: characteristics of a good hypothesis; criteria for selecting a topic; order of parts in a synopsis or thesis; meaning of ibid., op. cit., loc. cit., cf., passim, sic; references vs bibliography; forms of plagiarism and intellectual dishonesty; UGC plagiarism levels.
1. Research Methodology in History
1.1 Method vs methodology
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Research method | A specific technique: archival research, oral interview, quantitative analysis of revenue data, textual analysis |
| Research methodology | The reasoned plan and justification for the methods chosen: why these sources, these techniques and this framework answer this question |
| Research design | The blueprint of a particular study: problem, objectives, hypothesis, sources, methods, chapter plan, timeline |
1.2 Approaches used by historians
| Approach | Description | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Narrative / descriptive | Reconstructs what happened, in sequence | Political history of a reign |
| Analytical / problem-oriented | Organised around a question or explanation | Why did the Mughal jagirdari system face crisis? |
| Comparative | Compares cases across places or times | Peasant revolts in two regions |
| Quantitative | Statistics from prices, revenue, trade, census | Price movements in 17th-century Bengal |
| Qualitative / interpretive | Meanings, ideas, mentalities | Bhakti poetry as social protest |
| Biographical / prosopographical | One life, or a collective biography of a group | Members of the provincial legislative councils |
| Oral history | Testimony of living witnesses | Partition memories |
| Interdisciplinary | Uses concepts of anthropology, economics, geography | Caste and kinship in a village study |
1.3 Steps of a historical research project
graph TD
A["1. Select the topic
area, period, problem"] --> B["2. Review the literature
find the research gap"]
B --> C["3. Frame questions
and a working hypothesis"]
C --> D["4. Prepare the synopsis
(research proposal)"]
D --> E["5. Heuristics
collect sources"]
E --> F["6. Criticism
external, internal"]
F --> G["7. Note-taking
and organisation"]
G --> H["8. Synthesis
test the hypothesis"]
H --> I["9. Writing
drafts, footnotes, bibliography"]
I --> J["10. Submission
similarity check, viva"]The steps overlap in practice: reading sources often changes the hypothesis, and writing reveals gaps that send you back to the archive.
2. Selection of Topic and Area of Proposed Research
2.1 Criteria for selecting a topic
| Criterion | Question to ask |
|---|---|
| Interest | Will I sustain interest for several years? |
| Originality | Does it fill a gap: a new question, new sources, a new region, or a new interpretation? |
| Significance | Does the answer matter to the field? |
| Availability of sources | Do the sources exist, survive and are they accessible? |
| Researcher’s competence | Languages and scripts (Persian, Modi, Sanskrit, Tamil), palaeography, statistics? |
| Feasibility | Can it be done within the time, funds and travel available? |
| Manageable scope | Neither too broad (unfinishable) nor too narrow (trivial) |
| Supervision | Is guidance available in this field? |
| Ethics | Does it involve living persons, sensitive communities or restricted records? |
2.2 Defining the area of proposed research
Every topic must be delimited on three axes:
| Axis | Delimitation | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Spatial | Region, district, town, village | The Konkan; one district |
| Temporal | Start and end dates, with reasons | 1650–1720: from a revenue settlement to a change of regime |
| Thematic | Aspect studied | Revenue grants and village society, not all of agrarian life |
Justify the limits: a date range should correspond to a historical turning point or the span of the sources, not a round number chosen for convenience.
2.3 Review of literature and the research gap
The review of literature surveys what has been written on the topic, identifies the main interpretations and their sources, and shows where the gap lies: a question unasked, a region unstudied, a body of sources unused, or an interpretation that new evidence can test. A good review is critical and thematic, not a list of summaries.
3. Hypothesis in History
3.1 What a hypothesis is
A hypothesis is a tentative explanation or proposition about the relationship between facts, framed at the start of research to give direction to the search for evidence, and then tested against it.
Example: “The decline of a port’s trade in the early 18th century was caused more by the silting of its harbour than by political instability.”
3.2 Role of hypothesis in historical research
- Gives direction: tells the researcher which sources to look for (harbour records, shipping registers).
- Gives focus: separates relevant from irrelevant facts.
- Links research to theory and earlier debates.
- Provides a basis for conclusions: accepted, modified or rejected.
3.3 Characteristics of a good hypothesis
| Characteristic | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Clear and specific | Precise terms, defined scope |
| Testable (verifiable) against evidence | Sources exist that could support or refute it |
| Consistent with known facts | Does not contradict established evidence without reason |
| Simple | No more complex than needed |
| Related to existing knowledge | Grows out of the literature review |
| Open to revision | A working hypothesis, not a conclusion |
3.4 Hypothesis in history vs in experimental science
| History | Experimental science |
|---|---|
| Tested against surviving evidence | Tested by controlled experiment |
| Often explanatory (why something happened) | Often predictive (what will happen) |
| Statistical testing used only in quantitative history | Statistical testing standard |
| May be reformulated as sources are read | Formally fixed before the experiment |
| Some research (descriptive or exploratory) proceeds through research questions without a formal hypothesis | Hypothesis usual |
3.5 The synopsis (research proposal)
| Part | Content |
|---|---|
| Title | Precise, delimited |
| Introduction | Background and statement of the problem |
| Review of literature | Existing work and the research gap |
| Objectives | What the study will establish |
| Research questions / hypotheses | What will be tested |
| Area and scope | Spatial, temporal, thematic limits |
| Sources and methodology | Primary and secondary sources; methods of collection and analysis |
| Tentative chapterisation | Chapter plan |
| Significance | Expected contribution |
| Tentative bibliography | Main sources and works |
| Timeline | Plan of work |
4. Note-Taking
4.1 Systems
| System | How it works | Advantage |
|---|---|---|
| Card / slip system | One fact or idea per index card, with the source and page on every card; cards filed by theme | Notes can be rearranged as the argument develops |
| Notebook / register | Notes in sequence as sources are read | Simple; keeps context of the source |
| Digital notes and reference managers | Database of notes, quotations and bibliographic data (for example Zotero or similar tools) | Searchable; generates citations |
| Photography / scans of documents | Images of archival pages with reference numbers | Saves time in the archive; needs a careful index |
4.2 Kinds of notes
| Kind | Rule |
|---|---|
| Quotation (verbatim) | Copy exactly, in quotation marks, with page; mark omissions with an ellipsis (…) and your insertions with square brackets |
| Paraphrase | Restate in your own words and sentence structure; still cite |
| Summary | Condense the main point; still cite |
| Your comment | Mark clearly as your own (for example with your initials or a different colour) |
4.3 Principles
- Record full bibliographic details the first time: author, title, edition, publisher, place, year, volume, page; for archives, the repository, series, file number and folio.
- Separate quotation, paraphrase and your own ideas at the moment of writing. Most accidental plagiarism begins with notes that do not.
- One idea per note; give each note a subject heading.
- Note contrary evidence as carefully as supporting evidence.
5. References, Footnotes and Bibliography
5.1 Why historians use notes
Footnotes (at the foot of the page) or endnotes (at the end of a chapter or the work) do four jobs: acknowledge sources, let readers verify claims, discuss evidence or debates without breaking the text, and cross-refer within the work. History favours the notes-bibliography system of the Chicago Manual of Style; the author–date systems (APA) are less common in history. See the Paper 1 page on referencing styles for full examples.
5.2 Form of notes (Chicago notes-bibliography, outline)
| Item | First full note (pattern) | Later short note |
|---|---|---|
| Book | Author’s name in normal order, Title (Place: Publisher, Year), page. | Surname, Short Title, page. |
| Journal article | Author, “Title of Article,” Journal volume, no. issue (Year): page. | Surname, “Short Title,” page. |
| Archival document | Description of document, date, repository, collection, file number, folio. | Shortened description, file, folio. |
5.3 Latin abbreviations in notes
| Abbreviation | Full form | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| ibid. | ibidem | The same source as the immediately preceding note |
| op. cit. | opere citato | In the work already cited (not immediately before); a different page |
| loc. cit. | loco citato | In the same place already cited: same work, same page |
| idem / id. | idem | The same author |
| cf. | confer | Compare |
| et al. | et alii | And others (several authors) |
| passim | — | Here and there throughout the work |
| sic | — | Thus: the error is in the original |
| viz. | videlicet | Namely |
| supra / infra | — | Above / below in the same work |
| f. / ff. | — | And the following page / pages |
| n.d. / n.p. | — | No date / no place (or publisher) |
Current editions of the Chicago Manual discourage op. cit. and loc. cit. in favour of shortened notes, but UGC NET still tests their meanings.
5.4 References vs bibliography
| References (works cited) | Bibliography |
|---|---|
| Only works cited in the text | All works consulted, cited or not |
| Common in author–date systems | Traditional in history with footnotes |
Arrangement of a history bibliography: usually divided into primary sources (unpublished archival records → published documents → contemporary works, newspapers) and secondary sources (books → articles → theses), each arranged alphabetically by the author’s surname. An annotated bibliography adds a short evaluation after each entry.
6. Thesis and Assignment Writing
6.1 Structure of a history thesis
| Part | Contents |
|---|---|
| Preliminaries | Title page → declaration by the candidate → supervisor’s certificate → acknowledgements → contents → list of abbreviations, tables, maps, illustrations → (glossary, if placed in front) |
| Introduction | Problem, review of literature and gap, objectives, hypotheses, scope, sources, methodology, chapter outline |
| Main chapters | Thematic or chronological; each with its own introduction and conclusion |
| Conclusion | Findings, test of hypotheses, contribution, limitations, scope for further research |
| End matter | Appendices (documents, tables, maps) → glossary → bibliography → index (if any) |
6.2 Qualities of good historical writing
- Argument-led: every chapter advances the thesis.
- Evidence for every claim, cited precisely.
- Balanced: competing interpretations acknowledged.
- Chronological clarity: dates and sequences correct and explicit.
- Language: clear, formal, free of anachronism and unexplained jargon; consistent spelling of names and terms (with a glossary for Indian-language terms).
- Revision: several drafts; supervisor’s comments; proof-reading.
6.3 Assignment (term paper) writing
| Thesis | Assignment |
|---|---|
| Years of original research, mostly primary sources | Days or weeks; mainly secondary sources, some primary |
| Must make an original contribution | Must show understanding, analysis and correct use of sources |
| Long, multi-chapter | Short: introduction, body, conclusion |
| Viva voce and external examiners | Assessed by the teacher |
Both require citations, a bibliography and original wording.
7. Plagiarism, Intellectual Dishonesty and History Writing
7.1 Plagiarism
Plagiarism is presenting another person’s words, ideas, data or work as one’s own without acknowledgement.
| Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Direct (verbatim) | Copying text without quotation marks and citation |
| Mosaic / patchwriting | Stitching phrases from sources with a few words changed |
| Paraphrasing without credit | Rewording an idea but not citing it |
| Self-plagiarism | Reusing one’s own published work without disclosure |
| Citing unread sources | Copying another scholar’s references as if one had read the originals; the honest form is “quoted in” or “cited in” |
| Ghost-writing / contract cheating | Submitting work written by someone else |
| Accidental | Careless note-taking that mixes one’s words with a source’s |
UGC regulations (2018). The UGC (Promotion of Academic Integrity and Prevention of Plagiarism in Higher Educational Institutions) Regulations, 2018 set four levels of similarity after permitted exclusions: Level 0 (up to 10%), Level 1 (above 10% to 40%), Level 2 (above 40% to 60%), Level 3 (above 60%), with separate penalties for students and faculty. The full table is on the Paper 1 page Research Ethics and Plagiarism.
7.2 Intellectual dishonesty beyond copying
| Form | In history writing |
|---|---|
| Fabrication | Inventing documents, quotations or data |
| Falsification | Altering dates, figures or wording in sources |
| Selective use of evidence | Quoting the parts that support a thesis and suppressing the rest |
| Quotation out of context | Changing a source’s meaning by cutting it |
| Misrepresentation of others’ views | Attacking a position no scholar holds |
| Ideological distortion | Bending the past to serve a political, religious or national cause |
| Use of forged sources knowingly | Building arguments on documents known to be doubtful |
Cases historians cite
| Case | Issue |
|---|---|
| David Irving v. Penguin Books and Deborah Lipstadt (London, judgment 2000) | Irving sued for libel over being called a Holocaust denier and lost; the court found he had persistently and deliberately misrepresented historical evidence. The historian Richard J. Evans was an expert witness for the defence |
| Michael Bellesiles, Arming America (2000) | An inquiry found serious problems with his use of probate-record evidence; Columbia University rescinded the Bancroft Prize awarded to the book |
7.3 Why history is especially exposed
- History shapes identity and politics, so there is pressure to write a usable past.
- Sources are incomplete, which tempts writers to fill gaps with assertion.
- Textbooks and public history reach millions, so distortion has wide effects.
The safeguards are the method itself: transparent citation, criticism of sources, peer review, and the willingness to let evidence overturn one’s hypothesis.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Method — a technique | vs | Methodology — the justification of techniques |
| Hypothesis — tentative, to be tested | vs | Thesis — the argued conclusion (and the document presenting it) |
| Synopsis — proposal before research | vs | Abstract — summary after research |
| References — works cited | vs | Bibliography — works consulted |
| Footnote — foot of page | vs | Endnote — end of chapter or work |
| ibid. — preceding note | vs | op. cit. — earlier note, different page |
| Plagiarism — taking credit for others’ work | vs | Fabrication / falsification — inventing or altering evidence |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- What does “loc. cit.” mean in a footnote?
- Name the three axes on which the area of a historical research topic is delimited.
- What is the similarity range for Level 1 under the UGC 2018 plagiarism regulations?
Answers
- In the same place already cited: the same work and the same page.
- Spatial, temporal and thematic.
- Above 10% up to 40%.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Which of the following is not a characteristic of a good hypothesis in historical research?
- (a) It can be tested against available evidence
- (b) It is consistent with established facts
- (c) It must be retained even if the evidence contradicts it
- (d) It is clear and specific
Answer and explanation
(c). A hypothesis is tentative: if evidence contradicts it, it is modified or rejected.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- A bibliography in a history thesis may include works consulted but not cited.
- “Ibid.” refers to the source in the immediately preceding note.
- “Sic” indicates that the writer has corrected an error in the quoted source.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 2 only. Sic (“thus”) shows that an error is in the original and has been reproduced faithfully, not corrected.
Q3. (Practice) A thesis on Mughal revenue history is checked by similarity software and shows 40% similarity after permitted exclusions. Under the UGC 2018 regulations this falls in:
- (a) Level 0
- (b) Level 1
- (c) Level 2
- (d) Level 3
Answer and explanation
(b) Level 1. Level 1 is above 10% up to 40%; exactly 40% is still Level 1.
Q4. (Practice) A historian quotes only the passages of a traveller’s account that praise a ruler and omits the passages, in the same chapter, that describe a famine under him. This is best described as:
- (a) Plagiarism
- (b) Selective use of evidence
- (c) External criticism
- (d) Self-plagiarism
Answer and explanation
(b). It is intellectual dishonesty through suppression of inconvenient evidence, not copying.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): The review of literature should precede the formulation of the hypothesis. Reason (R): The review identifies the research gap that the hypothesis addresses.
Answer and explanation
(a). R explains A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Recording quotations, paraphrases and one’s own ideas separately while taking notes helps prevent plagiarism. Reason (R): The UGC 2018 regulations exempt paraphrased material from citation.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true. R is false: paraphrased ideas must be cited; the exclusions in the regulations cover properly attributed quotations, references and bibliography, standard terms and similar items, not uncited paraphrase.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (abbreviation) with List II (meaning).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. cf. | I. Here and there throughout |
| B. passim | II. Compare |
| C. op. cit. | III. Namely |
| D. viz. | IV. In the work already cited |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (3) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (4) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following steps of a historical research project in order:
- Note-taking from sources
- Selection of topic
- Formulation of hypothesis
- Review of literature
- Writing and referencing
- (a) 2, 4, 3, 1, 5
- (b) 2, 3, 4, 1, 5
- (c) 4, 2, 3, 1, 5
- (d) 2, 4, 1, 3, 5
Answer and explanation
(a) 2, 4, 3, 1, 5. Topic → literature review → hypothesis → source work and notes → writing.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange the parts of a thesis in the order in which they appear: bibliography, introduction, supervisor’s certificate, appendices, conclusion.
Answer and explanation
Supervisor’s certificate → introduction → conclusion → appendices → bibliography. (Practice varies on whether appendices come before or after the bibliography; many university formats place appendices first.)
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Methodology | Justification of methods, not the methods alone |
| Topic criteria | Interest, originality, significance, sources, competence, feasibility |
| Area of research | Spatial, temporal, thematic limits |
| Hypothesis | Tentative, testable, specific, consistent, revisable |
| Synopsis | Title → introduction → review → objectives → hypotheses → scope → sources and method → chapters → bibliography → timeline |
| Card system | One idea per card, source on every card |
| ibid. / op. cit. / loc. cit. | Preceding / earlier, other page / earlier, same page |
| sic / passim / cf. | Error in original / throughout / compare |
| Bibliography in history | Primary then secondary; alphabetical by surname |
| UGC 2018 levels | 0: ≤10%; 1: >10–40%; 2: >40–60%; 3: >60% |
| Irving v. Lipstadt | Judgment 2000; deliberate misrepresentation of evidence |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
The second half of the unit turns from method to the history of history-writing itself, starting with Herodotus and Thucydides in Greek, Roman, Church and Renaissance Historiography. For general research design, sampling and hypotheses beyond history, revisit Paper 1’s Methods and Steps of Research.