Historical Method and Historiography Short Notes
UGC NET History Unit 10 on one page: definitions, objectivity, method, research writing, Greek to Renaissance, Ranke, Marx, Spengler, Toynbee, Indian schools.
- 7 min
On this page · 8 sections
1. Nature of History
Definitions by author
| Thinker | Line or idea | Work |
|---|---|---|
| Cicero | Historia magistra vitae | De Oratore |
| Ranke | Wie es eigentlich gewesen | 1824 preface |
| Bury | “A science, no less and no more” | Cambridge inaugural, 1903 |
| Croce | All history is contemporary history | Theory and History of Historiography |
| Collingwood | All history is the history of thought; re-enactment | The Idea of History (1946) |
| Bloch | Science of men in time | The Historian’s Craft (1949) |
| Carr | Unending dialogue between present and past | What is History? (1961) |
| Carlyle | History as biography of great men | On Heroes (1841) |
Objectivity, science, causation
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Becker | “Everyman His Own Historian” (1931) |
| Beard | “That Noble Dream” (1935); Novick’s book of that title (1988) |
| Butterfield | The Whig Interpretation of History (1931) |
| Elton | The Practice of History (1967); empiricist reply to Carr |
| Windelband | Nomothetic (science) vs idiographic (history), 1894 |
| Dilthey | Verstehen; human sciences |
| Hempel | Covering-law model (1942) |
| Buckle | Laws of history; History of Civilization in England (1857–61) |
| Trevelyan | “Clio, a Muse”: history as art |
| Carr on causes | Hierarchy of causes; Cleopatra’s nose (Pascal); Robinson’s death; rational vs accidental |
| Thucydides | “Truest cause” vs stated grievances |
| Collingwood | Historical (a priori) imagination, 1935 |
| Verdict | Scientific in method, artistic in presentation, social science in concepts; not experimental |
Auxiliary sciences
| Science | Studies |
|---|---|
| Palaeography | Scripts, handwriting |
| Epigraphy | Inscriptions |
| Diplomatics | Authenticity of documents (Mabillon, 1681) |
| Numismatics | Coins |
| Sphragistics | Seals |
| Chronology / genealogy / heraldry | Eras / descent / coats of arms |
| Philology | Language of texts (Valla, 1440) |
| Codicology / metrology / toponymy | Manuscript books / weights and measures / place names |
2. Historical Method
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Stages | Heuristics → external criticism → internal criticism → synthesis → presentation |
| Heuristics | Finding sources (heuriskein) |
| Bernheim | Lehrbuch der historischen Methode (1889); remains vs tradition |
| Langlois and Seignobos | Introduction aux études historiques (1898); “no documents, no history” |
| Droysen | Grundriss der Historik (1868) |
| External (lower) | Genuine? Who, when, where? Restore the text |
| Internal (higher) | Positive (meaning) and negative (good faith, accuracy) |
| Corroboration | Independent witnesses only |
| Primary / secondary | Relative to the question |
| Original / transit | First form / transmitted by copying, translation, quotation |
| Bloch | “Witnesses in spite of themselves” |
| Forgeries | Donation of Constantine (1440), Piltdown (1953), Hitler Diaries (1983) |
| Oral history | Paul Thompson (1978); oral tradition — Vansina |
| National Archives of India | 1891, Imperial Record Department, Calcutta |
3. Research Methodology and Writing
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Methodology | Justification of methods |
| Topic criteria | Interest, originality, significance, sources, competence, feasibility |
| Area | Spatial, temporal, thematic |
| Hypothesis | Tentative, testable, specific, consistent, revisable; after literature review |
| Synopsis | Title, introduction, review, objectives, hypotheses, scope, sources and method, chapters, bibliography, timeline |
| Notes | One idea per card; source on every card; separate quote, paraphrase, own idea |
| ibid. | Immediately preceding note |
| op. cit. / loc. cit. | Earlier work, other page / same work, same page |
| cf. / passim / sic / viz. | Compare / throughout / error in original / namely |
| Bibliography | Primary then secondary; alphabetical by surname; includes works consulted |
| Thesis order | Preliminaries → introduction → chapters → conclusion → appendices → bibliography → index |
| UGC 2018 levels | 0: up to 10%; 1: above 10–40%; 2: above 40–60%; 3: above 60% |
| Dishonesty | Fabrication, falsification, selective evidence, quotation out of context |
| Irving v. Lipstadt | Judgment 2000; Evans as expert witness |
4. Greek, Roman, Church, Renaissance
| Historian | Work | Tag |
|---|---|---|
| Herodotus | Histories (Persian Wars) | Father of history (Cicero) |
| Thucydides | Peloponnesian War (to 411 BCE) | Critical; truest cause; possession for all time |
| Xenophon | Hellenica (411–362 BCE) | Continues Thucydides |
| Polybius | Histories (40 books) | Pragmatic, universal; anacyclosis |
| Fabius Pictor / Cato | In Greek / Origines in Latin | First Roman historians |
| Sallust | Catiline, Jugurtha | Moral decline |
| Livy | Ab Urbe Condita (142 books, 35 survive) | Patriotic |
| Tacitus | Annals, Histories, Germania | Sine ira et studio |
| Suetonius | Twelve Caesars | Biography |
| Eusebius | Ecclesiastical History | Father of Church history |
| Augustine | City of God (c. 413–426) | Two cities; linear, providential |
| Orosius | History against the Pagans | Augustine’s pupil-collaborator |
| Bede | Ecclesiastical History of the English People (731) | Popularised AD dating |
| Petrarch | — | Idea of a dark age |
| Bruni | History of the Florentine People | Civic humanist |
| Valla | Donation of Constantine (1440) | Philology |
| Machiavelli | Florentine Histories; The Prince | Secular causation |
| Guicciardini | Storia d’Italia | Document-based analysis |
| Bodin | Methodus (1566) | Method treatise |
| Voltaire / Gibbon | Age of Louis XIV (1751) / Decline and Fall (1776–88) | Enlightenment |
5. Philosophies of History
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Positive school | Comte (law of three stages, 1830–42), Buckle, Taine, Fustel de Coulanges |
| Negative (critical) school | Bayle (1697), Niebuhr (Roman History, from 1811), negative internal criticism |
| Ranke | 1795–1886; Berlin from 1825; 1824 book and critique; seminar; archives; Roman Popes; “every epoch is immediate to God”; von 1865 |
| Sybel | Historische Zeitschrift (1859) |
| Marx and Engels | German Ideology (1845–46); Manifesto (1848); Eighteenth Brumaire (1852); 1859 Preface; Capital I (1867); Engels, Socialism: Utopian and Scientific (1880) |
| Historical materialism | Forces + relations = mode of production (base); superstructure; class struggle; dialectic |
| Modes | Primitive communism → slave → feudal → capitalist → socialist; “Asiatic” mode (contested) |
| Ibn Khaldun | Muqaddimah (1377); asabiyya |
| Vico | New Science (1725); gods, heroes, men; corsi e ricorsi |
| Spengler | 1880–1936; Decline of the West (1918, 1922); culture → civilisation; 8 cultures; Apollonian, Magian, Faustian |
| Toynbee | 1889–1975; A Study of History (12 vols, 1934–61); Somervell abridgement |
| Toynbee’s terms | Challenge and response; golden mean; creative minority; mimesis; withdrawal and return; dominant minority; internal and external proletariat; universal state; universal church; suicide not murder |
| Critics | Popper (1945, 1957) on Marx; Geyl and Trevor-Roper on Toynbee |
6. Postmodernism, Trends, Indian Historiography
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Lyotard | The Postmodern Condition (1979); metanarratives |
| Hayden White | Metahistory (1973); romance, tragedy, comedy, satire |
| Foucault / Derrida / Barthes | Power-knowledge / deconstruction / death of the author |
| Jenkins / Evans | Re-thinking History (1991) / In Defence of History (1997) |
| Said | Orientalism (1978) |
| Annales | Bloch and Febvre, 1929; Braudel (1949): longue durée, conjunctures, events |
| History from below | E.P. Thompson (1963); Hobsbawm |
| Microhistory | Ginzburg (1976); Davis (1983) |
| Gender | Joan Scott (1986) |
| Cliometrics | Fogel and Engerman (1974) |
| Colonial | Jones (1784), Mill (1817), Elphinstone (1841), V.A. Smith (1904), Elliot and Dowson (1867–77) |
| Nationalist | R.C. Dutt (c. 1901–04), Jayaswal (1924), Raychaudhuri (1923), Jadunath Sarkar, R.C. Majumdar, Savarkar (1909) |
| Marxist | Kosambi (1956), R.S. Sharma (1958, 1965), Irfan Habib (1963), Bipan Chandra (1966), A.R. Desai (1948) |
| Cambridge | Anil Seal (1968); Locality, Province and Nation (1973) |
| Subaltern | Ranajit Guha, vol. I (1982); Elementary Aspects (1983); term from Gramsci; Chakrabarty (2000); Spivak (1988); Sumit Sarkar’s critique |
| Recent Indian trends | Regional (Stein 1980; Chattopadhyaya 1994), 18th-century debate (Bayly 1983; Alam 1986), environmental (R. Guha 1989), gender, Dalit, Partition oral history (Butalia 1998) |
| Institutions | Indian History Congress 1935; ICHR 1972 |
| Regional history | Corrects centre-bound narratives; regional sources; tests theories; builds national history; beware chauvinism |
Sequences to Know
| Sequence | Order |
|---|---|
| Historical method | Heuristics → external → internal → synthesis → presentation |
| Research project | Topic → literature review → hypothesis → synopsis → sources → criticism → notes → synthesis → writing |
| Greek historians | Herodotus → Thucydides → Xenophon → Polybius |
| Church historians | Eusebius → Augustine → Orosius → Gregory of Tours → Bede |
| Toynbee | Genesis → growth → breakdown → disintegration |
| Marx’s modes | Primitive communism → slave → feudal → capitalist → socialist |
| Indian schools | Colonial → nationalist → Marxist → Cambridge → Subaltern → recent |
| Key works by year | Vico 1725 → Mill 1817 → Ranke 1824 → Manifesto 1848 → Buckle 1857 → Langlois–Seignobos 1898 → Spengler 1918 → Annales 1929 → Toynbee 1934 → Kosambi 1956 → Carr 1961 → Seal 1968 → White 1973 → Lyotard 1979 → Subaltern Studies 1982 |
Top Traps
Back to: Unit 10 overview · History hub · Paper 1: Research Aptitude quick revision