Skip to content

Historical Method and Historiography Short Notes

UGC NET History Unit 10 on one page: definitions, objectivity, method, research writing, Greek to Renaissance, Ranke, Marx, Spengler, Toynbee, Indian schools.

  • 7 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 8 sections
  1. 1. Nature of History
  2. 2. Historical Method
  3. 3. Research Methodology and Writing
  4. 4. Greek, Roman, Church, Renaissance
  5. 5. Philosophies of History
  6. 6. Postmodernism, Trends, Indian Historiography
  7. Sequences to Know
  8. Top Traps

1. Nature of History

Definitions by author

ThinkerLine or ideaWork
CiceroHistoria magistra vitaeDe Oratore
RankeWie es eigentlich gewesen1824 preface
Bury“A science, no less and no more”Cambridge inaugural, 1903
CroceAll history is contemporary historyTheory and History of Historiography
CollingwoodAll history is the history of thought; re-enactmentThe Idea of History (1946)
BlochScience of men in timeThe Historian’s Craft (1949)
CarrUnending dialogue between present and pastWhat is History? (1961)
CarlyleHistory as biography of great menOn Heroes (1841)

Objectivity, science, causation

ItemFact
Becker“Everyman His Own Historian” (1931)
Beard“That Noble Dream” (1935); Novick’s book of that title (1988)
ButterfieldThe Whig Interpretation of History (1931)
EltonThe Practice of History (1967); empiricist reply to Carr
WindelbandNomothetic (science) vs idiographic (history), 1894
DiltheyVerstehen; human sciences
HempelCovering-law model (1942)
BuckleLaws of history; History of Civilization in England (1857–61)
Trevelyan“Clio, a Muse”: history as art
Carr on causesHierarchy of causes; Cleopatra’s nose (Pascal); Robinson’s death; rational vs accidental
Thucydides“Truest cause” vs stated grievances
CollingwoodHistorical (a priori) imagination, 1935
VerdictScientific in method, artistic in presentation, social science in concepts; not experimental

Auxiliary sciences

ScienceStudies
PalaeographyScripts, handwriting
EpigraphyInscriptions
DiplomaticsAuthenticity of documents (Mabillon, 1681)
NumismaticsCoins
SphragisticsSeals
Chronology / genealogy / heraldryEras / descent / coats of arms
PhilologyLanguage of texts (Valla, 1440)
Codicology / metrology / toponymyManuscript books / weights and measures / place names

2. Historical Method

ItemFact
StagesHeuristics → external criticism → internal criticism → synthesis → presentation
HeuristicsFinding sources (heuriskein)
BernheimLehrbuch der historischen Methode (1889); remains vs tradition
Langlois and SeignobosIntroduction aux études historiques (1898); “no documents, no history”
DroysenGrundriss der Historik (1868)
External (lower)Genuine? Who, when, where? Restore the text
Internal (higher)Positive (meaning) and negative (good faith, accuracy)
CorroborationIndependent witnesses only
Primary / secondaryRelative to the question
Original / transitFirst form / transmitted by copying, translation, quotation
Bloch“Witnesses in spite of themselves”
ForgeriesDonation of Constantine (1440), Piltdown (1953), Hitler Diaries (1983)
Oral historyPaul Thompson (1978); oral tradition — Vansina
National Archives of India1891, Imperial Record Department, Calcutta

3. Research Methodology and Writing

ItemFact
MethodologyJustification of methods
Topic criteriaInterest, originality, significance, sources, competence, feasibility
AreaSpatial, temporal, thematic
HypothesisTentative, testable, specific, consistent, revisable; after literature review
SynopsisTitle, introduction, review, objectives, hypotheses, scope, sources and method, chapters, bibliography, timeline
NotesOne idea per card; source on every card; separate quote, paraphrase, own idea
ibid.Immediately preceding note
op. cit. / loc. cit.Earlier work, other page / same work, same page
cf. / passim / sic / viz.Compare / throughout / error in original / namely
BibliographyPrimary then secondary; alphabetical by surname; includes works consulted
Thesis orderPreliminaries → introduction → chapters → conclusion → appendices → bibliography → index
UGC 2018 levels0: up to 10%; 1: above 10–40%; 2: above 40–60%; 3: above 60%
DishonestyFabrication, falsification, selective evidence, quotation out of context
Irving v. LipstadtJudgment 2000; Evans as expert witness

4. Greek, Roman, Church, Renaissance

HistorianWorkTag
HerodotusHistories (Persian Wars)Father of history (Cicero)
ThucydidesPeloponnesian War (to 411 BCE)Critical; truest cause; possession for all time
XenophonHellenica (411–362 BCE)Continues Thucydides
PolybiusHistories (40 books)Pragmatic, universal; anacyclosis
Fabius Pictor / CatoIn Greek / Origines in LatinFirst Roman historians
SallustCatiline, JugurthaMoral decline
LivyAb Urbe Condita (142 books, 35 survive)Patriotic
TacitusAnnals, Histories, GermaniaSine ira et studio
SuetoniusTwelve CaesarsBiography
EusebiusEcclesiastical HistoryFather of Church history
AugustineCity of God (c. 413–426)Two cities; linear, providential
OrosiusHistory against the PagansAugustine’s pupil-collaborator
BedeEcclesiastical History of the English People (731)Popularised AD dating
Petrarch—Idea of a dark age
BruniHistory of the Florentine PeopleCivic humanist
VallaDonation of Constantine (1440)Philology
MachiavelliFlorentine Histories; The PrinceSecular causation
GuicciardiniStoria d’ItaliaDocument-based analysis
BodinMethodus (1566)Method treatise
Voltaire / GibbonAge of Louis XIV (1751) / Decline and Fall (1776–88)Enlightenment

5. Philosophies of History

ItemFact
Positive schoolComte (law of three stages, 1830–42), Buckle, Taine, Fustel de Coulanges
Negative (critical) schoolBayle (1697), Niebuhr (Roman History, from 1811), negative internal criticism
Ranke1795–1886; Berlin from 1825; 1824 book and critique; seminar; archives; Roman Popes; “every epoch is immediate to God”; von 1865
SybelHistorische Zeitschrift (1859)
Marx and EngelsGerman Ideology (1845–46); Manifesto (1848); Eighteenth Brumaire (1852); 1859 Preface; Capital I (1867); Engels, Socialism: Utopian and Scientific (1880)
Historical materialismForces + relations = mode of production (base); superstructure; class struggle; dialectic
ModesPrimitive communism → slave → feudal → capitalist → socialist; “Asiatic” mode (contested)
Ibn KhaldunMuqaddimah (1377); asabiyya
VicoNew Science (1725); gods, heroes, men; corsi e ricorsi
Spengler1880–1936; Decline of the West (1918, 1922); culture → civilisation; 8 cultures; Apollonian, Magian, Faustian
Toynbee1889–1975; A Study of History (12 vols, 1934–61); Somervell abridgement
Toynbee’s termsChallenge and response; golden mean; creative minority; mimesis; withdrawal and return; dominant minority; internal and external proletariat; universal state; universal church; suicide not murder
CriticsPopper (1945, 1957) on Marx; Geyl and Trevor-Roper on Toynbee
ItemFact
LyotardThe Postmodern Condition (1979); metanarratives
Hayden WhiteMetahistory (1973); romance, tragedy, comedy, satire
Foucault / Derrida / BarthesPower-knowledge / deconstruction / death of the author
Jenkins / EvansRe-thinking History (1991) / In Defence of History (1997)
SaidOrientalism (1978)
AnnalesBloch and Febvre, 1929; Braudel (1949): longue durée, conjunctures, events
History from belowE.P. Thompson (1963); Hobsbawm
MicrohistoryGinzburg (1976); Davis (1983)
GenderJoan Scott (1986)
CliometricsFogel and Engerman (1974)
ColonialJones (1784), Mill (1817), Elphinstone (1841), V.A. Smith (1904), Elliot and Dowson (1867–77)
NationalistR.C. Dutt (c. 1901–04), Jayaswal (1924), Raychaudhuri (1923), Jadunath Sarkar, R.C. Majumdar, Savarkar (1909)
MarxistKosambi (1956), R.S. Sharma (1958, 1965), Irfan Habib (1963), Bipan Chandra (1966), A.R. Desai (1948)
CambridgeAnil Seal (1968); Locality, Province and Nation (1973)
SubalternRanajit Guha, vol. I (1982); Elementary Aspects (1983); term from Gramsci; Chakrabarty (2000); Spivak (1988); Sumit Sarkar’s critique
Recent Indian trendsRegional (Stein 1980; Chattopadhyaya 1994), 18th-century debate (Bayly 1983; Alam 1986), environmental (R. Guha 1989), gender, Dalit, Partition oral history (Butalia 1998)
InstitutionsIndian History Congress 1935; ICHR 1972
Regional historyCorrects centre-bound narratives; regional sources; tests theories; builds national history; beware chauvinism

Sequences to Know

SequenceOrder
Historical methodHeuristics → external → internal → synthesis → presentation
Research projectTopic → literature review → hypothesis → synopsis → sources → criticism → notes → synthesis → writing
Greek historiansHerodotus → Thucydides → Xenophon → Polybius
Church historiansEusebius → Augustine → Orosius → Gregory of Tours → Bede
ToynbeeGenesis → growth → breakdown → disintegration
Marx’s modesPrimitive communism → slave → feudal → capitalist → socialist
Indian schoolsColonial → nationalist → Marxist → Cambridge → Subaltern → recent
Key works by yearVico 1725 → Mill 1817 → Ranke 1824 → Manifesto 1848 → Buckle 1857 → Langlois–Seignobos 1898 → Spengler 1918 → Annales 1929 → Toynbee 1934 → Kosambi 1956 → Carr 1961 → Seal 1968 → White 1973 → Lyotard 1979 → Subaltern Studies 1982

Top Traps

Back to: Unit 10 overview · History hub · Paper 1: Research Aptitude quick revision

Advertisement
Advertisement