Skip to content

Historical Method, Research Methodology and Historiography

UGC NET History Unit 10: nature of history, historical method, thesis writing, Greek to Renaissance historiography, Ranke, Marx, Toynbee, postmodernism.

6
Topics
101
Min read

Chapter Overview

This is Unit 10 of the UGC NET History syllabus (Paper 2, subject code 06), and the only History unit that carries an official heading: Historical Method, Research, Methodology and Historiography. Where Units 1 to 9 ask what happened, this unit asks how we know, how historians work and how history has been written, from Herodotus to the Subaltern Studies collective.

Paper 2 has 100 questions for 200 marks, +2 each and no negative marking (NTA information bulletin, December 2026), so every question should be attempted. This unit rewards exact pairings (thinker → work → year → key term) and a clear grasp of method: the order of the stages of research, the difference between external and internal criticism, the meaning of a footnote abbreviation.

The official syllabus lists twenty-one lines for this unit:

  1. Scope and importance of history
  2. Objectivity and bias in history
  3. Heuristics operation, criticism in history, synthesis and presentation
  4. History and its auxiliary sciences
  5. History: a science, arts or a social science
  6. Causation and imagination in history
  7. Significance of regional history
  8. Recent trends of Indian history
  9. Research methodology; hypothesis in history; area of proposed research
  10. Sources: data collection, primary/secondary, original and transit sources
  11. Trends in historical research; recent Indian historiography
  12. Selection of topic in history; notes taking, references, footnotes and bibliography; thesis and assignment writing
  13. Plagiarism, intellectual dishonesty and history writing
  14. Beginnings of historical writing: Greek, Roman and Church historiography
  15. Renaissance and its impact on history writing
  16. Negative and positive schools of historical writing
  17. Berlin revolution in history writing: Von Ranke
  18. Marxist philosophy of history: scientific materialism
  19. Cyclical theory of history: Oswald Spengler
  20. Challenge and response theory: Arnold Joseph Toynbee
  21. Post-modernism in history

What You’ll Learn

By the end of this chapter, you will be able to:

  • Define history and historiography, state their scope and uses, and pair the standard definitions with their authors (Ranke, Croce, Collingwood, Bloch, Carr)
  • Argue the objectivity question, classify kinds of bias, and decide in what sense history is a science, an art and a social science
  • Explain causation (immediate and remote causes, Carr’s hierarchy of causes) and the disciplined role of historical imagination
  • Name the auxiliary sciences and what each contributes
  • Run the stages of historical method: heuristics, external and internal criticism, synthesis and presentation; classify sources as primary, secondary, original or transmitted
  • Plan a research project: topic, area, hypothesis, synopsis, notes, footnotes, bibliography, thesis; recognise plagiarism and intellectual dishonesty
  • Trace history writing from the Greeks, Romans and the Church through the Renaissance
  • Explain the positive and negative schools, Ranke’s Berlin revolution, Marx’s historical materialism, Spengler’s cycles and Toynbee’s challenge and response
  • Summarise postmodernism, world trends (Annales, history from below) and the schools of Indian historiography, and say why regional history matters

Prerequisites

None beyond an MA-level familiarity with Indian history. This unit overlaps directly with Paper 1 Research Aptitude: read its Methods and Steps of Research and Research Ethics and Plagiarism pages alongside topics 2 and 3 here.


Timeline of History Writing

timeline
    title From inquiry to postmodernism
    5th century BCE : Herodotus, Histories : Thucydides, Peloponnesian War
    2nd century BCE : Polybius, rise of Rome, anacyclosis
    c. 1st century BCE to 2nd century CE : Livy, Tacitus
    4th-8th centuries : Eusebius, Augustine's City of God, Bede (731)
    1377 : Ibn Khaldun, Muqaddimah
    1440 : Valla exposes the Donation of Constantine
    1681 : Mabillon founds diplomatics
    1817 : James Mill, History of British India
    1824 : Ranke, wie es eigentlich gewesen
    1848-1867 : Marx and Engels, Manifesto to Capital
    1898 : Langlois and Seignobos on historical method
    1918-1922 : Spengler, Decline of the West
    1929 : Annales founded
    1934-1961 : Toynbee, A Study of History
    1956 : Kosambi, Introduction to the Study of Indian History
    1961 : E.H. Carr, What is History?
    1973-1979 : Hayden White's Metahistory, Lyotard's Postmodern Condition
    1982 : Subaltern Studies I

Learning Path

graph TD
    A["1. Nature of History
scope, objectivity, science or art,
causation, auxiliary sciences"] --> B["2. Historical Method
heuristics, criticism,
synthesis, kinds of sources"] B --> C["3. Research Methodology
topic, hypothesis, notes,
footnotes, thesis, plagiarism"] C --> D["4. Greek to Renaissance
Herodotus to Guicciardini"] D --> E["5. Philosophies of History
positive and negative schools,
Ranke, Marx, Spengler, Toynbee"] E --> F["6. Postmodernism and
Recent Trends
Indian schools, regional history"] F --> G["Quick Revision
one-page sheet"]

Topics in This Chapter

#TopicSyllabus linesWhat it covers
1Nature of History: Scope, Objectivity, Causation and Auxiliary Sciences1, 2, 4, 5, 6Definitions by author, scope and uses, objectivity debate, kinds of bias, science/art/social science, causation, historical imagination, auxiliary sciences
2Historical Method: Sources, Heuristics, Criticism and Synthesis3, 10Bernheim and Langlois–Seignobos, heuristics, repositories and data collection, primary/secondary, original/transit, external and internal criticism, synthesis, presentation
3Research Methodology and Thesis Writing in History9, 12, 13Method vs methodology, steps of research, topic and area, hypothesis, synopsis, note-taking, footnotes and Latin abbreviations, bibliography, thesis and assignment, plagiarism and intellectual dishonesty
4Greek, Roman, Church and Renaissance Historiography14, 15Herodotus, Thucydides, Polybius, Roman historians, Eusebius, Augustine, Bede, Renaissance humanists, Valla, Machiavelli, Guicciardini
5Philosophies of History: Ranke, Positivism, Marx, Spengler and Toynbee16, 17, 18, 19, 20Positive and negative schools, Ranke and the Berlin revolution, historical materialism, Ibn Khaldun and Vico, Spengler’s cultures, Toynbee’s challenge and response
6Postmodernism, Recent Trends and Indian Historiography7, 8, 11, 21Postmodernism and its critics, Annales and other world trends, colonial, nationalist, Marxist, Cambridge and Subaltern schools, recent Indian trends, regional history
—Quick RevisionAllEvery thinker, work, year and term on one page

Official line → page

#Official syllabus lineCovered on
1Scope and importance of historyNature of History, section 2
2Objectivity and bias in historyNature of History, section 3
3Heuristics operation, criticism, synthesis and presentationHistorical Method, sections 1, 2, 4–6
4History and its auxiliary sciencesNature of History, section 7
5History: a science, arts or a social scienceNature of History, section 4
6Causation and imagination in historyNature of History, sections 5–6
7Significance of regional historyPostmodernism and Recent Trends, section 4
8Recent trends of Indian historyPostmodernism and Recent Trends, section 3.7
9Research methodology; hypothesis; area of proposed researchResearch Methodology, sections 1–3
10Sources: data collection, primary/secondary, original and transitHistorical Method, sections 2–3
11Trends in historical research; recent Indian historiographyPostmodernism and Recent Trends, sections 2–3
12Selection of topic; notes, references, footnotes, bibliography; thesis and assignment writingResearch Methodology, sections 2, 4–6
13Plagiarism, intellectual dishonesty and history writingResearch Methodology, section 7
14Greek, Roman and Church historiographyGreek to Renaissance, sections 1–3
15Renaissance and its impact on history writingGreek to Renaissance, section 4
16Negative and positive schools of historical writingPhilosophies of History, section 1
17Berlin revolution: Von RankePhilosophies of History, section 2
18Marxist philosophy of history: scientific materialismPhilosophies of History, section 3
19Cyclical theory: Oswald SpenglerPhilosophies of History, sections 4–5
20Challenge and response: Arnold Joseph ToynbeePhilosophies of History, section 6
21Post-modernism in historyPostmodernism and Recent Trends, section 1

How UGC NET Asks It

FormatWhat to expect in this unit
Direct MCQ“Who wrote A Study of History?”, “Which auxiliary science studies seals?”, “What does loc. cit. mean?”
Statement-basedTwo or three statements on objectivity, Toynbee’s stages, postmodernism or the Cambridge school, with combined options
Assertion–reasonWhy external criticism comes first; why Ranke is the father of scientific history; why Subaltern historians read against the grain
Match the followingHistorian → work (Thucydides, Tacitus, Bede, Guicciardini, Spengler, Kosambi, Seal); thinker → term (anacyclosis, asabiyya, Faustian soul, creative minority, longue durée, metanarratives)
SequencingStages of historical method; steps of a research project; Greek and Roman historians; schools of Indian historiography; works by year

Quick Reference: the Unit at a Glance

ItemKey fact
CarrWhat is History? (1961); “unending dialogue”
CollingwoodThe Idea of History (1946); history of thought; historical imagination
Stages of methodHeuristics → external criticism → internal criticism → synthesis → presentation
Langlois and SeignobosIntroduction aux études historiques (1898); “no documents, no history”
Herodotus / ThucydidesFather of history / critical history
AugustineCity of God; linear, providential history
RankeBerlin; 1824; wie es eigentlich gewesen; seminar
MarxBase and superstructure (1859 Preface); modes of production
Spengler / ToynbeeDecline of the West (1918–22) / A Study of History (1934–61)
PostmodernismLyotard (1979); Hayden White (1973)
Indian schoolsColonial → nationalist → Marxist → Cambridge → Subaltern

Related: History hub · Paper 1: Research Aptitude · Sources of Ancient Indian History


Start Learning

Begin with the first topic:

→ Nature of History: Scope, Objectivity, Causation and Auxiliary Sciences

Advertisement
Advertisement