Deindustrialisation, Drain, Modern Industry and Labour
UGC NET History Unit 8: craft decline, de-urbanisation, drain theory, world wars, industrial policy, modern industries, factory acts, trade unions.
- 18 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: The Weavers of Dacca
- 1. Decline of Indian Industries
- 2. The Economic Drain
- 3. World Wars and the Indian Economy
- 4. British Industrial Policy
- 5. Major Modern Industries
- 6. Nature of Factory Legislation
- 7. Labour and Trade Union Movements
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Colonial Trade, Commercialisation of Agriculture and Land Settlements — the export surplus and the shift to raw-material exports that this page builds on.
- M.K. Gandhi and J.L. Nehru — Gandhi’s critique of machine civilisation and Nehru’s planning ideas grew out of the debates on this page.
- Data Interpretation Calculations — percentage change, which you need for the deindustrialisation figures.
The Hook: The Weavers of Dacca
How UGC NET asks it: match nationalist economists with their books; statements on the drain theory; assertion–reason on deindustrialisation; match industries with first mills and founders; chronology of factory acts and labour organisations.
1. Decline of Indian Industries
1.1 Causes of the decline of handicrafts
| Cause | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Loss of court patronage | The decline of Indian courts and nobility after annexations removed buyers of luxury crafts: fine textiles, arms, jewellery, ivory |
| Company coercion (late 18th century) | In Bengal, Company gomastas forced weavers to accept advances (dadni) and sell only to the Company at low prices |
| Competition from machine goods | Cheap Lancashire cloth and yarn flooded India after 1813, while Indian goods faced high duties in Britain |
| One-way free trade | India was opened to British goods with low tariffs; Indian industry had no protection until the 1920s |
| Railways | Opened interior markets to imported goods and carried raw cotton to ports |
| New tastes | English-educated Indians and urban elites bought European goods |
| Raw-material drain | Export of raw cotton and silk raised prices for local craftsmen |
1.2 Changing socio-economic conditions of artisans
- Many artisans left their crafts for agriculture, adding to pressure on land; nationalists called this the ruralisation of the economy.
- Others survived by adapting: handloom weavers switched to mill-made yarn (imported or Indian) and to coarse cloth for local markets. Tirthankar Roy (Traditional Industry in the Economy of Colonial India, 1999) argues that handloom output held up, even grew, into the 20th century.
- Artisans increasingly worked under merchant-financiers (the putting-out system), losing independence even where the craft survived.
- Some artisans became factory workers or migrants; women’s spinning, a major source of household income, collapsed with mill yarn.
1.3 The deindustrialisation debate
De-industrialisation (a syllabus concept term) means a fall in the share (or absolute number) of the population dependent on industry, and a corresponding rise in dependence on agriculture.
| Position | Scholar | Argument |
|---|---|---|
| Nationalist | Dadabhai Naoroji, R.C. Dutt (The Economic History of India, 2 vols, 1902 and 1904), M.G. Ranade | British policy destroyed Indian manufactures and forced the people back on land |
| Revisionist | Morris David Morris, “Towards a Reinterpretation of Nineteenth-Century Indian Economic History” (Journal of Economic History, 1963; reprinted with replies in the Indian Economic and Social History Review, 1968) | No clear evidence of decline; cheap imported yarn may have helped weavers; the British state was too weak and too passive to “ruin” India |
| Replies to Morris | Bipan Chandra, Toru Matsui, Tapan Raychaudhuri (IESHR symposium, 1968) | Morris ignored the evidence of artisans’ distress and the structure of colonial exploitation |
| Quantitative case | Amiya Kumar Bagchi (1976) | Compared Francis Buchanan-Hamilton’s survey of Gangetic Bihar (1809–13) with the 1901 census: the share of population dependent on industry fell from about 18.6% to about 8.5% |
| Critique of Bagchi | Marika Vicziany (1979) | Buchanan’s data are not reliable enough for such comparisons |
| Adaptation | Tirthankar Roy | Decline in some crafts, survival and commercialisation in others |
1.4 De-urbanisation
- Old centres of court and craft declined: Dacca, Murshidabad, Surat, and many smaller textile towns. Political changes (loss of capitals) and the collapse of export crafts emptied them.
- New colonial towns, the Presidency ports and later railway and industrial towns, grew instead (see Money, Transport, Towns and Famines).
- The net effect in the 19th century was a stagnant urban share of the population: urbanisation in colonial India was slow and concentrated in a few port cities, unlike the industrial urbanisation of Britain.
2. The Economic Drain
2.1 The theory
Economic drain (a syllabus concept term) is the transfer of part of India’s national product to Britain without an equivalent economic or material return. It was the central argument of early Indian economic nationalism.
| Writer | Work | Contribution |
|---|---|---|
| Dadabhai Naoroji | Papers of the late 1860s and 1870s (“The Wants and Means of India”, “Poverty of India”); book Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901) | Systematic statement of the drain; first estimate of per capita income (about Rs 20 a year for 1867–68) |
| R.C. Dutt | The Economic History of India (vol. 1, Under Early British Rule, 1902; vol. 2, In the Victorian Age, 1904); Open Letters to Lord Curzon on famines | Linked drain, land revenue and famines |
| M.G. Ranade | Essays on Indian Economics (1898) | Argued for state-aided industrialisation; critic of laissez-faire (“Indian political economy”) |
| William Digby | “Prosperous” British India (1901) | A British critic who supported the drain and poverty argument |
| G.V. Joshi, G. Subramania Iyer, Prithwis Chandra Ray | Writings on finance and taxation | Extended the critique to taxation and expenditure |
2.2 Channels of the drain
graph LR
A["India's export surplus"] --> B["Home Charges"]
B --> B1["Interest on India's public debt
held in Britain"]
B --> B2["Pensions, furlough pay of
British officials"]
B --> B3["India Office costs in London"]
B --> B4["Military charges and
stores bought in Britain"]
A --> C["Guaranteed interest
on railway capital"]
A --> D["Private remittances of
officials, merchants, planters"]
A --> E["Profits and dividends
on British investment"]2.3 The counter-argument and the debate
| Imperial view | Nationalist reply |
|---|---|
| Home Charges paid for services: administration, defence, peace, and capital for railways and irrigation (argued, for example, by Theodore Morison, The Economic Transition in India, 1911) | India paid for services she did not choose, at prices set in London, and for wars outside India |
| Interest on loans is a normal payment for borrowed capital | Much of the “debt” was created by Company wars and the cost of suppressing 1857, then charged to India |
| India gained from integration with the world economy | Gains went to foreign firms; India’s surplus financed Britain’s deficits |
3. World Wars and the Indian Economy
| Aspect | First World War (1914–18) | Second World War (1939–45) |
|---|---|---|
| Indian contribution | Large army sent overseas; India paid much of the cost; a “gift” to Britain’s war finance (commonly cited as £100 million, 1917) | India became the main supply base for the Allied war in Asia; troops in Africa, Europe and Asia |
| Prices and people | Sharp inflation, shortages, heavy taxation and forced recruitment; unrest that fed the post-war mass movements | Severe inflation financed by printing money; Bengal famine of 1943 |
| Industry | Imports cut off; Indian industry (textiles, steel, jute) expanded; Indian Industrial Commission (1916–18, chair Thomas Holland); Munitions Board | War demand expanded textiles, steel, engineering and chemicals, but without new capital goods |
| Policy outcome | Fiscal Autonomy Convention (1919), Fiscal Commission (1921–22), discriminating protection from 1923–24 | Sterling balances: Britain owed India large sums for war supplies, turning India into a creditor of Britain; the Bombay Plan (1944) of leading industrialists |
Between the wars, the Great Depression (from 1929) halved agricultural prices, pushed peasants into debt and led to large exports of “distress gold”, a theme in the peasant movements of the 1930s.
4. British Industrial Policy
4.1 Phases
| Phase | Policy |
|---|---|
| To c. 1914 | Laissez-faire and free trade: no protection; low tariffs on British goods; stores bought in Britain; railways’ freight rates favoured ports |
| 1894–96 cotton duties | When import duties were imposed for revenue, Lancashire pressure led to a countervailing excise on Indian mill cloth (from 1896, 3.5% on all mill cloth); a long-standing nationalist grievance, abolished in the mid-1920s |
| 1905 | Department of Commerce and Industry created (Curzon) |
| 1916–18 | Indian Industrial Commission recommends a state role in industry |
| 1919–21 | Fiscal Autonomy Convention: Government of India may set tariffs in agreement with the legislature |
| 1921–22 | Fiscal Commission (chair Ibrahim Rahimtoola) recommends discriminating protection |
| 1923–24 onward | Tariff Board; protection to steel (1924), then cotton textiles, paper, matches, sugar (1932) |
| 1932 | Ottawa Agreement: imperial preference |
4.2 Structure of colonial industry
- Managing agency system: a few British firms (for example Andrew Yule, Bird and Co., Jardine Skinner) controlled dozens of companies in jute, coal, tea and shipping through management contracts.
- European dominance in jute, tea, coal, banking and shipping; Indian enterprise strongest in cotton textiles (Bombay, Ahmedabad), and later in steel, sugar, cement and shipping.
- Indian business organised politically: the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI) was founded in 1927 (G.D. Birla, Purshottamdas Thakurdas).
5. Major Modern Industries
| Industry | First / key enterprise | Year | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cotton textiles | Bombay Spinning and Weaving Company, Cowasji Nanabhai Davar | 1854 | Indian-owned; Bombay and Ahmedabad (first mill by Ranchhodlal Chhotalal, 1861) became the centres |
| Jute | Mill at Rishra near Serampore, George Acland | 1855 | Hooghly belt; British (Scottish) capital |
| Coal | Raniganj field | 19th century | Expanded with railways; Jharia later |
| Tea | Assam Company | 1839 | Plantations on indentured, migrant labour |
| Iron and steel | Tata Iron and Steel Company (TISCO), Sakchi (Jamshedpur) | Founded 1907; steel from 1912 | Planned by Jamsetji Tata (d. 1904), built under Dorabji Tata; earlier Bengal Iron Works at Kulti (1870s); protection 1924 |
| Shipping | Swadeshi Steam Navigation Company (V.O. Chidambaram Pillai, Tuticorin); Scindia Steam Navigation (Walchand Hirachand) | 1906; 1919 | Indian challenge to British shipping lines |
| Chemicals | Bengal Chemical and Pharmaceutical Works, P.C. Ray | 1890s (company 1901) | Swadeshi science-based enterprise |
| Sugar, cement, paper | Various | Mostly 1920s–30s | Grew under protection |
6. Nature of Factory Legislation
6.1 The main Acts
| Act | Main provisions (summary) |
|---|---|
| Factory Act 1881 (Ripon) | First factory law; children (7 to 12) limited to 9 hours a day; minimum age 7; applied to power factories with 100+ workers; dangerous machinery to be fenced |
| Factory Act 1891 (Lansdowne) | Minimum age 9; children (9 to 14) 7 hours; women 11 hours with a rest interval; weekly holiday; applied to factories with 50+ workers |
| Factory Act 1911 | First limit on men’s hours: 12 hours in textile factories; children 6 hours |
| Factory Act 1922 | After India joined the ILO (1919): 60 hours a week, 11 a day; minimum age 12; applied to factories with 20+ workers |
| Factories Act 1934 | 54 hours a week in perennial factories, 10 a day; further limits for children |
| Royal Commission on Labour (1929–31, chair J.H. Whitley) | Reported on all aspects of labour; basis for 1930s laws |
6.2 Why the early Acts were passed
| Factor | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Lancashire pressure | British textile interests complained that long hours and child labour gave Bombay mills an “unfair” advantage. Early Acts were therefore partly protectionist for Britain |
| Humanitarian concern | Reports of child labour and long hours; reformers like Sorabji Shapoorji Bengalee and N.M. Lokhande campaigned |
| International standards | After 1919, ILO conventions drove the 1922 and 1934 Acts |
Other labour laws: Workmen’s Breach of Contract Act (1859) imposed penal contracts on plantation workers; the Workmen’s Compensation Act (1923); the Trade Unions Act (1926); the Trade Disputes Act (1929); the Payment of Wages Act (1936).
7. Labour and Trade Union Movements
7.1 Phases
| Phase | Events |
|---|---|
| Philanthropic beginnings (1870s–1890s) | Sasipada Banerji: Working Men’s Club (1870) and the journal Bharat Shramjeebi (1874), Bengal. N.M. Lokhande: Bombay Mill Hands’ Association (1890) and the paper Deenabandhu |
| Swadeshi period | Strikes in Bengal (printing presses, railways, jute) linked to swadeshi; Bombay workers’ political strike of 1908 against Tilak’s conviction |
| Post-war upsurge (1918–22) | Madras Labour Union (1918, B.P. Wadia), often called the first organised trade union; Ahmedabad mill strike (1918), Gandhi’s fast, settlement by arbitration; Textile Labour Association (Majoor Mahajan), Ahmedabad (1920, Anasuya Sarabhai, Gandhi) |
| AITUC | All India Trade Union Congress founded 31 October 1920, Bombay; first president Lala Lajpat Rai; N.M. Joshi a key founder |
| Left turn (late 1920s) | Communist-led Girni Kamgar Union, Bombay; great textile strike of 1928; Meerut Conspiracy Case (1929–33) against communist and trade union leaders |
| Splits | 1929 (Nagpur session): moderates under N.M. Joshi leave to form the Indian Trade Union Federation; 1931: communists form the Red Trade Union Congress; reunification in the later 1930s |
| After 1945 | Strike wave of 1946; INTUC founded 1947 (Congress), followed by HMS (1948) and UTUC (1949) |
7.2 Plantation and mine labour
- Assam tea gardens recruited labour from Chotanagpur, Bihar and the Central Provinces under penal contract laws; desertion was a criminal offence. The 1921 Chargola exodus of tea workers from the Surma valley was a notable revolt.
- Coal mines used family labour, including women underground, until restrictions in the 1920s and 1930s.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Morris D. Morris — revisionist, 1963 (IESHR debate 1968) | vs | Malcolm Darling — Punjab peasant debt, 1925 |
| Amiya Bagchi — Gangetic Bihar figures | vs | Marika Vicziany — critique of Buchanan’s data |
| Indian Industrial Commission (1916–18, Holland) | vs | Fiscal Commission (1921–22, Rahimtoola) |
| Madras Labour Union (1918, Wadia) | vs | Textile Labour Association (1920, Ahmedabad, Gandhi) |
| AITUC (1920, Lajpat Rai) | vs | INTUC (1947, Congress) |
| ITUF (1929, N.M. Joshi, moderates) | vs | Red TUC (1931, communists) |
| Swadeshi Steam Navigation (1906, V.O.C.) | vs | Scindia Steam Navigation (1919, Walchand) |
| Bombay Plan (1944, industrialists) | vs | Bombay Mill Hands’ Association (1890, Lokhande) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who wrote Poverty and Un-British Rule in India?
- Who was the first president of the All India Trade Union Congress?
- In which year did India’s first factory act come into force?
Answers
- Dadabhai Naoroji (1901).
- Lala Lajpat Rai (AITUC, 1920).
- 1881 (Lord Ripon).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Which of the following was not a component of the “drain” as described by the early nationalists?
- (a) Pensions of British officials paid in Britain
- (b) Interest on India’s public debt held in Britain
- (c) Guaranteed interest on railway capital
- (d) Land revenue spent on canal construction within India
Answer and explanation
(d). Revenue spent inside India is not a transfer abroad. (a), (b) and (c) were all remittances to Britain.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Morris D. Morris questioned the nationalist thesis of deindustrialisation.
- Amiya Kumar Bagchi used Francis Buchanan-Hamilton’s survey data for Gangetic Bihar.
- Marika Vicziany supported Bagchi’s use of Buchanan’s data without reservation.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 2 only. Vicziany criticised Bagchi’s use of Buchanan’s data.
Q3. (Practice) In a district, the share of the population dependent on industry falls from 20% to 12%. By what percentage has the share fallen relative to its original level?
- (a) 8%
- (b) 40%
- (c) 60%
- (d) 66.7%
Answer and explanation
(b) 40%. The fall is 8 percentage points; relative to the original 20%, \( \tfrac{8}{20} \times 100 = 40\% \). Option (a) confuses points with per cent; (c) is the new share as a proportion of the old.
Q4. (Practice) The Fiscal Commission of 1921–22, which recommended discriminating protection, was chaired by:
- (a) Thomas Holland
- (b) Ibrahim Rahimtoola
- (c) J.H. Whitley
- (d) Colin Scott-Moncrieff
Answer and explanation
(b) Ibrahim Rahimtoola. Holland chaired the Industrial Commission (1916–18), Whitley the Royal Commission on Labour (1929–31), Scott-Moncrieff the Irrigation Commission (1901–03).
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Many Indian mill-owners and early nationalists opposed the Factory Acts of 1881 and 1891. Reason (R): They saw the Acts as a device of Lancashire interests to raise the costs of Indian mills.
Answer and explanation
(a). Opposition came from the perception (largely accurate) that British textile interests were behind the Acts.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): India ran an export surplus for most of the late 19th century. Reason (R): British policy gave Indian manufactures strong tariff protection in that period.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true (the surplus paid the Home Charges). R is false: there was no protection before the 1920s; India followed one-way free trade.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (enterprise) with List II (founder).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Bombay Spinning and Weaving Company | I. V.O. Chidambaram Pillai |
| B. Swadeshi Steam Navigation Company | II. Cowasji Nanabhai Davar |
| C. Bengal Chemical and Pharmaceutical Works | III. Walchand Hirachand |
| D. Scindia Steam Navigation Company | IV. P.C. Ray |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I
- (3) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
- (4) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Match List I (author) with List II (work).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. R.C. Dutt | I. Essays on Indian Economics |
| B. M.G. Ranade | II. “Prosperous” British India |
| C. William Digby | III. The Economic History of India |
| D. Bipan Chandra | IV. The Rise and Growth of Economic Nationalism in India |
- (1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
- (2) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
- (3) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
- (4) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
Answer and explanation
(1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange in chronological order: (1) Madras Labour Union, (2) Bombay Mill Hands’ Association, (3) AITUC, (4) Trade Unions Act, (5) Working Men’s Club of Sasipada Banerji.
- (a) 5, 2, 1, 3, 4
- (b) 2, 5, 1, 3, 4
- (c) 5, 2, 3, 1, 4
- (d) 5, 1, 2, 3, 4
Answer and explanation
(a). 1870 → 1890 → 1918 → 1920 → 1926.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Causes of craft decline | Loss of courts, Company coercion, machine imports, one-way free trade, railways |
| Debate | Nationalists (Naoroji, Dutt) vs Morris (1963; IESHR debate 1968); Bagchi 18.6% → 8.5% (Bihar); Vicziany; Tirthankar Roy |
| De-urbanisation | Dacca, Murshidabad, Surat decline; Presidency ports rise |
| Drain | Naoroji (Poverty and Un-British Rule, 1901; Rs 20 per head, 1867–68); Dutt (1902, 1904); Digby (1901); Ranade (1898) |
| Channels | Home Charges, railway guarantees, remittances, profits |
| Wars | WWI: inflation, Industrial Commission (Holland); WWII: inflation, sterling balances, Bengal famine, Bombay Plan 1944 |
| Policy | Laissez-faire; cotton excise 1894–96; Dept of Commerce and Industry 1905; Fiscal Commission 1921–22; protection from 1923–24; Ottawa 1932 |
| Industries | Cotton 1854 (Davar), jute 1855 (Rishra), Ahmedabad 1861, TISCO 1907, FICCI 1927 |
| Factory Acts | 1881, 1891, 1911, 1922, 1934; Whitley Commission 1929–31 |
| Unions | Sasipada 1870; Lokhande 1890; 1908 strike; Wadia 1918; TLA 1920; AITUC 1920; split 1929; Red TUC 1931; INTUC 1947 |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
The money, banks, railways and post that tied the colonial economy together come next: Money, Banking, Transport, Towns and Famines. For the political economy of independent India that inherited these structures, see State, Economy, Development and Globalisation.