The Research Process and the Literary Thesis
UGC NET English: kinds of literary research, research problem, question, hypothesis and thesis statement, review of literature, synopsis and thesis structure.
- 19 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: From a Topic to a Question
- 1. What Counts as Research in English Studies
- 2. The Research Process
- 3. The Review of Literature
- 4. The Synopsis (Research Proposal)
- 5. Structure of the Thesis
- 6. Sources: Primary, Secondary, Tertiary
- 7. Using Sources Honestly
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Research Methods and Materials in English: chapter overview — what this unit covers and how it differs from Paper 1
- Research: Meaning, Types and Approaches (Paper 1) — the general vocabulary of research (fundamental and applied, qualitative and quantitative) that this page applies to literature
- Methods and Steps of Research (Paper 1) — the standard research cycle; here we follow it through a literary thesis
The Hook: From a Topic to a Question
1. What Counts as Research in English Studies
Research in English is systematic, documented inquiry that adds something new to what is known about texts in English, their authors, their language, their contexts or their reception. “New” can mean a new fact (a manuscript found in an archive), a new text (a better edition), a new reading (an interpretation that changes how a work is understood) or a new connection (two literatures compared).
Kinds of literary research
| Kind | What it does | Typical question | Typical materials |
|---|---|---|---|
| Historical | Places a text in the history of its time | How did the 1857 rebellion shape Victorian fiction about India? | Newspapers, periodicals, letters, official records |
| Biographical | Uses the facts of a writer’s life | What do the letters show about the composition of a novel? | Letters, diaries, memoirs, biographies |
| Textual and bibliographical | Establishes what the author actually wrote and how it was printed | Which version of a poem should an editor print? | Manuscripts, early editions, proof sheets |
| Critical or theoretical | Interprets texts, often through a framework (feminist, postcolonial, ecocritical and so on) | How does a novel represent the subaltern? | Primary texts, theory, criticism |
| Comparative | Studies texts across languages, nations or media | How do two novels of Partition, one in English and one in translation, remember the event? | Texts in two or more traditions, translations |
| Archival | Recovers and interprets unpublished or neglected material | What did a forgotten periodical publish by women writers? | Library special collections, record offices, private papers |
| Source and influence study | Traces where a writer’s material came from | Which chronicle did a dramatist use for a history play? | Earlier texts, the writer’s library |
| Reception study | Studies how readers, reviewers and later writers responded | How was a novel reviewed on publication? | Reviews, sales records, adaptations |
| Empirical (linguistics and ELT) | Collects data from language users or learners | Does a task-based method improve learners’ writing? | Questionnaires, tests, recordings, classroom observation |
| Digital (digital humanities) | Uses computers to study large numbers of texts or to build digital editions | How does vocabulary change across 3,000 novels? | Text corpora, encoded editions, databases |
Intrinsic and extrinsic approaches
The distinction made by René Wellek and Austin Warren in Theory of Literature (1949) is still a useful way to sort research: extrinsic approaches study literature through biography, psychology, society, ideas and the other arts; the intrinsic study of literature attends to the work itself (its sound, style, imagery, narrative, genre). Most theses combine the two. The New Critical background to this distinction is in The New Criticism.
The classic handbooks of literary research
| Work | Author or editor | Year | Remember it for |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Scholar Adventurers | Richard D. Altick | 1950 | Stories of literary detection: forgeries exposed, lost papers found |
| The Art of Literary Research | Richard D. Altick | 1963 | The standard guide to the habits and tools of literary scholarship (later editions revised with John J. Fenstermaker) |
| The Craft of Research | Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams | 1995 | Topic → question → problem; claims, reasons and evidence; writing for readers (University of Chicago Press) |
| Research Methods for English Studies | Gabriele Griffin (ed.) | 2005 | Methods beyond close reading: archival work, oral history, interviews, discourse analysis, visual methods, numbers, creative writing as research (Edinburgh University Press) |
| MLA Handbook | Modern Language Association | First edition 1977; 9th edition 2021 | The documentation style of literary studies (see MLA Documentation Style) |
2. The Research Process
graph TD
A["Area or topic
(Partition fiction)"] --> B["Preliminary reading
primary texts, surveys, bibliographies"]
B --> C["Research problem
a gap, a puzzle, a disagreement"]
C --> D["Research questions and
working hypothesis"]
D --> E["Review of literature
what is known, where the gap is"]
E --> F["Method and framework
which texts, which approach, which theory"]
F --> G["Gathering evidence
close reading, archives, interviews, data"]
G --> H["Argument and drafting
chapters built on a thesis statement"]
H --> I["Documentation and revision
MLA citation, similarity check"]
I --> J["Submission and defence
viva voce"]
E -.-> D
G -.-> DThe dotted arrows matter: research is recursive. Reading the criticism often narrows or changes the question; the evidence often modifies the hypothesis.
The key terms, in order
| Term | Definition | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Area / field | The broad territory | Indian English fiction |
| Topic | A narrower subject within the area, not yet a problem | Partition in Indian English fiction |
| Research problem | A gap, contradiction or unexplained feature that needs investigation | Critics read Partition novels as trauma narratives but have not explained why so many end in a return home |
| Research question | The specific question the study will answer | How does the motif of return shape the endings of three Partition novels? |
| Hypothesis | A tentative, testable answer, stated before the evidence is fully examined | The return home works as a refusal of the new national border |
| Thesis statement | The central, arguable claim the finished work defends | The essay or thesis’s one-sentence answer, revised in the light of the evidence |
| Objectives | What the study will do, stated as actions | To examine, to compare, to trace, to evaluate |
| Scope and limitations | What is included and deliberately left out | Novels in English only, published after 1947 |
| Methodology | How the question will be answered: approach, framework, materials, procedures | Close reading with a postcolonial and memory-studies framework |
Qualities of a good research problem
- Researchable: answerable with available texts, archives or data within the time allowed
- Significant: its answer matters to the field (it changes a reading, fills a gap, corrects an error)
- Original: not already answered (the review of literature proves this)
- Specific: narrow enough for one thesis
- Feasible: the researcher has the languages, access and skills needed
- Ethical: it can be pursued without harming anyone or misusing anyone’s work
3. The Review of Literature
The review of literature (literature review) is a critical survey of the scholarship already published on the problem. It is not a list of summaries.
| Purpose | What it shows |
|---|---|
| Locates the gap | What has been said, by whom, and what has not been said |
| Prevents duplication | That the problem has not already been answered |
| Frames the study | Which debates the thesis joins and which concepts it borrows |
| Justifies the method | Why this approach suits this problem |
| Builds credibility | That the researcher knows the field |
How to organise it: thematically (by issue or debate) is usually better than chronologically, and both are better than author-by-author summary. Each entry should evaluate: what the study contributes and what it leaves out.
Related writing tasks
| Task | What it is |
|---|---|
| Annotated bibliography | A list of sources, each followed by a short annotation that summarises and evaluates it. In MLA style the entries follow the works-cited format, with the annotation after each entry. |
| Abstract | A short, self-contained summary of a paper or thesis placed at the front: the problem, method, main argument and conclusion. A descriptive abstract says what the work covers; an informative abstract also gives its findings. |
| Keywords | A handful of terms placed after the abstract so that databases and readers can find the work |
| Synopsis / research proposal | The plan of a thesis submitted for approval before the research is done (see below) |
| Précis | A condensed restatement of a text in the original’s order and emphasis, without comment |
4. The Synopsis (Research Proposal)
In Indian universities a PhD scholar submits a synopsis (research proposal) after coursework, usually before a research advisory committee. A typical synopsis contains:
- Title (precise; often with a subtitle naming the texts or framework)
- Introduction and background to the area and the texts
- Review of literature and the research gap
- Research problem and research questions (or hypothesis)
- Objectives
- Scope and limitations
- Methodology and theoretical framework
- Tentative chapterisation (a chapter-by-chapter plan)
- Significance or expected contribution
- Tentative bibliography (works cited so far, in MLA style)
Synopses of Indian theses are collected on INFLIBNET’s Shodhgangotri; completed theses go to Shodhganga (see Reference Works, Archives and Digital Resources).
5. Structure of the Thesis
A literary thesis has three blocks: preliminary pages, the body and the end matter.
| Block | Part | What it contains |
|---|---|---|
| Preliminaries (usually numbered in lower-case Roman numerals) | Title page | Title, candidate, degree, supervisor, department, university, year |
| Declaration | The candidate’s statement that the work is original and has not been submitted for another degree | |
| Certificate | The supervisor’s certificate that the work was done under supervision | |
| Acknowledgements | Thanks to supervisor, institutions, libraries, family | |
| Abstract | Summary of the problem, method, argument and conclusions | |
| Table of contents | Chapters and sections with page numbers | |
| List of abbreviations | Short forms of titles used in citations (common in literary theses) | |
| Body (Arabic page numbers from here) | Introduction | Background, problem, review of literature, research questions, method, chapter plan |
| Core chapters | Usually three to five, each developing one part of the argument | |
| Conclusion | Findings, answer to the research questions, limitations, scope for further research | |
| End matter | Works Cited / Bibliography | Every source in MLA format (Works Cited = sources cited; Bibliography = also those consulted) |
| Appendices | Interviews, transcripts, questionnaires, documents, tables too long for the body | |
| Index | Rare in theses; usual in published books |
Introduction vs conclusion
| Introduction | Conclusion |
|---|---|
| States the problem and why it matters | States what has been found |
| Reviews the literature and identifies the gap | Shows how the gap has been filled |
| Announces the method and the chapter plan | Admits limitations |
| Ends with what the thesis will argue | Ends with scope for further research |
6. Sources: Primary, Secondary, Tertiary
| Kind | In English studies | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Primary | The texts studied, and original documents from the period | The novels or poems under study; manuscripts, letters, diaries, first editions, contemporary reviews, interviews conducted by the researcher |
| Secondary | Works about the primary texts | Critical books and articles, biographies, literary histories |
| Tertiary | Works that compile or index primary and secondary sources | Encyclopedias, companions, bibliographies, dictionaries of literary terms, databases |
Evaluating a source
Ask of every secondary source: who wrote it (expertise), where it appeared (peer-reviewed journal, university press, popular website), when (is it superseded?), on what evidence (are its quotations and facts checkable?) and for whom (scholarly or general audience). Peer-reviewed journals and scholarly editions outrank anonymous web pages.
7. Using Sources Honestly
Quotation, paraphrase, summary
| Technique | What it does | Documentation needed? |
|---|---|---|
| Quotation | Reproduces the exact words, in quotation marks or as a block quotation | Yes, with page or line |
| Paraphrase | Restates a specific passage in the researcher’s own words and structure, about the same length | Yes, with page |
| Summary | Condenses the main idea of a longer passage or a whole work | Yes |
| Common knowledge | Facts widely known and found in many general sources (for example, that Hamlet is a play by Shakespeare) | No |
Forms of plagiarism
| Form | What it is |
|---|---|
| Verbatim (direct) plagiarism | Copying words without quotation marks and citation |
| Mosaic plagiarism / patchwriting | Stitching phrases from a source into one’s own sentences, or changing a few words while keeping the source’s structure |
| Paraphrase without citation | Restating another’s idea in one’s own words but not crediting it |
| Idea plagiarism | Presenting another’s argument, interpretation or discovery as one’s own |
| Self-plagiarism | Re-using one’s own published work without acknowledgement |
| Citing sources not consulted | Copying a reference from another work’s bibliography as if one had read the original (MLA’s honest form is “qtd. in”) |
India’s binding rules are the UGC (Promotion of Academic Integrity and Prevention of Plagiarism in Higher Educational Institutions) Regulations, 2018. Their similarity levels are: Level 0 up to 10% (no penalty), Level 1 above 10% to 40%, Level 2 above 40% to 60%, Level 3 above 60%. The penalties for students and faculty are tabled in Research Ethics and Plagiarism.
Ethics specific to literary research
- Interviews with authors, translators or readers need informed consent and accurate transcription; the transcript goes in an appendix.
- Unpublished papers in archives are often subject to the owner’s or the estate’s permission and to copyright; the researcher records the archive, the collection and the box or folder.
- Quotation for research and criticism is permitted as fair dealing under Section 52 of the Indian Copyright Act, 1957, but quotations should be no longer than the argument needs and always acknowledged.
- Data from learners (in ELT research) must be anonymised.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Topic (an area of interest) | vs | Research problem (a gap or puzzle needing investigation) |
| Hypothesis (tentative, tested) | vs | Thesis statement (the final claim defended) |
| Review of literature (critical survey of scholarship) | vs | Annotated bibliography (a list with a note on each item) |
| Synopsis (plan submitted before research) | vs | Abstract (summary of finished work) |
| Descriptive abstract (what the work covers) | vs | Informative abstract (also gives findings) |
| Paraphrase (one passage, same length, own words) | vs | Summary (main idea, much shorter) |
| Works Cited (sources cited) | vs | Bibliography (sources cited and consulted) |
| Declaration (by the candidate) | vs | Certificate (by the supervisor) |
| Shodhganga (completed theses) | vs | Shodhgangotri (synopses) |
| The Art of Literary Research (Altick, 1963) | vs | The Craft of Research (Booth, Colomb, Williams, 1995) |
| Intrinsic study (the work itself) | vs | Extrinsic study (biography, society, ideas) — Wellek and Warren, 1949 |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the difference between a hypothesis and a thesis statement?
- Who edited Research Methods for English Studies (2005)?
- On which INFLIBNET platform are synopses of Indian PhD theses collected?
Answers
- A hypothesis is a tentative answer tested against evidence; a thesis statement is the final, arguable claim the work defends.
- Gabriele Griffin.
- Shodhgangotri (completed theses are on Shodhganga).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) In a thesis on the reception of a Victorian novel, which of the following is a primary source?
- (a) A 1990s monograph on the novelist
- (b) A review of the novel published in a periodical in the year of its publication
- (c) An encyclopedia entry on Victorian fiction
- (d) A recent bibliography of criticism on the novelist
Answer and explanation
(b). For a reception study, contemporary reviews are primary evidence of how the novel was received. (a) is secondary; (c) and (d) are tertiary.
Q2. (Practice) A thesis similarity report shows 38% similarity after exclusions. Under the UGC 2018 regulations this falls in:
- (a) Level 0
- (b) Level 1
- (c) Level 2
- (d) Level 3
Answer and explanation
(b) Level 1, which covers similarity above 10% up to 40%. Level 2 begins only above 40%.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about the review of literature:
- It identifies the gap the research will address.
- It should be organised as a separate summary of each source in the order the researcher read them.
- It helps justify the choice of method and framework.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. A review synthesises and evaluates, usually thematically; reading-order summaries are what it should avoid.
Q4. (Practice) Restating a specific passage from a critic in one’s own words, at roughly the original length, and citing it, is called:
- (a) Summary
- (b) Précis
- (c) Paraphrase
- (d) Patchwriting
Answer and explanation
(c) Paraphrase. A summary condenses; a précis condenses in the original order without comment; patchwriting keeps the source’s structure with a few words changed and is a form of plagiarism.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): A paraphrased idea from a critic must be cited even though none of the critic’s words are used. Reason (R): Plagiarism consists in presenting another’s ideas, and not only another’s words, as one’s own.
Answer and explanation
(a). Both are true, and R explains A: since idea plagiarism is plagiarism, a paraphrase needs a citation.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): A critical essay by T.S. Eliot is always a secondary source. Reason (R): Whether a source is primary or secondary depends on the research question.
Answer and explanation
(d). A is false: in a thesis on Eliot’s criticism, his essays are primary. R is true and is exactly why A fails.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (work) with List II (author or editor).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. The Art of Literary Research | I. Gabriele Griffin (ed.) |
| B. The Craft of Research | II. René Wellek and Austin Warren |
| C. Research Methods for English Studies | III. Richard D. Altick |
| D. Theory of Literature | IV. Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb and Joseph M. Williams |
- (1) A-III, B-IV, C-I, D-II
- (2) A-IV, B-III, C-I, D-II
- (3) A-III, B-IV, C-II, D-I
- (4) A-I, B-IV, C-III, D-II
Answer and explanation
(1) A-III, B-IV, C-I, D-II.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following preliminary pages of a thesis in their usual order:
A. Abstract
B. Declaration
C. Title page
D. Table of contents
E. Acknowledgements
(1) C, B, E, A, D
(2) C, E, B, A, D
(3) C, B, A, E, D
(4) B, C, E, D, A
Answer and explanation
(1) C, B, E, A, D. Title page, declaration (with the supervisor’s certificate), acknowledgements, abstract, contents. Institutions vary slightly, but the title page always comes first and the contents list closes the preliminaries.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange these handbooks in chronological order of first publication:
A. The Craft of Research
B. The Scholar Adventurers
C. Research Methods for English Studies
D. The Art of Literary Research
(1) B, D, A, C
(2) D, B, A, C
(3) B, D, C, A
(4) B, A, D, C
Answer and explanation
(1) B, D, A, C. 1950 → 1963 → 1995 → 2005.
Quick Revision Table
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Research in English | Systematic, documented inquiry adding a new fact, text, reading or connection |
| Kinds | Historical, biographical, textual-bibliographical, critical-theoretical, comparative, archival, source study, reception study, empirical, digital |
| Intrinsic vs extrinsic | Wellek and Warren, Theory of Literature (1949) |
| Sequence | Area → topic → problem → question → hypothesis → thesis statement |
| Review of literature | Critical survey; locates the gap; organise thematically |
| Synopsis | Title, background, review, problem, questions, objectives, scope, method, chapterisation, bibliography |
| Thesis preliminaries | Title page, declaration, certificate, acknowledgements, abstract, contents, abbreviations |
| Body and end | Introduction, chapters, conclusion; Works Cited, appendices |
| Sources | Primary (texts, documents), secondary (criticism), tertiary (compilations); relative to the question |
| Handbooks | Altick 1950, 1963; Booth, Colomb, Williams 1995; Griffin 2005; MLA Handbook 1977 / 9th ed. 2021 |
| Plagiarism (UGC 2018) | L0 ≤10%, L1 >10–40%, L2 >40–60%, L3 >60% |
| Fair dealing | Section 52, Indian Copyright Act 1957 |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- MLA Documentation Style — how every source in the thesis is cited
- Bibliography and Textual Criticism — the oldest form of literary research: establishing the text
- Thesis Writing, Referencing and ICT (Paper 1) — the Paper 1 view of the same material, with APA and Chicago