Psychoanalytic and Reader-Response Criticism
UGC NET English Unit 9: Lacan's mirror stage and three orders, Kristeva's semiotic, Iser, Jauss, Fish, Holland, Rosenblatt, Eco and reception theory.
- 15 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Two Readers, One Poem
- Part A: Psychoanalytic Criticism
- 1. The Freudian Background
- 2. Jacques Lacan: The Return to Freud
- 3. Julia Kristeva and After
- Part B: Reader-Response and Reception Theory
- 4. Why the Reader?
- 5. The Konstanz School: Reception Theory
- 6. American Reader-Response Criticism
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Russian Formalism, Structuralism, Narratology, Frye and Bakhtin — Lacan reads Freud through Saussure and Jakobson’s metaphor/metonymy
- The New Criticism — the affective fallacy (1949) is the position reader-response critics set out to overturn
- Poststructuralism, Deconstruction and Postmodernism — Barthes’s “birth of the reader”
The Hook: Two Readers, One Poem
Part A: Psychoanalytic Criticism
1. The Freudian Background
Psychoanalytic criticism began with Sigmund Freud himself, before the war. The concepts the later theorists rework:
| Freudian concept | Literary use |
|---|---|
| The unconscious and repression | A text, like a dream, has a manifest and a latent content |
| Dream-work: condensation and displacement | Several ideas fused into one image; feeling shifted from its real object to a substitute |
| The Oedipus complex | Freud’s own reading of Oedipus Rex and Hamlet in The Interpretation of Dreams (1900) |
| “The Uncanny” (Das Unheimliche, 1919) | The frightening return of the familiar but repressed; read through Hoffmann’s “The Sandman” |
| “Creative Writers and Day-Dreaming” (1908) | The writer’s work as a socially acceptable fantasy |
The classic post-war application is Ernest Jones, Hamlet and Oedipus (1949), which explains Hamlet’s delay by his repressed Oedipal wishes: Claudius has done what Hamlet unconsciously desired.
Old-style psychoanalytic criticism looked for the author’s neuroses or the characters’ complexes. Post-war theory moved the focus to the text and to language.
2. Jacques Lacan: The Return to Freud
Jacques Lacan (1901–1981) called for a “return to Freud”, read through structural linguistics. His collected papers, Écrits, appeared in 1966. His teaching was mainly delivered in an annual Seminar.
The central claim
“The unconscious is structured like a language.” It works by the two operations Jakobson had found in language:
| Freud (dream-work) | Jakobson (language) | Lacan |
|---|---|---|
| Condensation | Metaphor (selection, similarity) | Symptom |
| Displacement | Metonymy (combination, contiguity) | Desire |
Lacan also inverts Saussure’s sign. Saussure placed the signified over the signifier; Lacan writes the signifier over the signified (S/s), with a bar that resists meaning. The signified constantly slides under the signifier, pinned only at certain quilting points (points de capiton).
The mirror stage
First presented in 1936 and published in its best-known form in 1949 (“The Mirror Stage as Formative of the Function of the I”). Between about six and eighteen months, an infant who cannot yet control its body sees its image in a mirror and identifies with it jubilantly. The image gives an illusion of wholeness and mastery. The ego is thus founded on a misrecognition (méconnaissance): it is an image of the self that comes from outside.
The three orders
| Order | What it is | Associated with |
|---|---|---|
| The Imaginary | The realm of images, identification and the dyad of mother and child; rivalry and fusion with the mirror image | The mirror stage; the ego |
| The Symbolic | The realm of language, law and social structure, into which the child enters by accepting the Name-of-the-Father (Nom-du-Père, a pun on non, the father’s “No”); the big Other | Language, the unconscious, desire |
| The Real | What resists symbolisation absolutely; not “reality”, but what language cannot capture | Trauma, the impossible |
Other terms: desire (always the desire of the Other, never satisfied because it arises from lack); objet petit a (the object-cause of desire); the phallus as signifier (not the organ).
“Seminar on ‘The Purloined Letter’”
Lacan’s reading of Poe’s story (seminar 1955, published 1957, placed at the opening of Écrits) shows how the letter (a signifier whose contents we never learn) determines the positions of the characters who possess it. He ends by declaring that a letter always arrives at its destination. Derrida challenged this in “Le facteur de la vérité” (1975), and Barbara Johnson commented on both in “The Frame of Reference” (1977). This exchange is a classic of post-war theory.
3. Julia Kristeva and After
| Concept | Work | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| The semiotic vs the symbolic | Revolution in Poetic Language (1974) | The semiotic is the pre-linguistic flow of drives, rhythms and sounds linked to the maternal body; the symbolic is the order of grammar, logic and law. Poetic language (Lautréamont, Mallarmé) lets the semiotic disrupt the symbolic |
| The chora | Same | A rhythmic, pre-verbal space (term taken from Plato’s Timaeus) |
| Abjection | Powers of Horror (1980) | The horror at what must be expelled to form the self: bodily waste, the corpse, the boundary between self and other |
| Intertextuality | Essays on Bakhtin (1966–67) | See the poststructuralism page |
Other psychoanalytic names in options:
| Critic | Work | Year | Contribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peter Brooks | Reading for the Plot | 1984 | Plot as desire; reading driven towards an end, as Freud’s death drive |
| Slavoj Žižek | The Sublime Object of Ideology | 1989 | Lacan used to read ideology and popular culture |
| Laura Mulvey | “Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema” | 1975 | Lacan and Freud used for a feminist theory of the male gaze (see Feminist, Gender and Queer Theory) |
| Harold Bloom | The Anxiety of Influence | 1973 | A Freudian model of poetic history (on the poststructuralism page) |
Part B: Reader-Response and Reception Theory
4. Why the Reader?
The New Critics Wimsatt and Beardsley had called the confusion between the poem and its results in the reader the affective fallacy (1949). From the late 1960s, a varied group of critics argued that meaning cannot be separated from the experience of reading. They differ sharply on how much power the reader has:
graph LR
A["Text-centred
(New Criticism)"] --> B["Text guides reader
Iser, Jauss, Eco"]
B --> C["Reader and text transact
Rosenblatt"]
C --> D["Reader's community decides
Fish"]
D --> E["Reader's psyche decides
Holland, Bleich"]Precursors
| Name | Work | Year | Idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| I.A. Richards | Practical Criticism | 1929 | Studied actual readers’ responses (“protocols”) |
| Roman Ingarden | The Literary Work of Art | 1931 | The work has places of indeterminacy that the reader concretises |
| Louise Rosenblatt | Literature as Exploration | 1938 | The first full statement of the reader’s role; later, the transactional theory |
| Hans-Georg Gadamer | Truth and Method | 1960 | Understanding is a fusion of horizons between the interpreter’s present and the text’s past; “prejudice” (pre-judgement) is a condition of understanding |
5. The Konstanz School: Reception Theory
At the University of Konstanz in West Germany, two critics founded reception aesthetics (Rezeptionsästhetik).
Hans Robert Jauss
- Inaugural lecture “Literary History as a Challenge to Literary Theory” (1967).
- Literary history should be a history of reception, not of authors and works.
- Horizon of expectations (Erwartungshorizont): the set of cultural, generic and literary assumptions with which readers of a given period meet a work.
- Aesthetic distance: the gap between a new work and the existing horizon. A work that merely satisfies the horizon is “culinary” entertainment; a great work changes the horizon.
- English collection: Toward an Aesthetic of Reception (1982).
Wolfgang Iser
| Work | Year | Key ideas |
|---|---|---|
| “The Reading Process: A Phenomenological Approach” | 1972 | Reading as a dynamic activity of anticipation and retrospection |
| The Implied Reader | 1972 (English 1974) | Studies of English novels from Bunyan to Beckett |
| The Act of Reading | 1976 (English 1978) | The full theory: repertoire, strategies, gaps, wandering viewpoint |
| Iser’s term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Implied reader | A role built into the text: the network of response-inviting structures that prestructure the reader’s part. Not any real reader |
| Gaps / blanks (Leerstellen) | What the text leaves unsaid, which the reader must fill; indeterminacy stimulates participation |
| Wandering viewpoint | The reader’s moving position within the text, never able to see it whole at once |
| Repertoire | The familiar territory (social norms, earlier literature) that the text draws on |
6. American Reader-Response Criticism
Stanley Fish
| Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Surprised by Sin: The Reader in Paradise Lost | 1967 | Milton’s poem traps the reader into error and makes the reader experience the Fall |
| “Literature in the Reader: Affective Stylistics” | 1970 | Ask not what a sentence means but what it does as it unfolds in time; the informed reader |
| Self-Consuming Artifacts | 1972 | Seventeenth-century texts that undo their own claims |
| Is There a Text in This Class? The Authority of Interpretive Communities | 1980 | Meaning is produced by interpretive communities: readers who share strategies of interpretation. Texts do not constrain readings; communities do |
Psychological reader-response
| Critic | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Norman N. Holland | The Dynamics of Literary Response (1968); 5 Readers Reading (1975) | — | Each reader responds through an identity theme; reading is a recreation of identity |
| David Bleich | Subjective Criticism | 1978 | Interpretation begins in the reader’s subjective response, negotiated in a community (the classroom) |
Louise Rosenblatt’s transactional theory
The Reader, the Text, the Poem (1978): the “poem” is an event in time, a transaction between reader and text. A reader takes one of two stances:
| Stance | Attention to | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Efferent (Latin efferre, to carry away) | What is to be carried away after reading: information, instructions | Reading a train timetable or a textbook |
| Aesthetic | What is lived through during reading: images, feelings, sounds | Reading a poem |
Other readers in the theory
| Theorist | Term | Work and year |
|---|---|---|
| Umberto Eco | Open work (opera aperta) | The Open Work (1962) |
| Umberto Eco | Model reader; open vs closed texts | The Role of the Reader (1979) |
| Michael Riffaterre | Superreader (archilecteur) | “Describing Poetic Structures” (1966), a reply to Jakobson and Lévi-Strauss on Baudelaire’s “Les Chats”; Semiotics of Poetry (1978) |
| Jonathan Culler | Literary competence | Structuralist Poetics (1975) |
| Gerald Prince | Narratee | 1970s |
| Walker Gibson | Mock reader | Essay, 1950 |
| Judith Fetterley | Resisting reader | The Resisting Reader (1978) (on the feminist page) |
| Georges Poulet | Reading as merging with another consciousness (Geneva School phenomenology) | “Phenomenology of Reading” (1969) |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Implied author (Booth, 1961) | vs | Implied reader (Iser, 1972) |
| Horizon of expectations (Jauss) | vs | Fusion of horizons (Gadamer) |
| Interpretive communities (Fish) | vs | Identity theme (Holland) |
| Efferent reading: information carried away | vs | Aesthetic reading: experience lived through |
| Meaning (fixed, authorial) | vs | Significance (changing) — Hirsch, 1967 |
| Imaginary (images, ego, mirror) | vs | Symbolic (language, law, the Other) |
| Semiotic (Kristeva: drives, rhythm) | vs | Semiotics (the general science of signs) |
| Condensation → metaphor | vs | Displacement → metonymy |
| Affective fallacy (Wimsatt and Beardsley, 1949): New Critical warning | vs | Affective stylistics (Fish, 1970): reader-response programme |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which theorist argued that “the unconscious is structured like a language”?
- Which critic coined the phrase “interpretive communities”?
- Name Rosenblatt’s two reading stances.
Answers
- Jacques Lacan.
- Stanley Fish (Is There a Text in This Class?, 1980).
- Efferent and aesthetic.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) The concept of “gaps” or “blanks” that the reader must fill is central to the theory of:
- (a) Hans Robert Jauss
- (b) Wolfgang Iser
- (c) Norman Holland
- (d) E.D. Hirsch
Answer and explanation
(b) Iser (The Act of Reading, 1976). Jauss’s key term is the horizon of expectations.
Q2. (Practice) In Lacan’s theory, the child’s entry into language and law is associated with:
- (a) The mirror stage
- (b) The Imaginary
- (c) The Name-of-the-Father and the Symbolic
- (d) The Real
Answer and explanation
(c). The Symbolic order is the order of language and law, entered through the Name-of-the-Father. The mirror stage belongs to the Imaginary.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Julia Kristeva:
- She distinguishes the semiotic from the symbolic in Revolution in Poetic Language.
- Her Powers of Horror develops the concept of abjection.
- She borrowed the term “chora” from Plato’s Timaeus.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(d) 1, 2 and 3.
Q4. (Practice) Which critic distinguished a text’s fixed meaning from its changing significance, in defence of authorial intention?
- (a) Stanley Fish
- (b) E.D. Hirsch Jr.
- (c) David Bleich
- (d) Umberto Eco
Answer and explanation
(b) Hirsch, Validity in Interpretation (1967).
Q5. (Practice) Ernest Jones’s Hamlet and Oedipus (1949) explains Hamlet’s delay chiefly through:
- (a) Hamlet’s melancholy humour
- (b) The absence of an objective correlative
- (c) Hamlet’s repressed Oedipal wishes
- (d) The demands of revenge-tragedy convention
Answer and explanation
(c). Claudius has fulfilled Hamlet’s own repressed desires, so Hamlet cannot punish him. (b) is Eliot’s argument in “Hamlet and His Problems” (1919).
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): For Lacan, the ego formed in the mirror stage rests on a misrecognition. Reason (R): The infant identifies with an external image of bodily unity that it does not yet possess.
Answer and explanation
(a). The wholeness the infant sees in the mirror is not its lived experience of an uncoordinated body; identification with that image is méconnaissance. R explains A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Stanley Fish holds that the text itself constrains which interpretations are valid. Reason (R): For Fish, readers’ interpretive strategies are shared within interpretive communities.
Answer and explanation
(d). A is false: for Fish it is the community’s strategies, not the text, that constrain interpretation. R is true.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Theorist) with List II (Concept).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Hans Robert Jauss | I. Identity theme |
| B. Norman Holland | II. Model reader |
| C. Umberto Eco | III. Horizon of expectations |
| D. Louise Rosenblatt | IV. Efferent reading |
- (1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
- (2) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
- (3) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
- (4) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
Answer and explanation
(1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order of original publication:
A. Fish, Is There a Text in This Class?
B. Gadamer, Truth and Method
C. Iser, The Implied Reader (German original)
D. Rosenblatt, Literature as Exploration
(1) D, B, C, A
(2) B, D, C, A
(3) D, C, B, A
(4) D, B, A, C
Answer and explanation
(1) D, B, C, A. Rosenblatt (1938) → Gadamer (1960) → Iser (1972) → Fish (1980).
Quick Revision Table
| Theorist | Work and year | Key term |
|---|---|---|
| Freud (background) | Interpretation of Dreams (1900); “The Uncanny” (1919) | Condensation, displacement, Oedipus complex, uncanny |
| Ernest Jones | Hamlet and Oedipus (1949) | Oedipal reading of Hamlet’s delay |
| Lacan | Mirror stage (1936/1949); Écrits (1966) | Imaginary, Symbolic, Real; Name-of-the-Father; objet petit a; unconscious structured like a language |
| Kristeva | Revolution in Poetic Language (1974); Powers of Horror (1980) | Semiotic/symbolic, chora, abjection |
| Brooks | Reading for the Plot (1984) | Plot as desire |
| Gadamer | Truth and Method (1960) | Fusion of horizons |
| Jauss | Konstanz lecture (1967) | Horizon of expectations, aesthetic distance |
| Iser | Implied Reader (1972); Act of Reading (1976) | Implied reader, gaps, wandering viewpoint |
| Fish | Surprised by Sin (1967); “Affective Stylistics” (1970); Is There a Text… (1980) | Informed reader, interpretive communities |
| Holland | 5 Readers Reading (1975) | Identity theme |
| Bleich | Subjective Criticism (1978) | Subjective response |
| Rosenblatt | Literature as Exploration (1938); The Reader, the Text, the Poem (1978) | Transaction; efferent vs aesthetic |
| Eco | Open Work (1962); Role of the Reader (1979) | Model reader; open/closed texts |
| Riffaterre | Semiotics of Poetry (1978) | Superreader |
| Hirsch | Validity in Interpretation (1967) | Meaning vs significance |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Next topic: Marxist Criticism and New Historicism — from the reader’s mind to history and ideology
- Feminist, Gender and Queer Theory — Cixous, Irigaray and Kristeva rework Lacan
- Eliot, Richards, Leavis and Empson — Richards’s protocols and Eliot’s “Hamlet” essay, the pre-war background
- Chapter overview · Quick Revision