Renaissance and Neoclassical Criticism: Sidney, Dryden, Pope and Johnson
UGC NET English: Sidney's Apology for Poetry, Dryden's Essay of Dramatic Poesy and its speakers, Pope's Essay on Criticism, Johnson's Preface to Shakespeare.
- 16 min
On this page · 14 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Defending the Stage
- 1. Sir Philip Sidney (1554–1586): An Apology for Poetry
- 2. Between Sidney and Dryden
- 3. John Dryden (1631–1700)
- 4. Alexander Pope (1688–1744): An Essay on Criticism (1711)
- 5. Samuel Johnson (1709–1784)
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Plato and Aristotle — Sidney answers Plato’s charges; the unities debate starts from the Poetics
- Horace, Longinus and Indian Poetics — “to teach and delight” and decorum come from Horace
- Literary Criticism: chapter overview
The Hook: Defending the Stage
1. Sir Philip Sidney (1554–1586): An Apology for Poetry
The text
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Titles | An Apology for Poetry and The Defence of Poesy: two editions of the same work, both published in 1595 (Sidney died in 1586) |
| Written | About 1580 |
| Occasion | Partly a reply to Stephen Gosson’s The School of Abuse (1579), which was dedicated to Sidney |
| Form | A classical oration, with exordium, narration, proposition, refutation and peroration |
| Sources | Aristotle (via Italian commentators), Horace, Plato, Scaliger and the Italian Renaissance critics |
Sidney’s argument
1. Antiquity and universality. Poetry was the first light-giver to ignorance; the earliest philosophers and historians wrote in verse. Every nation, even the “most barbarous”, has poetry.
2. The poet’s names. The Romans called him vates, a diviner or prophet; the Greeks called him poiētēs, a maker (from poiein, to make). Sidney builds on the second: the poet alone is not tied to nature but makes a new nature. Nature’s world is brazen; the poets deliver a golden one.
3. Definition. Poetry is an art of imitation (Aristotle’s mimesis), a speaking picture, with the end to teach and delight (Horace).
4. Poet vs philosopher vs historian. This is the heart of the Apology:
| Rival | His weakness | The poet’s advantage |
|---|---|---|
| Philosopher | Gives the precept, abstract and hard to grasp | The poet joins precept to a vivid example |
| Historian | Gives the example, but tied to what was, not what should be; the wicked often prosper in history | The poet shows the general truth and can reward virtue and punish vice |
| Poet | Joins precept and example, and moves the reader to virtue. Hence the poet is the monarch of all human sciences |
This is Aristotle’s chapter 9 (poetry is more philosophical than history) turned into a moral argument.
5. The kinds. Sidney defends each genre in turn: pastoral, elegiac, iambic, satiric, comic, tragic, lyric and heroic (epic), which he ranks highest.
6. Answering the charges (Gosson’s and Plato’s):
| Charge | Sidney’s answer |
|---|---|
| Poetry wastes time | It teaches and moves to virtue better than any other learning |
| Poetry is the mother of lies | The poet nothing affirms, and therefore never lies: he does not claim his fictions are fact |
| Poetry is the nurse of abuse (corrupts with wanton desires) | It is abused by bad poets, not by poetry; the same can be said of physic or law |
| Plato banished poets | Plato banished the abuse of poetry, not poetry; and Plato himself is the most poetical of philosophers |
7. English poetry in his day. Sidney regrets its poor state. He praises Chaucer, the Mirror for Magistrates, Surrey’s lyrics and Spenser’s Shepheardes Calender (while disliking its archaic language). He praises Gorboduc (1561) for its stately speeches but faults it for breaking the unities of time and place. He attacks the “mongrel tragicomedy” of the popular stage, which mingles kings and clowns. He was writing before Marlowe and Shakespeare, so his strictures fall on the drama of the 1570s.
2. Between Sidney and Dryden
| Critic | Work | Year | Remember |
|---|---|---|---|
| George Puttenham (usual attribution) | The Arte of English Poesie | 1589 | A full handbook of English figures and metres |
| Samuel Daniel | A Defence of Ryme | c. 1603 | Defended rhyme against Thomas Campion’s attack on it |
| Ben Jonson | Timber, or Discoveries | Published posthumously, 1640–41 | Classical learning and judgement; on Shakespeare, Jonson wished he had blotted a thousand lines, yet honoured him “this side idolatry” |
3. John Dryden (1631–1700)
Dryden was Poet Laureate, dramatist, satirist and translator. Samuel Johnson called him “the father of English criticism” (Life of Dryden). His criticism lives mostly in prefaces to his own works.
An Essay of Dramatic Poesy (1668)
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Written | During the plague of 1665–66, when the London theatres were closed |
| Form | A dialogue among four speakers |
| Setting | A barge on the Thames on the day of the naval battle against the Dutch (1665), as the gunfire fades downstream |
| Definition of a play | Given by Lisideius: “a just and lively image of human nature”, representing its passions and humours and the changes of fortune, for the delight and instruction of mankind |
The four speakers and the positions they argue:
| Speaker | Usually identified as | Argues for |
|---|---|---|
| Crites | Sir Robert Howard (Dryden’s brother-in-law) | The ancients (Greek and Roman drama, the rules); also argues against rhyme in plays |
| Eugenius | Charles Sackville, Lord Buckhurst | The moderns over the ancients |
| Lisideius | Sir Charles Sedley | The French drama (unities, decorum, no tragicomedy) |
| Neander (“new man”) | Dryden himself | The English drama; defends rhyme in serious plays |
What Neander argues:
- English tragicomedy and double plots give variety; mirth and grief can relieve each other, contrary to Lisideius.
- French plays are regular but thin: “the beauties of a statue, but not of a man”.
- The English have more life and more variety of character.
- Shakespeare had, of all modern and perhaps ancient poets, “the largest and most comprehensive soul”. He was “naturally learned” and did not need “the spectacles of books” to read nature.
- Ben Jonson is the more correct poet. Neander compares the two: he admires Jonson, but loves Shakespeare.
- Neander gives an examen (critical analysis) of Jonson’s The Silent Woman (Epicoene), the first such detailed analysis of an English play.
- He defends rhyme in serious plays (Dryden later changed his mind and wrote All for Love, 1678, in blank verse).
Dryden’s other criticism
| Work | Year | Key point |
|---|---|---|
| A Defence of An Essay of Dramatic Poesy | 1668 | Reply to Howard’s attack |
| Of Heroic Plays (preface to The Conquest of Granada) | 1672 | Defence of the rhymed heroic play |
| Preface to Troilus and Cressida, “The Grounds of Criticism in Tragedy” | 1679 | Aristotelian principles applied to Shakespeare |
| A Discourse concerning the Original and Progress of Satire | 1693 | Compares Horace and Juvenal; says Donne “affects the metaphysics” |
| Preface to Fables Ancient and Modern | 1700 | On Chaucer: “here is God’s plenty”; calls him the father of English poetry, a “perpetual fountain of good sense” |
Two neoclassical side-notes
- Thomas Rymer coined the phrase “poetic justice” in The Tragedies of the Last Age (1678) and in A Short View of Tragedy (1693) attacked Othello as a “bloody farce”.
- Joseph Addison’s essays in The Spectator (1711–12) on Paradise Lost and on the “Pleasures of the Imagination” (1712) brought criticism to a wide middle-class readership.
4. Alexander Pope (1688–1744): An Essay on Criticism (1711)
Written in heroic couplets when Pope was in his early twenties, the Essay is a verse summary of neoclassical doctrine in the tradition of Horace and Boileau. It has three parts: the qualities of the true critic and the rules; the causes of bad criticism (pride, “a little learning”, attention to parts not the whole, partiality); and the ideal critic, ending with a short history of criticism from Aristotle to Pope’s own day.
| Idea | Pope’s formulation |
|---|---|
| Nature as the standard | “First follow Nature” |
| The rules | Discovered, not devised: Nature methodised |
| Ancients | To copy nature is to copy the ancients (Homer and Nature were found to be the same) |
| True wit | “What oft was thought, but ne’er so well expressed” |
| Sound and sense | “The sound must seem an echo to the sense” |
| Against half-knowledge | “A little learning is a dang’rous thing” |
| Proverbial lines | “To err is human, to forgive divine”; “Fools rush in where angels fear to tread” |
5. Samuel Johnson (1709–1784)
Johnson was the great critic of the later eighteenth century: lexicographer (Dictionary, 1755), moralist (The Rambler, 1750–52), editor of Shakespeare and biographer of the poets. His criticism rests on general nature, common sense and moral purpose, but he was not a slave to rules: he judged the rules by experience.
Rasselas (1759), chapter 10: the business of the poet
The sage Imlac says the poet should examine not the individual but the species, and should not number the streaks of the tulip. He paints general, prominent features that recall the original to every mind. This is the classic statement of neoclassical generality, and the Romantics (Blake, Wordsworth’s eye for the particular) reacted against it.
Preface to Shakespeare (1765)
Johnson’s edition of Shakespeare (1765) opened with the Preface, his most-tested work.
Shakespeare’s excellences:
- Shakespeare is “the poet of nature”, who holds up to his readers a faithful mirror of manners and of life.
- His characters are species, not individuals: genuine progeny of common humanity.
- His plays have lasted long enough (more than a century) to pass the test of length of duration and continuance of esteem.
- He mingles tragedy and comedy, and Johnson defends this: it shows the real state of sublunary nature, in which good and evil, joy and sorrow, are mingled. There is always an appeal open from criticism to nature.
- His dialogue is the language of common life.
The unities. Johnson demolishes the unities of time and place. The argument from delusion (that a spectator who believes he is in Alexandria could not believe he is in Rome an hour later) fails, because the spectators are always in their senses and know they are in a theatre. Only unity of action is necessary. This was a decisive blow to neoclassical rule-worship.
Shakespeare’s faults (Johnson is even-handed):
- He sacrifices virtue to convenience: he seems to write without moral purpose, and justice is not always done.
- His plots are loosely formed; the later parts of his plays are often neglected.
- Anachronisms: he gives to one age or nation the customs of another.
- His comic scenes are sometimes gross; his tragic scenes laboured and tumid.
- His set speeches are often cold and wordy.
- Above all, his love of the quibble (pun): a quibble was to him “the fatal Cleopatra for which he lost the world, and was content to lose it”.
Lives of the Most Eminent English Poets (1779–81)
Fifty-two biographical-critical prefaces, from Cowley to Gray.
| Life | What to remember |
|---|---|
| Life of Cowley | Names and defines the metaphysical poets: their wit is a discordia concors, in which heterogeneous ideas are yoked by violence together. (Dryden had earlier said Donne “affects the metaphysics”; Johnson fixed the label for the school.) |
| Life of Milton | Praises Paradise Lost but says no one ever wished it longer; condemns Lycidas as artificial pastoral, its diction harsh and its numbers unpleasing |
| Life of Dryden | Calls Dryden the father of English criticism |
| Life of Pope | Compares Dryden and Pope: Dryden’s page is a natural field; Pope’s a velvet lawn |
| Life of Gray | Rejoices to concur with the common reader on the Elegy (Virginia Woolf later took The Common Reader as a title) |
Pre-Romantic stirrings
Edward Young’s Conjectures on Original Composition (1759) praised the original genius that grows like a plant over the imitation of models. With Burke’s Enquiry (1757) and the revival of interest in Longinus, it points towards the Romantic criticism of the next topic.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| An Apology for Poetry (Olney’s edition) | vs | The Defence of Poesy (Ponsonby’s edition): same work, both 1595 |
| Gosson, The School of Abuse (1579): the attack | vs | Sidney, Apology: the reply |
| An Essay of Dramatic Poesy (Dryden, 1668, prose dialogue) | vs | An Essay on Criticism (Pope, 1711, verse) |
| Crites: ancients | vs | Lisideius: French |
| Dryden: Donne “affects the metaphysics” (1693) | vs | Johnson: names the metaphysical poets (Life of Cowley, 1779) |
| “Here is God’s plenty”: Dryden on Chaucer | vs | “The poet of nature”: Johnson on Shakespeare |
| Johnson’s Preface to Shakespeare (1765) | vs | Pope’s preface to his own edition of Shakespeare (1725) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Whose pamphlet was Sidney partly answering in his Apology for Poetry?
- Which speaker in Dryden’s Essay of Dramatic Poesy represents Dryden himself?
- In which work does Johnson describe metaphysical wit as heterogeneous ideas yoked together?
Answers
- Stephen Gosson (The School of Abuse, 1579).
- Neander.
- The Life of Cowley in Lives of the Poets.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) According to Sidney, the poet is superior to both the philosopher and the historian because he:
- (a) alone knows the Forms
- (b) joins the general precept with the particular example
- (c) records what actually happened
- (d) is divinely mad
Answer and explanation
(b). The philosopher gives precept without example, the historian example without precept; the poet gives both and moves the reader to act.
Q2. (Practice) Who said of Chaucer, “here is God’s plenty”?
- (a) Sidney
- (b) Dryden
- (c) Johnson
- (d) Arnold
Answer and explanation
(b) Dryden, in the Preface to Fables Ancient and Modern (1700).
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Johnson’s Preface to Shakespeare:
- Johnson defends Shakespeare’s mingling of tragic and comic scenes.
- Johnson argues that the spectators are always aware that they are in a theatre.
- Johnson praises Shakespeare’s fondness for quibbles.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 1 and 2 only. The quibble is one of the faults Johnson lists: “the fatal Cleopatra” for which Shakespeare lost the world.
Q4. (Practice) “A little learning is a dang’rous thing” occurs in:
- (a) Dryden’s Essay of Dramatic Poesy
- (b) Pope’s Essay on Criticism
- (c) Johnson’s Rasselas
- (d) Addison’s Spectator essays
Answer and explanation
(b) Pope, An Essay on Criticism (1711), Part II.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Johnson rejected the unities of time and place. Reason (R): Johnson held that the spectators never actually believe the stage to be the place it represents.
Answer and explanation
(a). Since the audience is never deluded, there is no delusion for a change of scene or a lapse of years to break. That reasoning is exactly Johnson’s ground for rejecting the two unities.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Sidney held that the poet is not a liar. Reason (R): Sidney believed that poets record only historically verified facts.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true, but for the opposite reason: the poet “nothing affirms”, that is, he never claims his fictions are fact. R is false.
Q3. (Practice) Match the speakers in Dryden’s Essay of Dramatic Poesy (List I) with the positions they defend (List II).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Crites | I. English drama |
| B. Eugenius | II. French drama |
| C. Lisideius | III. Ancient drama |
| D. Neander | IV. Modern drama over the ancients |
- (1) A-III, B-IV, C-II, D-I
- (2) A-IV, B-III, C-II, D-I
- (3) A-III, B-II, C-IV, D-I
- (4) A-II, B-IV, C-III, D-I
Answer and explanation
(1) A-III, B-IV, C-II, D-I.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following works in chronological order of publication:
A. Lives of the Poets
B. An Apology for Poetry
C. An Essay on Criticism
D. An Essay of Dramatic Poesy
(1) B, D, C, A
(2) D, B, C, A
(3) B, C, D, A
(4) B, D, A, C
Answer and explanation
(1) B, D, C, A. 1595 → 1668 → 1711 → 1779–81.
Quick Revision Table
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Sidney | Apology for Poetry / Defence of Poesy; written c. 1580, published 1595 |
| Sidney’s target | Gosson, The School of Abuse (1579) |
| Sidney’s ideas | Vates and maker; brazen vs golden world; speaking picture; teach and delight; poet as monarch; “nothing affirms” |
| Sidney on drama | Praises Gorboduc but faults its unities; attacks “mongrel tragicomedy” |
| Jonson | Timber, or Discoveries (posthumous, 1640–41) |
| Dryden | Essay of Dramatic Poesy (1668); Crites, Eugenius, Lisideius, Neander |
| Neander | Defends English drama, tragicomedy, rhyme; Shakespeare’s “largest and most comprehensive soul”; examen of The Silent Woman |
| Dryden, 1700 | Preface to Fables: Chaucer, “God’s plenty”, father of English poetry |
| Rymer | “Poetic justice” (1678); Othello a “bloody farce” (1693) |
| Pope | Essay on Criticism (1711); “Nature methodised”; “What oft was thought…” |
| Johnson | Rasselas (1759): streaks of the tulip; Preface to Shakespeare (1765); Lives (1779–81) |
| Johnson on Shakespeare | Poet of nature; species not individuals; defends mixed drama; rejects time and place; faults incl. the quibble |
| Johnson’s Lives | Cowley: metaphysical poets, “yoked by violence”; Milton: Lycidas attacked; Dryden: father of criticism; Gray: the common reader |
| Young | Conjectures on Original Composition (1759) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Romantic and Victorian Criticism — Wordsworth rejects poetic diction and Coleridge defines imagination
- Eliot, Richards, Leavis and Empson — Eliot revisits Dryden and the metaphysicals with “dissociation of sensibility”
- Quick Revision