Plato and Aristotle: Mimesis, Tragedy and Catharsis
UGC NET English: Plato's case against poets (Ion, Republic III and X) and Aristotle's Poetics: mimesis, tragedy's six parts, hamartia, catharsis, unities.
- 18 min
On this page · 11 sections
Prerequisites
- Literary Criticism: chapter overview — the timeline from Plato to the New Critics
- English: subject overview — where this unit sits in Paper 2
- A rough idea of Greek tragedy (Aeschylus, Sophocles, Euripides) and of Homer’s epics: both philosophers argue through them
The Hook: The First Book Ban
1. Plato (c. 427–347 BCE)
Plato wrote dialogues, almost all with Socrates as the main speaker. He never wrote a treatise on poetry; his views have to be gathered from several dialogues. The base of everything is his theory of Forms (Ideas): the true reality is a world of eternal, unchanging Forms; the physical world is an imperfect copy of it.
Where Plato discusses poetry
| Dialogue | What it says about poetry |
|---|---|
| Ion | Ion, a rhapsode (professional reciter of Homer), cannot explain his art. Socrates concludes that poets compose not by skill or knowledge but by divine inspiration, “out of their senses”. The image of the magnet: the Muse is the magnet, and the poet, the rhapsode and the audience are iron rings hanging from it in a chain. The poet is called “a light and winged and holy thing”. |
| Republic, Books II–III | Education of the guardians. Stories that show gods as wicked, changeable or deceitful, or heroes as fearful and grieving, must be censored. Book III also classifies poetry by manner of narration (see below). |
| Republic, Book X | The full attack: imitation is “third from the truth”, poetry feeds the lower passions, and poets are banished except for hymns to the gods and praises of good men. |
| Phaedrus | Poetic madness is one of the forms of divine madness; the poet without the Muses’ madness fails. |
| Symposium | Diotima’s ladder of love, rising from beautiful bodies to the Form of Beauty itself. |
| Laws | Poetry to be supervised by the lawgivers in the well-ordered state. |
Book III: three modes of narration
| Mode (Greek term) | Meaning | Example given |
|---|---|---|
| Simple narration (haplē diēgēsis) | The poet speaks in his own voice | Dithyramb |
| Imitation (mimēsis) | The poet speaks through characters, as if he were someone else | Tragedy and comedy |
| Mixed | Both | Epic (Homer narrates and also gives speeches to characters) |
Plato prefers the guardians to imitate only good men, and that as little as possible. The distinction is the ancestor of the modern contrast between telling and showing, and of Aristotle’s “manner” of imitation.
Book X: the three charges
1. The metaphysical (epistemological) charge: imitation is “third from the truth”. Socrates takes the example of a bed:
| Maker | What he makes | Distance from truth |
|---|---|---|
| God | The Form of the bed, the one real bed | The truth itself |
| Carpenter | A particular bed, copying the Form | Once removed |
| Painter (and poet) | A picture of the carpenter’s bed, copying an appearance | “Third from the truth” |
So the poet is an imitator of an imitation. He knows nothing of the things he describes: Homer writes of generals and doctors but never won a war or healed anyone.
2. The psychological (emotional) charge. Poetry appeals not to reason but to the inferior, emotional part of the soul. Watching a hero lament on stage, we indulge grief we would be ashamed to show in life. Poetry “feeds and waters the passions” instead of drying them up.
3. The moral (and political) charge. Poets tell lies about gods and heroes, and young people imitate what they see and hear. In a just state the guardians must not be corrupted.
The verdict. Poets are to be sent away from the ideal city, though Socrates admits hymns to the gods and praises of famous men. He speaks of an “ancient quarrel between philosophy and poetry” and leaves a door open: if poetry’s lovers can show, in prose, that it is useful as well as pleasant, it may return. Every “defence of poetry” from Aristotle to Sidney and Shelley takes up that challenge.
2. Aristotle (384–322 BCE) and the Poetics
Aristotle studied in Plato’s Academy for about twenty years, later tutored Alexander, and founded his own school, the Lyceum, in Athens. The Poetics is conventionally dated to about 335 BCE. It survives as 26 short chapters, probably lecture notes. It deals mainly with tragedy and epic; a promised discussion of comedy (thought to be a lost second book) does not survive.
Where Plato reasoned from the Forms down, Aristotle reasons up from the works themselves: he looks at the tragedies that succeeded and asks why. That is why the Poetics is called the first work of descriptive (rather than legislative) criticism, though later ages turned it into rules.
Imitation (mimesis): Aristotle’s answer to Plato
| Plato | Aristotle |
|---|---|
| Imitation copies appearances and is “third from the truth” | Imitation is natural to human beings and the first way we learn (chapter 4) |
| The poet has no knowledge | The poet imitates what may happen, according to probability or necessity |
| Poetry is less true than philosophy | Poetry is more philosophical and a higher thing than history, because it speaks of the universal, history of the particular (chapter 9) |
| Poetry inflames passions | Tragedy brings about a catharsis of pity and fear |
| Poetry should serve the state’s morality | Poetry has its own standard of correctness, not the same as that of politics (chapter 25) |
Two causes of poetry (chapter 4)
- The instinct of imitation, implanted in us from childhood; we learn by it and enjoy imitations even of things painful to see.
- The instinct for harmony and rhythm.
Means, objects and manner (chapters 1–3)
All poetry is imitation, but kinds differ in three ways:
| Difference | Explanation | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Means (medium) | Rhythm, language, harmony, singly or combined | Dithyramb uses all three; epic uses language in metre |
| Objects | People better than us, worse, or as we are | Tragedy (better), comedy (worse) |
| Manner | Narration, or presenting the characters as acting | Epic narrates; drama presents |
The definition of tragedy (chapter 6)
Break it into its clauses and you get most of the questions this topic produces:
| Clause | What it means |
|---|---|
| Imitation of an action | Tragedy imitates action and life, not persons as such |
| Serious | Of weighty matter (as against the comic) |
| Complete | Has a beginning, a middle and an end |
| Of a certain magnitude | Long enough to allow a change of fortune, short enough to be held in memory |
| Embellished language | Rhythm and song: verse in the dialogue, song in the choral parts |
| Dramatic, not narrative | Distinguishes it from epic |
| Pity and fear → catharsis | Its proper effect, the “tragic pleasure” |
The six parts of tragedy, in order of importance
| Rank | Greek | English | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mythos | Plot | “The soul of tragedy”; the arrangement of incidents |
| 2 | Ethos | Character | Moral choice revealed in action |
| 3 | Dianoia | Thought | What characters say to prove a point or state a truth |
| 4 | Lexis | Diction | Expression of meaning in words |
| 5 | Melos | Song | The chief of the embellishments |
| 6 | Opsis | Spectacle | The least artistic; depends more on the costume-maker than on the poet |
Plot, character and thought are the objects of imitation; diction and song the means; spectacle the manner. Aristotle says there can be a tragedy without character, but not without action.
Plot: the core of the Poetics
Unity and wholeness (chapters 7–8). A whole has a beginning (which does not follow anything by necessity), a middle and an end (which follows something but has nothing after it). Unity does not come from having one hero: the incidents must be so connected that if any one is removed or displaced, the whole is disturbed. This is the only “unity” Aristotle insists on, the unity of action.
Simple and complex plots (chapter 10). A simple plot changes fortune without reversal or recognition; a complex plot has one or both. The complex plot is better.
| Term | Meaning | Classic example |
|---|---|---|
| Peripeteia (reversal) | A change of the situation into its opposite, by probability or necessity | The messenger who comes to cheer Oedipus about his parentage reveals the truth and does the opposite |
| Anagnorisis (recognition) | A change from ignorance to knowledge | Oedipus learns who he is; best when it coincides with reversal |
| Pathos (scene of suffering) | A destructive or painful action: death on stage, wounds, agony | The third element of plot |
| Desis and lusis | Complication (tying) and unravelling (dénouement) | Chapter 18 |
Episodic plots (episodes following without probability or necessity) are the worst. The unravelling should arise from the plot itself, not from the deus ex machina (the god let down by stage machinery).
The tragic hero and hamartia (chapter 13)
Aristotle rules out three changes of fortune:
- A virtuous man passing from prosperity to adversity: this is shocking (miaron), not pitiable or fearful.
- A bad man passing from adversity to prosperity: the most untragic of all.
- An utter villain falling: it may satisfy our moral sense but arouses neither pity nor fear.
What remains is the intermediate kind of person: not eminently good and just, whose misfortune is brought about not by vice but by some error or frailty (hamartia), and who is of high reputation and prosperity, like Oedipus and Thyestes. Pity is felt for undeserved misfortune; fear for one like ourselves.
Aristotle also says the best plot moves from good fortune to bad, and he calls Euripides “the most tragic of the poets”, whatever his faults of construction. Sophocles’ Oedipus the King is his model play throughout.
Character: four aims (chapter 15)
Characters should be good (relative to their type), appropriate (fitting their station: valour is not appropriate to a woman, says Aristotle, in his own time’s terms), like (true to life or to tradition), and consistent (even if inconsistent, consistently so).
Catharsis: three readings
As a term for tragedy’s effect the word appears only once in the Poetics, in the definition (its one other use, in chapter 17, refers to the ritual purification of Orestes). Aristotle does not explain it there; his Politics (Book VIII) uses it of music. Hence the long dispute:
| Reading | Meaning | Associated with |
|---|---|---|
| Purgation (medical) | Tragedy rids us of excess pity and fear, as a medicine purges the body | The dominant modern reading, given wide currency by the classicist Jacob Bernays in the nineteenth century |
| Purification (moral) | The emotions are refined, freed of their painful or excessive element | Older moral interpretations, from Renaissance commentators onward |
| Clarification (intellectual) | The audience comes to understand the action and the emotions it arouses | Leon Golden and others in the twentieth century |
For UGC NET, “purgation of pity and fear” is the standard answer; know the other two as alternatives.
The “three unities”: who said what
| Unity | What Aristotle actually says |
|---|---|
| Action | Insisted on: the plot must be one and whole |
| Time | Only an observation: tragedy tries, as far as possible, to keep within “a single revolution of the sun” or a little more; epic has no limit (chapter 5) |
| Place | Not mentioned at all |
The three unities as a rule were formulated by Italian Renaissance commentators, especially Lodovico Castelvetro (1570), and then enforced by French neoclassicism. Sidney accepted them; Dryden (through Neander) relaxed them; Johnson demolished time and place in the Preface to Shakespeare (1765). See Renaissance and Neoclassical Criticism.
Other points from the Poetics
- Origins: tragedy began from the leaders of the dithyramb, comedy from those of the phallic songs. Aeschylus raised the actors from one to two; Sophocles added a third and scene-painting.
- Comedy is an imitation of persons worse than average, not in every vice, but in the ludicrous, which is a species of the ugly: a mistake or deformity that causes no pain.
- Epic vs tragedy: epic is longer, uses narrative and one metre (the hexameter), and has more room for the marvellous. In the final chapter (26) Aristotle judges tragedy superior: it has all epic’s elements plus music and spectacle, and reaches its end in shorter compass with greater unity.
- Probability: a probable impossibility is to be preferred to an improbable possibility.
- Metaphor: the greatest thing by far is to be a master of metaphor, which cannot be learned from others and is a mark of genius (chapter 22).
- Chorus: should be treated as one of the actors and share in the action, as in Sophocles, not as in Euripides.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Plato’s mimesis: a copy of a copy, “third from the truth” | vs | Aristotle’s mimesis: a creative representation of the probable and universal |
| Republic Book III: modes of narration, censorship of stories | vs | Republic Book X: the bed, the banishment, the “ancient quarrel” |
| Ion: inspiration, the magnet | vs | Phaedrus: divine madness, its four kinds |
| Peripeteia: reversal of situation | vs | Anagnorisis: recognition, ignorance to knowledge |
| Hamartia: error of judgement | vs | Hubris: overweening pride (not a term the Poetics uses for the tragic hero) |
| Unity of action: Aristotle’s rule | vs | Unities of time and place: Renaissance rules (Castelvetro, 1570) |
| Plot = soul of tragedy | vs | Character = second in importance |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- In which dialogue does Plato compare the Muse to a magnet?
- What does Aristotle call “the soul of tragedy”?
- Which Renaissance commentator is credited with formulating the three unities as a rule?
Answers
- Ion.
- Plot (mythos).
- Lodovico Castelvetro (1570).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) According to Aristotle, poetry is “more philosophical” than history because:
- (a) it is written in verse
- (b) it deals with the universal, history with the particular
- (c) it is inspired by the Muses
- (d) it imitates the Forms directly
Answer and explanation
(b). Chapter 9: the historian relates what has happened, the poet what may happen according to probability or necessity. Option (a) is wrong because Aristotle says Herodotus put into verse would still be history.
Q2. (Practice) In Plato’s example of the three beds in Republic Book X, the painter’s bed is:
- (a) the Form of the bed
- (b) a copy of the Form made by the carpenter
- (c) an imitation of an appearance, third from the truth
- (d) the bed made by God
Answer and explanation
(c). God makes the Form; the carpenter copies the Form; the painter copies the carpenter’s bed as it appears, so he is “third from the truth”.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Aristotle’s Poetics:
- The tragic hero should be a perfectly virtuous man who falls into misfortune.
- The complex plot contains reversal, recognition or both.
- Aristotle considers tragedy superior to epic.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 2 and 3 only. Statement 1 is false: the fall of a perfectly virtuous man is shocking, not tragic. The hero is an intermediate figure who falls through hamartia.
Q4. (Practice) Which of the following is the correct meaning of anagnorisis?
- (a) A change of fortune into its opposite
- (b) A change from ignorance to knowledge
- (c) A scene of suffering
- (d) The unravelling of the plot
Answer and explanation
(b). (a) is peripeteia, (c) is pathos, (d) is lusis.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Plato would banish most poets from his ideal republic. Reason (R): Plato held that poetry imitates appearances, not truth, and nourishes the passions that reason should govern.
Answer and explanation
(a). The metaphysical and psychological charges of Book X are exactly why the poets are sent away.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Aristotle insisted on the unities of time, place and action. Reason (R): Aristotle held that the plot of a tragedy must be a unified whole with a beginning, a middle and an end.
Answer and explanation
(d). A is false: Aristotle insisted only on unity of action and never mentions place. R is true.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (term from the Poetics) with List II (meaning).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Hamartia | I. Thought |
| B. Dianoia | II. Error of judgement |
| C. Opsis | III. Reversal of situation |
| D. Peripeteia | IV. Spectacle |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (3) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
- (4) A-I, B-II, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following parts of tragedy in Aristotle’s order of importance, from most to least important:
A. Diction
B. Character
C. Spectacle
D. Plot
E. Thought
(1) D, B, A, E, C
(2) D, B, E, A, C
(3) B, D, E, A, C
(4) D, E, B, A, C
Answer and explanation
(2) D, B, E, A, C. Plot, character, thought, diction (then song), spectacle.
Quick Revision Table
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Plato’s base | Theory of Forms; the world is a copy of the Forms |
| Ion | Rhapsode; inspiration, not knowledge; the magnet and iron rings |
| Republic III | Simple narration, imitation, mixed; censorship of stories about gods |
| Republic X | The three beds; “third from the truth”; banishment; “ancient quarrel”; hymns and praises allowed |
| Phaedrus | Poetic madness as divine madness |
| Poetics | c. 335 BCE; 26 chapters; tragedy and epic; comedy section lost |
| Two causes of poetry | Instinct of imitation; instinct for harmony and rhythm |
| Means, objects, manner | Chapters 1–3 |
| Definition of tragedy | Chapter 6: serious, complete, magnitude, embellished language, dramatic form, pity and fear, catharsis |
| Six parts | Plot, character, thought, diction, song, spectacle |
| Poetry vs history | Chapter 9: universal vs particular |
| Complex plot | Peripeteia + anagnorisis (+ pathos) |
| Hero | Intermediate man, high fortune, falls through hamartia (Oedipus, Thyestes) |
| Character’s four aims | Good, appropriate, like, consistent |
| Catharsis | Purgation / purification / clarification |
| Unities | Action (Aristotle); time (observation); place (Castelvetro, 1570) |
| Tragedy vs epic | Tragedy superior (chapter 26) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Horace, Longinus and Indian Poetics — Rome’s rules of decorum, the sublime, and the Indian theory of rasa as a parallel to catharsis
- Renaissance and Neoclassical Criticism — Sidney answers Plato; Dryden and Johnson argue over the unities
- Quick Revision