Skip to content

Literary Criticism

UGC NET English Unit 8: literary criticism from Plato and Aristotle to Eliot, Richards, Leavis and the New Critics, with rasa and dhvani.

6
Topics
97
Min read

Chapter Overview

Literary criticism is the long argument about what poetry is, what it does to us and how it should be judged. In UGC NET English it runs from Plato’s charge against poets in the fourth century BCE to the New Critics of mid-twentieth-century America, who asked readers to attend to “the poem itself”. Along the way come Aristotle’s Poetics, Horace’s Ars Poetica, Longinus on the sublime, Sidney’s defence of poetry, Dryden and Johnson, the Romantic prefaces of Wordsworth and Coleridge, Arnold and Pater, and the Cambridge revolution of Eliot, Richards, Leavis and Empson.

The official syllabus gives only the heading “Literary Criticism”, with no named critics or texts. The scope used here is the one UGC NET papers have followed in practice: classical to New Criticism. Theory after the Second World War (structuralism, deconstruction, feminism, Marxism, postcolonialism and so on) belongs to Unit 9, Literary Theory post World War II, and is not covered in this chapter. A short section on Indian poetics (rasa, dhvani and the other schools) is included, because comparative questions on Bharata and Anandavardhana do appear.

What You’ll Learn

By the end of this chapter, you will be able to:

  • Match every major critic with his work, its year and its key term (mimesis, catharsis, the sublime, negative capability, touchstone, objective correlative, intentional fallacy)
  • Explain why each critic said what he said, which is what assertion–reason questions test
  • Arrange critics and works in chronological order, from Plato to Wimsatt and Beardsley
  • Separate look-alikes: fancy and imagination, historic and personal estimate, tenor and vehicle, intentional and affective fallacy
  • Place Indian concepts (rasa, dhvani, riti, vakrokti, auchitya) beside their Western counterparts

Prerequisites

  • English: subject overview — how Paper 2 is marked and how the ten units fit together
  • Paper 1 overview — Paper 1 and Paper 2 are taken in the same sitting
  • A reading knowledge of the major English poets and dramatists helps: almost every critic here argues through examples from Homer, Sophocles, Shakespeare, Milton, Donne and Wordsworth

Timeline: Twenty-Four Centuries in One Line

timeline
    title Landmarks of literary criticism (classical to New Criticism)
    4th c. BCE : Plato, Republic (Books III and X) : Aristotle, Poetics
    1st c. BCE to 1st c. CE : Horace, Ars Poetica : Longinus, On the Sublime (authorship and date uncertain)
    1595 : Sidney, An Apology for Poetry (published posthumously)
    1668 : Dryden, An Essay of Dramatic Poesy
    1711 : Pope, An Essay on Criticism
    1765 : Johnson, Preface to Shakespeare
    1800 to 1802 : Wordsworth, Preface to Lyrical Ballads
    1817 : Coleridge, Biographia Literaria
    1864 to 1880 : Arnold, Function of Criticism and The Study of Poetry
    1873 : Pater, The Renaissance
    1919 to 1921 : Eliot, Tradition and the Individual Talent and The Metaphysical Poets
    1924 to 1930 : Richards, Principles and Practical Criticism and Empson, Seven Types of Ambiguity
    1941 to 1954 : Ransom, The New Criticism and Brooks, The Well Wrought Urn and Wimsatt, The Verbal Icon

Learning Path

Follow the topics in this order:

graph TD
    A["1. Plato and Aristotle
Mimesis, the banishment of poets,
tragedy, catharsis, hamartia"] --> B["2. Horace, Longinus and Indian Poetics
Decorum, utile et dulce, the sublime,
rasa, dhvani, riti, vakrokti"] B --> C["3. Renaissance and Neoclassical
Sidney, Dryden, Pope, Johnson"] C --> D["4. Romantic and Victorian
Wordsworth, Coleridge, Shelley, Keats,
Arnold, Pater"] D --> E["5. Eliot, Richards, Leavis, Empson
Impersonality, practical criticism,
the great tradition, ambiguity"] E --> F["6. The New Criticism
Ransom, Brooks, Warren, Tate,
Wimsatt and Beardsley"] F --> G["7. Quick Revision
One-page sheet"]

Topics in This Chapter

#TopicWhat it covers
1Plato and AristotlePlato’s Ion, Republic III and X, the three beds and the banishment of poets; Aristotle’s Poetics: mimesis, the definition of tragedy, six parts, plot, hamartia, peripeteia, anagnorisis, catharsis, the “three unities”
2Horace, Longinus and Indian PoeticsArs Poetica: decorum, instruct and delight, in medias res; On the Sublime: five sources, transport; Bharata’s rasa sutra, the nine rasas, Anandavardhana’s dhvani, the six schools of Sanskrit poetics
3Renaissance and Neoclassical CriticismSidney’s Apology, Ben Jonson, Dryden’s Essay of Dramatic Poesy and its four speakers, Pope’s Essay on Criticism, Johnson’s Preface to Shakespeare and Lives of the Poets
4Romantic and Victorian CriticismWordsworth’s Preface, Coleridge’s Biographia Literaria (fancy and imagination), Shelley’s Defence, Keats’s letters; Arnold’s touchstones and “criticism of life”, Pater’s aestheticism, Ruskin and Wilde
5Eliot, Richards, Leavis and EmpsonTradition and impersonality, objective correlative, dissociation of sensibility; Richards’s emotive language and Practical Criticism; Leavis and Scrutiny; Empson’s seven types of ambiguity
6The New CriticismRansom’s structure and texture, Tate’s tension, Brooks’s paradox and heresy of paraphrase, Wimsatt and Beardsley’s intentional and affective fallacies, close reading and its critics
—Quick RevisionEvery critic, work, year and key term on one page

How UGC NET Asks It

Literary criticism is pure critic–work–term matching, and the questions reward exact recall.

FormatWhat to expect
Direct recall“Who coined the term objective correlative?” “In which work does willing suspension of disbelief occur?”
Match the followingCritic with work, work with year, critic with key term, Indian school with its founder. This is the single most common format in the unit.
SequenceArrange Sidney, Dryden, Johnson and Wordsworth (or their works) chronologically; arrange the six parts of tragedy in Aristotle’s order of importance.
Assertion–reasonTests the why: why Plato banished poets, why Eliot wanted poetry to be impersonal, why Wimsatt and Beardsley rejected intention.
Statement-based“Which of the following statements about Coleridge’s secondary imagination are correct?” with combined options.
Quotation identificationA short, famous phrase (“spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings”, “criticism of life”) and its author.

Quick Reference: The Big Questions and Who Answered Them

QuestionClassicalNeoclassicalRomanticVictorianModern / New Critical
What is poetry?Imitation (Plato, Aristotle)A “speaking picture” (Sidney), “a just and lively image of human nature” (Dryden)Expression of feeling (Wordsworth), product of imagination (Coleridge)A criticism of life (Arnold)An autonomous verbal structure (New Critics)
What is it for?To instruct and delight (Horace); to transport (Longinus)To teach and delight (Sidney, Johnson)To give pleasure, to awaken moral sympathy (Wordsworth, Shelley)To interpret life and console us, more and more in place of religion (Arnold); for its own sake (Pater)To balance and order our impulses (Richards); to be read as a self-sufficient object (New Critics)
Where does value lie?In plot and probability (Aristotle)In general nature, rules (Johnson, Pope)In the poet’s mindIn the “best that is known and thought”In the words on the page

Related chapters: English: all units · Research Aptitude (Paper 1)


Start Learning

Begin with the first topic:

→ Plato and Aristotle

Advertisement
Advertisement