Pragmatics, Discourse, Sociolinguistics and Language Change
UGC NET English: Austin and Searle's speech acts, Grice's maxims, politeness, cohesion, dialect, register, pidgin, diglossia and the history of English.
- 17 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: “It’s Cold in Here”
- 1. Pragmatics: Meaning in Context
- 2. Speech Act Theory
- 3. Grice and the Cooperative Principle
- 4. Politeness
- 5. Discourse Analysis
- 6. Sociolinguistics: Language and Society
- 7. Language Change and the History of English
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Nature of Language and the Major Linguistic Theories — Jakobson, Halliday and Hymes: the functional view on which pragmatics and sociolinguistics build
- Phonetics, Phonology, Morphology, Syntax and Semantics — semantics (meaning out of context) is the starting point for pragmatics (meaning in context)
- Barriers to Effective Communication — Paper 1’s semantic and cultural barriers are pragmatic failures in everyday dress
The Hook: “It’s Cold in Here”
1. Pragmatics: Meaning in Context
Charles Morris (Foundations of the Theory of Signs, 1938) divided the study of signs into syntax (relations of signs to one another), semantics (relations of signs to what they stand for) and pragmatics (relations of signs to their users). Pragmatics studies speaker meaning: what people mean by what they say in a given context.
Deixis
Deixis (“pointing” through language) covers words whose reference depends entirely on the context of utterance.
| Type | Examples | Depends on |
|---|---|---|
| Person deixis | I, you, we | Who is speaking to whom |
| Spatial (place) deixis | here, there, this, that, come, go | Where the speaker is |
| Temporal (time) deixis | now, then, today, yesterday, next week | When the utterance is made |
| Social deixis | tu/vous, tum/aap, honorifics | Social relationship |
| Discourse deixis | the following, the former, this chapter | Position in the text |
Presupposition and entailment
A presupposition is what the speaker assumes to be true before making the utterance. Its test is constancy under negation: My brother is a doctor and My brother is not a doctor both presuppose I have a brother. An entailment follows logically from the sentence and does not survive negation: He killed the tiger entails the tiger died; He did not kill the tiger does not.
2. Speech Act Theory
J.L. Austin
The Oxford philosopher J.L. Austin delivered the William James Lectures at Harvard in 1955; they were published posthumously as How to Do Things with Words (1962), edited by J.O. Urmson.
| Concept | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Constative | An utterance that describes and can be true or false | The door is open. |
| Performative | An utterance that does something in being said; it is not true or false but happy or unhappy | I name this ship …; I promise to come; I now pronounce you … |
| Felicity conditions | Conditions for a performative to succeed: the right conventional procedure, the right persons and circumstances, correct and complete execution, sincere intentions | A marriage pronounced by someone with no authority misfires |
| Locutionary act | The act of saying something: producing a meaningful utterance | Saying “Shoot her!” |
| Illocutionary act | The act performed in saying something: its force | Ordering, urging or advising him to shoot |
| Perlocutionary act | The act performed by saying something: its effect on the hearer | Persuading him to shoot; frightening him |
Austin eventually concluded that all utterances perform acts, so the constative/performative distinction collapses into a general theory of illocutionary force. His own five classes of illocutionary acts were verdictives, exercitives, commissives, behabitives and expositives.
John Searle
John Searle, Austin’s student, systematised the theory in Speech Acts (1969) and later reclassified illocutionary acts into five types:
| Searle’s class | The speaker … | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Representatives (assertives) | commits to the truth of a proposition | asserting, concluding, describing |
| Directives | tries to get the hearer to do something | requesting, ordering, advising |
| Commissives | commits himself or herself to a future action | promising, threatening, vowing |
| Expressives | expresses a psychological state | thanking, apologising, congratulating |
| Declarations | changes the world by the utterance | declaring war, sentencing, resigning |
Indirect speech acts. “Can you pass the salt?” is grammatically a question about ability but performs a request. “It’s cold in here” is a representative used as a directive.
3. Grice and the Cooperative Principle
H.P. Grice also gave William James Lectures at Harvard (1967). The key lecture was published as “Logic and Conversation” (1975). Conversation, he argued, rests on the Cooperative Principle: each participant contributes what the shared purpose of the exchange requires, at the point where it is required.
| Maxim | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Quantity | Be as informative as required, and no more |
| Quality | Do not say what you believe to be false or lack evidence for |
| Relation (relevance) | Be relevant |
| Manner | Be clear: avoid obscurity and ambiguity, be brief and orderly |
Implicature is what a speaker implies beyond what is literally said. A conversational implicature arises when the hearer assumes the speaker is cooperative even though a maxim seems to be broken. A conventional implicature is attached to particular words (but implies a contrast; even implies unexpectedness).
Ways of not fulfilling a maxim:
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Flouting | Openly breaking a maxim so that the hearer infers a hidden meaning: irony, metaphor, understatement |
| Violating | Quietly breaking a maxim, for example to mislead (lying violates quality) |
| Opting out | Signalling unwillingness to cooperate: “No comment.” |
| Clash | Being unable to fulfil one maxim without breaking another |
Example of flouting relation. A: “How was the new professor’s lecture?” B: “The canteen samosas were good.” B’s apparent irrelevance implicates that the lecture was not worth discussing.
4. Politeness
| Theorist | Work | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Erving Goffman | Interaction Ritual (1967) | Face: the public self-image a person claims in interaction |
| Robin Lakoff | “The Logic of Politeness” (1973) | Rules of politeness: don’t impose; give options; make the hearer feel good |
| Penelope Brown and Stephen Levinson | “Universals in Language Usage: Politeness Phenomena” (1978); book Politeness: Some Universals in Language Usage (1987) | Positive face (the wish to be liked and approved) and negative face (the wish to be unimpeded); face-threatening acts (FTAs); strategies: bald on record, positive politeness, negative politeness, off record, or not doing the FTA |
| Geoffrey Leech | Principles of Pragmatics (1983) | The Politeness Principle with six maxims: tact, generosity, approbation, modesty, agreement, sympathy |
“Could you possibly lend me your notes?” is negative politeness (it minimises the imposition). “You’re so organised, can I see your notes?” is positive politeness (it appeals to the hearer’s wish to be liked).
5. Discourse Analysis
Discourse analysis studies language above the sentence: how sentences connect into texts and how talk is organised.
Cohesion and coherence
M.A.K. Halliday and Ruqaiya Hasan, Cohesion in English (1976), identified five cohesive devices:
| Device | How it links | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Reference | Pronouns, demonstratives, comparatives point to something elsewhere in the text | Ravi came late. He had missed the bus. |
| Substitution | A word replaces another (one, do, so) | I need a pen. Do you have one? |
| Ellipsis | Something is left out and understood | She can sing and he can [sing] too. |
| Conjunction | Connectives mark relations (additive, adversative, causal, temporal) | however, therefore, then |
| Lexical cohesion | Repetition, synonymy, hyponymy, collocation | a car … the vehicle |
Reference that points backwards is anaphoric; forwards, cataphoric; outside the text, exophoric. Cohesion is the visible linking in the text; coherence is the underlying sense that the text makes to a reader, which may exist even without cohesive ties.
Conversation analysis
- Turn-taking: Harvey Sacks, Emanuel Schegloff and Gail Jefferson (1974) described how speakers take turns with minimal gap and overlap.
- Adjacency pairs: question–answer, greeting–greeting, offer–acceptance/refusal.
- Classroom discourse: John Sinclair and Malcolm Coulthard (Towards an Analysis of Discourse, 1975) found the IRF exchange: teacher Initiation, pupil Response, teacher Feedback. It is the backbone of the teacher-centred lesson discussed in ELT Methods, Syllabus, Skills and Testing.
6. Sociolinguistics: Language and Society
Varieties of language
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Idiolect | An individual’s personal variety |
| Dialect | A variety marked by vocabulary, grammar and pronunciation, tied to region (regional dialect) or social group (sociolect) |
| Accent | Pronunciation only; every speaker has an accent |
| Standard language | A dialect that has gained prestige and been codified in dictionaries and grammars |
| Register | A variety defined by use, not user: legal, medical, religious, sports commentary |
| Jargon | Specialised vocabulary of a profession |
| Slang | Informal, often short-lived in-group vocabulary |
| Pidgin | A simplified contact language with no native speakers, used between groups with no common language |
| Creole | A pidgin that has become the mother tongue of a community and so expands in grammar and vocabulary (creolisation) |
| Lingua franca | Any language used for communication between speakers of different first languages |
Bilingualism and diglossia
- Diglossia: Charles Ferguson (“Diglossia”, Word, 1959) described communities using two varieties of one language with separate functions: a High (H) variety for formal, written, religious and educational use, and a Low (L) variety for home and everyday talk. His examples: Arabic, Swiss German, Greek and Haitian (French and Creole). Joshua Fishman later extended the term to two unrelated languages in such a relation.
- Code-switching is moving between languages at sentence or clause boundaries; code-mixing inserts elements of one language within a sentence of another. Both are normal in multilingual societies.
- Language shift is a community’s move from one language to another; when the last speakers die, the result is language death.
- Language planning: status planning (which language gets which function) and corpus planning (standardising its spelling, grammar and vocabulary).
Landmark studies
| Scholar | Study | Finding |
|---|---|---|
| William Labov | The Social Stratification of English in New York City (1966); the department-store study | Pronunciation of postvocalic /r/ (fourth floor) varied with social class and formality: variation is systematic, not random |
| Labov | Martha’s Vineyard study (1960s) | Islanders’ vowels shifted as a marker of local identity |
| Basil Bernstein | Work on class and language (1960s–1970s) | Restricted code (context-bound, implicit) vs elaborated code (explicit, context-independent); schools reward the elaborated code |
| Peter Trudgill | Norwich study (1970s) | Class and gender variation; covert prestige of non-standard forms among men |
| Robin Lakoff | Language and Woman’s Place (1975) | Features she claimed marked women’s speech: hedges, tag questions, “empty” adjectives, super-polite forms |
7. Language Change and the History of English
How languages change
| Type of change | Examples |
|---|---|
| Sound change | The Great Vowel Shift (below); loss of the /k/ in knight and know |
| Grammatical change | Old English inflections lost; word order becomes fixed (SVO) |
| Borrowing | Norse, French, Latin, Greek and later Indian, Arabic and other loanwords |
| Semantic change: broadening | holiday: once a “holy day”, now any day off |
| Semantic change: narrowing | meat: once food in general, now animal flesh |
| Semantic change: pejoration | silly: once “blessed, happy”, now “foolish” |
| Semantic change: amelioration | knight: once “boy, servant”, now a man of honourable rank |
English in the Indo-European family
Indo-European → Germanic → West Germanic → English. English’s closest relatives are Frisian, then Dutch and German. Its basic vocabulary (father, mother, water, house) is Germanic; by most estimates, more than half its total vocabulary comes from French and Latin.
Periods of English
The boundaries are conventional and vary by a few decades between textbooks.
timeline
title Periods of English
c. 450 to 1100 : Old English (Anglo-Saxon) : Angles, Saxons, Jutes settle Britain : Beowulf
c. 1100 to 1500 : Middle English : Norman Conquest (1066) brings French : Chaucer
c. 1500 to 1700 : Early Modern English : Caxton's press (1476) : Great Vowel Shift : Shakespeare, King James Bible (1611)
1700 onwards : Late Modern English : Johnson's Dictionary (1755) : OED (1884 to 1928) : English as a world language| Period | Key features |
|---|---|
| Old English | Highly inflected (case, gender, number); grammatical gender; freer word order; Germanic vocabulary; Viking settlement brought Old Norse borrowings, including the pronouns they, them, their and words such as sky, skin, egg, window |
| Middle English | After the Norman Conquest (1066), French was the language of the court, law and administration (Latin remained the language of the Church); thousands of French words entered (government, justice, beef, pork, mutton beside English cow, pig, sheep); inflections levelled to unstressed -e; Chaucer wrote in the London dialect |
| Early Modern English | William Caxton set up the first printing press in England at Westminster (1476), helping fix spelling; the Great Vowel Shift changed the long vowels; Renaissance borrowings from Latin and Greek (the “inkhorn” controversy); Shakespeare and the King James Bible (1611) |
| Late Modern English | Standardisation and codification: Samuel Johnson’s A Dictionary of the English Language (1755), Robert Lowth’s prescriptive Short Introduction to English Grammar (1762); the Oxford English Dictionary (first part 1884, completed 1928, chief editor James Murray); global spread through empire and, later, American influence |
The Great Vowel Shift
Between roughly the fifteenth and seventeenth centuries, the long vowels of English were raised, and the two highest, /iː/ and /uː/, became diphthongs. The term was coined by the Danish linguist Otto Jespersen.
| Word | Before (Middle English, approx.) | After (Modern English) |
|---|---|---|
| bite | /iː/ | /aɪ/ |
| house | /uː/ | /aʊ/ |
| feet | /eː/ | /iː/ |
| name | /aː/ | /eɪ/ |
Because spelling had largely been fixed by printing before the shift was complete, English spelling still shows the older vowels: the main reason for the mismatch between letters and sounds in English.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Illocutionary act: force in saying | vs | Perlocutionary act: effect by saying |
| Austin’s five classes (verdictives, exercitives, commissives, behabitives, expositives) | vs | Searle’s five (representatives, directives, commissives, expressives, declarations) |
| Flouting a maxim (openly, to implicate) | vs | Violating a maxim (covertly, to mislead) |
| Presupposition: survives negation | vs | Entailment: does not |
| Cohesion: linking devices in the text | vs | Coherence: underlying sense |
| Anaphora: refers back | vs | Cataphora: refers forward |
| Pidgin: no native speakers | vs | Creole: native language of a community |
| Dialect: variety by user | vs | Register: variety by use |
| Diglossia (Ferguson, 1959): H and L in one community | vs | Bilingualism: an individual’s use of two languages |
| Code-switching: between clauses or sentences | vs | Code-mixing: within a sentence |
| Positive face: wish to be approved | vs | Negative face: wish to be unimpeded |
| Broadening (holiday) / narrowing (meat) | vs | Pejoration (silly) / amelioration (knight) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- In which year was Austin’s How to Do Things with Words published?
- Which of Grice’s maxims does a deliberate lie break?
- Which semantic change does meat (once “food” in general) illustrate?
Answers
- 1962, posthumously, from the 1955 William James Lectures.
- The maxim of quality.
- Narrowing (specialisation).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) In Searle’s classification, “I promise to submit the thesis by June” is a:
- (a) representative
- (b) directive
- (c) commissive
- (d) declaration
Answer and explanation
(c) Commissive. The speaker commits himself or herself to a future action.
Q2. (Practice) The concept of diglossia, with “High” and “Low” varieties, is classically associated with:
- (a) William Labov
- (b) Charles Ferguson
- (c) Basil Bernstein
- (d) Dell Hymes
Answer and explanation
(b) Charles Ferguson, “Diglossia” (Word, 1959). Bernstein is restricted and elaborated codes; Labov is variation and social class.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Halliday and Hasan list reference, substitution, ellipsis, conjunction and lexical cohesion as cohesive devices.
- A presupposition survives the negation of the sentence that carries it.
- Brown and Levinson’s negative face is the wish to be liked and approved.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 2 only. Statement 3 describes positive face. Negative face is the wish to be free from imposition.
Q4. (Practice) A: “Did you like my poem?” B: “The paper you printed it on is lovely.” B’s reply most clearly flouts the maxim of:
- (a) quality
- (b) quantity
- (c) relation
- (d) manner
Answer and explanation
(c) Relation. B answers about the paper, not the poem; the apparent irrelevance implicates that B did not like it. (Some readings also see quantity; relation is the clearest.)
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Austin held that performative utterances cannot be judged true or false. Reason (R): A performative utterance does an action rather than describing a state of affairs.
Answer and explanation
(a). Because “I promise” performs the promise, it is not a report that could be true or false; it can only be felicitous or infelicitous.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): English spelling often does not match modern pronunciation of long vowels. Reason (R): Spelling was largely fixed by printing before the Great Vowel Shift was complete.
Answer and explanation
(a). Bite and house keep spellings that reflect the older /iː/ and /uː/ pronunciations.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (scholar) with List II (concept).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. H.P. Grice | I. Restricted and elaborated codes |
| B. Basil Bernstein | II. Cooperative Principle |
| C. Erving Goffman | III. Social stratification of /r/ in New York |
| D. William Labov | IV. Face |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I
- (3) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
- (4) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following events in the history of English in chronological order:
A. Publication of Johnson’s Dictionary
B. The Norman Conquest
C. Caxton’s printing press at Westminster
D. Publication of the King James Bible
(1) B, C, D, A
(2) B, D, C, A
(3) C, B, D, A
(4) B, C, A, D
Answer and explanation
(1) B, C, D, A. 1066 → 1476 → 1611 → 1755.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Morris (1938) | Syntax, semantics, pragmatics |
| Deixis | Person, spatial, temporal, social, discourse |
| Austin | Lectures 1955; How to Do Things with Words (1962); constative/performative; felicity conditions; locution, illocution, perlocution |
| Searle | Speech Acts (1969); representatives, directives, commissives, expressives, declarations; indirect speech acts |
| Grice | Lectures 1967; “Logic and Conversation” (1975); Cooperative Principle; quantity, quality, relation, manner; implicature; flouting |
| Sperber and Wilson | Relevance theory (1986) |
| Politeness | Goffman’s face (1967); R. Lakoff (1973); Brown and Levinson (1978/1987); Leech’s six maxims (1983) |
| Cohesion | Halliday and Hasan (1976): reference, substitution, ellipsis, conjunction, lexical |
| Discourse | Turn-taking (Sacks, Schegloff, Jefferson, 1974); IRF (Sinclair and Coulthard, 1975) |
| Sociolinguistics | Ferguson diglossia (1959); Labov New York (1966); Bernstein codes; Trudgill Norwich; R. Lakoff (1975) |
| Varieties | Idiolect, dialect, sociolect, accent, register, pidgin, creole, lingua franca |
| History of English | OE c. 450–1100; ME c. 1100–1500; EModE c. 1500–1700; LModE 1700 on; 1066, 1476, 1611, 1755, 1884–1928 |
| Great Vowel Shift | Long vowels raised; /iː/, /uː/ → /aɪ/, /aʊ/; term by Jespersen |
| Semantic change | Broadening, narrowing, pejoration, amelioration |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Language Acquisition and Second Language Learning — how children and adults acquire all of the above
- English in Use: Grammar, Usage, Vocabulary and Style — register, cohesion and usage in practice
- Intercultural, Group and Classroom Communication — the Paper 1 side of language in social context