Nature of Language and the Major Linguistic Theories
UGC NET English Unit 5: design features of language, branches of linguistics, Saussure, Bloomfield, Sapir-Whorf, Chomsky, Jakobson, Halliday and Hymes.
- 21 min
On this page · 18 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Why Can a Child Say a Sentence Nobody Has Ever Said?
- 1. What Is Language?
- 2. Hockett’s Design Features of Language
- 3. Linguistics: Scope and Branches
- 4. Before Saussure: Comparative Philology
- 5. Ferdinand de Saussure: The Founder of Modern Linguistics
- 6. Structuralism after Saussure: Three European Schools
- 7. American Structuralism and the Sapir–Whorf Hypothesis
- 8. Noam Chomsky and Generative Grammar
- 9. Functional Theories: Language as Use
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Language and Pedagogy: chapter overview — how this unit is scoped and how the six topics fit together
- Communication: Meaning, Types and Characteristics — Paper 1’s models of communication are the everyday version of the functional theories on this page
- No prior linguistics is assumed. If you have read Saussure only through literary theory, this page gives you the linguist’s Saussure first
The Hook: Why Can a Child Say a Sentence Nobody Has Ever Said?
1. What Is Language?
Definitions worth knowing
| Linguist | Definition in brief | Emphasis |
|---|---|---|
| Edward Sapir, Language (1921) | A purely human, non-instinctive method of communicating ideas, emotions and desires through voluntarily produced symbols | Human, learned, symbolic |
| Bernard Bloch and George L. Trager, Outline of Linguistic Analysis (1942) | A system of arbitrary vocal symbols by which a social group co-operates | System, arbitrary, vocal, social |
| Noam Chomsky, Syntactic Structures (1957) | A set (finite or infinite) of sentences, each finite in length and built from a finite set of elements | Formal, generative |
| M.A.K. Halliday | A resource for making meaning; a “social semiotic” (Language as Social Semiotic, 1978) | Functional, social |
Most textbook definitions combine five words: language is a system of arbitrary, vocal symbols used for human communication. Each word is worth a statement in a multiple-choice question.
- System: sounds, words and sentences are organised by rules at every level.
- Arbitrary: there is no natural link between the word tree and the thing; French arbre and Hindi ped do the same job.
- Vocal: speech is primary; writing is a later and secondary representation. Every human community speaks; not every one writes.
- Symbolic: words stand for concepts by convention.
- Human and social: language is learned in a community and transmitted culturally, not genetically.
Human language and animal communication
Animal systems such as the bee’s dance (studied by Karl von Frisch), bird calls and primate alarm calls are rich, but they are closed: a fixed set of messages tied to the here and now. Human language is open-ended. The classic way of stating the difference is Hockett’s list of design features.
2. Hockett’s Design Features of Language
The American linguist Charles F. Hockett set out thirteen design features in “The Origin of Speech” (Scientific American, 1960). Later work added prevarication, reflexiveness and learnability, bringing the list to sixteen.
| # | Design feature | Meaning | Unique to humans? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Vocal-auditory channel | Produced by the vocal tract, received by the ear | No |
| 2 | Broadcast transmission and directional reception | Heard all round; the listener can locate the source | No |
| 3 | Rapid fading (transitoriness) | Speech does not last | No |
| 4 | Interchangeability | Any speaker can also be a receiver and vice versa | Largely |
| 5 | Total feedback | The speaker hears what he or she says | No |
| 6 | Specialization | Speech serves communication, not some other biological purpose | No |
| 7 | Semanticity | Signals have fixed associations with meanings | No |
| 8 | Arbitrariness | No natural link between form and meaning | No (but far more in humans) |
| 9 | Discreteness | Built from distinct, separable units (/p/ vs /b/) | Largely |
| 10 | Displacement | We can talk about things remote in time and place | Very largely |
| 11 | Productivity (openness, creativity) | New messages can be made and understood without limit | Yes |
| 12 | Traditional (cultural) transmission | Learned from others, not inherited | Largely |
| 13 | Duality of patterning | Meaningless sounds combine into meaningful units; the same small set of sounds yields thousands of words | Yes |
Example of duality. The three sounds /p/, /t/, /æ/ mean nothing by themselves. Arranged as /pæt/ (“pat”), /tæp/ (“tap”) and /æpt/ (“apt”), they make three different words. A small set of meaningless phonemes (about 44 in Received Pronunciation; see Phonetics, Phonology, Morphology, Syntax and Semantics) produces a vast vocabulary.
3. Linguistics: Scope and Branches
Linguistics is the scientific study of language. It is descriptive (it records how people actually speak and write) rather than prescriptive (telling them how they ought to).
Levels of analysis (core or “micro” linguistics)
| Branch | Studies | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Phonetics | The physical production (articulatory), transmission (acoustic) and perception (auditory) of speech sounds | Phone |
| Phonology | How sounds function as a system in a particular language | Phoneme |
| Morphology | The internal structure of words | Morpheme |
| Syntax | How words combine into phrases, clauses and sentences | Sentence |
| Semantics | Meaning of words and sentences, independent of context | Sense, reference |
| Pragmatics | Meaning in context: what speakers mean by what they say | Utterance, speech act |
Interdisciplinary (“macro”) branches
| Branch | Studies |
|---|---|
| Sociolinguistics | Language and society: dialect, register, bilingualism, language and class, gender, power |
| Psycholinguistics | Language and mind: acquisition, comprehension, production, memory |
| Neurolinguistics | Language and the brain: Broca’s and Wernicke’s areas, aphasia |
| Historical (diachronic) linguistics | Language change; comparative reconstruction of language families |
| Applied linguistics | Language teaching, testing, translation, lexicography, language planning |
| Computational linguistics | Language and computers: parsing, machine translation, corpora |
| Stylistics | Linguistic analysis of literary and non-literary style |
Pairs of approaches
| Pair | Contrast |
|---|---|
| Synchronic vs diachronic | Language at one point in time vs language changing through time (Saussure’s terms) |
| Descriptive vs prescriptive | How language is used vs how it “should” be used |
| Theoretical vs applied | Building models of language vs using them for teaching, testing, translation |
| Formal vs functional | Language as a structure of forms (Bloomfield, Chomsky) vs language as a tool for meaning in society (Prague School, Halliday) |
4. Before Saussure: Comparative Philology
Nineteenth-century linguistics was historical and comparative.
| Landmark | Year | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Sir William Jones, discourse to the Asiatic Society, Calcutta | 1786 | Noted that Sanskrit, Greek and Latin share so much that they must spring from a common source; the start of Indo-European comparative study |
| Jacob Grimm, Deutsche Grammatik (2nd edition) | 1822 | Stated the regular consonant correspondences now called Grimm’s Law (the First Germanic Sound Shift: Latin pater vs English father) |
| Karl Verner | 1875 | Verner’s Law explained the apparent exceptions to Grimm’s Law by the position of the accent |
| The Neogrammarians (Leipzig, 1870s) | 1870s | “Sound laws admit no exceptions”: sound change is regular |
Saussure himself was trained in this tradition. His revolution was to insist that a language can also be studied as a system at one moment in time.
5. Ferdinand de Saussure: The Founder of Modern Linguistics
Ferdinand de Saussure (1857–1913), Swiss linguist, taught general linguistics at Geneva. The Course in General Linguistics (Cours de linguistique générale) was published posthumously in 1916, compiled by his colleagues Charles Bally and Albert Sechehaye from students’ lecture notes. He did not write it as a book.
Saussure’s key distinctions
| Distinction | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Langage / langue / parole | Langage is the human faculty of language in general; langue is the abstract, social system shared by a community; parole is the individual, concrete act of speaking. Linguistics studies langue |
| Signifier (signifiant) and signified (signifié) | The linguistic sign unites a sound-image (signifier) and a concept (signified), not a name and a thing |
| Arbitrariness of the sign | The bond between signifier and signified is unmotivated; it rests on convention. (Onomatopoeia is a limited exception) |
| Linearity of the signifier | Speech unfolds in time, one element after another |
| Synchronic vs diachronic | Study of a language as a system at one time vs study of its changes through time; Saussure gave the synchronic priority |
| Syntagmatic vs associative (later called paradigmatic) relations | Relations in praesentia (between units in a sequence: the – cat – sat) vs relations in absentia (between a unit and those that could replace it: cat / dog / rat) |
| Value and difference | A sign’s value comes from its difference from other signs in the system: “in language there are only differences” |
| Semiology | Saussure called for a general science of signs, of which linguistics would be a part |
The chess analogy. Saussure compared langue to the rules of chess. The material of the pieces does not matter; what matters is the value each has within the system. A lost knight can be replaced by any token, provided both players agree on its value.
6. Structuralism after Saussure: Three European Schools
| School | Key figures | Key ideas |
|---|---|---|
| Prague School (Prague Linguistic Circle, founded 1926) | Vilém Mathesius, Nikolai Trubetzkoy, Roman Jakobson | The phoneme as a bundle of distinctive features; Trubetzkoy’s Principles of Phonology (published posthumously, 1939); functional sentence perspective (sentence divided into theme, the given, and rheme, the new); language as a functional system |
| Copenhagen School | Louis Hjelmslev | Glossematics: language as pure form; planes of expression and content, each with form and substance (Prolegomena to a Theory of Language, 1943 in Danish) |
| London School | J.R. Firth, later M.A.K. Halliday | Meaning is function in a context of situation (a term borrowed from the anthropologist Malinowski); collocation: “You shall know a word by the company it keeps” (Firth, 1957) |
7. American Structuralism and the Sapir–Whorf Hypothesis
Boas, Sapir and Bloomfield
| Linguist | Work | Year | Contribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Franz Boas | Handbook of American Indian Languages (introduction) | 1911 | Describe each language in its own terms, not through Latin categories; fieldwork on unwritten languages |
| Edward Sapir | Language: An Introduction to the Study of Speech | 1921 | Language, culture and thought; the “psychological reality” of the phoneme |
| Leonard Bloomfield | Language | 1933 | The bible of American structuralism: rigorous, mechanistic (behaviourist) description; meaning set aside as not yet scientifically analysable; immediate constituent (IC) analysis |
| Zellig Harris | Methods in Structural Linguistics | 1951 | Discovery procedures for segmenting and classifying data; Chomsky’s teacher |
American structuralism (descriptivism) worked bottom-up from recorded data: phonemes first, then morphemes, then larger units, by distribution. It joined hands with behaviourist psychology: language was a set of habits formed by stimulus, response and reinforcement. That partnership produced the Audio-Lingual Method of language teaching (see ELT Methods, Syllabus, Skills and Testing).
The Sapir–Whorf hypothesis (linguistic relativity)
Benjamin Lee Whorf (1897–1941), Sapir’s student and by profession a fire-insurance inspector, argued from his study of Hopi (a Native American language) that the grammar of a language shapes how its speakers perceive time, matter and events. His essays were collected posthumously as Language, Thought, and Reality (1956). The label “Sapir–Whorf hypothesis” was given later; the two men never co-wrote a statement of it.
| Version | Claim | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Strong: linguistic determinism | Language determines thought; we cannot think what our language cannot express | Largely rejected: translation is possible; new words are coined when needed |
| Weak: linguistic relativity | Language influences habitual thought and perception | Some experimental support (colour terms, spatial reference, grammatical gender) |
8. Noam Chomsky and Generative Grammar
Noam Chomsky (born 1928) turned linguistics from describing a corpus to explaining the knowledge that lets a speaker produce and understand an infinite number of new sentences.
Landmark works
| Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Syntactic Structures | 1957 | Transformational-generative grammar (TGG): phrase-structure rules plus transformations; “Colorless green ideas sleep furiously” (grammatical but meaningless) |
| Review of Skinner’s Verbal Behavior (in the journal Language) | 1959 | Demolished the behaviourist account of language learning (see Language Acquisition) |
| Aspects of the Theory of Syntax | 1965 | The Standard Theory: competence vs performance; deep structure vs surface structure |
| Cartesian Linguistics | 1966 | Places his ideas in the rationalist tradition of Descartes |
| Lectures on Government and Binding | 1981 | Principles and Parameters framework |
| Knowledge of Language | 1986 | I-language (internal, individual) vs E-language (external, social) |
| The Minimalist Program | 1995 | Reduces grammar to the most economical operations |
Key concepts
| Concept | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Competence | The ideal speaker-hearer’s unconscious knowledge of the rules of the language |
| Performance | The actual use of language in concrete situations, affected by memory limits, distraction, slips and false starts |
| Deep structure | The underlying abstract structure that carries the basic meaning relations |
| Surface structure | The form actually spoken, derived from deep structure by transformations |
| Transformations | Rules that move, delete or insert elements (active to passive, statement to question) |
| Creativity (productivity) | Speakers produce and understand sentences they have never heard |
| Language Acquisition Device (LAD) | An innate mental faculty that allows children to acquire language from limited input |
| Universal Grammar (UG) | The set of principles common to all human languages, part of our genetic endowment |
| Principles and parameters | UG has fixed principles and open parameters (for example, head-first vs head-last order) that each language sets differently |
| Poverty of the stimulus | The input children hear is too limited and messy to explain what they come to know, so much must be innate |
| Levels of adequacy | A grammar may be observationally, descriptively or explanatorily adequate; explanatory adequacy (accounting for how a child could acquire it) is the highest |
Deep and surface structure illustrated.
- John is eager to please and John is easy to please have the same surface structure but different deep structures (John pleases others vs others please John).
- The dog bit the man and The man was bitten by the dog have different surface structures but the same deep structure.
- Flying planes can be dangerous is structurally ambiguous: one surface structure, two deep structures.
9. Functional Theories: Language as Use
Jakobson’s six functions of language
Roman Jakobson, in “Closing Statement: Linguistics and Poetics” (published 1960), named six factors in any act of communication and the function that dominates when the message is oriented towards each.
| Factor | Function | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Addresser | Emotive (expressive) | “Alas!” “What a relief!” |
| Addressee | Conative | “Sit down.” “Listen to me.” |
| Context | Referential (denotative, cognitive) | “Water boils at 100 °C at sea level.” |
| Message | Poetic | “I like Ike”; rhyme, metre, parallelism |
| Contact | Phatic | “Hello, can you hear me?” “Nice weather.” |
| Code | Metalingual | “What do you mean by ‘phatic’?” |
The poetic function focuses on the message for its own sake; it is dominant in poetry but present everywhere. The phatic function takes its name from Bronisław Malinowski’s term “phatic communion”, in his essay “The Problem of Meaning in Primitive Languages”, printed as a supplement to Ogden and Richards’s The Meaning of Meaning (1923).
M.A.K. Halliday: systemic functional linguistics
Michael Halliday (1925–2018), Firth’s student, built systemic functional linguistics (SFL): language as a set of choices (systems) for making meaning.
| Halliday’s three metafunctions | What language does |
|---|---|
| Ideational (experiential and logical) | Represents experience: who did what to whom, where, when |
| Interpersonal | Enacts relationships: statements, questions, commands, attitudes |
| Textual | Organises the message into coherent text: theme and rheme, cohesion |
In his studies of child language, Halliday also proposed seven functions that children’s early language serves (outlined in his essays of the late 1960s and early 1970s and worked out in Learning How to Mean, 1975):
| Function | Child’s purpose | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Instrumental | “I want” | “Milk!” |
| Regulatory | “Do as I tell you” | “Go away.” |
| Interactional | “Me and you” | “Hello, Mummy.” |
| Personal | “Here I come” | “I’m a big boy.” |
| Heuristic | “Tell me why” | “What’s that?” |
| Imaginative | “Let’s pretend” | “I’m a lion. Roar!” |
| Representational (informative) | “I’ve got something to tell you” | “Daddy’s car is red.” |
Halliday’s register variables (field, tenor, mode) are treated in English in Use, and his work on cohesion with Ruqaiya Hasan in Pragmatics, Sociolinguistics and Language Change.
Dell Hymes: communicative competence
The American sociolinguist Dell Hymes objected that Chomsky’s “competence” left out everything that makes a speaker socially competent. A child acquires knowledge not only of what is grammatical but of when to speak, when not, what to talk about with whom, where and in what manner. Hymes called this communicative competence (developed in the late 1960s; his paper “On Communicative Competence” appeared in the early 1970s).
Hymes’s four questions about any utterance: is it formally possible (grammatical), feasible (processable), appropriate to the context, and actually performed?
He also proposed the SPEAKING model for analysing a speech event: Setting and scene, Participants, Ends, Act sequence, Key, Instrumentalities, Norms, Genre.
Michael Canale and Merrill Swain (1980) broke communicative competence into grammatical, sociolinguistic and strategic competence; Canale (1983) added discourse competence. This model is the theoretical base of Communicative Language Teaching.
After Chomsky: cognitive linguistics
George Lakoff and Mark Johnson, Metaphors We Live By (1980), argued that metaphor is not ornament but a basic structure of thought (“ARGUMENT IS WAR”, “TIME IS MONEY”). Cognitive linguistics treats meaning as grounded in bodily experience and denies a separate, innate language module.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Langue (Saussure): social system | vs | Competence (Chomsky): individual mental knowledge, generative |
| Parole (Saussure): individual speech act | vs | Performance (Chomsky): actual use, with errors and limits |
| Competence (Chomsky): grammatical knowledge | vs | Communicative competence (Hymes): grammatical + social appropriateness |
| Synchronic: one point in time | vs | Diachronic: change through time |
| Syntagmatic: in sequence (in praesentia) | vs | Paradigmatic / associative: substitution (in absentia) |
| Phonetics: all speech sounds, physically | vs | Phonology: the sound system of one language |
| Semantics: meaning out of context | vs | Pragmatics: meaning in context |
| Sapir, Language (1921) | vs | Bloomfield, Language (1933) |
| Linguistic determinism (strong Whorf) | vs | Linguistic relativity (weak Whorf) |
| Duality of patterning (Hockett) | vs | Double articulation (Martinet): the same idea, two names |
| Jakobson’s six functions | vs | Halliday’s seven child functions and three metafunctions |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who edited Saussure’s Course in General Linguistics for publication in 1916?
- Which design feature lets us talk about events far away in time or space?
- Which of Jakobson’s functions is dominant in “Hello, are you still there?” on a phone call?
Answers
- Charles Bally and Albert Sechehaye, from students’ lecture notes.
- Displacement.
- The phatic function: the message checks the contact (the channel), not information.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) The distinction between competence and performance was set out by Chomsky in:
- (a) Syntactic Structures (1957)
- (b) Aspects of the Theory of Syntax (1965)
- (c) Cartesian Linguistics (1966)
- (d) Knowledge of Language (1986)
Answer and explanation
(b). Aspects (1965) set out the Standard Theory, with competence vs performance and deep vs surface structure. Knowledge of Language (1986) introduced I-language vs E-language.
Q2. (Practice) “Language is a system of differences without positive terms” best expresses the thought of:
- (a) Leonard Bloomfield
- (b) Ferdinand de Saussure
- (c) Edward Sapir
- (d) Dell Hymes
Answer and explanation
(b) Saussure. For him, a sign’s value comes only from its difference from other signs in the system.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Hockett listed duality of patterning among the design features of language.
- The strong version of the Sapir–Whorf hypothesis holds that language merely influences thought.
- Halliday’s three metafunctions are ideational, interpersonal and textual.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Statement 2 describes the weak version (relativity). The strong version (determinism) says language determines thought.
Q4. (Practice) The term “communicative competence” was introduced by:
- (a) Noam Chomsky
- (b) M.A.K. Halliday
- (c) Dell Hymes
- (d) Michael Canale
Answer and explanation
(c) Dell Hymes, as a critique of Chomsky’s narrowly grammatical “competence”. Canale and Swain (1980) later divided it into components.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Chomsky argued that children must be born with an innate capacity for language. Reason (R): The input children hear is too limited and imperfect to account for the complex grammar they acquire.
Answer and explanation
(a). R is the poverty of the stimulus argument, which is Chomsky’s main reason for positing an innate Language Acquisition Device and Universal Grammar.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Saussure gave priority to the synchronic study of language. Reason (R): Saussure held that the value of a sign depends on its relations with other signs in the system at a given time.
Answer and explanation
(a). Because value is relational within a system, the system must be studied as it exists at one moment. Historical change alters the system but does not explain how it works at any given time.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (linguist) with List II (concept).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Ferdinand de Saussure | I. Phatic communion |
| B. Bronisław Malinowski | II. Langue and parole |
| C. J.R. Firth | III. Communicative competence |
| D. Dell Hymes | IV. Context of situation and collocation |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (3) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
- (4) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III. Firth borrowed “context of situation” from Malinowski, so B-IV is the tempting wrong pairing; Malinowski’s own coinage in the 1923 essay is “phatic communion”.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following works in chronological order of first publication:
A. Bloomfield, Language
B. Chomsky, Aspects of the Theory of Syntax
C. Saussure, Course in General Linguistics
D. Sapir, Language
(1) C, D, A, B
(2) D, C, A, B
(3) C, A, D, B
(4) C, D, B, A
Answer and explanation
(1) C, D, A, B. 1916 → 1921 → 1933 → 1965.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Design features | Hockett, “The Origin of Speech” (1960): 13 features; big five = arbitrariness, duality, productivity, displacement, cultural transmission |
| Double articulation | Martinet’s name for duality |
| Comparative philology | Jones (1786), Grimm’s Law (1822), Verner’s Law (1875), Neogrammarians (1870s) |
| Saussure | Course (1916, posthumous; Bally and Sechehaye); langue/parole; signifier/signified; synchronic/diachronic; syntagmatic/associative; arbitrariness |
| Prague School | Founded 1926; Mathesius, Trubetzkoy (Principles of Phonology, 1939), Jakobson; distinctive features; theme/rheme |
| Copenhagen School | Hjelmslev; glossematics; expression and content |
| London School | Firth; context of situation; collocation |
| American structuralism | Boas (1911), Sapir (Language, 1921), Bloomfield (Language, 1933), Harris (1951); IC analysis |
| Whorf | Language, Thought, and Reality (1956); Hopi; determinism (strong) vs relativity (weak) |
| Chomsky | Syntactic Structures (1957); Skinner review (1959); Aspects (1965): competence/performance, deep/surface; GB (1981); I-/E-language (1986); Minimalism (1995) |
| Jakobson | “Linguistics and Poetics” (1960): emotive, conative, referential, poetic, phatic, metalingual |
| Malinowski | Phatic communion (1923) |
| Halliday | SFL; ideational, interpersonal, textual; seven child functions |
| Hymes | Communicative competence; SPEAKING |
| Canale and Swain | 1980: grammatical, sociolinguistic, strategic (+ discourse, Canale 1983) |
| Lakoff and Johnson | Metaphors We Live By (1980) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Phonetics, Phonology, Morphology, Syntax and Semantics — the levels of language analysed one by one
- Pragmatics, Sociolinguistics and Language Change — Austin, Searle, Grice, dialect, register and the history of English
- Eliot, Richards, Leavis and Empson — Ogden and Richards’s The Meaning of Meaning (1923), where Malinowski’s essay first appeared