English in Independent India: Constitution, Commissions and Policy
UGC NET English: English after 1947: Munshi-Ayyangar formula, Articles 343-351, Official Languages Act, three-language formula, Kothari, NEP 2020.
- 15 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Fifteen Years That Never Ended
- 1. The Constituent Assembly and the Munshi–Ayyangar Formula
- 2. Part XVII: The Language Articles
- 3. From 1955 to 1968: The Language Crisis
- 4. The Education Commissions and the Place of English
- 5. English in Courts, Services and Institutions
- 6. Status of English Today: A Summary
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- English in Colonial India — how English became the language of law, administration and higher education by 1947
- Post-Independence Higher Education — Paper 1 covers the same commissions for their educational content
- Independent India: Integration, Constitution and States — linguistic reorganisation of states
The Hook: Fifteen Years That Never Ended
1. The Constituent Assembly and the Munshi–Ayyangar Formula
The language question was among the most bitter in the Constituent Assembly. Three positions competed:
| Position | Argument |
|---|---|
| Hindi (or Hindustani) only, at once | A free nation needs its own language; English is a colonial relic |
| Hindustani (Gandhi’s preference, in both Devanagari and Urdu scripts) | A common spoken language of North India across religions; lost ground after Partition |
| Continued English (many members from the South and East) | Immediate Hindi would put non-Hindi speakers at a disadvantage in services and courts |
The compromise drafted by K.M. Munshi and N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar, the Munshi–Ayyangar formula, was adopted on 14 September 1949. That date is now observed as Hindi Diwas. It became Part XVII of the Constitution (Articles 343–351).
2. Part XVII: The Language Articles
| Article | Subject | What it says about English |
|---|---|---|
| 343 | Official language of the Union | (1) Hindi in Devanagari; numerals in the international form of Indian numerals. (2) English to continue for all official purposes for 15 years from the commencement of the Constitution. (3) Parliament may by law provide for English to continue after 15 years |
| 344 | Commission and Committee of Parliament on official language | A Commission after 5 years (and again after 10) to recommend progressive use of Hindi and restrictions on English; a parliamentary committee to examine its report |
| 345 | Official language(s) of a State | The State legislature may adopt one or more languages or Hindi; until it does, English continues |
| 346 | Language between States, and between a State and the Union | The official language of the Union; two States may agree to use Hindi |
| 347 | Language spoken by a section of a State’s population | The President may direct its official recognition |
| 348 | Language of the Supreme Court, High Courts, Acts, Bills | English, until Parliament provides otherwise; a Governor may, with the President’s consent, authorise Hindi or the State language in High Court proceedings, but judgments and orders stay in English unless law provides otherwise |
| 349 | Special procedure for language laws | Bills on language in the first 15 years need the President’s prior sanction |
| 350 | Representations for redress of grievances | In any language used in the Union or a State |
| 350A | Primary education in the mother tongue | Every State to provide facilities for instruction in the mother tongue at the primary stage to children of linguistic minority groups (added by the Seventh Amendment, 1956) |
| 350B | Special Officer for linguistic minorities | Appointed by the President (also the Seventh Amendment, 1956) |
| 351 | Directive for the development of Hindi | Hindi to be developed as a medium of expression of India’s composite culture, assimilating forms and expressions of Hindustani and the other Eighth Schedule languages, and drawing for its vocabulary primarily on Sanskrit and secondarily on other languages |
The Eighth Schedule
| Stage | Languages |
|---|---|
| Original (1950) | 14 languages |
| 21st Amendment (1967) | Sindhi added |
| 71st Amendment (1992) | Konkani, Manipuri, Nepali added |
| 92nd Amendment (2003) | Bodo, Dogri, Maithili, Santali added |
| Today | 22 languages |
English is not in the Eighth Schedule. Its constitutional home is Articles 343(2)–(3), 345 and 348, and the Official Languages Act.
3. From 1955 to 1968: The Language Crisis
| Year | Event | Bearing on English |
|---|---|---|
| 1955–56 | Official Language Commission under B.G. Kher (Article 344) | Recommended the progressive replacement of English by Hindi; dissenting notes from non-Hindi members |
| 1957–59 | Committee of Parliament under G.B. Pant reviews the Kher report | Advised a gradual change with no fixed cut-off for English |
| 1956 | States Reorganisation Act | States on linguistic lines; regional languages become State official languages |
| 1959 | Nehru’s assurance in Parliament | English to remain an associate or additional language for as long as non-Hindi-speaking people wished |
| 1963 | Official Languages Act | Section 3: English may continue to be used, in addition to Hindi, for official purposes of the Union and in Parliament after 26 January 1965 |
| 1965 | Anti-Hindi agitation in Madras State (Tamil Nadu) as the 15-year period ends | Violent protests; the Union reaffirms the use of English |
| 1967 | Official Languages (Amendment) Act | Continuation of English made effectively indefinite: it can end only when the legislatures of all States that have not adopted Hindi pass resolutions for it, and both Houses of Parliament agree |
| 1968 | Official Language Resolution of Parliament | Programme for the spread of Hindi; adoption of the three-language formula; English or Hindi as qualifying languages for Union services |
4. The Education Commissions and the Place of English
| Commission / Policy | Year | Chair | On English and language |
|---|---|---|---|
| University Education Commission | 1948–49 | S. Radhakrishnan | English to be replaced as the medium of higher education by an Indian language as early as practicable, but to be studied in higher secondary schools and universities so that India keeps in touch with the growing body of world knowledge |
| Secondary Education Commission | 1952–53 | A. Lakshmanaswami Mudaliar | Mother tongue or regional language as the medium of secondary instruction; English among the languages studied |
| Three-language formula first framed | Late 1950s | Central Advisory Board of Education (CABE); endorsed by a conference of Chief Ministers (1961) | Each child to learn three languages |
| Education Commission | 1964–66 | D.S. Kothari | Report Education and National Development; a modified (graduated) three-language formula; regional languages as media of higher education in time; English as a library language and a key language of science and higher learning |
| National Policy on Education | 1968 | — | Adopted the three-language formula; energetic development of Indian languages; English and other international languages to be studied |
| National Policy on Education | 1986 (Programme of Action 1992) | — | Reaffirmed the 1968 language policy |
| National Curriculum Framework | 2005 | NCERT | Multilingualism as a resource; a National Focus Group position paper on the teaching of English |
| National Knowledge Commission | 2005–09 | Sam Pitroda | Recommended teaching English as a language from Class I, alongside the first language |
| National Education Policy | 2020 | K. Kasturirangan (drafting committee) | Home language / mother tongue / regional language as medium of instruction “wherever possible” until at least Grade 5, preferably Grade 8 and beyond; three-language formula with flexibility, at least two of the three languages native to India; no language imposed on any State |
The three-language formula, as framed in 1968
| Where | First language | Second | Third |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hindi-speaking States | Hindi | English | A modern Indian language, preferably a southern one |
| Non-Hindi-speaking States | The regional language | Hindi | English |
5. English in Courts, Services and Institutions
Courts
Under Article 348(1), proceedings in the Supreme Court and the High Courts, and the authoritative texts of Acts, Bills, Ordinances and rules, are in English. Under Article 348(2), several Hindi-speaking States (Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Bihar) have authorised Hindi in their High Court proceedings, with the President’s consent. Recent years have seen Supreme Court judgments translated into Indian languages, but English remains the language of record.
Services
The Union civil services examinations allow answers in English or in any Eighth Schedule language, with compulsory qualifying papers in English and an Indian language. English competence still shapes access to elite jobs, which is why the policy debates in the next topic, Indian English and the Futures of English, are so charged.
Institutions for English and languages
| Institution | Founded | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Central Institute of English, Hyderabad | 1958 | Became the Central Institute of English and Foreign Languages (CIEFL), and later the English and Foreign Languages University (EFLU), a central university |
| Central Institute of Indian Languages, Mysuru | 1969 | Research and teaching of Indian languages; multilingual education |
| Sahitya Akademi | 1954 | National academy of letters; recognises English as one of the languages in which its annual awards are given (first English award: R.K. Narayan, The Guide, 1960) |
6. Status of English Today: A Summary
| Role | Status |
|---|---|
| Constitutional | Associate official language of the Union in practice (Art. 343(3) and the Official Languages Act); language of the higher judiciary and authoritative legal texts (Art. 348) |
| Federal | Link language between the Union and non-Hindi States, and among States |
| State | Official language of some States and Union Territories (for example Nagaland and Meghalaya) and an additional official language in many |
| Education | Medium of most higher, professional and scientific education; an aspirational school medium with rapid growth of English-medium schools |
| Social | Marker of class and mobility; first language of a very small population but second or third language of a large and growing one (see the accuracy note below) |
| Literary | Recognised by the Sahitya Akademi; home of a large body of Indian writing (see Indian Writing in English after 1947) |
A note on numbers
Census figures on English are often quoted and often misquoted. The 2011 Census counted English as a mother tongue for only a few lakh people, but as a second or third language for well over ten crore. Quote such figures only with their source and year; UGC NET is far more likely to ask the Article or the Act than the census count.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Official language of the Union (Art. 343) | vs | National language (none named) |
| Art. 343: Hindi + English for 15 years | vs | Art. 348: English in courts and legal texts |
| Art. 350A: mother tongue at primary stage | vs | Art. 351: directive to develop Hindi |
| Official Languages Act 1963: English “may continue” | vs | 1967 amendment: continuation made indefinite |
| Kher Commission (1955, official language) | vs | Kothari Commission (1964–66, education) |
| Radhakrishnan Commission (university education) | vs | Mudaliar Commission (secondary education) |
| NPE 1968: three-language formula adopted | vs | NEP 2020: formula kept, with flexibility; two of three native |
| Eighth Schedule: 22 languages | vs | English: not in it, yet an official language of the Union |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which Article of the Constitution makes Hindi in the Devanagari script the official language of the Union?
- For how many years from the commencement of the Constitution was English to continue under that Article?
- On which date was the Munshi–Ayyangar formula adopted?
Answers
- Article 343(1).
- Fifteen years (to 26 January 1965).
- 14 September 1949 (now Hindi Diwas).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Under which Article are the proceedings of the Supreme Court to be in English, until Parliament provides otherwise?
- (a) Article 345
- (b) Article 348
- (c) Article 350A
- (d) Article 351
Answer and explanation
(b) Article 348. 345 is State official languages; 350A is mother-tongue instruction; 351 is the directive for Hindi.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- English is listed in the Eighth Schedule of the Constitution.
- The Official Languages (Amendment) Act of 1967 made the continued use of English effectively indefinite.
- Article 350A was inserted by the Seventh Amendment in 1956.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 2 and 3 only. English is not a scheduled language.
Q3. (Practice) Under the three-language formula as adopted in 1968, a student in a Hindi-speaking State was to study Hindi, English and:
- (a) Sanskrit
- (b) a foreign language
- (c) a modern Indian language, preferably one of the southern languages
- (d) Urdu
Answer and explanation
(c). In practice many States substituted Sanskrit, which is the trap in option (a).
Q4. (Practice) Which commission recommended that English be studied in universities so that India stays in touch with world knowledge, while an Indian language replaces it as the medium of higher education?
- (a) Kothari Commission
- (b) Mudaliar Commission
- (c) Radhakrishnan Commission
- (d) Hunter Commission
Answer and explanation
(c) University Education Commission (1948–49), chaired by S. Radhakrishnan. Hunter (1882) is colonial; Mudaliar was on secondary education.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): English continued as an official language of the Union after 26 January 1965. Reason (R): The Official Languages Act, 1963, provided that English may continue to be used in addition to Hindi after that date.
Answer and explanation
(a). Article 343(3) allowed Parliament to extend English by law; the 1963 Act did so.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): NEP 2020 recommends the home language or mother tongue as the medium of instruction until at least Grade 5, wherever possible. Reason (R): NEP 2020 abolishes the three-language formula.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true. R is false: NEP 2020 retains the three-language formula with more flexibility.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (commission or policy) with List II (chair or feature).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. University Education Commission | I. D.S. Kothari |
| B. Official Language Commission | II. S. Radhakrishnan |
| C. Education Commission 1964–66 | III. At least two of three languages native to India |
| D. NEP 2020 | IV. B.G. Kher |
- (1) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (2) A-IV, B-II, C-I, D-III
- (3) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (4) A-I, B-IV, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange in chronological order:
A. Official Languages Act
B. Munshi–Ayyangar formula adopted
C. States Reorganisation Act
D. Official Languages (Amendment) Act
(1) B, C, A, D
(2) B, A, C, D
(3) C, B, A, D
(4) B, C, D, A
Answer and explanation
(1) B, C, A, D. 1949 → 1956 → 1963 → 1967.
Quick Revision Table
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Munshi–Ayyangar formula | 14 September 1949 (Hindi Diwas) |
| Art. 343 | Hindi in Devanagari; international numerals; English for 15 years; Parliament may extend |
| Art. 344 | Official Language Commission (Kher, 1955) and parliamentary committee (Pant) |
| Art. 345–347 | State languages; inter-State link; languages of sections of a population |
| Art. 348 | English in Supreme Court, High Courts, Acts and Bills |
| Art. 350A / 350B | Mother tongue at primary stage / Special Officer for linguistic minorities (7th Amdt, 1956) |
| Art. 351 | Directive to develop Hindi |
| Eighth Schedule | 14 → 22 languages (1967, 1992, 2003); English not listed |
| Official Languages Act | 1963 (Sec. 3); amended 1967 |
| Official Language Resolution | 1968 |
| Anti-Hindi agitations | 1937–40 (Madras Presidency); 1965 (Madras State) |
| Radhakrishnan Commission | 1948–49: English studied, Indian languages as media |
| Mudaliar Commission | 1952–53 |
| Kothari Commission | 1964–66: modified three-language formula; English as library language |
| NPE | 1968 (formula adopted); 1986, POA 1992 |
| NKC | 2005–09: English from Class I |
| NEP 2020 | Mother tongue to Grade 5 (preferably 8); flexible formula; two of three native |
| CIE / CIEFL / EFLU | Hyderabad, from 1958 |
| Sahitya Akademi | 1954; first English award, Narayan’s The Guide, 1960 |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Indian English and the Futures of English — the variety these policies produced, and the debates over its future
- English in Colonial India — revise the colonial background
- Policies, Governance and Administration — NEP 2020 from the Paper 1 side