Defining Culture: Arnold, Leavis, Eliot and the Mass Culture Debate
UGC NET English: what 'culture' means, Tylor, Arnold, the Leavises and Eliot, high, mass, folk and popular culture, and the Greenberg-Macdonald debate.
- 19 min
On this page · 14 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Opera, Cricket and Biryani
- 1. The Word “Culture”
- 2. The “Culture and Civilisation” Tradition
- 3. Mass Culture: the Debate in Britain and America
- 4. Kinds of Culture: High, Folk, Mass, Popular
- 5. Why “Cultural Studies” and Not Just “Literary Studies”
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Cultural Studies: chapter overview — scope of the unit and how UGC NET asks it
- Romantic and Victorian Criticism — Arnold’s Culture and Anarchy and “The Study of Poetry” in their critical setting
- Eliot, Richards, Leavis and Empson — Leavis and Scrutiny as literary critics; this page reads them as theorists of culture
The Hook: Opera, Cricket and Biryani
1. The Word “Culture”
Williams’s warning
In Keywords: A Vocabulary of Culture and Society (1976), Raymond Williams wrote that culture is one of the two or three most complicated words in the English language. Its oldest English sense is agricultural: the tending of crops or animals (as in agriculture, horticulture). From the sixteenth century it was extended by metaphor to the cultivation of the mind. Only in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries did it become an independent noun for a whole body of intellectual and artistic life, or for the way of life of a people.
Williams identified three broad modern senses of the noun in Keywords:
| # | Sense | Example |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | A general process of intellectual, spiritual and aesthetic development | “a man of culture”; the Arnoldian sense |
| 2 | A particular way of life, of a people, a period or a group | “youth culture”, “working-class culture”; the anthropological sense |
| 3 | The works and practices of intellectual and especially artistic activity | “the Ministry of Culture”, “culture pages” of a newspaper |
Williams’s three categories of definition (The Long Revolution, 1961)
In the chapter “The Analysis of Culture” in The Long Revolution (1961), Williams sorted definitions of culture into three categories. This is a separate list from the Keywords senses, and a frequent source of confusion.
| Category | Culture is… | Task of analysis |
|---|---|---|
| Ideal | A state or process of human perfection, in terms of certain absolute or universal values | Discover and describe the timeless values in lives and works |
| Documentary | The body of intellectual and imaginative work in which human thought and experience are recorded | Criticism: describe and value the works |
| Social | A description of a particular way of life, expressing meanings and values in institutions and ordinary behaviour as well as in art and learning | Clarify the meanings and values implicit and explicit in a whole way of life |
Williams argued that an adequate theory must hold all three together; cultural studies grew mainly out of the social definition.
The anthropological definition: E.B. Tylor
The most quoted early anthropological definition is Edward Burnett Tylor’s in Primitive Culture (1871): culture or civilisation, “taken in its wide ethnographic sense”, is “that complex whole which includes knowledge, belief, art, morals, law, custom, and any other capabilities and habits acquired by man as a member of society”. Two points matter for the exam:
- Tylor treats culture as acquired (learned), not inherited.
- He uses culture and civilisation as synonyms; in the English literary tradition the two words were set against each other.
Thick description: Clifford Geertz
The American anthropologist Clifford Geertz, in The Interpretation of Cultures (1973), defined culture semiotically: man is “suspended in webs of significance he himself has spun”, and culture is those webs. Its analysis is “not an experimental science in search of law but an interpretive one in search of meaning”. His method, thick description (a term he took from the philosopher Gilbert Ryle), reads a social act (Ryle’s example is the difference between a twitch and a wink) for its layered meanings. Geertz’s essay on the Balinese cockfight is the classic demonstration. New historicists later borrowed the method for reading literary texts.
2. The “Culture and Civilisation” Tradition
Williams’s Culture and Society 1780–1950 (1958) traced how the idea of culture developed in England as a response to the Industrial Revolution and democracy. The tradition he described (Burke, Coleridge, Carlyle, Arnold, Ruskin, Morris, Eliot, Leavis) has come to be called the “culture and civilisation” tradition. Its members disagreed on politics but shared three assumptions:
- Culture is the best that a society has produced, and is held by a minority.
- Industrial, commercial, democratic society (“civilisation”, “mechanism”, “the masses”) threatens it.
- Culture, especially literature, has a social mission: to humanise, to unify, to replace or support religion.
The line at a glance
| Thinker | Work | Year | Idea of culture |
|---|---|---|---|
| S.T. Coleridge | On the Constitution of the Church and State | 1829 (title page 1830) | A national “clerisy” (learned class) to cultivate the nation; cultivation must ground civilisation |
| Thomas Carlyle | “Signs of the Times” | 1829 | Attacks the “Mechanical Age” (his later “cash nexus” phrase comes from Chartism, 1839, and Past and Present, 1843) |
| Matthew Arnold | Culture and Anarchy | 1869 | Culture as the pursuit of perfection through “the best which has been thought and said”; sweetness and light |
| John Ruskin | Unto This Last | 1860 (essays), 1862 (book) | “There is no wealth but life”; art and labour bound together |
| William Morris | Lectures and essays on art and socialism | 1870s–1890s | Art as joy in labour; culture bound to social change |
| F.R. Leavis | Mass Civilisation and Minority Culture | 1930 | A minority keeps the language and standards alive against mass civilisation |
| Q.D. Leavis | Fiction and the Reading Public | 1932 | Popular fiction offers compensation and “fantasy”; the reading public has been fragmented |
| F.R. Leavis and Denys Thompson | Culture and Environment: The Training of Critical Awareness | 1933 | Teach schoolchildren to resist advertising and the popular press; mourn the lost “organic community” |
| T.S. Eliot | Notes Towards the Definition of Culture | 1948 | Culture as the whole way of life of a people, transmitted through class, family and religion |
Matthew Arnold: culture against anarchy
Arnold’s Culture and Anarchy (1869; the chapters first appeared in the Cornhill Magazine, 1867–68) was written in the years of the Second Reform Act (1867) and the Hyde Park riots (1866). Its argument:
- Culture is “a pursuit of our total perfection by means of getting to know, on all the matters which most concern us, the best which has been thought and said in the world”.
- Culture seeks “sweetness and light” (beauty and intelligence), a phrase Arnold took from Swift’s The Battle of the Books.
- Anarchy is the “doing as one likes” of an England without a centre of authority; the working class demonstrating in Hyde Park is Arnold’s example.
- English society is divided into Barbarians (the aristocracy), Philistines (the middle class) and the Populace (the working class). Culture belongs to the “aliens” in each class who are led by “the love of human perfection”.
- Two forces shape Western civilisation: Hebraism (“strictness of conscience”) and Hellenism (“spontaneity of consciousness”). England had too much Hebraism and needed Hellenism.
- The State, as the nation’s “best self”, should promote culture, above all through education (Arnold was an inspector of schools).
Leavisism
“Leavisism” is the name later given to the programme of F.R. and Q.D. Leavis and the journal Scrutiny (1932–1953). Its cultural argument:
| Claim | Detail |
|---|---|
| Minority | “In any period it is upon a very small minority that the discerning appreciation of art and literature depends” (the opening of Mass Civilisation and Minority Culture) |
| Decline | The machine, mass production, standardisation, the press, advertising, cinema, broadcasting and the book club have levelled down taste |
| Organic community | Before industrialisation, England had an “organic community” of village and craft, whose lost way of life Leavis found in George Sturt’s The Wheelwright’s Shop (1923) |
| Remedy | Education: train a critical minority, through English studies, to discriminate and resist; take the fight into schools (Culture and Environment) |
| Literature as the repository of values | The living language of the great writers preserves what mass civilisation destroys |
Q.D. Leavis’s Fiction and the Reading Public (1932) was a pioneering study of reading habits: lending libraries, bestsellers, magazines. She argued that the eighteenth-century reading public had been a single public, but by the twentieth century it had split into “highbrow”, “middlebrow” and “lowbrow”, and that bestsellers offered wish-fulfilment that unfitted readers for serious fiction. The book is an ancestor of cultural studies’ interest in readers and popular reading, even though its judgement of popular fiction is hostile.
T.S. Eliot: culture as a whole way of life
Eliot’s Notes Towards the Definition of Culture (1948) is a conservative book with a surprisingly broad definition. Eliot says culture “includes all the characteristic activities and interests of a people”, and gives a famous list of English examples, from the Derby, the Henley regatta and a cup final to Wensleydale cheese, boiled cabbage and the music of Elgar. That is the anthropological sense.
But his conclusions are elitist:
- Culture is transmitted mainly through the family; a class structure with a cultural elite is necessary for a high culture to survive.
- Culture and religion are aspects of the same thing: a culture is “the incarnation” of a religion.
- Unity and diversity: a healthy culture needs regional and class variety within an overall unity.
Williams admired the breadth of Eliot’s definition and rejected his conclusions; in Culture and Society he discussed Eliot and Leavis among the twentieth-century heirs of the tradition.
3. Mass Culture: the Debate in Britain and America
The word “mass” carries the charge of the whole debate. “Mass culture” is culture produced industrially for a mass market and consumed passively; the term already contains a judgement.
The American intellectuals
| Critic | Work | Year | Argument |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clement Greenberg | “Avant-Garde and Kitsch” (Partisan Review) | 1939 | Kitsch (popular, commercial art and literature: magazine covers, Hollywood, Tin Pan Alley) is the “rear-guard” of the avant-garde; it uses the “debased and academicized simulacra” of genuine culture and offers vicarious, predigested experience |
| Dwight Macdonald | “A Theory of Mass Culture” | 1953 | Mass culture is imposed from above by businessmen; it threatens to absorb high culture |
| Dwight Macdonald | “Masscult and Midcult” | 1960 | Masscult (mass culture) is bad enough; worse is Midcult, the middlebrow imitation of high culture, which claims to respect its standards while watering them down |
The Frankfurt School parallel
In Germany and in American exile, Adorno and Horkheimer made a Marxist version of the same case: popular entertainment is produced by a culture industry that standardises its products and its consumers. Their argument, and the left-wing critique of mass culture generally, is treated in Frankfurt School, Gramsci, Althusser, Barthes and Bourdieu.
4. Kinds of Culture: High, Folk, Mass, Popular
| Term | Meaning | Who stresses it |
|---|---|---|
| High culture | The canon of “serious” art, literature and music, valued for complexity and permanence | Arnold, Leavis, Eliot |
| Folk culture | Culture made by the people themselves, usually rural, oral and pre-industrial (ballads, folk tales, crafts) | Romantic collectors; the Leavisite “organic community” |
| Mass culture | Culture made for the people by industry, standardised and commercial | Leavisites, Greenberg, Macdonald, Adorno and Horkheimer |
| Popular culture | Culture widely enjoyed by ordinary people; in cultural studies, a site where meanings are made and contested | Hall, Fiske, Storey |
| Subculture | The culture of a group within a larger culture, often youth, marked by style | Birmingham CCCS, Hebdige |
| Counterculture | A culture opposed to dominant values (the 1960s hippie movement is the usual example) | Theodore Roszak’s The Making of a Counter Culture (1969) |
John Storey’s six definitions of popular culture
John Storey’s textbook Cultural Theory and Popular Culture: An Introduction (first published in 1993 as An Introductory Guide to Cultural Theory and Popular Culture) organises the field around six ways of defining popular culture. They are a useful map of the whole unit:
| # | Popular culture is… | Associated with |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Culture that is widely favoured or well liked by many people | Quantitative approaches: sales, ratings |
| 2 | What is left over once we have decided what high culture is: the inferior residue | The culture and civilisation tradition |
| 3 | Mass culture: commercial, mass-produced, passively consumed | Leavisism, Frankfurt School, American mass-culture critics |
| 4 | Culture that originates from “the people”: an authentic folk voice | Romantic and some left-wing positions |
| 5 | A site of struggle between the forces of resistance of subordinate groups and the forces of incorporation of dominant groups | Gramscian hegemony theory, Hall and the CCCS |
| 6 | A category that postmodernism dissolves, since the line between high and popular no longer holds | Jameson, Baudrillard |
5. Why “Cultural Studies” and Not Just “Literary Studies”
| Literary studies (Leavisite) | Cultural studies |
|---|---|
| Studies a canon of great works | Studies all signifying practices: novels, soap operas, advertisements, fashion, music, sport |
| Evaluates (great or not) | Interprets meanings and their relation to power |
| Culture = the best | Culture = a whole way of life and a site of struggle |
| The reader is to be trained in taste | The audience actively makes meaning |
| Politics kept out of criticism | Politics (class, gender, race, nation) at the centre |
| Single discipline | Interdisciplinary: literature, sociology, history, anthropology, media studies |
In short, cultural studies refused to separate “culture” from “society”, the separation Williams’s Culture and Society had set out to undo. The next topic follows how that project was institutionalised at Birmingham.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Culture and Anarchy (Arnold, 1869) | vs | Culture and Society 1780–1950 (Williams, 1958) |
| Culture and Environment (F.R. Leavis and Denys Thompson, 1933) | vs | E.P. Thompson (historian, The Making of the English Working Class, 1963) |
| Mass Civilisation and Minority Culture (F.R. Leavis, 1930) | vs | Fiction and the Reading Public (Q.D. Leavis, 1932) |
| Notes Towards the Definition of Culture (Eliot, 1948) | vs | Keywords (Williams, 1976) |
| Kitsch (Greenberg, 1939) | vs | Midcult (Macdonald, 1960) |
| Keywords three senses of “culture” | vs | The Long Revolution three categories (ideal, documentary, social) |
| Folk culture (made by the people) | vs | Mass culture (made for the people) |
| Tylor’s culture = civilisation (synonyms) | vs | Leavis’s culture against civilisation (opposites) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who wrote Fiction and the Reading Public (1932)?
- In which book did Raymond Williams call culture one of the two or three most complicated words in English?
- Name Arnold’s three classes of English society.
Answers
- Q.D. (Queenie) Leavis.
- Keywords (1976).
- Barbarians (aristocracy), Philistines (middle class) and the Populace (working class).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) “That complex whole which includes knowledge, belief, art, morals, law, custom…” is a definition of culture given by:
- (a) Matthew Arnold
- (b) E.B. Tylor
- (c) T.S. Eliot
- (d) Clifford Geertz
Answer and explanation
(b) E.B. Tylor, Primitive Culture (1871). It is the classic anthropological definition, treating culture as acquired by man as a member of society. Geertz’s definition is semiotic (“webs of significance”).
Q2. (Practice) Which of the following works argued that “upon a very small minority” depends the discerning appreciation of art and literature?
- (a) Culture and Anarchy
- (b) Notes Towards the Definition of Culture
- (c) Mass Civilisation and Minority Culture
- (d) The Uses of Literacy
Answer and explanation
(c) F.R. Leavis’s pamphlet of 1930. The minority thesis is the core of Leavisism. The Uses of Literacy (Hoggart, 1957) is the reply from inside working-class life.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Dwight Macdonald’s “Masscult and Midcult” regards middlebrow culture as more insidious than mass culture.
- Clement Greenberg’s “Avant-Garde and Kitsch” celebrates kitsch as the authentic art of the people.
- Eliot’s Notes Towards the Definition of Culture treats religion and culture as closely bound together.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Greenberg treats kitsch as ersatz culture that imitates the effects of real art; he does not celebrate it.
Q4. (Practice) In John Storey’s account, the definition of popular culture as “a site of struggle between resistance and incorporation” derives mainly from:
- (a) Leavisism
- (b) Gramscian hegemony theory
- (c) Romantic folk collecting
- (d) Postmodernism
Answer and explanation
(b). The neo-Gramscian turn in British cultural studies (Hall and the CCCS in the 1970s) treated popular culture as contested ground. Leavisism corresponds to the “mass culture” and “what is left over” definitions.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Arnold looked to the State and to education to spread culture in England. Reason (R): Arnold believed that England lacked a centre of authority, and that culture, as the nation’s “best self”, could check the anarchy of “doing as one likes”.
Answer and explanation
(a). Arnold’s turn to the State follows directly from his diagnosis of anarchy: culture needs an authority above the classes to carry it.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Cultural studies retained the Leavisite habit of close reading. Reason (R): Cultural studies accepted the Leavisite verdict that popular culture is a form of mass manipulation.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true: Hoggart and Williams read popular songs, newspapers and advertisements closely, as Leavis had taught. R is false: they rejected the verdict that popular culture is simply debased or manipulative.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (work) with List II (author).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Primitive Culture | I. Clement Greenberg |
| B. The Interpretation of Cultures | II. E.B. Tylor |
| C. “Avant-Garde and Kitsch” | III. Clifford Geertz |
| D. Culture and Environment | IV. F.R. Leavis and Denys Thompson |
- (1) A-II, B-III, C-I, D-IV
- (2) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
- (3) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (4) A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-III, C-I, D-IV.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order of first publication:
A. Notes Towards the Definition of Culture
B. Culture and Anarchy
C. Fiction and the Reading Public
D. Mass Civilisation and Minority Culture
(1) B, D, C, A
(2) B, C, D, A
(3) D, B, C, A
(4) B, D, A, C
Answer and explanation
(1) B, D, C, A. 1869 → 1930 → 1932 → 1948.
Quick Revision Table
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Keywords (Williams, 1976) | “Culture” one of the two or three most complicated words; three senses: process, way of life, works |
| The Long Revolution (Williams, 1961) | Three categories: ideal, documentary, social |
| Tylor, Primitive Culture (1871) | “That complex whole…”; culture = civilisation; acquired |
| Geertz, Interpretation of Cultures (1973) | Webs of significance; thick description (from Ryle) |
| Arnold, Culture and Anarchy (1869) | Best which has been thought and said; sweetness and light (Swift); Barbarians, Philistines, Populace; Hebraism and Hellenism |
| F.R. Leavis (1930) | Mass Civilisation and Minority Culture: the minority keeps standards |
| Q.D. Leavis (1932) | Fiction and the Reading Public: highbrow, middlebrow, lowbrow; bestsellers as wish-fulfilment |
| Leavis and Denys Thompson (1933) | Culture and Environment: resist advertising; organic community |
| Eliot (1948) | Notes Towards the Definition of Culture: whole way of life; class, family, religion |
| Greenberg (1939) | “Avant-Garde and Kitsch” |
| Macdonald (1960) | “Masscult and Midcult” |
| Storey | Six definitions of popular culture; no. 5 = site of struggle (Gramsci) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- The Birmingham School: Hoggart, Williams, Thompson and Hall — how “culture is ordinary” became a research programme
- Frankfurt School, Gramsci, Althusser, Barthes and Bourdieu — the theories of ideology cultural studies used
- Mass Media and Society (Paper 1) — the Paper 1 view of the same mass media
- Cultural Studies: Quick Revision