FDI, FPI and Balance of Payments
UGC NET Commerce: FDI vs FPI, types and theories of FDI, costs and benefits to home and host, trends, India's FDI policy, and BOP components.
- 19 min
On this page · 15 sections
Prerequisites
- International Business, Globalisation, Trade Theories and Trade Barriers — FDI is the deepest of the entry modes.
- Political, Legal and Socio-cultural Environment and CSR — FEMA’s current and capital account split is the legal side of the BOP.
- Paper 1: Data Interpretation Calculations — BOP questions are sums and percentages.
This page covers two official lines: “Foreign direct investment (FDI) and foreign portfolio investment (FPI); types of FDI, costs and benefits of FDI to home and host countries; trends in FDI; India’s FDI policy” and “Balance of payments (BOP): importance and components”.
The Hook: 1991, Gold on a Plane
1. FDI and FPI: Meaning and Difference
Foreign direct investment (FDI) is investment by a resident of one economy in an enterprise in another economy with a lasting interest and a significant degree of influence or control over its management. The IMF and OECD benchmark is ownership of 10% or more of the voting power.
Foreign portfolio investment (FPI) is investment in financial securities (shares, bonds) of another country without management control, made mainly for financial return.
The Indian line (since 2014)
Following the Arvind Mayaram Committee (2014), India uses the 10% test, now in the FEMA (Non-Debt Instruments) Rules, 2019:
| Investment by a person resident outside India | Classified as |
|---|---|
| 10% or more of the post-issue paid-up equity of a listed Indian company | FDI |
| Less than 10% of a listed company | FPI |
| Any investment in an unlisted company | FDI |
Once an investment is classified as FDI it remains FDI even if the holding later falls below 10%. An FPI whose holding crosses 10% must divest the excess or have the whole holding reclassified as FDI.
FDI vs FPI
| Basis | FDI | FPI |
|---|---|---|
| Objective | Control, long-term business interest | Financial return |
| Stake (India) | ≥ 10% of a listed company, or any stake in an unlisted company | < 10% of a listed company |
| Investor’s role | Active (management, technology) | Passive |
| Time horizon | Long term; hard to withdraw | Short to medium term; easy exit |
| Stability | Stable (“cold” money) | Volatile ("hot money"); can reverse quickly |
| What it brings | Capital plus technology, management, market access | Capital and market liquidity |
| Indian regulator | DPIIT policy; RBI under FEMA | SEBI (Foreign Portfolio Investors) Regulations, 2019; RBI |
FPI regime in India: SEBI’s 2014 regulations merged the earlier Foreign Institutional Investors (FIIs), their sub-accounts and Qualified Foreign Investors (QFIs) into one class, the FPI; the 2019 regulations replaced them. A single FPI (with its investor group) must hold less than 10% of a company’s paid-up equity. Participatory notes (P-notes), offshore derivative instruments issued by registered FPIs against Indian securities, are regulated by SEBI.
2. Types of FDI
| Basis | Type | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Direction | Inward | Foreign investment coming into the country |
| Outward (OFDI / ODI) | Domestic firms investing abroad (India: FEMA (Overseas Investment) Rules, 2022) | |
| Activity | Horizontal | Same industry and stage abroad as at home (a carmaker builds a car plant abroad) |
| Vertical: backward | Into an industry that supplies inputs (a steelmaker buys an iron-ore mine abroad) | |
| Vertical: forward | Into an industry that uses or sells the output (an oil producer buys a refinery or distribution abroad) | |
| Conglomerate | Into an unrelated industry | |
| Mode | Greenfield | New facility from scratch |
| Brownfield / M&A | Acquiring or merging with an existing firm; brownfield also means leasing or buying existing facilities | |
| Purpose | Export-platform | Investing in a country to export from it to third countries |
Motives (Dunning’s typology)
Resource-seeking (raw materials, cheap labour), market-seeking (serve the host market, avoid tariffs), efficiency-seeking (rationalise production across countries) and strategic-asset-seeking (buy technology, brands, capabilities).
Theories of FDI
| Theory | Thinker | Idea |
|---|---|---|
| Monopolistic (ownership) advantage | Stephen Hymer (1960 thesis) | Foreign firms face a “liability of foreignness”, so they invest only with a firm-specific advantage (technology, brand) |
| Internalisation | Peter Buckley and Mark Casson (1976) | Firms internalise markets (FDI) when licensing know-how through the market is costly or risky |
| Product life cycle | Raymond Vernon (1966) | Production moves abroad as the product matures and standardises |
| Oligopolistic reaction | Frederick Knickerbocker (1973) | Firms in oligopolies follow rivals into foreign markets |
| Eclectic (OLI) paradigm | John H. Dunning | FDI needs Ownership, Location and Internalisation advantages together |
3. Costs and Benefits of FDI
To the host country
| Benefits | Costs |
|---|---|
| Resource transfer: capital, technology, management skills | Adverse effects on competition: foreign subsidiary may crowd out or buy up local firms and gain monopoly power |
| Employment creation (direct and indirect) | Adverse BOP effects later: repatriation of profits, royalties and fees; imports of inputs |
| BOP gains: initial capital inflow; import substitution; exports from the subsidiary | Loss of national sovereignty and autonomy: key decisions taken abroad |
| Competition and growth: efficiency, spill-overs to local suppliers, higher tax revenue | Transfer pricing and tax avoidance; environmental and labour concerns; cultural effects |
To the home (source) country
| Benefits | Costs |
|---|---|
| Inflow of earnings (profits, royalties, fees) to the BOP | BOP: initial capital outflow; possible fall in exports if foreign production replaces them; imports back from the subsidiary |
| Demand for home exports (capital goods, components) | Employment effects: jobs move abroad (offshoring) |
| Reverse resource transfer: learning skills and technology from foreign markets | Less investment at home |
| Access to resources and markets for home firms |
4. Trends in FDI
The authoritative global source is UNCTAD’s annual World Investment Report (published since 1991). For India, data come from DPIIT (FDI equity inflows, published quarterly) and the RBI (BOP data). Broad trends that hold over the past two decades:
- Global flows are cyclical: they fell sharply after the 2008 global financial crisis and again in 2020 during the pandemic, then recovered unevenly. Large swings come from cross-border mergers and acquisitions and from conduit flows through financial centres.
- Developing Asia has become the largest recipient region among developing economies; developing countries are also outward investors (China, India and others).
- Greenfield project announcements have shifted toward digital economy, semiconductors, renewable energy and critical minerals; supply-chain “friend-shoring” and “near-shoring” reshape location choices.
- Investment screening for national security has spread among developed economies, and many countries also tightened rules on investment from particular sources.
India:
- FDI inflows rose sharply after 1991 and again after the liberalisation of the 2010s; India is consistently among the larger recipients of greenfield project announcements.
- Top sources of cumulative FDI equity since April 2000 (DPIIT): Mauritius and Singapore lead, reflecting tax treaties and the routing of investment through holding companies; the USA, Netherlands and Japan are other major sources.
- Top sectors: the services sector (financial, banking, outsourcing, R&D), computer software and hardware, trading, telecommunications, automobiles, construction (infrastructure).
- Indian outward FDI has grown too, through acquisitions and greenfield investment abroad.
5. India’s FDI Policy
Evolution in brief
| Period | Policy |
|---|---|
| FERA, 1973 | Foreign equity generally limited to 40% |
| 1991 (New Industrial Policy) | Automatic approval of foreign equity up to 51% in specified high-priority industries; Foreign Investment Promotion Board (FIPB) set up |
| 2000s–2010s | Caps raised sector by sector; consolidated policy issued by DIPP |
| 2017 | FIPB abolished; replaced by the Foreign Investment Facilitation Portal (FIFP): proposals go to the concerned administrative ministry |
| 2019 | DIPP renamed Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT); FEMA (Non-Debt Instruments) Rules, 2019 |
| 2020 | Press Note 3 (2020): investment from an entity of a country sharing a land border with India (or where the beneficial owner is from such a country) needs government approval |
Two routes
| Route | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Automatic route | No prior government approval; only reporting to the RBI after investment |
| Government route | Prior approval of the government (through the FIFP and the administrative ministry) |
Prohibited sectors (illustrative)
FDI is prohibited in: lottery business (including online lotteries); gambling and betting, including casinos; chit funds; Nidhi companies; trading in Transferable Development Rights (TDRs); real estate business or construction of farm houses (development of townships, construction of residential and commercial premises, roads and bridges is not “real estate business”); manufacturing of cigars, cheroots, cigarillos and cigarettes of tobacco or tobacco substitutes; and activities not open to private investment such as atomic energy and railway operations (other than those permitted).
Selected sectoral caps
| Sector | Cap and route |
|---|---|
| Defence manufacturing | 74% automatic; above 74% through the government route (where it brings modern technology or for other recorded reasons) |
| Telecom services | 100% automatic (since 2021) |
| Single-brand product retail trading | 100% automatic |
| Multi-brand retail trading | 51%, government route |
| E-commerce: marketplace model | 100% automatic; inventory-based model not permitted |
| Private sector banking | 74% (up to 49% automatic, beyond that government route) |
| Public sector banking | 20%, government route |
| Print media (newspapers, periodicals) | 26%, government route |
6. Balance of Payments
Meaning
The balance of payments (BOP) is a systematic record of all economic transactions between the residents of a country and the rest of the world during a given period (usually a year or a quarter). It is kept on the double-entry principle: every transaction has a credit and a debit, so the BOP as a whole always balances in the accounting sense.
- Credit (+): transactions that bring foreign exchange in: exports, inward investment, borrowing from abroad, receipts of income and transfers.
- Debit (−): transactions that use foreign exchange: imports, investment abroad, repayments, payments of income and transfers.
The international standard is the IMF’s Balance of Payments and International Investment Position Manual, sixth edition (BPM6, 2009), which the RBI follows.
Components
graph TD
A["Balance of Payments"] --> B["Current account"]
A --> C["Capital account"]
A --> D["Financial account"]
A --> E["Errors and omissions"]
B --> B1["Goods (merchandise)
= balance of trade"]
B --> B2["Services
(travel, transport, software, ...)"]
B --> B3["Primary income
(investment income, compensation of employees)"]
B --> B4["Secondary income
(transfers, remittances, grants)"]
D --> D1["Direct investment (FDI)"]
D --> D2["Portfolio investment (FPI)"]
D --> D3["Other investment
(loans, trade credit, banking capital, NRI deposits)"]
D --> D4["Reserve assets"]| Account | Contents |
|---|---|
| Current account | Goods (visible trade): exports and imports of merchandise. Invisibles: services, primary income (interest, dividends, profits, wages of workers abroad), secondary income (current transfers: private remittances, gifts, grants) |
| Capital account (BPM6 sense) | Capital transfers (debt forgiveness, migrants’ transfers) and acquisition or disposal of non-produced, non-financial assets (patents sold outright, land for embassies) |
| Financial account | Direct investment, portfolio investment, financial derivatives, other investment (loans, trade credit, currency and deposits), reserve assets |
| Errors and omissions | Balancing item for statistical discrepancies |
The RBI’s presentation: in India’s published BOP, the “capital account” is used in the older, broad sense and includes foreign investment (FDI and portfolio), loans (external assistance, external commercial borrowings, short-term trade credit), banking capital (including NRI deposits), rupee debt service and other capital. Then come errors and omissions and the change in foreign exchange reserves.
Balances to know
| Balance | Formula |
|---|---|
| Balance of trade | Merchandise exports − merchandise imports |
| Balance on current account | Balance of trade + net services + net primary income + net secondary income |
| Overall balance | Current account + capital (and financial, excluding reserves) account + errors and omissions |
| Settlement | An overall surplus adds to reserves; a deficit is met by drawing down reserves (or IMF borrowing) |
This pattern (a large trade deficit, offset by a services surplus and strong remittances, with capital inflows financing a small current account deficit) is the typical shape of India’s BOP.
BOP equilibrium and disequilibrium
Because of double entry the BOP always balances on paper. Disequilibrium refers to the balance of autonomous transactions (made for their own sake: trade, investment) as distinct from accommodating (compensatory) transactions undertaken to settle the gap (reserve use, IMF loans). This distinction is associated with James Meade.
| Causes of disequilibrium | Corrective measures |
|---|---|
| Economic development (heavy imports of capital goods) | Monetary measures: tight money, higher interest rates (attract capital, reduce demand) |
| Cyclical fluctuations | Expenditure-reducing policies: fiscal tightening |
| Structural changes (loss of export markets, oil-price shocks) | Expenditure-switching policies: devaluation / depreciation, tariffs, export promotion |
| Inflation higher than trading partners | Exchange control |
| Political instability, capital flight | Borrowing from the IMF |
Marshall–Lerner condition: a devaluation improves the trade balance only if the sum of the price elasticities of demand for exports and imports exceeds one. The J-curve describes the short-run worsening of the trade balance after a devaluation before it improves.
Importance of the BOP
- Shows a country’s international economic position and its ability to pay for imports and service debt.
- Guides monetary, fiscal, trade and exchange rate policy.
- Signals pressure on the exchange rate; a persistent current account deficit may weaken the currency.
- Used by investors, rating agencies and the IMF to judge external vulnerability.
- Indicates the structure of trade and capital flows (dependence on remittances, short-term debt, hot money).
Convertibility in India
- Current account convertibility: India accepted the obligations of Article VIII of the IMF Articles in August 1994.
- Capital account convertibility remains partial; the RBI’s S. S. Tarapore committees (1997 and 2006) set out preconditions and a phased road map.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | First | Second |
|---|---|---|
| FDI vs FPI | ≥ 10% listed, or any unlisted; control | < 10% listed; no control |
| Greenfield vs brownfield | Build new | Buy or lease existing |
| Backward vs forward vertical FDI | Toward inputs | Toward customers |
| Horizontal vs conglomerate FDI | Same industry | Unrelated industry |
| Balance of trade vs BOP | Goods only | All transactions |
| Current vs capital account | Goods, services, income, transfers | Assets and liabilities (investment, loans) |
| Primary vs secondary income | Earned (interest, dividends, wages) | Transfers (remittances, grants) |
| Autonomous vs accommodating | For their own sake | To settle the gap |
| Hymer vs Buckley–Casson | Ownership advantage | Internalisation |
| FIPB vs FIFP | Board, abolished 2017 | Portal; ministries decide |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- In India, a foreign investment of 9% in a listed company is classified as what?
- Who proposed the eclectic (OLI) paradigm?
- In which account of the BOP are private remittances from workers abroad recorded?
Answers
- FPI (less than 10% of a listed company).
- John H. Dunning.
- Current account (secondary income / private transfers).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) An Indian steel company acquires an iron-ore mine in Australia. This is:
- (a) Horizontal FDI
- (b) Backward vertical FDI
- (c) Forward vertical FDI
- (d) Conglomerate FDI
Answer and explanation
(b) Backward vertical FDI: investment in an input-supplying stage of the value chain, and outward FDI from India’s side.
Q2. (Practice) A country’s merchandise exports are 300, imports 420, net services +90, net primary income −20 and net secondary income +60 (all USD billion). Its current account balance is:
- (a) −120
- (b) +10
- (c) −30
- (d) +130
Answer and explanation
(b) +10. Trade balance = 300 − 420 = −120. Current account = −120 + 90 − 20 + 60 = +10 (a surplus despite a trade deficit).
Q3. (Practice) In which of the following is FDI prohibited in India?
- (a) Single-brand retail trading
- (b) Chit funds
- (c) Defence manufacturing
- (d) E-commerce marketplace
Answer and explanation
(b) Chit funds. The others are open: single-brand retail and marketplace e-commerce 100% automatic; defence 74% automatic.
Q4. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Press Note 3 (2020) requires government approval for investment from entities of countries sharing a land border with India.
- The Foreign Investment Promotion Board continues to approve FDI proposals under the government route.
- Under the automatic route, no prior government approval is needed.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. The FIPB was abolished in 2017; government-route proposals now go through the Foreign Investment Facilitation Portal to the concerned ministry.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): FPI is generally more volatile than FDI. Reason (R): Portfolio investors hold liquid securities without management control and can exit quickly.
Answer and explanation
(a). Liquidity and the absence of a long-term controlling interest are exactly why portfolio flows reverse quickly (“hot money”).
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): The balance of payments always balances in the accounting sense. Reason (R): The current account of every country must be in balance each year.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true because of double-entry recording. R is false: current accounts are routinely in deficit or surplus; the capital and financial account and reserves offset them.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Theory of FDI) with List II (Proponent).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Monopolistic advantage | I. Buckley and Casson |
| B. Internalisation | II. Knickerbocker |
| C. Oligopolistic reaction | III. Hymer |
| D. Eclectic paradigm | IV. Dunning |
- (1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
- (2) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
- (3) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
- (4) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order:
A. FIPB abolished
B. FERA enacted
C. India accepts IMF Article VIII (current account convertibility)
D. Press Note 3 on investment from land-border countries
E. New Industrial Policy permits automatic approval up to 51% foreign equity in priority industries
(1) B, E, C, A, D
(2) B, C, E, A, D
(3) E, B, C, A, D
(4) B, E, A, C, D
Answer and explanation
(1) B, E, C, A, D. 1973 → 1991 → 1994 → 2017 → 2020.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| FDI benchmark | ≥ 10% voting power (IMF/OECD); India: ≥ 10% listed, any unlisted |
| Mayaram Committee | 2014; FDI–FPI distinction |
| NDI Rules | FEMA (Non-Debt Instruments) Rules, 2019 |
| FPI rules | SEBI (FPI) Regulations, 2019; FII + QFI merged into FPI in 2014 |
| Types | Inward/outward; horizontal, vertical (backward, forward), conglomerate; greenfield, brownfield |
| Motives | Resource, market, efficiency, strategic asset |
| Theories | Hymer; Buckley–Casson; Vernon; Knickerbocker; Dunning OLI |
| Host costs | Competition, BOP (repatriation), sovereignty |
| Home benefits | Earnings inflow, exports of inputs, reverse learning |
| FDI trends | UNCTAD World Investment Report (from 1991); DPIIT data |
| Top sources to India | Mauritius, Singapore (cumulative since 2000) |
| FDI routes | Automatic; government (FIFP; FIPB abolished 2017) |
| Press Note 3 (2020) | Land-border countries need approval |
| Prohibited | Lottery, gambling, chit funds, Nidhi, TDRs, real estate business, tobacco cigarettes, atomic energy |
| BOP | Systematic record; double entry; BPM6 |
| Current account | Goods, services, primary income, secondary income |
| Capital / financial | FDI, FPI, loans, banking capital, reserves |
| Marshall–Lerner | Sum of elasticities > 1 |
| Convertibility | Current account August 1994; capital account partial (Tarapore 1997, 2006) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Regional Economic Integration and International Institutions — the IMF’s role in BOP crises
- World Trade Organisation — TRIMs, the WTO’s rules on investment measures
- Business Environment: Economic Systems and Policies — monetary policy and the exchange rate
- Quick Revision